HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mbenjaminsmith

1,329 karma · joined July 9, 2009

SSEuAAGo60Ssb9UMZhmYW77MLQcz1azm xSTO8k2zwIBX7jfw4PQEDozixMnjkZ8L
submissionscomments
mbenjaminsmith··on Scrivener Temporarily Withdrawn from Sale on the Mac App Store
No, neither time. You do get a certain number for free per license so neither of those were actually out of pocket.
mbenjaminsmith··on Scrivener Temporarily Withdrawn from Sale on the Mac App Store
"2.4.1 was rejected on Monday night for a reason that didn’t make sense (the reviewer said it wasn’t sandboxed when it was)."

I've had some incredibly fun (sarcasm) experiences with the review team for the MAS over the last few months. Reading that sentence got a belly laugh out of me.

The first major WTF that I had with the review team was their insistence that an app I had submitted was calling a private method. A method with the same name was present in an included library but rather than explain that to them I found it quicker just to remove the library (a workaround was simple enough). The hair pulling started when they again rejected the app for exactly the same reason. As the app relied on a heavy 3rd party framework it took a lot of investigation to understand what (wasn't) happening. Finally I took out a $50 tech ticket and after a week the engineer explained that the review team's tool for checking API usage was broken and it had nothing to do with my app.

The next time the review team rejected an app (seemingly within minutes of it going into review) because it was "producing garbage output". This time I just did a cursory review of the app before using another $50 tech support ticket. The app was sometimes writing files with the format somefile.ext.sb-randomstring. I suggested to the reviewer that the app was messing up an atomic write and given the sb- part of the filename had something to do with sandboxing. A week later the engineer explained what it was to me -- which was exactly what I had suggested.

My advice to anyone dealing with this is to spend zero time talking to the review team. Don't resubmit (unless it's something really obvious) and don't try to reason with them. Filing a $50 tech support ticket will basically guarantee that someone capable of passing the Turing test (have a conversation via iTunes Connect and you'll understand what I mean) will look into the problem. The tech support team will usually ask the review team to expedite your review once the problem has been solved -- something you'll rarely get if you ask yourself.

mbenjaminsmith··on Why Are Lego Sets Expensive?
Ditto Thailand. I was looking at a set the other day that was just under $1k US. It was a very large set but still one thousand dollars is a lot of money for a plastic building toy. This was a static set too, not anything with motors or controllers.
mbenjaminsmith··on Are Designers Crazy?
>> The higher quality thing is still higher quality, regardless of time or value constraints. If you choose a lower quality path while acknowledging you're balancing time and money, you're still choosing lower quality.

Framed like that I would say "yes, I never want to deliver something of 'lower quality'", but in this case (the two interfaces) one really doesn't qualify as lower quality. We're talking about the difference between "good" and "slightly, almost imperceptibly better". Having said that I'm not a designer and maybe if I were I would have a different opinion about this particular case.

>> But it is important to strive for that high quality as an ideal, even if you can never reach it.

No, I think it's entirely possible to deliver high quality. But we do have to deal with the law of diminishing returns and it's up to us (programmers, designers) to know what's best for our client (or ourselves).

mbenjaminsmith··on Are Designers Crazy?
Writing "good code" is always preferable, especially when you do things "right" the first time.

But what happens when you want to refactor something when 1) it's not strictly necessary in terms of functionality and 2) it will cost the client some non-zero amount of money. You easily slip into a gray area that this visual example illustrates well. Sure there are differences but are they material to the overall design goals? It's hard to say yes.

There's no such thing as "giving a damn" in an absolute sense. It's hard to say that any software product is ever done. If that's the case then it's the programmer's / artist's responsibility to say when something is good enough for the project's current goals.

mbenjaminsmith··on Ask HN: What's your programming setup?
Sounds like you're already doing my number one tip: take the time to write tools to automate repetitive tasks. If you do anything more than a few times and it can be automated then it's worthwhile to do so. Python is a great language for writing tools IME though you could use anything you're comfortable with (and has the requisite libraries).

