HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

martindbp

1,418 karma · joined February 3, 2019

submissionscomments
martindbp··on Founder Mode
The thing is, as a consumer I can't tell any difference between the technical solutions of Netflix vs Disney+, HBO Max or basically any other streaming service at this point, which proves that it's not actually that hard of a problem, at least today. I'm sure they were very innovative when they pioneered streaming but this is 2024. I'm sure their tech is better in multiple ways, but not in ways that actually lead to an edge, or is even noticeable to consumers. Now it's all about what content they have.

For comparison, I can tell a MacBook is better than a Windows laptop in 100 different ways. I can tell that the touch screen UI and self driving features in a Tesla is 15 years ahead a Toyota, but I cannot tell Netflix is better than its competitors.

martindbp··on Investors are suddenly getting concerned that AI isn't making any serious money
? Why wouldn't you want to automate tasks?

Current level AI will be able to automate quite a bit, it just takes time to proliferate, there is a lot of inertia in organizations.

martindbp··on Children should be allowed to get bored (2013)
> My theory is that every person in this thread who thinks this is simple doesn’t have children.

As always. "Why don't you just..."

Minecraft has been great for my 6 year old, learning fluent English etc, but I have to be very active in enforcing rules, especially around Minecraft YouTubers (only British, they tend to build advanced machinery and explain well).

But anything can turn into an addiction. Recently he wanted to do Duolingo to learn intermediate English, but now I get the sense he does it to get "allowed" screen time and doesn't actually learn much.

It's very nuanced. I want to provide screen time because we're nerds and you need to spend time with technology to learn about it, but there are way more distractions than when I was a kid, and our home computer didn't even have internet.

martindbp··on China's Banking System Headed for Crisis, Reports Say
And when the insurance companies fail due to heavy unforseen losses?
martindbp··on 10% of Cubans left Cuba between 2022 and 2023
> With 1m people leaving in a year, it clearly has its issues - but lots of the comments here are a good example of how your country's media and propaganda can significantly colour your opinions.

What? 10% of a country leaving in one year tells you what Cubans think of Cuba. That's not propaganda, that's fact. On the contrary, it seems like you have some kind of preconceived notion of that life in Cuba is in fact not that bad (poor but laid back perhaps?), but if that were true people would not leave would they?

martindbp··on I am sick of LeetCode-style interviews
It's also a great way to filter out anyone who has any kind of commitment like kids, aging parents to take care of, or have health issues themselves that makes it hard to cram leet code non stop on top of a busy career.

For companies this is very rational, you want non-distracted employees who can work over time.

martindbp··on Helen Keller on her life before self-consciousness (1908)
Thanks, I'll check it out, it's a fascinating topic and can probably teach us how we can make AI think (or how it does think).
martindbp··on Helen Keller on her life before self-consciousness (1908)
Yeah, most things lend themselves to visualizing, but even things that don't I have to visualize something, the answer doesn't just come to me unless I have something to look at if that makes sense.

Let me ask, when you decide what to eat for dinner, how do you arrive at the answer? I visualize what's in the fridge, what I can cook with the ingredients. Or if I want to eat out I visualize our neighborhood like Google Maps and look around at the different options.

When I'm solving an algorithmic problem I visualize the data, spatially if possible otherwise just as text, lists or vectors. It's like I'm using a notebook but it's faster and a bit more fuzzy.

martindbp··on We need 70% less coders as the AI handles most of the coding
Most coding is not rocket science, just drudgery. Still, 7/10 implies some very junior level tasks.
martindbp··on Helen Keller on her life before self-consciousness (1908)
Is this the norm? I can have an internal dialog but I mainly visualize things, I'd say that 90% of my thinking is visual. I'm not even sure how you'd solve, for instance, an algorithmic problem without visualizing the process. Maybe this is why I feel like a slower thinker than most peers, answers just seem to come them while I have to visualize things first. In college I'd generally take longer than the fast smart people but end up doing slightly better in the end, which always puzzled me. I have terrible memory for facts though.
martindbp··on A Grand Unified Theory of the AI Hype Cycle
Hype or not, evaluate the tech for what it is. Just because there's too much hype doesn't invalidate the tech. The hype is directionally correct, although the magnitude may be off.

Or maybe not. We have very smart AI/RL researchers claiming AGI in 2-5 years. Dismissing this could be the same as dismissing the nuclear bomb in 1942. Maybe there's one or several missing components, but just like physics can predict a nuclear chain reaction, scaling laws show empirically what happens when you add more data, more compute and increase the model size. Pair that with Moore's law and that's why AI researchers are so confident we haven't plateaued.

