HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

martythemaniak

11,234 karma · joined February 26, 2007

submissionscomments
martythemaniak··on SpaceX Pulls Employees from Brazil, Discourages Travel There
There's a lot of comments in here repeating Musk's "out of control judge" line. FYI: the original ruling has been upheld by the wider court: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/article/2024/sep/02/b...
martythemaniak··on OpenAI is good at unminifying code
You should give it a try and report back! One easy way would be to take an open-source Android app, compile the APK, then decompile it and feed the bytecode to an LLM and ask it to write the java/kotlin equivalent and compare the source and LLM decoded one.
martythemaniak··on French prosecutors say Telegram CEO freed from custody, will appear in court
Some credit reports that Durov travelled to Russia more than 60 times between 2014 and 2021. https://x.com/YaroslavAzhnyuk/status/1828498176854385111

Honest question for this group: Does anyone actually believe Telegram has any sort of privacy? Like, I assume all your TG data is available to the Kremlin in the same way that all your TikTok data is available to the CCP.

martythemaniak··on A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar (2021)
That version gave you the ability to customize the bottom bar. You can still put that same icon in the same stop if that's what you want.
martythemaniak··on Figure 02 – the most advanced AI hardware
Well, nobody can answer that question because humanoids don't exist. That is, the only way to get that answer is to actually try it out.

Broadly speaking, humanoid robots like this should be the "worse is better" kind of tech. They're cheap ($20-30k at scale or like $1/hr), imprecise (cm vs mm), weak (manipulate several kg) and flexible. The question is where in the factory can you take advantage of this kind of labour or can you redesign your process to take advantage of it.

martythemaniak··on Partisan bot-like accounts continue to amplify divisive content on X
Ironically, the number one reason I don't use Threads is because it's full of Musk content. Every time I open it, there's multiple posts about some bad shit he's done, how cybertrucks are terrible etc etc. I have Musk and tons of Musk-adjacent accounts blocked on Twitter so I get a Musk-free experience there, but it is increasingly hard to find the nuggets of good content in the sea of crap.
martythemaniak··on SpaceX in talks to land and recover Starship rocket off Australia's coast
One thing I haven't seen any discussion of - what happened to the IFT-4 starship? It landed in the Indian Ocean and just sank? But that thing has six of the world's most advanced rocket engines, if you're China or India why wouldn't you salvage that?
martythemaniak··on Why Americans aren't having babies
Just ask yourself: what level of effort was required from your parents, especially your dad, to raise you? What about the effort required from your grandparents to raise your parents?

We all know it takes a much greater amount of effort to raise a kid today because our standards are so much higher, which is particularly true of fathers. You could be a "good dad" in the 80s if you only beat your children in response to them doing something bad versus randomly beating them when you got black out drunk. I would definitely say that dogs today receive a higher standards of care (nutrition, toys, doctor visits, training) than children did in the 50s.

martythemaniak··on TSMC rides AI demand to raise revenue forecast, says no to US joint venture
> That would be geopolitical suicide

Yeah, but's only true if you believe in the American-led world order and organizations like NATO. We know Trump either doesn't care or is actively hostile (he loves to threaten pull out of NATO and things like that).

There should be no doubt that he'll pull all support for Ukraine on Day 1. Ukraine will survive because they're already fighting and will still have the support of Europe, though that won't be enough to win. Taiwan will be actively pressured to capitulate without a shot. It will be "fine" the way Hong Kong is "fine".

martythemaniak··on Electric Vehicle Batteries Surprising New Source of 'Forever Chemical' Pollution
Example #4,928,422,857 of people's inability to think about rapidly changing quantities.
martythemaniak··on Batteries: How cheap can they get?
Current prices are kinda nutty and are largely determined by the size of your buy. Retail prices for home batteries (a few kWhs) are roughly $1000/kWh. A Model 3 gets you about $700/kWh (with two free motors and an ipad). A Tesla megapack is $290/kWh, but you have to spend $1000000 to get that price. Tesla probably gets cells from the factory at round $80-$90/kWh.

Long-term it seems pretty reasonable that retail prices should be a small multiple of the factory price (which keeps decreasing), so I think $1000 for a 20kWh battery is totally reasonable.

martythemaniak··on Ask HN: Those of you who've left the SWE world, what did you transition into?
> I've been an EM, which might arguably be the most miserable position that exists. I've been senior/staff at places, and honestly I just don't enjoy arguing about the structure of software anymore, I'm tired of the personalities,

> My strengths revolve around people and strategy

These don't seem to jive. EM or Staff is about as much people and strategy you get.

martythemaniak··on TikTok says US ban is inevitable without a court order blocking law
It's a CCP ban, not a TikTok ban. TikTok can continue to do exactly what they've been doing, just without the CCP oversight, control and reporting.
martythemaniak··on Canada imposes 5% tax on streaming to fund local news, diverse content
I agree with the general shittyness of these comments, but they're probably real people. Whenever Canadian politics makes an appearance here, it's a combination of ignorant foreigners projecting their own local politics without any context, or groups like the convoyers or Ontario Proud spewing their usual garbage.
martythemaniak··on Noam Chomsky 'no longer able to talk' after 'medical event'
> The Russia-Ukraine crisis continues unabated as the United States ignores all of Russian President Vladmir Putin’s security demands and spreads a frenzy of fear by claiming that a Russian invasion of Ukraine is imminent.

> February 4, 2022

https://chomsky.info/20220204/

Questions of human conflict are incredibly complex, but occasionally life gives you a freebie. Occasionally, things actually are black and white, there are good guys and bad guys and you should not support the bad guys. If you had trouble getting this one absolutely dead simple case right, maybe you should not bother having an opinion on these matters at all.

martythemaniak··on OpenAI Welcomes Sarah Friar (CFO) and Kevin Weil (CPO)
The thing with Linda is that while she's theoretically the boss, and Musk reports to her as CTO/CPO everybody knows that Musk is the boss and she's there to... sell ads? Actually I don't know what she's supposed to do, but it doesn't matter, she's certainly not allowed to touch either the product or the technology and Musk can fire her at any point as owner/chairman.

This, OTOH is a just a simple straightforward C-Suite. Sam is the boss, and he hired two reports to handle areas where they have expertise. This might be the simplest corporate thing OpenAI has ever done, lol.

martythemaniak··on Canadians are angry with their biggest supermarket
There are tons of small-to-medium sized grocery stores with a strong ethnic focus and a focus on prices. You don't hear about them because they one-offs and not a national chain.
martythemaniak··on Largest Autonomous Ride-Hail Territory in US Now Even Larger
What you see in those cars is not FSD, but Autopilot that comes with every car. Autopilot is lane keeping + traffic aware cruise control plus a few small features like green light chimes and speed sign detection.

FSD looks very different and you can see everything in the road and what the car is planning to do. There's some good YouTube channels where they test different versions of FSD in different situations, AIDRIVR does a good job, eg https://youtu.be/rMDNFLsXFEU?si=SHWAm24ZY3psnO4Z&t=136. Nice thing about those channels is you can also look at old videos and see the rate of improvement.

I had FSD for one month on my car and it was really impressive. There were plenty of disengagements, but they were all what I'd call "quality of life" issues. Car was too hesitant during blind lefts, or advanced lefts, car slowed down too much for speed bumps, it got into turn-only lanes later than I'd like, etc, etc. The hardest part of driving in my town is a 3 lane roundabout where upon exiting the roundabout you have to very quickly and confidently change 2 lanes in order to get on the highway, it handled it with ease. Overall, I would not buy it today, but didn't see any reason why they can't solve the issues I saw.

martythemaniak··on Largest Autonomous Ride-Hail Territory in US Now Even Larger
Is it possible you were similarly mistaken about FSD?
martythemaniak··on How Waymo outlasted the competition and made robo-taxis a real business
Indeed, cameras are absolutely necessary for self-driving. They're the only ones that can read lane markings, signs, etc. LIDAR alone is not sufficient - you cannot navigate the roads using nothing but an unlabled 3D scene. It simply does not have the necessary information for you to drive ie, is that hexagonal sign a STOP or a GO, pretty important bit of info.

So the question is: is LIDAR also necessary or are cameras sufficient? IE, can cameras+motion give you an accurate-enough 3D scene the way LIDAR can. And that's a narrow technical question, and it isn't even the most question when you consider self-driving as a whole.

"LIDAR is necessary" is not exclusively a Waymo talking point - it is shared by all companies using LIDAR, suppliers of LIDAR etc. But it is just a talking point, there's no reason to think it's actually true.

martythemaniak··on How Waymo outlasted the competition and made robo-taxis a real business
Please re-read this part of my post:

> Say you're driving down the road and there's a bit of construction, there's a guy holding SLOW/STOP sign directing traffic.

Here's a picture of a guy holding a hexagonal SLOW sign. They are very common. https://nj1015.com/how-slow-should-you-go-through-constructi...

LIDAR cannot tell you what's on that sign. It cannot read any sign, nor any road markings, nor streetlights, blinkers, stop lights, etc. If you believe that cameras are not capable of being used as input due to dynamic range or any other reason, then that's fine, you just believe that self-driving is impossible (lidar or not). But to believe that one can safely drive using nothing but a completely blank and unlabeled 3D scene (ie, LIDAR-only)? That's pretty crazy.

martythemaniak··on How Waymo outlasted the competition and made robo-taxis a real business
I think a lot of people have uncritically been repeating Waymo's marketing talking points for so long they've started mistaking it for "consensus" or even worse "truth". Waymo's tech is impressive and it works, but that doesn't mean it is the only way to make it work. The Tesla/Waymo approaches are far far more alike than they are different, so the whole debate is about very little.

The question of Camera vs LIDAR+Camera is a narrow technical question about how to construct a 3D scene. That's it. It says nothing about making sense of this 3D world for which you you have a 3D point cloud and it says nothing about how to actually navigate that world. Say you're driving down the road and there's a bit of construction, there's a guy holding SLOW/STOP sign directing traffic. LIDAR will tell you it's a hexagonal sign, but it can't tell you what it says, you need a camera to read the sign and tell you what it says. It doesn't tell you how to drive, how fast you should go, how much space to give the guy with the sign etc. Everything AV-related which is not constructing a 3D scene is actually the same across all AV stacks, which includes the hardest part - the actual driving itself.

martythemaniak··on 300k airplanes in five years
What's funny is that right as you were typing out your bullshit, an ATACMS strike took out a S400 battery in Donetsk. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ikgDkf4ATEo

This is the Block I ATACMS which stopped production in 1996 and is considered too old to be usable by the US Army itself. Mean while the Patriots have no issues taking out multiple "hypersonic" missiles, which are mostly just marketing bullshit.

martythemaniak··on 300k airplanes in five years
Nope, the USSR's efforts were also the result of US's industrial and financial output. Here's an essay to get you started: https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1505247886908424195.html
martythemaniak··on [dead]
What the mainstream media won't tell you is that the pilot was a Mossad agent named Eli Copter.
martythemaniak··on CFPB Takes Action Against Coding Boot Camp BloomTech and CEO Austen Allred
VCs would improve their public image if they took the occasional L.
martythemaniak··on End of an era: Final Delta IV heavy rocket carries NROL-70 on historic mission
Wikipedia says NRO launches are $440m, so the price difference is really really big, which is the reason why this is the last launch - not even the US Government has that kinda cash for launches.

The other reason is there's a lag of several years between when a capability is established (Falcon Heavy) and when large customers can take advantage of it. For example, we really shouldn't expect Starship to make a dent in way satellites and telescopes are designed and built until the 2030s.

martythemaniak··on The baffling intelligence of a single cell: The story of E. coli chemotaxis
I find this to be an incredibly bizarre thing to say. Nobody is stopping you from thinking anything, of course you're allowed and surely you know this very well.

I suspect what you're really saying is "Will you still respect me for being a creationist". And the answer is, LOL of course not. Nobody is entitled to have their wacky ideas be respected. A lot of the "free speech" complaints are really demands that other people treat your bullshit with respect, which is an absurd demand.

But if my suspicion above is way off, please tell me. I am curious why anyone would say what you said.

martythemaniak··on Paris preserves its mixed society by pouring billions into public housing
Maybe the reason people accuse you of being "racist/classist/luddite" is because you're fearmongering, and they suspect these talking points are just a cover for looking out for your financial interest (keep increasing property prices), or keeping your community free from "others" or something.

Why is this fearmongering? Because your figures are wildly, wildly out of touch with reality. If you legalize quadplexes by right, you're not going to magically see a doubling of housing, there just aren't that many people! That is completely made up bullshit. Fast growing place have growth rates in the low single digits, like 2%/a, not 50%. Growth projections for fast growing regions like the Toronto area have 50% growth projections on the scale of decades. But "If we legalize quadplexes, our 100 home with turn into 102 home next years and there'll be one extra car" just doesn't have the same zing and it's hard to keep the housing crisis going with realistic complaints.

martythemaniak··on Countries That Close Gender Gaps See Substantial Growth Returns
Why would that lead to fewer kids?
← PreviousPage 9 of 34Next →