Buying tools, even if they only do one thing, is worthwhile as well. For me the price point where I'll buy is around $20. If you have a simple app that does one or two things I need on occasion -- and the app is relatively current and bug free -- then I'll buy it. I've rarely been disappointed with $20 tool purchase.

Beyond that I haven't found that code editors really have that much advantage over any other (I'm an experienced Vim user and I've used a handful of popular editors with project management features). Sometimes you're forced to use an IDE, like Xcode, or have to work on a different computer/OS, so there's not much point in finding the ultimate editor.

mbenjaminsmith··on The Games Industry Is Driven By Marketing Stories
This article is full of hand waving and I after reading it I still don't understand what a "marketing story" is. To focus on the stuff I did understand (but took issue with):

>> The odds are increasingly stacked against any developer who’s unable to pull a Peter Molyneux and attract a whole lot of press attention to a zany idea. Their problem is that most often their games look and act very similar to others’ games, have the same look, gameplay and overall dynamic as competitors’ games.

No, two things are going on here: Peter Molyneux innovated and "most often their games look and act very similar to others’ games". Peter Molyneux's cube was a publicity stunt and it pretty much worked. But you don't need to do the same thing to attract attention for a decent game idea provided that it's somehow innovative, polished and fun.

>> That’s why Apple has all the power on the App Store, why Google is sort-of getting there with the Play store, and why Zynga has all the power within the sub-ecosystem it has developed on Facebook. In commodity markets, visibility is everything.

This is the real core of what we're talking about. It was the case for a brief period that an indie could sell a game in the App Store with little marketing and have it become an App Store hit. Then the market filled with both established publishers and hobby developers and -- holy shit -- started to resemble just about every other low-barrier-to-entry market and the gold rush was over.

When people say the sky is falling on mobile they are lamenting the end of the gold rush. Those are different things.

>> This year the tablet space in particular has had a marked increase of graphical polish, and that trend shows every sign of continuing. In some respects it’s like watching the console and PC games industry play its story out all over again, but with good reason: Graphics, in particular a stylish look, can really push a game forward into the market in ways that innovation rarely does ... However this does not give much solace for the developer who cannot afford to spend a fortune.

It's surprising to hear something like this out of someone inside the industry. Art costs for mobile games, including many of the top earners, are not particularly high. Compared to marketing and programming costs art won't cost a fortune for nearly any mobile game.

Also, polish isn't just about graphics. It's really an all encompassing effort. The developer who isn't willing to invest the time and money polishing something created solely for pleasure is probably doing the wrong thing.

>> This newfound tribal funding and evangelism model has appeared at a time when the official industry finds itself in a deeply troubled state. Nobody’s really sure whether they even want a new console anymore, or a gaming PC, or whatever. Developers have no idea which market will be the hot ticket, or which might at least allow them to survive. The metrics simply do not track fast enough for anyone to have a firm grasp on what the hell is going on anymore.

New consoles: Nintendo has put out one incrementally advanced new console of which the sales were OK and now the console industry is dead? We don't have a choice about new consoles because the important ones -- Xbox and PS -- aren't out yet and no one knows how much of a step forward they'll be. If they make us go "wow" they're likely to go quick. If they're less thrilling they'll still do fine because they're new and the AAA gaming industry continues to produce high quality content that people enjoy. On the other end of the power spectrum, OUYA was a mega-success in terms of people voting with their wallets.

This type of sky is falling article is unfortunately very common in the game industry. I read a couple a week though many of them are postmortems and therefore have more value than this article. The main themes are not the market conditions themselves but: 1) companies that failed to acquire the necessary knowledge or 2) companies that did acquire that knowledge but failed to act on it.

[Edited]

mbenjaminsmith··on From Idea (Saturday) to Build (Sunday) to TechCrunch (Tuesday). And Now?
I punched through a dozen or so and 100% of those were rhetorical.

You need to combine it with some NLP like Kevin's doing here: http://reviewsignal.com/webhosting/

mbenjaminsmith··on Hyperloop should start as a high speed alternative to road and air freight
You're assuming a few things here.

1. People would shy away from this new form of transportation. Why? People get on airplanes every day without thinking much about it. Ditto for driving 60+ mph a few feet from stationary obstacles and opposing traffic. Risk and transport seem to go hand in hand.

