HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mbg721

2,922 karma · joined January 6, 2021

submissionscomments
mbg721··on Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is religion the key factor?
As a religious believer, I upvoted this because I think you have a very good point--denying sensory evidence without a good reason is weak. The strongest argument for religion, the Aquinas-style one, is that faith fills in the missing pieces of what we see and hear, not that it replaces them with outrageous lies.
mbg721··on Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is religion the key factor?
The Mythbusters had it right; the difference between science and screwing around is paying attention and writing it down.
mbg721··on Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is religion the key factor?
Is that genuinely true of Catholics in your area? I had thought the organized structure of the brand made them far less prone to young-earth theory than non-denominated Protestants.
mbg721··on Acceptance of evolution by high school students: Is religion the key factor?
Yeah, as a Catholic-school graduate, that seems bizarre. It would be more likely to hear my teachers deny transsubstantiation than to deny evolution.
mbg721··on Scientists generate XX and XY cells from a person with Klinefelter syndrome
Maybe in 50 years I'll sound as cringey as Song of the South or something, but I still maintain that gender identity is a created social phenomenon and that encouraging alternative identities is destructive.
mbg721··on Scientists generate XX and XY cells from a person with Klinefelter syndrome
Because there's no particular reason to act differently from your birth sex other than for sexual practice. What else does gender actually mean, if it means anything at all? The fundamental conflict of the current culture-war is "Is sexual attraction a choice or is it innate?" and "It's innate" is the only polite thing to say, but it also creates contradictions.
mbg721··on Scientists generate XX and XY cells from a person with Klinefelter syndrome
Having a sex at birth isn't, but the idea of gender being a separate thing from gender is contentious precisely because it's connected to sexual practice.
mbg721··on Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illegal in Sacramento, CA
It's interstate commerce for sure.
mbg721··on Scientists generate XX and XY cells from a person with Klinefelter syndrome
Alternatively, we can't think sexual practice is in any way a willful choice, or else we're demanding a backward theocracy.
mbg721··on Is forced treatment for the mentally ill ever humane?
That's the heart of the problem; society can't decide what behavior, if any, is deviant, and so we err on the hands-off side. Except that we then have unused outrage, so we lash out when somebody runs an errand and leaves their dog in a locked car.
mbg721··on I was a useful idiot for capitalism
To add to this, in the US at least, a lot of that income is paid in the form of various benefits such as health insurance and retirement contributions that aren't immediate liquid cash, so it feels like less on the receiving end.
mbg721··on Wells Fargo Penalties Since 2000: $22B
The problem is, who else would have the desire and expertise to be on the committee? Regulatory capture is a hard problem, because anyone qualified to regulate is going to have some interest.
mbg721··on Wells Fargo to pay $3.7B for mistreating customers
I think the real lesson, rather than "leave the USA", is "have a close-knit support structure".
mbg721··on Wells Fargo to pay $3.7B for mistreating customers
I think the answer I was expecting was that it's a two-step process: 1) Be lucky, and 2) Don't be unlucky. My next-door neighbor is actually a local politician, but her party affiliation is the one I dislike, so I'm getting a life-lesson in humility.
mbg721··on Facial recognition tech gets woman booted from Rockettes show due to employer
Even if it were, would that make it better??
mbg721··on Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative
When the reaction to a slur is pure confusion, then you've won.
mbg721··on Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative
"We've got it! Quit walking alone! Brilliant!"
mbg721··on Wells Fargo to pay $3.7B for mistreating customers
I agree 100%; what can a layman like me do to fix it?
mbg721··on Wells Fargo to pay $3.7B for mistreating customers
The fact that people experience this and then somehow don't say "burn it all down" is miraculous.
mbg721··on Amsterdam's 'stay away' campaign targets troublesome visitors
It should be pretty obvious who's a low-info vice tourist and who's a geeky Dutchophile. I can't imagine those circles intersecting very much.
mbg721··on Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative
Lots of pro-life organizations actually do meaningfully help children after they are born. I regularly give money to a pregnancy center that buys car-seats for low-income moms. But that would get in the way of the story.
mbg721··on Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative
Darn, and I was so hoping to be a chess grand-good-at-things-person. How are the Guardians and the Commanders doing?
mbg721··on Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative
You're right, I am a pasty white guy, and I'm also not in the business of telling people what to say or not say. All I know is that there are a couple of magic words I can say that will instantly ruin my life.
mbg721··on Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative
In a professional context, using your real name? I never would, in this political climate. I probably never would have anyway, but morality is unimportant in the face of zealousness. I think most people agree that it's a stupid and irrelevant thing to care about, but nobody is going to be the first one to stick their neck out.
mbg721··on Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative
Yeah, I heard "blind, deaf, and dumb", but never in actual context until then.
mbg721··on Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative
That's a little different, it's more like saying "Hey, the horse is escaping!" when the barn was already leveled to build a KFC which later became, briefly, a beeper store, and is now a place that sells THC-related goods.
mbg721··on Elon Musk’s $44B education on free speech
I'm using "casually religious" to mean "I go to church because my parents always did, but I don't really believe in that superstitious nonsense." Catholicism in particular is going through a stark divide right now, because the "Christmas and Easter" Catholics are no longer bothering to show up for Christmas or Easter. So at a glance, it looks like the Church is getting more conservative, but it's really mostly attrition.

But that's all outward religious practice; my comment was more getting at my suspicion that many human behaviors are effectively religion in disguise. Where do axioms come from?

mbg721··on Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative
I heard it used in the non-vocal sense once in a Perry Mason episode, and it took me a minute or two to realize what they meant.
mbg721··on Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative
What one can learn by doing that is that the abrupt "stop the record" noise still exists even though records aren't a thing. Like the "save" icon.
mbg721··on Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative
The politicians who want to ban specific words for being violent are the same people who want to ban guns for being violent, and it doesn't effectively address the problem in either case.
← PreviousPage 12 of 34Next →