HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mcdonje

1,757 karma · joined August 10, 2017

submissionscomments
mcdonje··on Extreme Heat conference cancelled due to extreme heat warning
We deserve to be scolded for a lot of things, but not that.
mcdonje··on Can you see three trees?
I read Don Quixote and thought it might be fun to visit some parts of Spain mentioned in the books. Then after looking at some maps and seeing a stark lack of trees, I decided I wouldn't enjoy the trip.
mcdonje··on Show HN: Kage – Shadow any website to a single binary for offline viewing
Not to load you up with too many ideas, but a markdown folder sounds a lot like obsidian, which has a plugin system now.

Epub would also be a great target.

mcdonje··on Electric motors with no rare earths
Another comment said they're not using brushes, so they shouldn't need more maintenance.
mcdonje··on How do you design a $30k electric pickup? Inside Ford's skunkworks
US companies outsourcing all of their manufacturing to countries with cheaper labor and laxer environmental & labor laws led to this. What did those titans of industry think would happen down the road? "I'll be retired." Corporations have way too much power in the US, and that has considerably weakened it.
mcdonje··on Facebook is paying people overseas promoting Alberta separatism
They definitely play both sides to spread chaos. That's been extremely effective for them in reducing American power and influence. Getting their messaging out there is also a goal.
mcdonje··on Show HN: I Derived a Pancake
Good start, but it still requires eggs?
mcdonje··on My Software North Star
Quote the entire sentence.

>It doesn’t matter that the language you use is memory-safe, if you didn’t design for correctness or have no process that will eventually lead you to fixing all bugs.

It's also worth noting that they linked a post about how memory safety is literally a matter of life and death, so it seems like their point is that memory safety is one class of bug, and a compiler guarantee about it doesn't equate to a guarantee of correct, bugless, unexploitable code.

Like, the linked author brought up that Khashoggi's wife's phone was hacked. Maybe that was due to a memory bug or some other kind of bug. Maybe the next journalist who gets hacked is a victim of a memory bug or some other kind of bug. But that linked post didn't take a holistic view of correctness, but went straight to, "Rust is safe. Rust saves lives." There's a logical error there that's being pointed out.

If you really want to save lives, you need to eliminate exploits. Not just do a victory lap because your compiler ostensibly eliminates one class of them. The compiler doesn't catch all bugs. The compiler isn't the only tool for catching bugs.

That's my reading of it, anyway. I think he has a point, and the Rust people do as well. I think it's wrong to portray him as bitter.

mcdonje··on Zig: Build System Reworked
Not really
mcdonje··on Zig: Build System Reworked
You have a weirdly restrictive definition of "tinker"
mcdonje··on What Apple and Google are doing to push notifications
What you're describing seems reasonable, but it doesn't align with what I quoted, unless I'm missing something, which I very well could be.

Having apps sleep and a daemon wake them to handle notifications doesn't require all of the notifications coming from Apple.

mcdonje··on What Apple and Google are doing to push notifications
The entire architecture here is surprising to me.

>an iPhone could not afford to let every installed application maintain its own background poll against a remote server. The proposal...a single persistent TLS connection from each device to Apple, over which any registered third party could deliver alerts.

I thought apps were sending notifications locally in the device. Like, if a messaging app receives a message, there's a network call for that. Then if the messaging app wants to tell the user they received a message, it can just hit a local API for that, right?

Is the pattern actually that the app makes another network call to the notification service to register the notification, which makes another network call to the device to deliver it?

mcdonje··on Canada to order military plane fleet from Sweden in shift from US suppliers
Seems like you're claiming Ukraine's 2014 "Revolution of Dignity" and subsequent democratic elections were something the USA did. That's a controversial claim, and one that ignores the recorded actions and sentiments of the Ukrainian people. It's also unrealistic and gives the US too much credit.

The US does have their hands in pies across the globe, but that was a large scale uprising of Ukrainian people. No outside force can make something like that happen if the people aren't already aligned.

The simpler explanation is the Ukrainian people wanted to be closer to the EU, and didn't like Yanukovych's authoritarian tendencies. I wouldn't be surprised if some propaganda blamed it on the US, but it doesn't make sense. If the US wanted to do regime change and the public wasn't behind it, it would look very different. There are unfortunately many examples.

mcdonje··on Texas woman arrested for Facebook post about town water quality
Whataboutism. Which is funny because it's literally the same problem.