2. It would be cheaper to build an "unsafe for humans" version first. Why? If the ultimate goal is human transport then I think it's easy to argue the opposite. Why build a system with different design goals, different termination points, etc and then build a system with completely different goals.

3. Lowered road traffic. That might be true but at what scale would that kick in? Is that a worthwhile near/mid-term goal? What about the negative press generated by killing truck driving jobs?

You also have to look at the perceived value of the system, especially early on. If you put a link between two major cities and can significantly impact travel (from an individual perspective) between the two the PR will be fantastic. In comparison, how much freight are you going to have to move around before there's a noticeable impact? What would that impact even be? Shipping is one of those things that is invisible to most people unless it's not functioning properly.

Also don't forget that Elon is already tackling two modes of human transportation with a very high potential for blowback in the case of a fatal accident. I don't think he would shy away from it.

mbenjaminsmith··on World's tallest skyscraper to be built in just 90 days
I don't know if building cheap housing really solves any problems however. C.f., the famous housing "projects" in Chicago. You can replace those with any low-income housing project anywhere in the world and see the same effects. You might put roofs over people's heads but you create a new set of problems by throwing all of those marginally functional people together. I imagine increasing population density would just amplify those problems.

This building is supposed to have a mix of low and high income housing (how does that work?) as well as schools and other social services. Given that space in China is not at a premium I don't think you can call this anything but a social experiment. Maybe if it works they can export it to HK where it might actually be useful. (Though it does conjure images of a sort of neo-Walled City.)

Given that this type of construction produces boring, utilitarian space I don't understand why they're not using it for offices. I imagine this would be much more tolerable as office space and the footprint / usable space ratio would make sense for commercial districts.

mbenjaminsmith··on "Why don't you sell Triple Town for 99 cents and make tons of money?"
Well you're pretty obviously on the extreme end of the spectrum.

Personally I don't play many F2P games and am much more 'core than the center of the market as well. Probably 95% of my gaming time goes to console games and I prefer the biggest budget, most polished titles available (just finished my second character in Borderlands 2). And yes I pay for them up front (and have them delivered by messenger to my home the day they launch, which absolutely makes my day every couple of months).

But as someone trying to build a profitable games company it seems suicidal at this point to not at least attempt to make some form of F2P work with my other design goals. Does that mean I'm going to make shitty games? I don't plan on it. I can say that designing a compelling in-game economy (that can be monetized) is without a doubt the most challenging part of design for me.

You can do what Zynga has done and build games from their monetization outward, but I don't think that's the only way to do it. I hope to do a lot better and I'm sure other companies have or will as well. Don't forget that the F2P model that is now so reviled (by people like you) is relatively new (freemium is not of course) so I think it's a little premature to say that all F2P titles will suck, forever and ever.

mbenjaminsmith··on "Why don't you sell Triple Town for 99 cents and make tons of money?"
>> As a player, I'd rather pay a small sum once to avoid the virtual currency - and find other ways to create whales (e.g., as suggested, more like content creation, sponsoring and some vanity items).

Except that I bet you wouldn't. Most players when asked say they would prefer a "fair price, pay once" model. Yet in aggregate they act very differently. If that weren't true we wouldn't now have a market where:

1) Seemingly most people complain about F2P

2) F2P is increasingly the most successful model

I think the people annoyed by monetization efforts are a relatively tech savvy, vocal minority.

>> it often seems that the rest of the players (the 99%, if you wish), have their experience hampered by constant dangling of offers in front of you.

I don't think that's really the case. Again, vocal minority.

But let's say it is. Speaking as a game developer now, we don't have to present the same experience to every player. A "cheap" player may be nearly a lost cause for direct monetization but valuable for word of mouth. If they're not buying we can actually scale back on the amount of ads presented and instead gently persuade them to, say, post their high scores on Twitter. If you're the type of player that likes to brag, then a prompt with a pre-filled Twitter post won't annoy you at all. It's not hard to figure out which player is which and it's not hard to adapt in-game marketing efforts to suit that player.

mbenjaminsmith··on Show HN: I'm 14, I learned Objective-C, and this is my first iPhone game
Congratulations.

I'm going to echo the more pleasant half of HN and say don't let anybody dismiss your accomplishment. Shipping is all that really matters and shipping is hard.

mbenjaminsmith··on Is it better to turn up the volume in the software or on the speakers?
You're correct that lowering amplitude ~= reducing bit depth. I'm not sure that lowering amplitude digitally keeps S/N constant but I'm a bit out of my depth (excuse the pun) at this point.

To further muddy the waters, in most cases using software volume control won't noticeably reduce audio quality. The main point I was trying to make is that on most computer setups 100% volume should be the least noisy, most accurate signal that it's capable of.

mbenjaminsmith··on Is it better to turn up the volume in the software or on the speakers?
Little late to the party here but you're wrong. Unless something is being done to the signal (eq, other processing, etc) then you want the digital side to remain at max volume (i.e., no reduction in bit depth). The audio will have been mastered close to 0 db with little or no clipping (exceeding the maximum amplitude possible) and should not be "too loud" for your amplifier. If it is there is something wrong with the gain configuration of your setup.

As discussed, lowering the volume in software (which is what you likely mean by "controlling the DAC") is accomplished by reducing bit depth. By definition you're reducing the amount of signal present which makes your S/N worse. If by "controlling the DAC" you mean reducing the signal at the DAC's analog stage then there's nothing theoretically wrong with that (except that it's rarely if ever the case in computer sound cards or hi-fi DACs) as it is the equivalent to adjusting the volume on your (integrated) amp.

Probably the most common exception to the above is people using a digital EQ to attempt to improve the sound of a mediocre computer audio setup. Most digital EQs allow for both "boost" and "cut" -- increasing or decreasing the amplitude of individual frequency bands. If you EQ the music the proper way you should only cut frequency bands in order to emphasize the other bands to suit your listening tastes. For example if you want to try to increase the amount of bass you should cut the mids and the highs and turn up the volume (on your amp) to compensate. EQing this way ensures that you're not forcing the signal into clipping by boosting too much.

You still won't get great results because if you're lacking bass or highs then it's most likely because you're not running full range speakers. If the sound does change when you EQ it's most likely due to increased distortion, not because you're appreciably increasing the amount of bass present. That's not true for full range speakers but if you have full range speakers you probably wouldn't need to EQ in the first place. (Full range speaker are usually 20 - 50hz to 20khz.)

If it's still not clear than think of it this way: Standalone CD players don't have volume controls. Their output will be "max volume" of what's on the CD. You can think of your computer and sound card like a (crappy) CD player. Make sure it's at max volume and adjust the level on your external amp or amplified speakers.

mbenjaminsmith··on Satellite burns up following SpaceX rocket glitch
Apparently you know nothing about PR "best practices". No consultant worth their salt would have allowed SpaceX to handle the secondary mission failure they way they did. They made a series of classic and potentially disastrous mistakes. The best thing they could have done was address the issue head on with what information they had and then filled in further details as they were known.

To build credibility you have to admit failure. You can't just omit the bad news while focusing on the good news. You can't allow rumor and speculation to be your spokesperson. There's no way around the fact that an engine failure led to the failure of their secondary mission. Test platform or not, fully insured or not, an expensive piece of hardware became a shooting star. Someone didn't get what they paid for.

How it was handled was seriously amateurish. It made me cringe because I really want to see SpaceX (and Musk) succeed. Shit happens, but how you respond to that as an organization defines you for better or worse.

mbenjaminsmith··on Parallella: A Supercomputer For Everyone
I don't really have any comment on the project itself (not something I would ever use and I don't know the value of what they're proposing).

But on purely geek terms this thing seems to warrant a "holy shit":

http://www.adapteva.com/products/silicon-devices/e64g401/

Again I don't know how (un)common that sort of thing is but I wasn't expecting to see 64 cores in that tiny form factor. Does anyone here know how cutting edge this thing is if at all?

[Edit]

Also does anyone here want to address use cases for this thing?

mbenjaminsmith··on 5 days of insanity in a social media startup
"I’ve worked in the internet industry for almost 10 years... After almost 6 months of startup job fairs, Silicon Alley newsletters, digital DUMBO drinks and 2-3 applications per week I had yet to receive a single invitation to an interview."

Can any NYC tech people comment on why that might be the case? She mentions something vague about her experience being UX and it sounds like she doesn't design or do programming. Is her skill set too nebulous to get her an interview?

mbenjaminsmith··on The Ludum Dare October Challenge: Finish a game, Take it to market, Earn $1
Do you have a link or any info you can share?
mbenjaminsmith··on The Ludum Dare October Challenge: Finish a game, Take it to market, Earn $1
> Also, in your post you sounded as if you were worried about how this will affect the current state of indie games, and I can assure that indie games are doing better now than they ever have.

No, not at all. But I do think it reinforces a trend of quickly producing (and even publishing) unpolished, unplayable games.

> Any of the great indie games you've played have been made by people who have previously made dozens of horrible prototypes and "Ludum dare style" games.

I'd love to see some data on that. Personally I don't think producing a string of "horrible prototypes" is a necessary introduction to game development. There are plenty of aspects of game development that aren't adequately covered by producing 48-hour throwaway demos.

> Developers don't simply go from zero to making award-winning games, there is a large amount of learning and practice that has to happen, which LD facilitates.

Except for some very rare outliers, "developers" (used here in the singular) don't make award winning games at all. An indie darling like Braid was produced at a substantial cost and with the addition of at least one artist as well as musicians. Blow didn't "jam" that game into existence. It was a very long, very difficult project that included throwing out the artwork and starting over at one point (if memory serves).

I'm cherry picking a bit there but make a list in your mind of how many great indie games were "jammed" into existence using well honed "jamming" skills. I can't think of any.

My point is that developing games people actually want to play involves "game jam skills" + n, where n probably represents over 95%. We can all jam out throwaway games to our hearts' content. If we're going to make great games or even just good games then we need to put our time into learning n. LD, given its strong following, could better serve the community by focusing more on n. I have absolutely nothing against LD or its participants, but I think it could be more than it is.

mbenjaminsmith··on The Ludum Dare October Challenge: Finish a game, Take it to market, Earn $1
> Realistically, if your game is good enough to make $1, it will probably make more than one dollar, but the goal of the October challenge is to finish a game that is good enough that you want to sell it.

I don't really agree with that. It's entirely possible to produce something that can be put on Kongregate or even submitted to an app store that makes a few bucks and nothing more. In fact that's pretty much my whole complaint. We don't need more games that make $23.65 over their lifetime. People don't need to make them and other people don't need to play them.

> LD48's emphasis on game rapid creation and innovation

I do agree with you there. And the better entires I played from LD23 were innovative. However, those were a minority. If the goal is innovation then I think LD fails most participants.

> you can't apply an arbitrary quality bar to entries

I wasn't suggesting that a wall be put up. I was suggesting that by changing the format more emphasis would be put on quality automatically. I think if you can set aside a full weekend for game development you can likely set aside n hours over the course of a month as well. Not in all cases of course but in enough to keep the event open and inclusive.

> Galcon, Depict1 and McPixel come to mind as games that started in LD48 or Global Game Jam and have had decent commercial success after the fact.

Picking Galcon because it's a game I'm familiar with, the success of that game over the years had a lot to do with continued work on it, adding features, moving to new platforms, etc. Sure, it may have started in a jam but I don't think LD was a necessary condition of that game's success.

Look at it another way. Galcon was successful mostly because of the work done after LD. Hassey had the wherewithal to follow through with the game to make it successful. It's really the "after the demo" follow through that matters the most for both creative and financial success. I think LD (or other jams) would better serve the community if more emphasis could be placed there. I think a longer format and higher goals would be a step in the right direction.

mbenjaminsmith··on The Ludum Dare October Challenge: Finish a game, Take it to market, Earn $1
I absolutely see the value in "getting down to it" and producing and MVP or demo or whatever. I think iterative, agressive development is the way to go when making any software product (which is what I do for a living).

My point is to criticize the emphasis on turning out "just enough" and then moving on. This isn't only within LD but I've seen plenty of it in the indie game development community in general as well. As a strong undercurrent in the community I think it's harmful.

If LD is to be about game development as a craft in its entirety (and maybe that's not LD's role) then I think it has to be about more than just producing a quick demo of an idea.

mbenjaminsmith··on The Ludum Dare October Challenge: Finish a game, Take it to market, Earn $1
This is general to Ludum Dare (not to this challenge) but since it's infrequently discussed here I thought I'd post.

I'm not really sure what the point of Ludum Dare is. I participated once in the main competition for LD23. I produced a pretty horrible game with the time I had allotted but did enjoy having a reason to screw up my schedule and drink too much coffee.

The winning game I thought was innovative and I actually played it for more than 10 minutes. There was one other game that I played (I played twenty or so to vote on them) that was fun to play. It also (deservedly) ranked well. The rest (based on an admittedly small sample) simply weren't games, at least not yet.

My observation is that if Ludum Dare is about creating games -- if nothing else than for the sake and love of games -- then the format is completely wrong. If you look at the industry as a whole there is an abundance of poorly made games (largely made in Flash, though iOS, Android and most other platforms have their share) that do nothing for the developers or the limited number of people that play them.

This October challenge reemphasizes the misplaced focus of Ludum Dare: make something overnight that makes just $1. The world doesn't need any more games worth $1. Here's a better challenge for the game development community: Make a game in a month that makes (over its life) $1,000 - $10,000. I want to play those games. A month is still insanely short, especially assuming most could only put in their free time, but it's infinitely better than 48 hours. A simple game has some chance of being polished in that amount of time.

Instead of Ludum Dare squandering the significant amount of attention is generates on 1000s (it broke 1000 entries in LD23) of shovel-ware games, why not encourage and then help promote a smaller number of reasonably well produced games. Raising the bar for entires would cut the numbers dramatically so it would be win-win.

You could say that I already answered my question when I said I enjoyed participating. I did enjoy it yes, but I don't think I would do it again. I also don't think that it has any value for the game development community or people who love games for the reasons I've already outlined. The emphasis is all wrong. You don't want to just finish a game. Games aren't made that way. Instead shift the emphasis to creating, polishing and even marketing simple games.

mbenjaminsmith··on Glass - A social network I made for me.
Tell me something is challenging and I'm likely to do it. It wasn't actually that bad. I think signing up for a new gmail account is much worse.
mbenjaminsmith··on Show HN: escape from meetings, etc with a prearranged phone call: GetOutCall.com
Missed this comment.

I still don't agree. I think it's important to realize people can't always separate their work and personal lives -- especially things like taking a call from a mechanic at 11:00am. I wouldn't expect people to make all of their personal calls at 6:01 every day since it's generally not practical. I say this from a management perspective where I used to be pretty demanding about attention. After a while I realized that sometimes your team has to take that call from their vet. I think letting your team make that decision for themselves goes a long way in building a relationship.

I kind of see it like this:

You're either in an "all hands" type meeting or a small group or two-person meeting. If it's the former then I think participation is completely optional as you're likely to get a recap from a colleague afterwards or via email. If it's the latter then you're likely to be a relatively important part of that meeting and the others can wait for you if you need to interrupt. Of couse that doesn't mean that you should take every call whether business or personal but I don't think it's a case of either/or. There are plenty of company-related calls that could be temporarily ignored and vice-versa.

mbenjaminsmith··on Ask HN: How have you been celebrating programmer's day?
Wrote a notification system for Lua. Nothing exactly challenging but something I plan on posting on github to save other programmers ~30 minutes.
mbenjaminsmith··on Show HN: escape from meetings, etc with a prearranged phone call: GetOutCall.com
I used to work in a very client-focused industry. Internal meetings, even those led by a CEO, were secondary to your relationship with your client. People would pop in and out of meetings constantly taking calls and following up on things.

My current company doesn't have a very big team or office space, but if/when I set one up that's the sort of culture I would expect. Mettings should be voluntary and secondary in importance to the work that you do. It's me talking after all, not a prophet.

I'm probably 10 years older than the average HN'er as well.

mbenjaminsmith··on An invitation to come and hack on Buffer
That certainly makes (more) sense. Good luck with the move and the hires.
mbenjaminsmith··on An invitation to come and hack on Buffer
Especially given the 'US based have to live in / move to SF' part.

Wasn't this company kicked out of the US because they couldn't sort out visas for the team? If so, why would they require someone to be in SF or any other market if they're not there as an organization? It almost sounds like they're trying to setup a "presence" in SF via a new hire. Given that and the low salary this sounds more like a co-founder role, not an employee.

So on the low end of the scale you're looking at 50k (a salary I can't even imagine for the Bay Area) for full time work plus what, handing out business cards at events?

Pure speculation of course, but since this company was once in TC for not being able to stay in SF asking for SF-based employees only is weird at best.

Also, given that this is a feature company built on Twitter and Facebook I'd say any equity deal is extra risky. It sounds like they haven't run afoul of Twitter's guidelines yet. That doesn't mean Twitter won't change their mind next week.

mbenjaminsmith··on How an app with 200,000 downloads led to developer homelessness
#3 is just wrong.

These guys want to make video games. Maybe that's enough to make it work and maybe not. Time will tell. But by the logic of #3 we should all just do whatever puts money in the bank. That argument quickly devolves into a lot of would-be entrepreneurs sulking back to jobs they vowed they would learn to live without or building companies that are temporary money making opportunities, not something worth the devotion required.

Most importantly, these kids are making games with traction -- 200k downloads in a week is very, very good, especially since they don't seem to be that focused on actually marketing their games. That means they've got some special sauce. Tweaking what they have to bring up conversions is a solvable problem. Finding pizza money is a solvable problem.

If they're broke and people are playing their games then that means their customer acquisition costs are basically zero (since they don't have any money for it anyway). They don't have to get conversions up that far to turn an acceptable profit (especially since these guys apparently live on peanuts).

"You're competing for the business of toxic people who hate paying money" -- that's simplistic to say the least. I don't want to bother to dig up numbers but plenty of money is spent on games on mobiles and everywhere else. If you want to generalize that way you might say that about the whole mobile "app" market and the drive towards free or $.99 -- people expecting a lot for nothing -- yet it's still a thriving industry. If you're talking about the freemium or f2p model (in apps or games) it's not like the concept was invented by Zynga. The fact that freemium works was discovered -- it's a model the market supports and supports well.

"Well-funded corporations (which have high production values and effective, ruthless monetization)" -- high production values, especially on mobile where AAA graphics and open, 3D worlds aren't possible or even desirable, is not the issue it is on the consoles and PCs. Plenty of successful games are relatively simple 2D and have limited content. High production values in those cases can be measured in thousands of dollars, not millions. Ruthless monetization? What difference does that make in terms of competition, especially since we're talking about "well-funded corporations?"

If you're not that familiar with the market, pick up a big EA title and then play something like Tiny Wings. Which one was more fun? What do you think their comparative budgets were?

The "big corporations" -- EA et al I guess you mean -- were slow to move to this newest mobile market and have had a hard time making games people really like. They make up for it with marketing spend, but it's not like people aren't playing games like Tiny Wings because they can't pull themselves away from Mass Effect: Infiltrator.

If you mean mobile publishers like Chillingo et al then there's absolutely nothing stopping these guys from having a publisher like that pick up their game. There are pros and cons to doing so, but I doubt these guys would have any problem finding a publisher with the number of d/l they're getting.

"And amateur hobbyist artistes (who have "that vision thing" and are willing to starve to deliver it for free)." -- I'm not sure who these people are, but if you mean part-time developers flooding the market with low quality, free games, that only hinders visibility in the app stores. App store visibility as a sales tool was a fluke of the birth of these app stores and is now gone, never to return (although people are still seeing those effects in the Android markets). The amateur, as in most markets, has very little effect on the market as a whole.

If you're talking about developers with vision -- say the developers of Braid or World of Goo or say Notch -- these people don't work for free or hurt the industry. I'd say they elevate the entire state of the industry and turn more people onto games.

These guys should definitely learn the business side of what they're doing but it sounds like they absolutely should not stop making games.

← PreviousPage 5 of 15Next →