HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mbillie1

1,367 karma · joined September 24, 2012

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/yaaase; my proof: https://keybase.io/yaaase/sigs/fvD3PEuhQqq86qzQkkMCvjBk_YaqvbGWKDvQGG9eHwA ]
submissionscomments
mbillie1··on The Law on Cursing at Cops
> If you curse out a cop, you're probably up to no good

I just want to point out that this is an overwhelmingly class-based statement. If you are materially comfortable, especially if you're white, you would likely never have the slightest reason to curse at the police. If you are constantly seeing friends harassed and detained without cause, shot and killed, or experiencing it yourself (as at least a few of the folks in this article seemed to experience it), you might think a little differently. It's easy to make the fallacious argument that "anyone mixed up with the police was up to do good in the first place" when you live in a relatively affluent area, when you are not perceived as a "dangerous minority", etc.

mbillie1··on The Art of Command Line
vi keybindings are ubiquitous, so familiarity with the editor is beneficial outside the editor. Just offhand, both ncdu and tig (which I have used in the past hour) respond to vi keystrokes.

It's not as hard as it first seems to learn, either. Well worth the time spent, vi is worlds more powerful than nano.

mbillie1··on The Art of Command Line
https://github.com/jlevy/the-art-of-command-line/pull/12
mbillie1··on Apple iPad Gets Split-Screen Multitasking in iOS 9
https://xkcd.com/1172/

Some of us like fullscreen windows...

mbillie1··on Oh My Zsh
I love oh-my-zsh but am confused why this is news... it's been around for years, almost everyone I know in OSX either uses it or has used it at some point in the past. I do love it though!
mbillie1··on Why Are Palo Alto's Kids Killing Themselves?
> Just because upper-class enclaves exist as goals to lure the beguiled doesn't mean they're actually utopias.

Very well put.

mbillie1··on Why Are Palo Alto's Kids Killing Themselves?
> Why are kids killing themselves in utopia? Why are some of the worlds most intelligent, rich, and power adults burying their children?

I think the ideas that Palo Alto is "utopia," and that intelligence, wealth and power are all you need to make your children happy, are really quite telling. Perhaps expensive houses and influential careers are orthogonal to children's happiness and well-being, or perhaps even an intensely competitive career- and wealth-focused environment has negative side-effects with respect to one's family?

I don't think that suburban ennui is anything new, and equating affluence and education to happiness is short-sighted in my mind.

mbillie1··on Ask HN: Do you feel like you're in a filter bubble?
Not to mention that daily exercise will improve your overall happiness / mental health noticeably. Run, bike, find a rock climbing gym and learn how to rock climb, anything. It is important in so many ways for people like software developers who have highly mentally stressful but physically sedentary jobs to do something physically active and not involving a screen, and to do it daily. Your quality of life will improve exponentially.
mbillie1··on Stop Fearing Artificial Intelligence
I'm not sure I understand your point. Computers communicate with one another constantly. There certainly does seem to be something different about us, but I've yet to see any scientific or philosophical proof that our self-awareness is necessarily involved with our intelligence or behavior. There's a good deal of philosophical literature around this idea ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophical_zombie ), and virtually no scientific explanation of consciousness.

I grant of course that this may not be a terribly useful way for human beings to view themselves, and it is quite contrary to popular belief, but for all that it could still be true.

mbillie1··on Stop Fearing Artificial Intelligence
> But if we make machines that are smarter than us and have desires

It is a hypothesis that human desires - the conscious processes involved in thinking "I want such-and-such" - influence human behavior. Consciousness is not whatsoever a solved problem, and it may be that we are just complex, deterministic automatons whose consciousness and desires are caused by our behavior (like the steam produced by an engine), rather than causing it.

I'm not necessarily in this camp, but I bring this up to point out that there is an awful lot of common prejudice bundled up in what we consider our own intelligence/consciousness to be, and we project these biases onto what we imagine AI will be. We almost certainly misunderstand our own consciousness profoundly in this way, and at any rate there is no definitive scientific (or philosophical) answer to "what is self awareness" or "what role do desires play in human behavior" (again, the desire could be the steam from the engine).

mbillie1··on Stop Fearing Artificial Intelligence
Virtually all of these discussions of AI come from the very peculiar way in which we view our own intelligence. It's only the notion of a "conscious will" or whatever unifying feature we find in reflective self-awareness that prevents us viewing intelligence as nothing more than large chains of deterministic complexity. It is a hypothesis that there is something to even human behavior which is more than this deterministic complexity. In other words, there may be no qualitative leap from the AI we currently have to some sort of "real AI" or singularity or whatnot. It may be that you just build up more complex cases over time.

That way of thinking is hurtful to our egos (we would be simply complex deterministic automatons) but there is really nothing other than our pride to suggest that this is not, or could not, be the case. It would also put to rest concerns about machine AI, as it would be an extension of what currently exists, simply on a larger scale.

mbillie1··on How I Start: Clojure
Well... I may be biased as one of those folks who uses both vim and emacs, but: there is a big (positive) difference in my opinion between evaluating code in-line, right from your source file, in your editor, than copy+pasting it into a REPL somewhere. Loading up your ns in cider and then being able to evaluate functions, edit them, and see their output right in emacs is terrifically powerful. Even in SublimeText or IntelliJ or something you have to wrap the function in question in a print statement to do that, sometimes affecting lexical scope, etc.
mbillie1··on Ask HN: Isn't networking usually a waste of time?
Anecdotally, as an engineer, I have found maintaining personal relationships (even those I did not initially suspect would be fruitful) has been invaluable to my career and has lead to some very interesting job offers, at least one of which I have accepted.
mbillie1··on Raven paradox
It is a helpful context in which to view the seemingly "logical" arguments you hear all the time from politicians and moralists of all persuasion. A reminder that a good-sounding, intuitively appealing argument can have absurd or utterly fallacious conclusions.
mbillie1··on Raven paradox
One of my favorite paradoxes, I recall learning this in a formal logic class in college. These sorts of mental exercises are fascinating and well worth doing. The point of paradoxes is not to "solve" them, the point is to understand more about how we reason, and about the boundaries of our reason.
mbillie1··on Google Fiber Is Coming to Salt Lake City
NYC bureaucracy is on a whole different level from KS, TN, etc. NYS in general has ludicrous amounts of regulation compared to most states, and NYC is the creme de la creme.
mbillie1··on Google Fiber Is Coming to Salt Lake City
Living in SLC, this is super exciting. I cannot wait to ditch Comcast (who has raised my rates for the same service every 6 months over the past 2 years) as soon as conceivably possible.
mbillie1··on I Can’t Write My Name in Unicode
> some languages are insanely complex to implement

I don't understand this, is there more to implementing a language than creating glyphs for its character set? I wouldn't think the linguistic complexity would matter at all, only the number of glyphs in the 'alphabet' or similar?

mbillie1··on “Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900”
http://www.upout.com/blog/san-francisco-3/5-castles-that-are...
mbillie1··on My Roommate, the Darknet Drug Lord
> Oh c'mon, he ordered a hitman inside a play the FBI fully staged for him. There was never any harm done to anybody.

I'm not sure this line of reasoning makes a lot of difference. We judge criminal intent, not simply outcome, and it's pretty clear that the intent in hiring a hitman is to have someone killed - staged or not. It's surely different from pulling the trigger yourself, but I think it's quite fair to expect a gut-check moment when one decides not to pay for murder, and to hold someone criminally accountable for ignoring that gut-check and deciding to go ahead with the hit anyway.

(edited for grammatical clarity)

mbillie1··on 2015 Chromebook Pixel
> Google releases high quality hardware with their OS to prove that a good machine could be make with it, but at a price that does not compete with others.

That is a very interesting notion that I had not considered at all, but can that be entirely true? It must cost a small fortune to get a device like this ready for public consumption, even if they don't sell very many of them.

mbillie1··on Why didn't you back me up?
> If you can't be around a clothed woman without breaking down mentally just because she is clothed in a certain way, that is your problem.

Yes, thank you. The whole "I'm a victim of being attracted to pretty people" schtick has gone quite far enough. You're an adult in a place of business, try acting like it.

mbillie1··on $350M Might Not Be Enough to Save Las Vegas
> It'll be really hard to ever make that appealing

How about folks drinking beer on the street, the ceaseless outside speakers, and totally shameless flaunting of the sex trade on every corner? I'm not a prude, but there is something to be said for a little class. I didn't even notice the block/street size when I was there.

mbillie1··on Google Plans New Headquarters, and a City Fears Being Overrun
While I'm sympathetic to the situation folks find themselves in with skyrocketing housing prices due to an influx of tech workers, sentiments like “Nobody wants change,” and "[residents who] want to halt the city’s growth" are unrealistic.

