HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

maybewhenthesun

531 karma · joined September 12, 2025

submissionscomments
maybewhenthesun··on GIMP Development Update
I like it that the scruffy teenager hacker mentality is preserved in the name. It was also a bit of self deprecating humour at the time, because using Gimp instead of Photoshop did make you feel crippled a bit.

I hope they never give in to the corporate-lawyer induced bland-washing .

maybewhenthesun··on Godot will no longer accept AI-authored code contributions
Dingdingding, we have a winner. The main use of such a policy is to be able to just close those giant wall-of-text PRs and have something to point to when people start to scream it's not fair.
maybewhenthesun··on European digital ID wallets rely on safety services of Google and Apple
19th century begs to differ.

A better answer would be 'not always'.

The proposed regulations forcing everybody to use google or apple are ridiculous and very much the opposite of the kind of regulations we need though...

maybewhenthesun··on European digital ID wallets rely on safety services of Google and Apple
I don't think so. Because the theories about elastic markets and monopolies do have a high 'spherical frictionless cow` smell. And they are posed here as gospel. So while it might be a bit of an ad hominem to frame someone as a 120 year old it does succinctly point out a problem and hence adds information.
maybewhenthesun··on World Capitals Voronoi
Very nice.

I guess most dutchies would disagree with the decision to pick De Hague as the Main Capital, though :-)

While all power is in De Hague , Amsterdam definitely is the Capital. De Hague is for complaining about, Amsterdam is for celebrating.

maybewhenthesun··on Voxel Space (2017)
Still, it was called voxel rendering back then. Not technically correct, sure, but it sounded as cool as it looked!
maybewhenthesun··on Bttf is a command line datetime Swiss army knife
exactly. and chromium is a good looking space shooter with too few levels!
maybewhenthesun··on Google changes its search box
I strongly disagree. Altavista had exactly the same function as google, but with worse results. Both linked to original sources. Early google had a very good idea with pagerank and that payed off.

An llm rephrashing / regurgitating other websites is imo different, because you loose the direct connection to the original source. Even if llms give sources they also directly give you a plausible (but unreliable) answer to your question. They are right often enough that you get lulled in to the false sense of security of not needing to read the original sites. I'd much prefer them to just give a clean list of sources like early google, but then why would you need an llm.

It's a pity that probably the main reason you'll need an llm to find anything on the web is to weed out all the llm-generated low quality garbage.

maybewhenthesun··on Google changes its search box
Google search has been over for a few years already.

Nearly all other search engines give better results with less annoying ads at the top. First thing I do when installing a new browser is switch the default search engine to duckduckgo. Duckduckgo's results are less good than google used to be, bu way better than google currently is.

maybewhenthesun··on Belgium stops decommissioning nuclear power plants
> what has fukushima to do with storing nuclear waste.

They had (still have I think) a rather nasty problem with storing lots of contaminated water in leaking containers on the Fukushima site. Storing nuclear waste might be 'easy' when stuff goes as planned. I still think it's completely unrealistic to think you can store something for thousands of years. I'm quite glad the ancient egyptians didn't stash caches of plutonium in various places, for example.

>Better reactors were already invented

Better reactors are invented. But as Belgium's crumbling reactors show (and Fukushima, obv.), people are hesitant to spend money on actually building those.

A theoretical better reactor is nice, but you can't just handwave reality away. And the reality is that there are lots of practical risks in the practical application of nuclear power. Mainly because of politics, maybe. But still that's reality.

We need nuclear, but we should strive to use something better in the end.

maybewhenthesun··on Belgium stops decommissioning nuclear power plants
When a debater makes a lot of bad points, extrapolating to be suspicious of any point he makes is not and ad-hominem.

And ad hominem is when you dismiss his points because he might have done something immoral in a completely unrelated field.

maybewhenthesun··on Googlebook
I like the top panel in gnome. You need a place for your clock and you status icons. I don't really care much if it's at the top or bottom or sides.

As an aside: From a 'clickability' perspective the app menus in the top bar are nice of course and I theoretically agree that's the best place for an app menu. But in practice I really dislike macos' 'separated' app menus when a window is not maximized.

maybewhenthesun··on I'm scared about biological computing
But how do you know it's not conscious? It's a very poorly defined concept.

I know various people that to this day say that fish do not feel pain (because they want to catch them with a hook through their mouth without feeling guilty). That seems a ridiculous notion to me, as pain is extremely evolutionary useful and a fish displays all sorts of pain-like behaviour when hooked. But still, since we can't really look inside the fish' mind people can make themselves believe they don't feel pain.

If you ask the right AI if it's conscious, it's very well possible it will say yes. Because it was trained on the world literature maybe and behaves as learned. Is there a difference with us? I'm not so sure.

To me it's kinda weird the ethical implications for striving for AGI are so little talked about.

maybewhenthesun··on I'm scared about biological computing
People having been saying for aeons that consciousness originates in the (mammalian) cortex and not in the brainstem. To justify killing all sorts of animals ;-)

The whole thing makes one thing extremely clear: people are very good at moving goalposts. We've blasted past the 'turing test' for all practical purposes, but we moved the definition of 'true intelligence'. Consciousness and intelligence have long seen as higly correlated or even the same thing. But now we have need of a separation between the two.

If we eventually (we're not there yet, I think) create a true intelligent AI it will probably be a long time before people will accept that creating an intelligent being probably means it should have 'rights' as well.

We're definitely not there yet, but at what point does turning off an AI become the same as killing a being? I think that's not being talked about enough. Sure LLMs are just prediction engines. But so are we. Our brains are prediction engines tuned by evolution to do the best possible prediction of the near future to maximize survival. We are definitely conscious. But a housefly, is that conscious? What makes the difference? it's hard to tell.

Otoh, an AI has no evolutionary reason to have the concept of fear/suffering so maybe it's more like the douglas adams creature that doesn't mind to be killed?

maybewhenthesun··on Belgium stops decommissioning nuclear power plants
My experience is that politicians tend to hand-wave this problem away, while physicists and geologists acknowledge the problem and actually think about it.

So imo not really a political problem.

maybewhenthesun··on Belgium stops decommissioning nuclear power plants
I know it's not a green ooze. But thinking it is possible to store something safely for >10000 years is just wishful thinking. The waste is a lot more dangerous than the uranium we dug out and packaging it in a way where you are sure it won't surface for sure is really not a solved problem.

> Nuclear waste is small and solid

As long as all goes well. Fukushima has a slightly different experience.

> You can just bury it deep in a mountain, which is where you extracted the uranium from in the first place.

Imo it's stupid to put nuclear waste in a place where you can't get at it anymore. In the ideal case we invent better reactors where you recycle all radioactive parts as usable fuel and the output is truly 'spent'.

I don't disagree with you that the pros of nuclear (as opposed to fossil) outweigh the cons. But there are cons, and eventually we'd be better off harvesting our energy from the sun.

maybewhenthesun··on Belgium stops decommissioning nuclear power plants
The engineering side might be a theoretically solved problem, anybody looking at belgium's crumbling nuclear powerplants can help but feeling slightly nervous!

I agree we probably need nuclear to bridge the gap until solar or wind can take over fully, but there are a lot of problems with nuclear and the most pressing ones are connected to the unwillingness of people to spend money before a disaster happens.

On top of that, uranium is a limited resource, it's extraction is (energetically) expensive and dirty and the storage of the nuclear waste is very far from a solved engineering problem. Storing safely stuff for thousands of years is just not a realistic scenario whatsoever.

All this is not to say we should just skip on nuclear power altogether, we can't afford that I think and burning all the fossil fuels will probably have more disastrous consequences. But we shouldn't close out eyes to the problems either.

maybewhenthesun··on For Linux kernel vulnerabilities, there is no heads-up to distributions
It might be a scared cow, but at least deservedly so. There is imho a difference between accidental incompetence (debatable, even) and active malice. Microsoft has done a lot of the latter so gets bashed more, nor surprise there.
maybewhenthesun··on For Linux kernel vulnerabilities, there is no heads-up to distributions
The problem is that the kernel devs (correctly imo) consider all bugfixes security fixes. So the distros need to decide for themselves which ones are important enough to warrant an update. Apparently this one had a quite unclear commit message, so it importance was missed.

Not ideal, but also: shit happens? It's always a balancing act choosing the lesser of multiple evils and most of the time it seems to work ok-ish, which is probably the best we can hope for ;-P

maybewhenthesun··on For Linux kernel vulnerabilities, there is no heads-up to distributions
The distros dropped the ball. imho. One of the (main) tasks of the distro is watching the changed of you upstream packages for important changes. This is slightly complicated by the fact that the linux kernel considers all bugfixes security fixes, so it's quite a lot to read it all. But that's life. The kernel developers are not wrong as it's nearly impossible to be sure a bug in the kernel is not (also) a security problem.
maybewhenthesun··on Windows 9x Subsystem for Linux
You can setup handlers to automatically launch windows executables using wine/proton .

This trickery is called binfmt_misc , which is a linux kernel system to associate random binary files with custom userspace 'interpreters'

I have had it working in the past. And while it is kinda neat I prefer manually running 'wine program.exe' to have a bit more control.

I have seen reports that a binfmt_misc setup + wine is good enough to get infected by certain windows viruses ;-P

maybewhenthesun··on Brussels launched an age checking app. Hackers took 2 minutes to break it
The problem here, and the source of OOPs annoyance I think, is that the governments of the constituting member states have the habit to present unpopular regulations as 'from Brussels' while taking credit for the popular things as from 'Den Haag','Berlin' or 'Paris' or whatever the local capital is. This habit is the main driver of anti-EU sentiments across the whole of europe. Which is a pity, mainly because it takes the attention away from highly needed reforms in the EU structures because people who could drive the reforms now just want out.

So while linguistically it's the same system as using 'Washington' or 'Moscow', Brussels is specifically in the bad spot where it gets blamed for impopular stuff but never praised for popular things.

maybewhenthesun··on NASA had to train Apollo 11's astronauts to not use profanity (2019)
The eufemism treadmill works bot ways. Eufemisms loose their politeness. Swearwords loose their strength (to be replaced by new ones). Language changes. I don't think people are inherently more rude and disrespectful.

"The children now love luxury; they have bad manners, contempt for authority; they show disrespect for elders and love chatter in place of exercise." - Socrates

maybewhenthesun··on NASA had to train Apollo 11's astronauts to not use profanity (2019)
The linguistics of swearwords are interesting I think. They need to be taboo or they don't work. A certain amount of offensiveness is needed for their function.

I think swearwords are very useful. Both when used of emphasis, comedy or (their original use) venting frustation or pain.

And they have secondary uses as well. When someone swears a lot in inappropriate situations you can tell they are generally inconsiderate persons. And when somebody gets very upset by swearwords you know they are probably overly religious. For both things it's nice the be forewarned ;-P

maybewhenthesun··on The local LLM ecosystem doesn’t need Ollama
exactly
maybewhenthesun··on The local LLM ecosystem doesn’t need Ollama
The second interpretation is nonsense of course. If you want GPL-like obligations, use the GPL.

A license is what it says in the license, nothing extra. It's a legal document not a moral guideline.

I do think it's a very good idea to always use the GPL (even though commercially minded types always get their panties in a bunch about the GPL) for any user-facing software, to force everybody to 'play fair and share'. The only reason to use MIT imho is for a library implementing some sort of standard where you want that standard used by as many people as possible.

I don't understand people who use MIT for their project and then complain some commercial firm takes their contributions and runs with it. If that's not what you want don't use that license.

Apart from license terms and moral obligations being a bad mix, companies don't have morals. Don't get me wrong, I think they should have! But they don't.

People have morals. Groups of people (a company, a country , a mob) not so much. Sadly.

maybewhenthesun··on Light on Glass: Why do you start making a game engine?
Agreed a 100% CRTS were wobbly flickery mess. Especially in the 60Hz era. Everyhting below 90Hz on a crt gave me horrible migraines when working longer than 4 hours.

LCDs that were just constantly lit were so much easier on the eyes than a CRT where every bright pixel is flashing at 60Hz.

But one thing is true: a low res game designed to look good on a CRT looks much worse on a low res LCD. CRTs being a blurry mess gave you free 'antialiasing'.

maybewhenthesun··on “Your frustration is the product”
Ok, point taken. I've heard very different numbers for dutch newspapers and blindly extrapolated that to the US. And if the numbers are like that than maybe the numbers I heard about dutch newspapers are bullshit too, who knows!
maybewhenthesun··on Denmark was reportedly preparing for full-scale war with the US over Greenland
ok, the I apparently read different threads. Which is very well possible of course.
maybewhenthesun··on An update on Steam / GOG changes for OpenTTD
No. Or maybe yes (with the current US government the end of the world is quite easy to imagine... )

But what I can imagine has very little to do with what actually happens.

← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →