HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mc-lovin

241 karma · joined May 5, 2013

submissionscomments
mc-lovin··on The Echo Chamber of Silicon Valley
I'm biased because I thought of about making an app similar to twist, but I think this is a great app, and not just something that appeals to "techies" or whatever we are calling nerds now. In fact, I think it has the potential to reduce road accidents by reducing unnecessary phone calls while driving.
mc-lovin··on What is Happening in Istanbul?
It seems that some of what you are saying is not that different to the claims I was replying to, but with a different interpretation.

E.g. you consider weakening the power of legal bodies, the media and the military to be bad, but from their point of view, these bodies were supporting an undemocratic power structure that favored the pro-secular minority.

On alcohol, there is not a blanket ban, but fairly strict restrictions (in particular limiting sales of alcohol from 6am to 10pm). And lifting the ban on head-scarfs seems like the lifting of excessive restrictions, not the imposition of Islamic ideas.

As to Erdogan's general ideas on the nature of democracy, can you be more specific?

mc-lovin··on Poll: Full-time software engineers in the Bay Area, what's your annual salary?
Log base 10 would be a good compromise with the ridiculously vague "N figure salary" descriptions.

Makes for much more accurate boasting: "they were offering me a 6.3 figure salary, but in the industry I'm in, it's no big deal"

mc-lovin··on What is Happening in Istanbul?
Excuse my ignorance in the following, I am trying to understand the situation based on very little prior knowledge:

What you say makes a lot of sense, but can you comment on how this generally "good" government seems to be using excessive force, and the claimed media blackout on the protests?

I understand that the government may be more respectful of democracy than their opponents, but is it possible that the protesters still want more freedom and democracy, rather than supporting the Kemalist ideology?

mc-lovin··on What is Happening in Istanbul?
"religion-free" is a highly ambiguous term. Can you clarify?

I think that a person has a right to wear whatever clothing they feel appropriate, assuming they aren't committing indecent exposure and they don't have giant spikes protruding from their clothing that could endanger others.

Can you clarify what individual rights you think exist on university campuses, and how these interact with your goal of keeping universities "religion-free"?

mc-lovin··on What is Happening in Istanbul?
You should also look into the "door to door searches", that was a more serious issue, especially since there is a real danger of a slippery slope for this particular policing strategy.
mc-lovin··on Learn C
I was in a similar situation to the author: largely self-taught, very little formal training or knowledge of the "big picture" ideas.

It's a bit like learning a language. You can learn a foreign language without formally studying grammar, and most of the time you will instinctively get things right, and have an intuitive idea of how grammar works.

But formally studying the grammar of a new language makes learning much faster, and you have a deeper understanding.

mc-lovin··on Learn C
While I'm very sympathetic to Allen's viewpoint, it seems that there was, and still is, a large class of problems where C-like languages (where the programmer does the optimizations) are better than high level languages with optimized compilers.

The best example for her case would be Fortran, where the language is both higher level, and faster, because the compiler can make much more assumptions (my understanding is the restrict keyword somewhat evens the playing field with C, but that is kind of a hack).

However, plenty of numerical work is also done in C, in spite of Fortran's availability.

mc-lovin··on Ask HN: Is 30 too old to start in software engineering or CS?
I agree that you want to ensure that the coursework is of sufficient quality. However, I wouldn't avoid terminal masters degrees with no financial support in themselves. E.g. Stanford's MS in CS falls into this category.

Edit: not that the parent post was implying that such programs should be avoided, bit it is common advice.

mc-lovin··on New Camera Sensor Eliminates Need for Flash
Yeah, that also struck me as very odd.

Assuming all the other claims are true, my best explanation is that this guy's research is coming out of left field, and so he is not very familiar with how the industry works, and so he can't be certain of anything when it comes to how his research will be used.

mc-lovin··on Poll: Full-time software engineers in the Bay Area, what's your annual salary?
>This is probably the most "echo chamber" friendly statement of any I've seen here.

And what does the fact that all the replies disagree, and the post was down-voted, tell you about the existence of an "echo chamber"? (Remember to avoid confirmation bias here!)

Also the poster didn't claim a causal relationship. The claim was the reading HN was correlated to success, not that it caused it.

> An assertion with no evidence, seemingly rooted in a self satisfying sense of superiority The evidence was in the survey, but if you don't believe in a particular causal relationship (in this case, better engineer -> higher salary) then any correlation can always be dismissed as "not evidence".

The assumption of "a self satisfying sense of superiority" was all yours. To many people it's simply obvious that there is a correlation between how good you are at your job and how much you get paid.

mc-lovin··on Poll: Full-time software engineers in the Bay Area, what's your annual salary?
And I think many in the valley are sick of your false egalitarianism.

Some people smarter than other people. And those people, on average will get paid more.

I don't see a whole lot of rage when people talk about how it takes good people skills to get a lot of jobs. But the moment intelligence becomes a requirement, everyone suddenly thinks that's unfair, or there is no such thing as intelligence.

I don't deny that there are many factors leading to higher SV salaries, but intelligence is also a factor.

For example I came from a very ordinary middle class background. To the extent that I have more education and a higher salary than people with the same background, I attribute it to my intelligence. I don't think that makes me better than other people, even though I'm constantly told that having better social skills makes you better than other people. And I don't think that there is a level playing field either, but conditional on my background I still earn a relatively high salary.

The counterpart to the smugness you complain about is your moral smugness. And there is plenty of that on HN too.

mc-lovin··on Solitary in Iran Nearly Broke Me. Then I Went Inside America's Prisons
You are making a lot of assumptions, which seem taylored to bolster a particular worldview, rather than be based in fact. In particular, you assume

1. People differ vastly in their innate ability to follow societal rules.

2. The justice system is able to distinguish between people who make simple mistakes, and people who are unable to follow society rules.

3. The above is a big factor in sentencing.

While there is evidence that some aspects of behavior are innate, there is also a huge literature linking the environment a person is raised in, and their tendency towards crime. Furthermore, sentencing is generally extremely inconsistent by any standards, so it is very unlikely that sentencing would fit your criteria for being lenient to the right people. Finally, it's hard to think of sentencing criteria that fit the criteria you propose, and are also objective.

mc-lovin··on The declining value of the MS in Computer Science
In my experience, employers care more about research than you might imagine (for reasons the other replier has mentioned).

That said, a coursework MS will make you generally much more attractive to employers. It's just that they will interpret the degree as more of a signal of your capability and intelligence (and this effect is greatly underestimated by HN) than an indication of any specific expertise.

So with a coursework masters, you stand a chance of having generally great job opportunities, but you may be disappointed that you are not eligible for the most interesting jobs, even though they are related to your coursework.

mc-lovin··on Giving Up Paying Off $186,000 Student Loan Debt
What I meant was that the amount of wealth redistribution would be a function of your income, not the fact that you really need more money to do a particular thing.

So if I decide it would be really life assuming to quit my job and become an artist, society doesn't have more duty to help me do this than they do to help anyone else on a particular income.

mc-lovin··on Giving Up Paying Off $186,000 Student Loan Debt
What I meant was that when designing rules for bankruptcy etc., but also for how education is funded and other things, society has high level goals which are guided by morality.

My point was that when society considers what it's goals are, it should never be a goal that a person should be able to do things that "give their life meaning" when they can't afford them, because ultimately it is a person's own responsibility how they manage their money.

So my post was aimed at people who thought "isn't it horrible that this woman can't do what she wants in life simply because she can't afford it"

mc-lovin··on Giving Up Paying Off $186,000 Student Loan Debt
As a consumer your only duty is to obey they law.

However, moral duty is relevant when it comes to how society should think about debt. Everyone has things they would like to do if they had more money. Society should not be arranged to give people a free pass just because they want to do something that requires money.

mc-lovin··on The declining value of the MS in Computer Science
Having an MS on your resume is worth it for itself, let alone all the extra knowledge you can get.

So the real questions is: can you handle the coursework?

Only you can answer that. If you can pass the degree, and it is from a decent school, I don't see how it could fail to be worth it.

mc-lovin··on The declining value of the MS in Computer Science
It seems like your objection is to the fact that undergrad-like course loads are branded as MS degrees.

But the question here is what is best for the poster.

Assuming he can pass the MS degree, a future employer will give much more credit to an MS than a second BS in CS. Furthermore, as he describes it, the coursework already includes the equivalent of an undergrad in CS or more.

mc-lovin··on How to Negotiate a Job Offer
Most companies are willing to negotiate, especially when you have a counter-offer. So in general, it is good advice. Most companies do not have the attitude of "I don't care how much money you would make at an other company, because you want to join our company" because they know that most people value some combination of enjoying their work, and how much they get paid, not just one or the other.

>The first part is very personal. People having mortgage and two kids just overvalue themselves. Immigrants in US (and I guess everywhere) just don't need as much money as they don't see the neighbour's grass. Can you explain what you are saying here? Are you saying that only immigrants are willing to take the offers you make, or that you make higher offers to people who overvalue themselves?

mc-lovin··on Teacher under fire for informing kids of their Fifth Amendment rights
He sighed. That's the confession we need.
mc-lovin··on My takeaways from "Clean Code"
The best thing about functions with no side effects and no output arguments, is they often get optimized out by the compiler.
mc-lovin··on Is Data Science Your Next Career?
I would also add that econometricians are highly focused, almost exclusively focused in fact, on finding causal relationships.

This means that descriptive work such as clustering, dimension reduction, is often either ignored, or considered as a kind of pre-processing before the real work starts.

mc-lovin··on Is Data Science Your Next Career?
My take on data science, and what makes it distinct from other fields, is that it combines a knowledge of the business logic (i.e. software engineering) with knowledge of statistics.

For example, a statistician might wonder exactly what a particular ID referred to. Does it mean a person, an IP address, a single "session". They could, of course, find this out, but the data scientist would already know this.

Similarly, a software engineer might wonder what information they need to be collecting from the user. The data scientist knows what analysis will ultimately be done, and so knows what information must be collected.

So data science combines statistics and software engineering, and this is useful because it allows a holistic view of the data analysis process, from the collection of data, to the statistical analysis of the processed data.

mc-lovin··on Is Data Science Your Next Career?
This is a free version of the book "Mining Massive Datasets".

Basically statistical methods that work with big datasets, which is the core of data science.

http://infolab.stanford.edu/~ullman/mmds.html

mc-lovin··on How to hire good people instead of nice people
It's a new loophole: guilt them out of exercising their rights under federal law to get pregnant on your dime.
mc-lovin··on How to hire good people instead of nice people
You will have to hug him. But he's alpha, so it won't be creepy. Learn the difference.
mc-lovin··on Sucks to be an old engineer
Now that the issue of "discrimination" has reared its ugly head, no one can give a straight answer to your question.

By that I mean that any explanation of why people over 30 really are worse programmers, will be interpreted as "discrimination" and therefore wrong. Any explanation of why people over 30 are better programmers, will be taken as evidence that there must be a lot of discrimination since the older programmers are not only not worse, but better.

mc-lovin··on Is Silicon Valley only interested in the problems of twentysomethings?
You characterize the situation very well.

It reminds me of the parody of the academic left in sci fi such as the novels of Neal Stephenson and Vernor Vinge. And the parodies of religion and philosophy are even worse.

It certainly came as a shock to me to realize that much of academia is simultaneously incoherent and pretentious, and full of deep insights.

mc-lovin··on Show HN: Got my Pebble and built a seven minute workout watchapp today
mine is a regexp
← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →