HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mdnahas

267 karma · joined April 7, 2020

Masters in CS and Econ Designer of par2 file format Employee #7 in successful fintech startup Quantitative trader

https://michaeldnahas.com

submissionscomments
mdnahas··on The Tyranny of the Marginal User
Partly, it’s the business model. I was at OkCupid and we made money by ads, rather than successful matches, and this drives the business.

Another is the metrics. OkCupid tried to focus on “three ways”, which was a message, a reply, and a reply to the reply. That’s just enough communication to make a date for Marl. If we had focused on users who had a better-than-marginal experience, it might have preserved the features this author liked.

But, really, a different business model makes a big difference.

mdnahas··on How to write correct code by construction using the Coq Proof Assistant
If you’re interested, here is my Coq tutorial.

http://michaeldnahas.com/doc/nahas_tutorial.html

It has been mentioned on HN before (multiple times).

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21625852

mdnahas··on The Carrot Problem
The Dean of UVA business school was heard saying “Don’t compete unless you have an unfair advantage.”
mdnahas··on Ask HN: Who wants to be hired? (July 2023)
Location: Austin, TX Remote: No Willing to relocate: Yes Technologies: economist, predictive mathematics, Python, C/C++/Java, distributed systems Résumé/CV: https://www.linkedin.com/in/michael-nahas-1012232/ Email: hackernews@mike.nahasmail.com

Designer of Par2 (and Par3) file format.

I got a Masters in CS. I designed and coded low-latency distributed trading systems for hedge funds. Was employee #7 for a successful startup. I predicted stocks for a hedge fund and made more money. I retired for a few years. I got a Masters in Economics. I've been analyzing housing prices for a non-profit in Austin, TX, trying to lower rents. Now looking for work again.

My "secret sauce" is being able to understand a problem, find the realm of mathematics that applies to it, and then use that math in code to solve it.

My ideal job would use my knowledge of econ and require me to deliver code.

mdnahas··on Ask HN: Where have you found community outside of work?
High-end coffee shops. I’ve been lucky that two of them that I’ve gone to had a bunch of interesting regulars. They were usually foodies (and I’m not), but they have other interests (travel, data, politics, woodworking, etc.). And, if you ever need an impressive restaurant for a date or business meeting, they have great recommendations.

I believe a lot of the fostering of a “regular cwrowd” has to do with the architecture of the space. Both places had tight spaces near the staff. Also, the staff were interesting in each places, which started conversations or kept them going during slow times. So the crowd may not be at the tippy-top best coffee shop.

mdnahas··on Ask HN: Comment here about whatever you're passionate about at the moment
I played a lot of Civ as a kid and it got me into Economics. I’ve been trying to understand the housing market, especially why rents and home prices have jumped dramatically in my home of Austin, TX. I’m putting together a website (below) to explain the problem. It has data from the 50 largest cities, if you’re interested.

Another project is trying to connect economics to Shannon’s information theory. Economists talk about information all the time but never quantify it.

http://mdnahas.github.io/HousingCrisis/index.html

mdnahas··on Ask HN: Books that teach you to think
Textbooks on rhetoric. Aristotle’s book is okay. I also had a book from the 1950s.

They didn’t teach me logic, but taught me how other people think. Or, at least how they act after you communicate to them.

mdnahas··on Ask HN: What interesting problems are you working on?
I’m working on combining economics and information theory. Econ talks a lot about “informed markets”, but doesn’t measure that in Shannon’s bits.
mdnahas··on Bringing back the golden days of Bell Labs
My father worked at Bell Labs, with Thompson, Ritchie, Aho, etc.. My dad says Bell Labs was the result of the monopoly laws restricting AT&T. The government forced AT&T's prices to be based on its costs from 2 years previously with a fixed rate of profit. So, prices were something like 104% of its costs from 2 years earlier (or something like that). That meant that the only way that AT&T could increase its profits was by innovating to lower its costs. For example, if research lowered its costs by 2% per year, the company's profits would double! Thus, research was a top priority for AT&T and Bell Labs was well-funded and well-managed.

(BTW, I loved "take your kid to work day" at Bell Labs --- I got to use computers with 5-button mice and play hilarious computer games. I was also given a copy of "the old testament" (pre-ANSI "The C Programming Langauge" book) in high school. My dad worked in hardware and really enjoyed his time there helping to design the CRISP and Hobbit processors.)

mdnahas··on Yes, social media is undermining democracy
I did some thinking about this months ago and I think the origin of the problem is how groups make decisions. I think it is similar to a Flocking algorithm. In the algorithm, each bird starts in a random direction but then keeps adjusting its heading a little based on the average of its nearest neighbors. After many little adjustments, the birds will form flocks where all the birds fly in the same direction.

Similarly, in group decisions, each person starts with their own ideas. As people interact in the group, each person learns and modifies their position a little bit. Eventually, the group's members are all thinking similar ideas.

The big question is: Does this algorithm produce 1 flock or many flocks? If there is a force bringing all the birds together, they'll form a single flock. But if there isn't, the birds will separate into many flocks that each head in different directions and do not influence each other.

Before social media, most of our group interactions were physical. If we disagreed with our neighbor at a school meeting, the school was still a force to bring us back together. If we disagreed with family, there was still family reunions or holidays to bring us back together.

But social media allows us to "unfriend". That is, to cut connections to people who disagree with us. There is no forced interactions between strident voices of one political team and strident voices of another political team. The mantra of "for the good of the country" doesn't force us to communicate and bring everyone back together. On social media, we're fracturing into many flocks.

A different social media paradigm/algorithm might include a force that brings us back together. E.g., not allowing "unfriend" or forcing people at random to interact.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flocking_(behavior)#Algorithm

mdnahas··on Show HN: A central bank simulator game with a realistic economic model
Too true. I’d prefer a game where you see every action by the agents, not differential equations.
mdnahas··on Ask HN: What game do you wish existed?
A website with classic games (tic tac toe, crossword puzzles, minesweeper, soduko, etc.) that collected all (and I mean all) the data from every game and showed insane statistics about how well you did, relative to all the other players. If possible, showed you how to get better.
mdnahas··on WTF Happened in 1971?
Agreed.

Also, the US was one of a handful of countries not bombed during WWII and had to be very profitable from 1945 to 1960s. We were shipping cars and factory parts everywhere. By the 1970s, that advantage was disappearing.

mdnahas··on WTF Happened in 1971?
What I believe your saying is the price of bread in terms of gold was standard for centuries. Does that relationship still hold?

The thing is that money doesn’t matter. It’s just a unit for the transactions does in the short term. The relationship of real things, like bread and gold, matter.

mdnahas··on WTF Happened in 1971?
I’m an economist and have noticed a lot of the trends identified by WTF 1971. But the thing is the date “1971” is not specific in any of the trends. They start somewhere between 1970 and 1990 or so. Also, the gold standard had been abandoned prior to 1971, it was only in 1971 that it could stop being denied by the legal system.

My best hypotheses for the origins of the trends are (1) the change to how the US nominates presidents following the 1968 presidential election, (2) the aging of people who went through WWII together and felt a debt to the working-class people who fought the war, or (3) the SAT test, which allows smart working-class children to move into the professional class, rather than having them running unions and working-class social organizations.

My best guess is #1. The nominees for higher office are now chosen by popular primaries rather than by the party machine in a “smoke-filled room”. The party machine wasn’t perfect by a long shot, but it nominated qualified centrist candidates who could win the general election. Now, we have a “popular” election where only a small segment of the population votes, It is easier for special interests to influence. (Listen to the “No Compromise” podcast for how they do it.)

Theory #1 doesn’t explain everything, but it does explain how the US’s unfair healthcare system can cost almost twice as much as other developed countries and we struggle to fix it. The lack of a gold standard does not.

mdnahas··on Ask HN: If you used to be socially awkward and shy, how did you improve?
I did many things, but the best two were to make an effort to try more and to take an acting class. Psychology is the study of interacting with people - in theatre, you actually practice interacting.

The class’s games were fun. People were accepting. Everyone was learning.

I eventually joined a theatre troupe, which was a ton of fun and where I met some life-long friends.

mdnahas··on Ask HN: Why do we tax profits and not losses?
Yes, it is backwards.

But most economists agree that companies should not be taxed. Well, they should be taxed for things like carbon emitted, waste, resources used, value-added, etc.., but their income and profits shouldn’t be taxed.

Economists see the taxes paid by companies as being paid by their owners. So, if a poor person owns a share and you tax the company, the poor person pays taxes. Better to have the company disperse profits to their owners and then tax the rich owners.

https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2012/07/19/157047211/six-...

mdnahas··on Ask HN: Who wants to collaborate?
I'm the designer of Par2, employee #7 of a successful startup (Broadway Technology LLC), a former Wall Street quant, and winner of two research grants.

I'm looking at starting a company/public-benefit-corporation/non-profit to support formal math. The Lean prover (similar to Coq) is gaining traction, but academics and large corporations are not always good at innovation. There are multiple potential products to consider creating. Near-term plans are to pick one and apply to "America's Seed Fund" (SBIR) for initial funding. Will also consider angel funding and, obviously, applying to Y Combinator.

I'm looking for someone else who wants to join me and can fund themselves for 6 to 9 months, until initial funding arrives. Ideally, someone experienced in formal math and with startups. But I'm open to anyone who is passionately interested in math and has significant skills to bring to the table. Skills include: running an early startup, running scalable online systems, growing an online community, grant writing, and ... a lot more than I can list, but those are the big ones. I'm based in Austin but am willing to move to work together.

Contact me at hackernews2022@mike.nahasmail.com

P.S. Just finished the draft specification for Par3. https://parchive.github.io/

mdnahas··on Renting Is Cheaper Than Buying in All 50 Major Metro Areas in the United States
No. When you rent, you usually are paying (1) the owner's mortgage, (2) taxes, (3) maintenance and (4) profit. So renting the same place is almost always much more expensive than the mortgage payment.

Rents do not have to rise. They have been rising in most cities because people are moving to cities. Rents dropped in Detroit when a lot of people left. (Rents also rise with inflation.)

I do wonder about the data. It compares the median rental to the median house purchase. And people usually rent smaller places. So, renting is usually cheaper because of that. I don't know that it is an apples-to-apples comparison.

mdnahas··on Ask HN: Anybody Started a Research Institute?
I've pursued personally-funded research for more than a year. Some thoughts:

Think about your competitive advantages. What makes working at your place different from a university and why would a researcher choose yours? It could be they don't like to teach. It could be that they want their life taken care off and you can hire a cook/cleaner/etc. for them. It could be that they don't like writing grants. Or they have trouble winning grants. (E.g., their topic is out of favor for various reasons.) It could be the freedom to work on anything. It could be the location. It could be that they could be the most senior person at your institute. Perhaps they want to start something new. It could be that they love that you think their research is valuable.

Your own institute has weaknesses, but they can be ameliorated. Make it easy to travel to. Putting it near a major university may help earn academic traffic and provide for collaboration.

One way to structure the institute is to have one good mind and many followers on. That is easy to bootstrap, once you get the good mind. The other sustainable structure is to pick a topic and have the largest most-focused group working on that topic. People will come for that, but getting it off the ground will be difficult. Perhaps you can a few good minds right after they get their PhDs and build around that team.

If the key is the people, I suggest you talk to the people. Find out what top researchers don't like about university life.

If you need a topic to focus on, I did research on formal proofs --- writing a mathematical proof on a computer. Every other industry has moved to digital, computer-aided design, except the field most suited to it! The way that mathematicians advance their careers in academia is working against the adoption of the technology. A place outside academia might make more progress in the area.

mdnahas··on Commits are snapshots not diffs (2020)
I strongly disagree.