It's somewhat intractable at this point unless or until we can figure out how to structure society in a way that can actually prevent it. Not sure we have the organizational knowledge at this point.

The government used to have better guards in place, but then what happened? They got weakened because of the monied interests already existed were successful at largely capturing the government. Guess what else happened during much the same time period; The government largely stopped breaking up monopolies, and many unions were busted or otherwise weakened or eliminated.

mcdonje··on Texas woman arrested for Facebook post about town water quality
His ability to use his wealth to influence the government and the populous would be significantly reduced. There's a big difference between "rich" and "rich enough circumvent democracy."
mcdonje··on Texas woman arrested for Facebook post about town water quality
They got captured
mcdonje··on Texas woman arrested for Facebook post about town water quality
"would"? There is currently a disparity in how rich and poor people are policed.

I get the point that there should be some limited immunity so they can do their jobs. Debatable, but worth the debate.

The argument about the repercussions of eliminating immunity is logical. It just seems like one of those things where there are multiple factors contributing to undesirable outcomes, and that makes it necessary to talk to experts.

mcdonje··on Deno 2.8
seL4 is an operating system that uses capabilities
mcdonje··on The case against boolean logic
True. Radix economy.
mcdonje··on A case against Boolean logic
I thought about mentioning nulls, but it's a complicated subject. Not all columns are nullable. Null handling rules differ. It's not always ISO/ANSI.
mcdonje··on A case against Boolean logic
A bool can be represented by a single bit. A tern(?) takes 2 bits or 1 trit to represent. Alternatively, a bool takes a trit to represent.

So, in terms of radix economy, ternary computing is the most efficient, but you're leaving information density unused if you use it for binary, and representing ternary with binary is inherently inefficient.

mcdonje··on A case against Boolean logic
In one respect, boolean logic is popular because of bits. If we had ternary processors, ternary logic would be more popular.

In another respect, boolean logic is popular because it's easy to reason about. The truth tables are relatively small in size and quantity. Not the case with ternary.

Ternary is probably way better at modeling the real world, but the complexity could make code hard to understand. Maybe that can be solved.

That said, boolean logic is more expressive than I think the blog post gives it credit for because it's usually only a part of the code. Like, it gets used a lot in SQL, where you're reasoning about with several columns. So, yeah, it's binary thinking on each dimension, but there are N dimensions.

The alternative presented is intuitionist logic, which is practically what in the computing world? Where is it used? Or where could or should it be used? I guess it can be represented in lamba calculus...

mcdonje··on Bun Rust rewrite: "codebase fails basic miri checks, allows for UB in safe rust"
A souffle has not been made
mcdonje··on Project Gutenberg – keeps getting better
Prescient
mcdonje··on Floats Don't Agree with Themselves
Yeah, they often call this to mind: "Better ingredients. Better pizza. Papa John's."
mcdonje··on The surprisingly complex journey to text-selectable client-side generated PDFs
EPUB is the ebook standard, outside of Amazon-land, so it has staying power in its space. I think it would be good for the ecosystem if it broke containment and got tooling in enough places to challenge PDF.
mcdonje··on SQLite Is a Library of Congress Recommended Storage Format
Man, Access could've been so good if they just made an app around SQLite. Or since it's Microsoft and they need to do everything their own way, it would've been so good if they made a flat file DB à la SQLite, but with T-SQL (or a subset thereof) instead of JET-SQL.

Increase interoperability. Funnel data people from Excel into real DB technologies.

And if they did more to blur the lines between spreadsheets and databases, and make it seamless to work out of both Excel and Access, add more spreadsheet features to the data views, etc.

mcdonje··on SQLite Is a Library of Congress Recommended Storage Format
PII sniffers are pretty good at dealing with excel files. Excel is seen more as an analyst tool than a dev tool. Any place that bans Excel needs to either let analysts use some other turing complete data tools, like python or R or something, or they'll have trouble attracting analyst talent. They'll have devs and data entry users and that's it.

The only way that works is if the dev team is large enough to be responsive to business needs, which almost never happens because devs are expensive. The juniors who are tweaking business logic every day are functionally doing a role analysts can do if you just give them a sane API and data tools.

mcdonje··on Pomiferous: The most extensive apples (pommes) database
Why are you making my screen look dirty? lol
mcdonje··on The Onion to Take over InfoWars
We're not going to have a rehash of the McDonald's coffee settlement argument here, are we?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punitive_damages

← PreviousPage 2 of 24Next →