HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mcprwklzpq

126 karma · joined June 26, 2018

submissionscomments
mcprwklzpq··on Mondragon Corporation
This quote without context might give impression that Chomsky is critical of Mondragon. A bit of context around it helps to understand his point. From [1]:

“LF: So it sounds as if you might support something like the Cleveland model where the ownership of the company is actually held by members of the community as well as the workers…

NC: That’s a step forward but you also have to get beyond that to dismantle the system of production for profit rather than production for use. That means dismantling at least large parts of market systems. <<here this quote about Mondragon>>

Markets also have a very bad psychological effect. They drive people to a conception of themselves and society in which you’re only after your own good, not the good of others and that’s extremely harmful.

LF: Have you ever had a taste of a non market system — had a flash of optimism –– oh this is how we could live?

NC: A functioning family for example, and there are bigger groups, cooperatives are a case in point. It certainly can be done. The biggest I know is Mondragon but there are many in between and a lot more could be done.”

1 - https://www.counterpunch.org/2012/04/30/talking-with-chomsky...

mcprwklzpq··on A Virtual Museum of Soviet Everyday Life
There are still a lot of "communalkas" in russia. In Saint Petersburg there were 76 600 of them in 2017 [1] and in Moscow 58 000 in 2008 (down from 118 000 in 1998) [2]. These are only that "communalkas" that are owned by the people that live in them. You can imagine how hard it is to turn a "communalka" into a flat that is owned by a single family. If somebody tries to buy the whole "communalka" any owner can refuse to sell and every owner has the "first right" to any part of the "communalka" so owners that want to sell their part have to get signed refusals of that right from all other owners.

There are also flats that have single owner but rented as "communalkas" to multiple families, and number of these flats is growing.

You can see "communalkas" in many soviet and russian movies, for example in "The Pokrovsky Gate" (1982) [3].

1 [rus] - https://mirndv.ru/blog/peterburg-gorod-mostov-belyh-nochej-i...

2 [rus] - https://www.cian.ru/novosti-v-rossii-po-prezhnemu-mnogo-komm...

3 [rus] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xo5PiDzYQCg

mcprwklzpq··on Programming Languages: Survivors and Wannabes (1996)
> bad tech book writer

You can't possibly mean his "Code: The Hidden Language of Computer Hardware and Software" or "The Annotated Turing: A Guided Tour through Alan Turing's Historic Paper on Computability and the Turing Machine"? These books are great.

mcprwklzpq··on Ask HN: What talks or videos do you suggest to watch on a long flight?
There is this youtube channel that regularly uploads short excerpts of Chomsky speaking on particular topics. Chomsky's Philosophy https://www.youtube.com/user/chomskysphilosophy

And this channel did a great compilation that introduces to all Chomsky's works. Table of contents is in the video description. Topics are: War, State Power, and American Exceptionalism. Capitalism, Neoliberalism, and Corporate Propaganda. Anarchism, Libertarian Socialism, and Classical Liberalism. Science, Philosophy, and Language. Noam Chomsky - The Essentials https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1umiaNjOinE

mcprwklzpq··on Ask HN: What talks or videos do you suggest to watch on a long flight?
Never had a mindset to understand what sometimes are they talking about in humanities. Recently found this series of short and clear leactures on many of such topics. Philosophy of the Humanities https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLPeStI124dee1ByfcDzRv...

Then this huge series of lectures on western philosophy introduces to a lot of ideas about everything. Can listen anytime. Arthur Holmes: A History of Philosophy https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL9GwT4_YRZdBf9nIUHs0z...

Then this category theory keeps popping up everywhere, completly incomprehensible, seems like mathematicians are gone mad. I found that this lectures help like no others to catch up to them. Category theory for programmers by Bartosz Milewski https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLbgaMIhjbmEnaH_LTkxLI...

mcprwklzpq··on Complicating the Narratives
Oh, then i read and understood it wrong. I did not think that article about different topic would make any difference.
mcprwklzpq··on Complicating the Narratives
Yes, 'other community' questions imply binary division on issue. I think this questions were proposed to a mediator between the debating parties to try to move conversation into more productive direction. This questions aren't that useful when you start a conversation and can frame it not as a debate.
mcprwklzpq··on Complicating the Narratives
I took this notes.

Journalist Amanda Ripley says that "Complexity is contagious" and that "Complicating the narrative means finding and including the details that don’t fit the [binary] narrative — on purpose."

So in some study participants talk about polarizing issue. Before talking they read one article about it.

If article is similar to news article with 2 sides to the story, participants take sides, argue and leave with negative impression that conversation is meaningless.

If article is similar to anthropologist’s field notes, with emphasis on complexity of the issue and without binary division, then participants “don’t solve the debate” but "do have a more nuanced understanding and more willingness to continue the conversation" researcher and social psychologist Peter T. Coleman says.

Then in a long case study of some american talk show some specialists propose general questions to bring more nuance to conversations.

What divides us?

What is oversimplified about this issue?

How has this conflict affected your life?

What do you think the other side wants?

What’s the question nobody is asking?

What do you and your supporters need to learn about the other side in order to understand them better?

What do you think the other community thinks of you?

What do you think of the other community?

What do you want the other community to know about you?

What do you want to know about the other community?

mcprwklzpq··on China’s social credit system ‘could interfere in other nations’ sovereignty’
Am i parsing this wrong?

The first headline says: China’s social credit system ‘could interfere in other nations’ sovereignty’

And the second headline says: [China’s social credit system] is shaping behaviour of foreign businesses

So "to interfere in other nations sovereignty" is "to shape behaviour of foreign businesses"? So "other nation" is "foreign business"? So "business" is "nation"?

mcprwklzpq··on Luck in Wesnoth: Rationale (2008)
I read somewhere that Wesnoth was in parts inspired by sega genesis game Warsong, but i see that not in one important part trough, or players would not feel so unlucky and get into situations where they want to abuse save/load mechanics to get a better luck. In Wesnoth each unit accumulates experience and they get more and more valuable and irreplaceable later in the game campaigns. In Warsong commander units each have up to 8 hired units under their command and get experience from hired units fights, while hired units do not accumulate experience at all, being cannon fodder. Before players would lose valuable commander to luck they would lose 8 unvaluable troops in a row at which point it is impossible to blame luck. Players always feel in control of the battle even through fight outcomes are very random.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2