Snapshots are a useful concept for programming. Each snapshot represent a compilable program with a certain set of features. So snapshot A has a certain set of features and B has another.

Diffs are not a useful concept. Does the diff between A and B represent the new features in B? No. Because if it did, it would mean I could take any another compilable snapshot C and apply the diff of A and B to it, then I should end up with a snapshot D is compilable and has all the features of C with the new features in B. And that doesn't work with any programming language I know.

It doesn't even work with the most trivial features.

Diffs may be a useful concept when working with some data formats. But for programming languages, snapshots are the right concept.

mdnahas··on Commits are snapshots not diffs (2020)
Sadly, the bad part is git's user interface. It hides the pretty parts underneath.

There is a concept of "the next commit" or, equivalently, "the pending commit". In the documentation, this gets called "indexed" or "cached" or "staged" --- three different names! And if you want to diff with it, you can't refer to it by name. You need to use an option, so it's "git diff --cached <other commit>.

I know git's internals, mostly because it lets me navigate its bad user interface.

mdnahas··on GameStop Is Rage Against the Financial Machine
Options are valuable because they are how Wall St. deals with probabilities.

We don't actually know what a company is worth. You can imagine estimating the worth (a.k.a., "net present value") of a company based on its future dividends (or stock buybacks). But any formula will contain a lot of probabilities of when each dividend will occur, the amount, and the discount factor (that is, how much future money is worth today). So what you get is actually a distribution of how much a company is worth.

The stock market doesn't deal with distributions directly. It uses options. A call option is the ability to buy a stock at a given price called the "strike price". So, from the prices for two call options, you can infer the probability that the stock's worth is between their strike prices.

mdnahas··on The Life in the Simpsons Is No Longer Attainable
I'm a computer scientists who went back for an econ degree. The answer is two parts: salary has not increased and we get less for our money. The salary stagnation is pretty well known, but I've been looking into the other side:

We Americans currently spend $4,000 more per person per year than other countries for healthcare, and we live 4 years shorter than them. For a family of 5, like the Simpsons, that's $20,000 per year. https://medium.com/numbers-that-matter/our-healthcare-system...

Because of industry consolidation, over the last 20 years, we Americans are paying an extra $2,000 per person per year for higher priced goods. And losing out on $800 per person per year on goods we don't buy because consolidation raised the price beyond what we'd pay. For a family of 5 like the Simpsons, that's worth $14,000 per year. https://medium.com/numbers-that-matter/monopoly-oligopoly-co...

Another major factor is housing. More people live in cities, but housing hasn't been created at the same pace. It drives up rents and housing prices. Some economists have measured the effect of housing in just San Francisco and New York and said it is worth _nationally_ on the order of $1,200 per person per year. That's just f*ed up.

So, even as wages have stagnated, that's not the whole story. Lower class people are actually worse off.

mdnahas··on Global capital is the tail that wags the U.S. economic dog
Ideally, global savings would go to help industrialize poor countries. However, investors are usually scared that they will not get their money back. Either because of corruption or "nationalization". Thus, investors are likely to choose a less productive use in a country with strong rules to reward investment.
mdnahas··on If founders treated their investors the same way they treated their employees
I think I had this conversation word-for-word with one company. I told the CEO my salary demand and he could pay me in cash or in stock at the previous valuation (which had happened a week earlier, so I knew the price and that they had cash). He just kept blowing smoke at me. I decided I couldn't work for someone who lied to me (or, perhaps, believed his own BS?).
mdnahas··on Ask HN: What is your blog and why should I read it?
https://medium.com/numbers-that-matter

I try to find important issues and simplify them to one good number. E.g., America's healthcare system costs us $4,000 more per person that other developed countries and we live 4 years shorter on average. (Okay, in that case, it was 2 numbers.)

Basically, I had a hard time pulling the important stuff out of politics. I started my own blog to help me ... and others too.

← PreviousPage 6 of 6