HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mbakke

2,258 karma · joined June 5, 2015

I am an infrastructure engineer who enjoys building high performance systems. I also spend a lot of my spare time working on GNU Guix.

https://github.com/mbakke

submissionscomments
mbakke··on OpenBSD 7.4
Aww, I was most excited about the release song! Is it not happening anymore?
mbakke··on Using OpenBSD Relayd(8) as an Application Layer Gateway
> Scaling is rumored to be a wall most OpenBSD products hit at some point

I suspect the vast majority of OpenBSD users never hit a "scaling wall". What do you mean by product?

In a previous life I installed two OpenBSD routers with a 10GbE card each. With carp(4) they could push nearly 20Gbps total. This was back in 2015 or so.

"Scaling" would just be matter of adding more nodes, or replace with 40GbE cards (which would require a more powerful CPU).

Perhaps running a high traffic relayd on them would have reduced the throughput. But that smells like poor architecture: let routers be routers and load balancers be load balancers :)

mbakke··on Using OpenBSD Relayd(8) as an Application Layer Gateway
For those of us not currently at an OpenBSD console, the man pages can be browsed on-line here:

https://man.openbsd.org/man8/relayd.8

https://man.openbsd.org/man8/relayctl.8

https://man.openbsd.org/man5/relayd.conf.5

Side note, I haven't heard failover used in the context of kicking unhealthy backends before. Failover is typically something that would be implemented with carp(4) (aka VRRP, but with support for active/active setups) on two different machines running relayd.

https://man.openbsd.org/man4/carp.4

Nothing beats the sheer elegance of OpenBSD for networking tasks. :-)

mbakke··on Disney packed big emotion into a little robot
> The ability to generate emotion exists within the imageo and not the observed

I was thinking the exact same thing while pondering the parents assertion.

Qualia is just the notion of being something. The classic example is a bat: what is the qualitative experience of being nearly blind, but having wings and a highly accurate echolocation system?

Plants too have qualia. What is it like to be a tree. To feel the nurture of the sun, the change in seasons, and to heal a broken branch.

The qualia of a stone is less exciting, but we can still imagine being a dense pack of minerals. Perhaps rolling down a mountain and losing some weight. Suddenly finding ourselves on the ocean floor, drifting aimlessly, while providing cover and nutrition to all sorts of life. After staying stationary for thousands of years.

That rock has seen things, man!

Down at the atom level things get more excited. What is the qualitative experience of interacting with other atoms? Or a photon? Of being entangled? State transitions?

Anyway. It's clear to me that this robot absolutely has qualia. I can imagine what it's like to be be a circuit board, with an operating system, a bunch of sensors, a neural processing engine, and a hard shell. How it feels.

It makes me appreciate being human more. But also evokes empathy for that adorable lump of silicon, metals, and plastics. Don't let the GP comment bring you down, little one. You are perfect just as you are.

mbakke··on Ask HN: How do you tell if something has a keylogger implemented
That is now a solved problem thanks to GNU Mes and M2-planet:

https://joyofsource.com/the-full-source-bootstrap-building-f...

And will gradually become a non issue as distros incorporate it (or more likely: reproducible binaries generated from it) in their bootstrap.

mbakke··on Linux ate my RAM (2009)
What distribution are you using?

IME, if a process grows out of control, Linux won't notice until the whole system is thrashing, at which point it's too late and it tries killing random things like browser tabs way before the offending process.

In rare cases Linux might recover, but only because I hammered C-c the right place 30 minutes ago. In most cases a hard reboot is required (I left it overnight once, fans spinning at max, hoping the kernel would eventually accept my plea for help, but she had other priorities).

mbakke··on NSA publishes ten most common misconfigurations in networks
Right? I'm disabling firewalls and network monitoring as we speak. Nice try, NSA.
mbakke··on MiniOS – a lightweight Linux distribution designed for USB drive
Probably you just grew up.

I hope kids today find the weird world of user-friendly operating systems (license- and tinkering-wise) just as interesting as we once did.

mbakke··on Glibc dynamic loader hit by a nasty local privilege escalation vulnerability
Additionally writing security rules in JavaScript just feels wrong. And alienates users who simply want to mount USB drives without root.
mbakke··on Reorient GitHub pull requests around changesets
I see now that the grandparent was enforcing squash commits, did not mean to single out your comment.

It just blows my mind as someone with a somewhat perfectionist approach to rebasing (to the extent I sometimes intentionally break up or reorder commits to make the changes more intentional or natural, even when it causes nasty local merge conflicts) :P

mbakke··on Reorient GitHub pull requests around changesets
I didn't know about --first-parent, thanks! That gives me something to do while narrowing down the exact commit :)
mbakke··on Reorient GitHub pull requests around changesets
It's simple, scalable, and has none of the mentioned problems.

The main drawback is that contributors have to learn a proper mail user agent (Gmail is notoriously bad with patches).

mbakke··on Reorient GitHub pull requests around changesets
That makes "git bisect" and "git blame" fairly useless. Please don't do that. Better to keep "oops" commits than squashing a series of logical changes into one monster commit.
mbakke··on Reorient GitHub pull requests around changesets
Force pushes makes reviews hard to follow, especially if there are multiple rounds. GitLab handles it much better.

Relatedly, does GitHub merge understand !squash and !fixup commands? I kind of gave up on those and just accepted a few trailing bugfix commits on PRs to not mess up peoples reviews (some projects also invalidate review on force push).

mbakke··on Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hacker Meeting talk [video]
Right, I worded that poorly. The point is that Tesla cannot remotely change the metal in your car, whereas they can with the software.

We as users should demand insight into the software running on hardware we own. Otherwise we only partially own it, and if the device is connected to the internet, we can lose ownership any time.

mbakke··on Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hacker Meeting talk [video]
A metal bar will always be a metal bar.

Software is malleable, and Tesla (or hackers) can change it under your feet. You should be able to inspect it and have a say in what it does or whether to accept the next update.

See the recent Philips Hue debacle for an example of when software that's been running well for years suddenly turns on the user.

mbakke··on Richard Stallman reveals he has cancer in the GNU 40 Hacker Meeting talk [video]
Arguably there should be laws mandating that medical equipment MUST be open for everyone to inspect, contribute, and share.

That does not answer your question though. It goes both ways: if the doctor recognises that a firmware tweak may save your life, then she should be able to do so.

mbakke··on Ask HN: Which is the oldest software alive still in 0.x, used by many?
I'm working on a GNU/Hurd hosting service, maybe that will help it gain traction. Preview:

https://tryhurd.gexp.no

mbakke··on That's a Lot of YAML
But then you have to evaluate things, which brings all kinds of problems.

Your parser is no longer 300 lines, and eventually you might snap and throw it all away for a full-blown interpreter which makes dealing with user provided input difficult.

I'm actually investigating using S-expressions for describing jobs and systems, but haven't figured out how to safely evaluate them short of running in isolated VMs.

Edit: thinking more about this, it is possible to represent all those things without evaluation. It's just awkward to create them... but that can be solved on a different level.

mbakke··on Mistral 7B
Forgive my ignorance, I haven't studied the AI tooling landscape yet. Are you saying these models have a structured binary format and "running" them is just a matter of having a "player" with the right "codec"?

Or are they directly executing CPU instructions?

mbakke··on Forty years of GNU and the free software movement
That's a false dichotomy. It's possible to have a locked down device that allows full access/visibility if you jump through enough hoops.

(Android is almost there, software wise, but closed vendor firmwares are still rampant).

mbakke··on Snowden leak: Cavium networking hardware may contain NSA backdoor
> If state have means to bug raspberry pi it has means to re-seal the box...

That's a good point that I never made sense of. The most likely explanation is simply an oversealouz toll agent. It just left a bad taste in my mouth so I didn't want to play with them...

I had largely forgotten about it until the Google Pixel got stuck.

mbakke··on Snowden leak: Cavium networking hardware may contain NSA backdoor
I generally hold a similar opinion. However I have two data points that suggests back-doors are not available by default (for my government at least), but that they are aggressively bugging (or auditing, lol) devices:

* When I ordered the first generation Raspberry Pi, they were stuck in the toll a long time, and when they arrived all the warranty seals were broken. Consequently I never really used them.

* When I ordered the first generation Google Pixel, before it was generally available in my country, it was stuck in domestic mail for almost a week. The person who imported them sold and sent two phones the same day: the other one arrived after just two days and travelled a lot further. I used it regardless as I already considered phones a lost cause... (and could not with good conscience sell a possibly compromised device).

At this point I don't trust anything sent by mail.

mbakke··on Forty years of GNU and the free software movement
<this comment was removed because of general bitterness>

Apologies to anyone who had to endure my display of contempt.

I agree with the parent comment that FSF (and friends) needs to step up their game to have any influence on the tech scene of the future.

mbakke··on Forty years of GNU and the free software movement
Right, Guix solved that a while back:

https://guix.gnu.org/blog/2018/bootstrapping-rust/

I was thinking about the fact that building Rust requires cURL, Python, CMake, and more, which makes the "bootstrapping graph"[0] very complicated if coreutils is rewritten in Rust.

0: https://guix.gnu.org/en/manual/devel/en/guix.html#Full_002dS...

mbakke··on Forty years of GNU and the free software movement
I think the FSFE (Europe) is doing a lot better than its American sister foundation, with active involvement in EU politics, running campaigns, etc.

Individual GNU projects are doing fairly well on the technical side (toolchain, Emacs, Guix, Mes), but there is little to no coordination across GNU, much less with the FSFs.

FSF Asia seems to have fallen off the earth, even though India appears to have a fairly active free software movement.

I don't think rewrite in Rust is a solution to "modernize" GNU tools. Maybe another memory safe language, but Rust has severe bootstrapping issues which is a hard sell for distros that care about source to binary transparency.

mbakke··on Chili Oil Notes
Do you have a link to such a study? My google-fu is failing.

I don't doubt you but would like to read it and try to confirm my bias anyway!

My experience is mainly with completely crap grinders vs high-end burrs which is very distinguishable. Probably low/mid end burrs do okay as long as there aren't too many fines. Grind size variability may even be advantageous :)

mbakke··on Chili Oil Notes
Even amateurs will notice the difference between a "perfect" pour over from a $50 grinder and a $200 grinder. The GP clearly does not own a V60 :)

Above the $200 range really only matter for espresso. Manual brews don't need that fine grind precision, just consistency (no fines, no rocks) at medium grind levels.

mbakke··on How the Mac didn’t bring programming to the people
How can we make better operating systems if devices are locked down? How can hobbyists keep the hardware useful when the manufacturer no longer cares?

Devices must remain open for the kernel programmers and hardware hackers of tomorrow to follow their curiosity and develop their potential.

mbakke··on static-server: an HTTP server in Go for static content
Caddy is amazing. I accidentally wiped my fairly complex nginx configuration (yay apt-get purge) and have been so spoiled by Guix that I did not care about etckeeper or ansible on my one Debian server.

Anyway I decided to try Caddy to quickly get up and running and had a good setup in minutes including certificates for multiple domains. Even added wildcard certificates which I never figured out with Lets Encrypt, just because I could.

Thanks for this amazing software :-)

← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →