HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mc-lovin

241 karma · joined May 5, 2013

submissionscomments
mc-lovin··on Interviewing in Silicon Valley
Not really. These are two separate issues. If I am a gold panner, I might be very satisfied with my gold panning technique, and yet complain that there is a shortage of gold in the river.
mc-lovin··on Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Against Rent Increases
Free speech is the point because if the government decided that expressing a political opinion counted as provocation in an assault or battery charge, this would probably violate the first amendment. Legally the issue is around assault and battery, but the underlying issue is freedom of speech.

"The first amendment doesn't protect you from blowback and it's not supposed to."

Correct that is what the criminal code, and the fascist police, are for.

"Freedom of speech is not freedom from criticism."

This discussion is about violence, not criticism.

"However if you consider freedom of speech an issue between citizens, wouldn't the right to bear arms be the greatest enemy of freedom of speech? Seems like "an armed society is a polite society" is a recipe for a society where nobody speaks their mind for fear of losing their life..."

Possibly though I haven't heard of someone getting shot for expressing an opinion. Most people are afraid to go to jail for murder, while leftists who push and shove rarely even get charged.

mc-lovin··on If you get a PhD, get an economics PhD
Econ aims to capture important aspects of real world systems, not model them perfectly. You can compare it with CS: big O notation is not useless even though in principle the constants in the big O notation could be huge. Turing machines are a useful abstraction even though in real life it is impossible to build one.

The criticism by mainstream economists of agent based models, is that they are so flexible you can create almost any kind of behavior you like. That said, the constraints that rationality impose on models don't prevent this either: with enough work you can get any kind of phenomenon you like in an econ model.

At the end of the day, economics is hard because people, institutions and technology are complex, much more complex than atoms. If you stuck with it, I'm sure your viewpoint would have softened somewhat. Once you try to actually do economics, you'll see why people made so many assumptions that seemed stupid before.

mc-lovin··on Interviewing in Silicon Valley
Well it's hard to quantify the relative importance of personality and cultural fit vs intelligence and programming ability. You can turn what you said around, and say that you can be the nicest, coolest person in the world, but if you are a fucking moron who can't code, you won't be very useful.

But the big tech companies seem to have settled on the current process, and are therefore probably fairly happy with the people their interview process is giving them. As to looking at previous projects, that makes sense but it might be more time consuming to properly evaluate someone like that.

mc-lovin··on Interviewing in Silicon Valley
I think there is a lot of negative bias here, because people who do badly in algorithms and data structure questions, or dislike them for some other reason, are more likely to speak on the issue.

I think that these questions are good because they are difficult, and a smarter more capable person is much more likely to get them right. Notice that big tech companies have stopped with the "brainteaser" style questions like how many potholes in Manhatten, but there is no move away from algorithms and data structures questions. And I don't consider the format to be high pressure. Apart from the pressure inherent in having to answer the question on the spot, I never felt any pressure from the interviewer, they tended to be very polite and mild mannered. At worst they didn't understand or agree with my solution.

Telling people that these interview questions suck and they should look for jobs where they don't have to answer them, is really bad advice. Some of the best jobs (for most people) require them. If you face such an interview, the very best thing you can do is study. I probably did 100 interview questions in preparation for my job interviews.

mc-lovin··on Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Against Rent Increases
You misunderstood my use of the term "unsympathetic".

I meant it in the sense of being unsympathetic towards an opinion (the opinion that there is something unjust about gentrification) not towards the alleged victims of gentrification.

My aim is to express an opinion: That tech workers have a right to live where they want to, and that it's not the right of the local community, or people claiming to represent them, to stop them living where they choose to and frequenting the businesses they choose to.

Now this might be upsetting to people who think of themselves as victims of gentrification, but I didn't formulate this viewpoint for the purpose of upsetting them. If I have to change my viewpoint, or choose not to express it, because someone finds it upsetting, then that is not freedom of speech.

So unless you think that people should be forced to curtail their speech and keep their opinions to themselves, whenever that opinion is offensive to someone who has (or feels they have) suffered some ill fortune, you should stop comparing what I proposed to do with willfully inciting violence towards myself.

mc-lovin··on Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Against Rent Increases
The funny thing is, I never considered when I posted that that there would be violence beyond the usual getting in your face that I've seen at left wing protests.

Why does the fact that these people are upset make their cause any more just? Why do my rights (and more importantly the rights of any tech employees who might happen to pass through there) end where their feelings begin?

Also, how sympathetic would you feel towards a Black man who "antagonized" white people by passing through a White neighborhood, and was attacked by Whites who were already upset by the civil rights movement.

mc-lovin··on Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Against Rent Increases
You make some good points, and I will bear them in mind when dealing with these people.

However, what you say makes the complaints by the protesters about the heavy police presence seem ridiculous: it cannot be the case that this protest is "peaceful" and yet anyone present who appears to be against hem would be in serious danger.

mc-lovin··on Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Against Rent Increases
Perhaps group B have legitimate complaints, but I somehow doubt they are serious enough to justify violence against anyone who makes light of their "struggle".

If it's true that these people have organized an event where someone would be physically assaulted for wearing a Google sweater (if there were no police there) then that's precisely why I would want to do it. People have a right to express themselves, they don't have a right to make other people feel unsafe.

mc-lovin··on Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Against Rent Increases
You seem to know much more about this situation than me, but given my experience in the left, I would be very surprised if the people involved in an open air drug den had much to do with the people attending and organizing this protest.

And there seems to be a discrepancy between the extreme danger you claim I would be in, and the claims of other people that this is a harmless gathering. Can you shed some light on this? No sarcasm intended there, I really am surprised by how you characterize the situation because in my experience, no one provoking left wingers is ever in serious danger.

mc-lovin··on Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Against Rent Increases
I agree with you about the right to protest. I wasn't aware that was an issue: pretty sure that's not what the person I was replying to was talking about. Certainly none of the articles on the issue claimed that the police were acting outside the law. Maybe the guy beating a pinata with a pole was the issue, I don't know.
mc-lovin··on Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Against Rent Increases
How do poorer people lack a voice in local government? It seems to me their issue is that they want to extend their control over local affairs far beyond what is their right. It is simply not the right of local residents to determine what kind of person gets to live in that neighborhood. This was a block "party" to make a very specific kind of person feel unwelcome. And then they think of themselves as oppressed when the police break it up.
mc-lovin··on Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Against Rent Increases
As someone who generally believes in free markets, I am already unsympathetic to these people. However the venom directed at tech employees strikes me as something more than just economics.

People are having a go at nerds because they can. The scales of social status haven't changed since high school, but it turns out that nerds can earn a good salary, and in the "fascist" free market economy, this means they can live where they like, and the police will even protect them!

I wish I knew about this so I could show up in my Google sweater.

mc-lovin··on Experiment in paying villagers in India an unconditional basic income
My own point of view is that I'm not infallible and therefore it is better to state what I think is true, and let people draw whatever conclusions they like, and take whatever actions they like, based on what I say.

I expect on averaging that stating the truth should be beneficial rather than harmful, because people with good intentions will seek to base their arguments and actions on the truth, while people with bad intentions in many cases won't care.

So ultimately I also only care about "improvement" but I don't define this in terms of my own ideology, because I could be wrong on many things.

mc-lovin··on “SNL” Parodies Google Glass
Isn't it enough that nerds are constantly denigrated in the mainstream media without having to put up with this on tech sites too?
mc-lovin··on Experiment in paying villagers in India an unconditional basic income
You seem to be ignoring a third possibility, which is stating things because they are true, not because of how your statements will be "used".
mc-lovin··on Difference Engine: Luddite legacy
Getting rid of minimum wage is probably unnecessary: when people have a basic income, the "income effect" means that they are less willing to take low wages.

The main problem with your scheme is that in the far future, free trade could mean that countries with only labor and no capital would get a bad deal, and that without restrictions on people taking their wealth to other countries, the rich could theoretically use this to bargain the tax rate down so low that there was no money for a basic income (i.e. a "race to the bottom"). I don't think this will be an issue for a long time though.

mc-lovin··on Experiment in paying villagers in India an unconditional basic income
Funny how when things favor women they are just "objective facts" and therefore can't be labelled "sexist".

While all the things men are better have have already been proven to be results of cultural bias by esteemed sociologists...

mc-lovin··on Experiment in paying villagers in India an unconditional basic income
These decisions aren't made at a personal level.

E.g. when you provide people with free healthcare instead of giving them money, your are implicitly constraining their choices. Same for food stamps, free public transport for the poor, etc.

Determining who is in need means, for example, not giving welfare to people who are not genuinely searching for work. This is a difficult decision to make but it is done fairly well in Australia. It is mostly based on objective criteria e.g. filling in a list of places where you applied for work, showing up to interviews that are arranged for you.

I suspect that your objection is not to the general principles listed above, but rather to listing them explicitly without any disclaimers like "I know the government often gets this wrong" etc.

mc-lovin··on Experiment in paying villagers in India an unconditional basic income
Economists have long known that negative income tax (which is equivalent to a guaranteed basic income) is theoretically optimal under the usual assumptions of perfect markets and perfect rationality. However only very few economists, such as Milton Friedman, have advocated it as a practical policy.

On the one hand, guaranteed income is much more resistant corruption, since the distribution of money follows a simple rule where there is no discretion on the part of officials, and is similarly resistant to other kinds of rent seeking.

On the other hand, through traditional welfare systems, governments may be able to determine who is really in need, and thus save money on giving out welfare to people who could be earning more if they had to. Governments can also give out welfare in kind rather than cash, helping people to make better choices, or make welfare conditional on getting education or training.

I very much doubt that a negative income tax could improve over the best administered welfare systems such as Australia's. What is interesting is whether countries with much less ability to administer public services, would be better off with a guaranteed income.

← PreviousPage 5 of 5