The same thing happened in places like Rockland County, NY - once a small, rural community of primarily Norwegian immigrants, it has seen skyrocketing property taxes, cost of living and population due to the increased population / desirability of NYC over the past say 60 years, as well as the Tappan Zee Bridge making it a viable home for Manhattan-working commuters. The residents (at least some of the old time residents, whose number includes several of my family members) are understandably upset, but you simply don't get to control your community size in this fashion. If you want to live in a small, rural community and find your lifelong hometown increasingly developed, the unfortunate reality is that you are not the only human being who wants her peace and quiet, and you may have to move.

mbillie1··on Why I Quit OS X – Geoff Wozniak
I appreciate the points made, but without comparisons on a point-by-point basis, I'm still left wondering what the specific linux runes are to replace OS X - even for this one user.
mbillie1··on Salvatore Sanfilippo, the author of Redis: from Sicily with talent and passion
It's not too often that the top response to the Stackoverflow threads I find via search comes from the main author of the software, but antirez is all over it with Redis - above and beyond, definitely one of the people I most strive to emulate.
mbillie1··on “I am not authorizing you to release a Ruby port of Metaphone 3”
All I can think of is this: http://steve-yegge.blogspot.co.uk/2010/07/wikileaks-to-leak-...

"They have no right to do this. Open Source does not mean the source is somehow 'open'. That's my code, not theirs. If I make something private, it means that no matter how desperately you need to call it, I should be able to prevent you from doing so, even long after I've gone to the grave."

mbillie1··on The pilots of Instagram: violating rules of the air
That article was an amazing read.
mbillie1··on Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?'
> Your point only makes sense if there is a divine set of rules that makes some things right and others wrong.

There's a difference between absolutism (which I am arguing against, btw, and my argument against conviction is consistent with my position against absolutism) and abject relativism, where the value of a thing is equivalent to its acceptance. How about the empirical demonstration of the goodness/badness of a thing? (amount of overall harm caused, assuming harm is considered bad, etc).

> A cause is as strong as people who understand it

This is essentially my objection. This is relativism. If you were right here, then all the religious zealots in the world believing in creationism would render that position valid, and the strength of their conviction would be in some sense an asset to that position. My point is that all of that is nonsense. A thing is wrong/false/stupid independently of its believers' numbers, or their zeal or conviction. You don't need to appeal to some divinity to make that point, you can appeal to common empirical demonstrability (aka science). It is more complicated when dealing with "purely" ethical matters, but only more complicated - it is our choice whether we reduce issues to "pure" ethics or not, and I suggest that we should not.

> I don't believe there is such a thing.

Neither do I. I just reject the "feel-good" position that peoples' convictions are all meaningful and valid, and that we have to respect things that people believe strongly in. To me that is nonsense. Plenty of things are simply wrong, stupid and contemptible. You can be kind to people holding those positions without forcing yourself to believe that there is some worth in their ideas simply because they feel strongly about them.

mbillie1··on Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?'
> So maybe you should consider respecting someone who thinks taking his life and innocent lives to make a point, or at least respect the point he is trying to make.

"Even today it takes only the crudity of a persecution to give an otherwise completely indifferent sectarianism an honorable name. How? Does it change the value of a thing if someone gives his life for it? An error that has become honorable is an error which is that much more seductive."

> you cannot possibly ignore the fact that Sunde went to prison on his own for what he believed was right

Yes, but I don't find that in itself worthy of respect. Martyring yourself is a dramatic pose, a type of moralism that appeals to emotion and not reason. What Sunde did with his own personal life has absolutely nothing to do with the rightness or wrongness of TPB (btw I am entirely in favor of that sort of filesharing).

But this childish fetish our society has with idolizing people who "feel strongly" and "sacrifice" does us no credit. It just muddies the already murky waters of whatever topic is under debate. The fact that someone makes a sacrifice in favor of some belief or conviction simply makes no difference whatsoever as to the rightness or wrongness of that belief. It is only a symptom of the type of person s/he is. And I see no reason to respect the willingness to sacrifice as a virtue in itself, since one could sacrifice for "evil" (bad/stupid/harmful) ends.

← PreviousPage 5 of 13Next →