HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mattstocum

145 karma · joined June 2, 2013

submissionscomments
mattstocum··on Questions about Cameron’s ‘new’ porn-blocking
Snuff films face uproar because they depict actual murder, not simulated. I'm not arguing it should be legal to sell video of an actual rape.
mattstocum··on Questions about Cameron’s ‘new’ porn-blocking
>it is a scene where a sapient, intelligent being subjugates a 'lesser' creature using a sexual organ for their own goals

If you take out the "sexual organ" (I partially disagree with that term as it is also used for the transfer of thoughts) how is this any different than a human riding a horse? In both situations you have a sapient, intelligent being subjugating a "lesser" creature for their own goals.

mattstocum··on Questions about Cameron’s ‘new’ porn-blocking
> Considering the film Avatar literally has what can only be considered an animal rape scene

First, have you ever seen two animals have sex? It's almost always what humans would call rape. Second, the "animal rape" scene isn't any more rape than a human riding a horse is (I'm assuming you're referring to the Navi riding the dragon things). It depicted an activity that was normal for those species in their culture.

mattstocum··on Questions about Cameron’s ‘new’ porn-blocking
I agree there's clearly room for nuance, but there always is. No law should ever be treated as black or white, that's why we have prosecutorial discretion, judges, and juries.
mattstocum··on Questions about Cameron’s ‘new’ porn-blocking
> but to deny it could solve problems at all requires evidence

No, to make something illegal, you should have to prove that it is harmful. There is no proof that rape porn is harmful. You can't just throw out a hypothesis and then say "prove me wrong". That's not how science works, and it's not how law should either.

mattstocum··on Questions about Cameron’s ‘new’ porn-blocking
How is rape porn any different than watching violent movies? Both depict illegal acts. Why is one okay, but the other not? The act of rape is illegal, why isn't that enough?
mattstocum··on Questions about Cameron’s ‘new’ porn-blocking
And we know it's the sexualized imagery and not the violent imagery that led to violent attitudes.
mattstocum··on Questions about Cameron’s ‘new’ porn-blocking
If the law made it illegal to posses images or video of an ACTUAL rape, I'd agree with it 100% (I hope this already is illegal). If it's a simulation made by two consenting adults, where's the harm? I find Justin Bieber to be "deeply offensive", why can't he be outlawed?
mattstocum··on Why Is Netflix Secretly Cropping Movies?
The linked Wikipedia article is mistaken in stating that pan and scan applies only to 4:3. The same technique can, and often is, used to prevent letterboxing when showing a films shot at 2.35:1 on a 16:9 display.
mattstocum··on Why Is Netflix Secretly Cropping Movies?
That's just pan and scan from a 2.35:1 source to 16:9. It's actually quite common. "Normal" people hate seeing black bars on their TV, some even more on their fancy new widescreen HDTV. The big problem here is that pan and scan jobs look particularly shitty, as if they were just blew up the center and cropped the edges.
mattstocum··on Snowden withdraws Russian asylum bid after Putin says he must 'stop harming' US
I think what air was saying is that in the US, propaganda, of any sort, cannot be a crime, due to the 1st amendment to the US constitution. That is freedom of speech.
mattstocum··on A 17 Year Old with Severe Autism and His Six Completed Coursera Courses
"Even more limiting, he is dependent on an adult to bring him to the task, keep him working on it, and hold his hand while he spells."

It's, sadly, nothing more than facilitated communication.

mattstocum··on A 17 Year Old with Severe Autism and His Six Completed Coursera Courses
It is done with a computer, in this case it appears to be an iPad. The problem is you have a facilitator, "steadying" the hand of the person who is communicating. In reality, the facilitator is actually guiding the person's hand, most likely without being aware of it themselves. It's easy to see why parents believe this method works. If you had a non-communicative child, and were suddenly told, just by pointing at this board, your child can talk to you, and his first words are, "I love you dad," you'd want to believe that more than anything else.
mattstocum··on A 17 Year Old with Severe Autism and His Six Completed Coursera Courses
"Not scientifically validated," is being awfully generous. It doesn't work, plain and simple. The facilitator is the one responding in 100% of cases.

You not only can see the father guiding his hand, but Daniel isn't even looking at the board. I would challenge anyone to respond to a question by poking at an iPad, without looking, while someone else holds their hand.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2