HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mbrukman

243 karma · joined June 27, 2016

https://misha.brukman.net
submissionscomments
mbrukman··on Google Cloud is 50% cheaper than AWS
I am a Google Cloud PM, but not on Dataflow specifically.

Do you know how long the Dataflow processing will take? You may be able to estimate the length of the full-size process (assuming it's batch rather than streaming) by running on a small data sample to see how many vCPU hours it takes and estimate from there, assuming your data takes a uniform amount of time to process.

Since Dataflow is running code that you wrote, it doesn't know how complex your processing will be for any given value, so it's hard to give any reasonable estimate. In general, automatically predicting how long an arbitrary piece of code will take to run on a given input is even harder than the Halting problem (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halting_problem), which is already undecidable.

Details on Dataflow pricing: https://cloud.google.com/dataflow/pricing

Pricing calculator to estimate cost for Dataflow and other products: https://cloud.google.com/products/calculator/

Hope this helps!

mbrukman··on Google Cloud is 50% cheaper than AWS
Thanks for the feedback!

I'm PM for another Google Cloud database (not Cloud SQL), but will share this with the team.

mbrukman··on Google Cloud is 50% cheaper than AWS
I am a Google Cloud Platform PM.

Googlers are very active in many forums, including HN, Stack Overflow, mailing lists, and other forums, not just via paid support.

If a customer is having trouble reaching someone at Google regarding Google Cloud Platform issue, I'm sorry to hear that, and would love to hear what was tried and did not work so we can improve the process, but we are listening and paying attention, and happy to hear constructive criticism.

It's definitely NOT the intent that you must personally know someone at Google to resolve an issue with your Google Cloud Platform account.

mbrukman··on Google and Amazon Vie for Big Inroad into Wall Street Data Trove
They're not doing sequential scans of files on disk, they're doing random reads and writes in a database, where each write is replicated and durable, in parallel, across the entire key space of market transactions. The task was to reconcile market transactions end-to-end by matching orders with their parent/child orders (e.g., as orders get merged/split or routed from broker/dealers to others or to exchanges to be executed), thus building millions (billions?) of graphs across the entire dataset. You can see more details in the video of the presentation at the bottom of this blog post: https://cloudplatform.googleblog.com/2016/03/financial-servi... but I presume you're much more familiar with the intricacies of the stock market than I am. :)

Here's the performance you can expect to see per Cloud Bigtable server node in your cluster, whether for random reads/writes or for sequential scans: https://cloud.google.com/bigtable/docs/performance

Here's a benchmark comparing Cloud Bigtable to HBase and Cassandra that may be of interest (on a different benchmark than presented in the FIS blog post, but shows the relative price/performance): https://cloudplatform.googleblog.com/2015/05/introducing-Goo...

Disclosure: I am the product manager for Google Cloud Bigtable. Let me know if you have any other questions, I'm happy to discuss further.

mbrukman··on How Diane Greene Transformed Google's Cloud
Thanks for all the feedback!

Appreciate your taking the time to write this up in detail, and thanks for not sugar-coating it. We'll share this with the relevant teams and work on improvements across the board. Great to hear that you like the changes to the docs!

Please keep providing feedback and suggestions.

mbrukman··on How Diane Greene Transformed Google's Cloud
I'm curious why you would need to delete projects and create new ones just to try out new products and services—could you please clarify?

A project is just a container for resources. You can use any combination of GCP products and services within a single project—you are only charged for the resources you use, so just deleting what you created earlier would get you to a zero-state.

mbrukman··on How Diane Greene Transformed Google's Cloud
Hi, I'm a product manager on Google Cloud Platform. Sorry to hear that your credits expired before you could try out GCP.

I inquired on your behalf, and was told that the Web Summit you're referring to is from 2014 (2 years ago), and the credits expired in 2015 (1 year ago), and unfortunately, this program is no longer available.

That said, we do have a credits program for startups (https://cloud.google.com/startups/) but you cannot apply for it directly, you need to "contact your VC, Accelerator, or Incubator and ask about GCP for Startups application details." (quote from the site)

In the mean time, if you just want to kick the tires, you can sign up on https://cloud.google.com for a free trial.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2