martindbp··on A Grand Unified Theory of the AI Hype Cycle
I just don't understand how you can look at the current state of AI and the rate of progress and think "this is just like the expert systems hype". "Just a pile of linear algebra", "just curve fitting", "just a stochastic parrot". I've never liked these kinds of arguments which is essentially reasoning through analogy instead of through first principles.
martindbp··on We are a step closer to taxing the super-rich
I know this is controversial, but here's my take: self made rich people live in reality. Whatever ideas they have about reality will be tested relentlessly, otherwise they wouldn't have succeeded at business. Government bureaucrats however do not live in reality. They live in lala-land where they spend other people's money. Who knows how they got to the point where they can make the choice of how money and resources are spent, but whatever it is, the actions they take is never really checked against reality. There is no competition between government agencies where badly run ones are allowed to fail. For that reason alone, self made rich people are on average much better at spending money wisely, as we've seen with for example the Gates foundation.
martindbp··on Discussion: Job seekers can't find a job and Employers can't find an employees
Maybe it's similar to Tinder. In the past you got a few local applicants and you made your pick, but now you get hundred of applicants, so you narrow your requirements while probably filtering out good matches, just like girls who filter on 6 feet tall and six figures.
martindbp··on Eco-brutalism: when angular concrete meets the wonder of nature
It's certainly an acquired taste
martindbp··on The Natural Selection of Bad Vibes
You don't think everyone saying they don't want kids because "I don't want to bring a child into this world" is making a moral statement?
martindbp··on Eco-brutalism: when angular concrete meets the wonder of nature
I want to dislike brutalism and generally prefer older European architecture, but after seeing a brutalist library on a sand beach in China I kind of learned to like it. Maybe it was the surrounding nature in combination with it that made it click. It's located in a gated community that has several brutalist structures: https://www.domusweb.it/en/architecture/2018/11/16/china-cha...
martindbp··on The Natural Selection of Bad Vibes
I think, in particular the younger generations, have been let to believe that being pessimistic about the state of the world and it's future is some kind of moral virtue.
martindbp··on 38% of webpages that existed in 2013 are no longer accessible a decade later
I have one of those catalogs from 1996 with an index of web pages for different topics. Maybe I should scan it and do the same experiment
martindbp··on Tesla's self-driving tech ditched by 98 percent of customers that tried it
Except according to Elon Musk on X "It's way higher than 2%. Please"

Before you retort with "Musk lies", this is a very specific claim and not a prediction, and would land him in legal trouble as said by an CEO of a public company.

As always anything touching Tesla in the media is extremely biased, like this headline.

martindbp··on Elicit – AI Research Assistant
Unfortunately, AI could lead to more verbose everything, because it also enables us to distil huge amounts of text. Forgot where I read about this, but it has been shown that digitalization has enabled the tax code to go from something one person can read and understand to something completely unmanageable (could be from The Utopia of Rules: On Technology, Stupidity, and the Secret Joys of Bureaucracy), because digital tools allows us to deal with more tax code. Similarly, doctors, teachers and many other occupations are drowning in administration duties that were enabled by digital technology.

I hope I'm wrong. Eventually, when only AI produces and consumes text, it could be more brief, but at that point will it matter? Eventually a less ambiguous format could be used, something more like code, that computers and AI can consume and apply.

martindbp··on Player-Driven Emergence in LLM-Driven Game Narrative
LLMs need to either be extremely good with insane context or LLM output has to be conditioned by and translated into formal logic, like Prolog or Datalog to make sure it's compatible with the rules and state of the world, and determine which effect player and NPC actions have on the world.
martindbp··on Woodworking as an escape from the absurdity of software
8 hours is a long time to be bored every day.
martindbp··on mRNA Cancer Vaccine Reprograms Immune System to Tackle Glioblastoma in 48 Hours
Capitalism and technology will make it cheaper over time, if we just let it. Africans without reliable electricity has magic pocket devices straight out of Star Trek. We can find a way to make personalized medicine dirt cheap too, but you can't force it through legislation.
martindbp··on Lawsuits test Tesla claim that drivers are solely responsible for crashes
What do you think would have happened to the automobile if Ford had to take liability for every accident? There will be a few years when FSD is worse than human drivers, and then it will be super human. But to get there you need data. Or you can go the slow route of Waymo, but delay this technology by 5 years and you've killed a great number of people, probably thousands. 40k die in car accidents every year in the US, only a handful of them are ADAS-related. Not only that, but Tesla releases statistics that show cars using autopilot have fewer accidents than those who don't. There may be issues with the data, but it's clear that it's not significantly worse.
martindbp··on Lawsuits test Tesla claim that drivers are solely responsible for crashes
Maybe just FSD.
martindbp··on Lawsuits test Tesla claim that drivers are solely responsible for crashes
By nagging every 30 seconds and giving you a strike against the account if you look away for more than a few seconds. Older cars dont have a cabin camera, but the nags for newer vehicles are frequent. At some point you have to give liability to the end user or we can't have ADAS anymore. Which means we'll delay self driving for personal vehicles for many years, costing thousands of lives every year.
martindbp··on What can LLMs never do?
It's clear that what's missing is flexibility and agency. For anything that can be put into text or a short conversation, and I'd have to chose between access to ChatGPT or a random human, I know what I'd chose.
martindbp··on Chinese students in US tell of 'chilling' interrogations and deportations
Yeah, I was there for three months right before the end of restrictions. Not very excited to go back after that.
martindbp··on Chinese students in US tell of 'chilling' interrogations and deportations
I wonder how much of that is due to Covid, but I remember some stat like the number of people learning Chinese since 2008 was down at least 50% even before Covid, and that includes people studying in their home country.
← PreviousPage 3 of 17Next →