HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mc-lovin

241 karma · joined May 5, 2013

submissionscomments
mc-lovin··on Bitcoin is Deflationary, and That's OK
Milton Friedman wasn't a Keynesian, and yet he advocated monetarism, which is essentially the same as inflation targeting, except instead of keeping inflation constant, you keep the rate of increase of the money supply constant.

In academic economics, even Keynes never advocated permanently distorting the economy towards consumption and away from spending. Of course people who like government spending for other reasons will incorrectly cite Keynes to justify their position.

Real interest rates determine the saving vs consumption decision, not inflation.

See here for the arguments that real economists use to justify a 2% inflation rate

http://econfan.blogspot.com/2011/07/why-target-inflation-at-...

mc-lovin··on An eBook pricing model that resulted in $100,000 in sales
Neo-classical economics suggests that it is, in fact ethical to get as much money as possible out of your customers.

Not because people should only care about themselves, but because redistribution through the tax system, and charitable giving, are far more efficient at producing net gain for society, than being "nice" to your customers.

Competition is what prevents people from being "gouged" when it comes to the necessities of life, and in the absence of competition, yes, government intervention is justified.

While the author is a monopolist ex post, in that once he writes his book, he has a monopoly, the market is competitive ex ante, in that anyone can choose to write a book on that subject matter.

So it is almost certainly justified to maximize profit, just as it is in most other businesses.

mc-lovin··on Soylent Campaign
It's a diet shake where the seller goes "you know what, fuck it, I don't recommend that you eat a balanced diet, and I do recommend you replace all your meals with this shake"
mc-lovin··on Warren Buffett: Success in investing doesn't correlate with IQ
You don't seem to understand what is meant by the term "efficient market".

The efficient market hypothesis does not preclude the possibility that share prices could be improved by a buyout or activist shareholder.

mc-lovin··on One-Time Pad reinvented to make electronic copying impossible
>But one of the other requirements set forth in the paper is that if the slab is stolen, Eve must not be able to send or receive messages. I'm not sure how that is fulfilled here.

If a "full" message involved both sides randomly picking a P, then this could still be satisfied.

But it doesn't seem to live up to my hopes for security: all it really guarantees is that the probability of Eve decrypting an intercepted message (assuming she steals the slab for time t and knows all the P's) is t/T where T is the time Bob and Alice spend generating K(B) + K(A) for different P's.

mc-lovin··on Warren Buffett: Success in investing doesn't correlate with IQ
I wasn't joking.

> If it were, as Buffett has noted frequently, his success would have been completely impossible. Indeed, the most money is made from the highest inefficiencies.

Survivorship bias? I don't know, but in any case market efficiency is a very general claim, it doesn't rule out some "special" people with innate talent to predict future prices.

>And there's no inherent or guaranteed mechanism that drives under or over valued stocks back into any theoretical fair value line. Stocks are governed by human judgment ultimately - which typically swings emotionally to extremes - there's nothing efficient about that.

Just empty rhetoric. Look into the literature of econometric tests of the efficient market hypothesis.

mc-lovin··on One-Time Pad reinvented to make electronic copying impossible
Thanks, that's what I thought but I'm glad you confirmed it and put it in their notation.

So here is my issue:

Eve knows P, so she can steal the object and hence compute K(B).

The difficulty in "copying" the object is only significant when Eve does not know P.

But that same difficulty would apply if K(A) and K(B) were random numbers that Alice and Bob generated when they met.

Or is the point that Alice and Bob generate K(A) + K(B) for a lot of values of P, and then randomly select the ones to use when sending a message? That doesn't seem to be what the authors intended, although it would now be secure against stealing the object for a short amount of time.

mc-lovin··on Warren Buffett: Success in investing doesn't correlate with IQ
It should be the other way around: below a certain IQ all you need is the efficient market hypothesis and you will be an adequate investor.
mc-lovin··on The Next Facebook — Musings About Text Boxes
> I'm a pretty good looking guy with a good job that goes to a great school. So why the fuck is adding someone on FB

Not that I think that your friend request was creepy, but why would a judgment as to the creepiness of your actions depend on any of these things?

Or are you just accepting the reality that people are labeled 'creepy' based on their desirability and not the inherent creepiness of their actions.

mc-lovin··on One-Time Pad reinvented to make electronic copying impossible
Can someone explain this to me? I read the article but it didn't make sense.

The physical object as I understand it provides a source of random data, with the property that it is fast to do a single lookup (shine an arbitrary light pattern on it), but slow to copy the whole data.

This means that an attacker who steals the object, but doesn't know which lookups will be done, won't be able to copy all the data.

Now my objection is that the only lookups that the person who steals the object will not be able to do, is the ones based on random patterns that have not been published, i.e. the ones that are generated next time Alice and Bob meet.

But from that point of view, it would be no less safe if Alice and Bob simply generated a one time pad and stored it when they met.

mc-lovin··on Solving the Research Integrity Crisis
Formal auditing strikes me as a completely unhelpful layer of bureaucracy.

What is needed is a culture of sharing code and data (unless that is impossible due to restrictions on the data that was used), and the tools to allow this to happen.

This is already happening, we just need more of the same.

One issue is the incentive structure in many fields means that you only get rewarded for both collecting data, and analyzing it. Therefore there is a big incentive not to share data, since you get little or no credit when someone else uses your data.

mc-lovin··on The biggest merger you didn't hear about today
The problem with your reasoning is that people already know that the pharma industry has a complex industrial structure, and that mergers happen from time to time. Furthermore, prices change constantly for a variety of reasons. None of this imply that this merger is particularly interesting as news.

By your logic, people should be constantly bombarded with "important" stuff like price indices for medical services, world food prices, aggregate steel production, measures of industry concentration in the wholesale corn market etc.

mc-lovin··on [dead]
(a) how dare you imply Slate don't have every right to put pop-ups anywhere they like on their property. (b) but she makes a great straw woman for people who don't want to debate against classical economic arguments.
mc-lovin··on Tesla Rides High, But Faces Formidable Foe: Car Dealers
Unfortunately the argument that in a free market, what maximizes profit is socially optimal, is not taught in schools, and alien to many people.

It doesn't help that in public debate, this argument is usually espoused by people on the right who mix it in with other unrelated arguments. So people end up thinking that if they support the free market, they also have to support cutting all welfare.

mc-lovin··on Dear American Consumers: Please don’t start eating healthfully
Excellent point. Furthermore, new foods can be developed that achieve better combinations of satiation and satiety, and other desired outcomes.

I think it's fair to say that the entire medical profession has in the past suffered from a tendency to convince people to maximize their health, rather than maximize the combination of their health, and whatever other outcomes people desire, such as eating tasty food or feeling satiated. This tendency is flawed because it is not consistent with what people want to do, and is always therefore an uphill battle.

As the field matures, this is definitely changing, but the discussion around nutrition shows there is still a long way to go.

mc-lovin··on Containers have been more important for globalisation than freer trade
Could you shed some light on the strange employment structure in your industry?

My impression is that unions in this industry are a combination of the bad (artificially restricting the supply of labor, to the benefit of union members, and the detriment of non members) and good (giving workers to power to maintain safety standards, and making sure that workers feel they can trust their fellow workers).

What limits communication? Is it the fact that a lot of the workers are temp workers, or is it unrelated?

mc-lovin··on Containers have been more important for globalisation than freer trade
What do you think are the main potential areas for improvement in the field? Is there potential for more automation?

It sounds like a fascinating job, those cranes look really cool.

mc-lovin··on Containers have been more important for globalisation than freer trade
>this comment also shows that for some of the work (here loading and packing), the container just moves to the burden to a different entity (here the manufacturer instead of the longshoremen).

But shifting the burden to the manufacturer is clearly advantageous, because, as the post also shows, the manufacturer knows more about their product and how to pack it.

Also, because neither origin or the final destination of the container are the port, there is less loading/unloading of the individual objects. The container is packed and unpacked exactly once, and apart from that only the whole container need be moved

mc-lovin··on Open source is not a war zone
It's an unspoken assumption that goes unchallenged because it's easier for people targeted by these stereotypes to distance themselves from "nerds" than to challenge these assumptions.
mc-lovin··on Call Mom Maybe
Well said.

It seems to me that while we have deconstructed certain normative ideas (e.g. that everyone should be heterosexual), there is no general interested in pursuing a truly liberal agenda where people define for themselves who they are and how they want to live, rather than live by arbitrary rules.

What is happening is that the old rules are now being replaced by new rules. And people who break these rules are no longer called degenerates, they are called autists.

mc-lovin··on U.S. Students Rank Worst in New Sleep Study
But they are working through the night to prepare the article for submission.
mc-lovin··on Ruchi Sanghvi, Dropbox VP, testifies on immigration reform [video]
So what exactly was Orwellian about my terminology? I missed the point where you said that.

You have basically dodged my argument about taxes an economic efficiency. By your logic, a policy that destroys $1 worth of real goods in a randomly selected company, and provides 10c of wealth to a "worker", would be justified. This in spite of the fact that the taxation system could accomplish a much more efficient redistribution of wealth.

Why are you arguing about H-1B visas when you really should be arguing for higher taxes (for the top 10% of income earners).

mc-lovin··on Ruchi Sanghvi, Dropbox VP, testifies on immigration reform [video]
While you are correct that H-1B visa's benefit employers of tech workers, and harm American tech workers, you are wrong to claim that this means it is a matter of billionaires vs "workers".

Most of these companies are public, and therefore pay money to shareholders, and also pay taxes. The distribution of wealth is a separate issue, that could be dealt with by changes to the tax system.

Both sides on the H-1B debate come up with bad arguments for their cause, but the economics is very simple: labor is like any other commodity, and free trade is optimal, ignoring externalities. In this case the main externality is having a bunch of foreigners living in the US, and possibly staying: it's up to Americans how costly (or beneficial) they think this is.

mc-lovin··on With Rifle and Bibliography: General Mattis on Professional Reading
The argument you are making is basically an argument from authority, which would be fine if you understood the nature of the authority in question, but you do not.

Peer reviewed journals contain a lot of garbage. Whether this should be the case is irrelevant. There are plenty of people on HN qualified to both judge and understand the study and my criticism of it. If you cannot understand my comment or for some other reason are unwilling to comment on its substance, that's fine, but there is no reason to dismiss it out of hand.

Also, there is a fundamental flaw in your logic. You keep saying that it irrelevant whether the studies methodology is valid or not, and yet this is the only evidence you give for your position. You say that I failed to give a counter-argument, and yet I directly addressed the only argument you gave for the relationship between empathy and reading, namely that study.

mc-lovin··on With Rifle and Bibliography: General Mattis on Professional Reading
"I'll let you take that up with the authors."

That's a fairly flippant way to deal with my criticism. If you post a study here, it's fine if you haven't read it, but you shouldn't pretend that anything that's been published is infallible.

mc-lovin··on With Rifle and Bibliography: General Mattis on Professional Reading
"In order to rule out the role of personality, we first identified Openness as the most consistent correlate. This trait was then statistically controlled for, along with two other important individual differences: the tendency to be drawn into stories and gender. Even after accounting for these variables, fiction exposure still predicted performance on an empathy task."

This methodology is fundamentally flawed. There is no technical fix to get around the fact that you cannot distinguish between reading causing more empathy, or greater empathy causing more reading.

They are trying to measure the relationship between personality traits and reading, and then claiming to control for personality!

mc-lovin··on This Is What One Half Second of High Speed Trading Looks Like
Thanks, that was a good explaination. If you look carefully, the timing between exchanges is identical, so hopefully they at least chose some representative latency between exchanges.
mc-lovin··on Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill (2012)
The whole point of the article was to question the validity of the diagnosis of mental illness, which you completely ignore when you blithely add the disclaimer that "these folks" refers only to people who are mentally ill.
mc-lovin··on Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill (2012)
Not necessarily. The power of the government stems not only from it's ability to inflict violence against groups (e.g. bombing a city) but also individuals (e.g. arresting a single person). Against the latter, ordinary weapons are still very effective. When police overstep their legal rights, it is even lawful in some states to use force to defend yourself.
mc-lovin··on If you get a PhD, get an economics PhD
The issue is that there just isn't that much data. You collect a bunch of macro level time series variables. Ok now what? No matter how cool or sophisticated your model is, there is just too little data to tell which models actually fit reality.

The criticism I describe is what most economists tell me when I bring up agent based models. In practice they mostly just ignore the field.

← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →