HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

meanguy

256 karma · joined October 5, 2011

submissionscomments
meanguy··on Git, Cloud, Node, Metro, is Microsoft starting to get a little bit cool?
... have you tried PowerShell? It's actually more like a scripting language. But if they called it PowerScript we'd just make fun of it for being bad Python. And the command window itself still sucks. I use cygwin/rxvt/screen/bash and only get burned a few times a week.
meanguy··on Git, Cloud, Node, Metro, is Microsoft starting to get a little bit cool?
The shell really is inexcusable.

Ever seen this? So close yet so far: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_Services_for_UNIX

I moved to cygwin+bash years ago which is 95% there -- and boy does the 5% have really sharp edges.

meanguy··on Github: CoffeeScript cracks the top 10 languages
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Selection_bias

I don't think this says much about CoffeeScript, which I use. However I do think it says quite a bit about how GitHub has plenty of room to grow as they make themselves more attractive to a broader market.

A very interesting chart would be GitHub account revenue broken down by file extension. Note that I didn't say language, as the real money is in assets, not code.

meanguy··on JQuery knobs
That's "traditional" in audio software. In 2D graphics software, radial manipulation is common. And don't forget the wonky 3D software modes where you just wiggle the mouse until something sort of rotates. Those are my favorite.
meanguy··on JQuery knobs
They take up less room than a slider. And certain controls are commonly radial: dimmers, volume dials, focus. Sometimes it just feels right.
meanguy··on JQuery knobs
Audio software made a bit of mess with the whole knob vs. slider thing. Digidesign released several products that used their linear fader code, but they only changed the graphics -- not the mouse code! Yup, you'd move up or down and the thing would randomly turn clockwise or counterclockwise.

Somehow this became a standard.

20 years of customer confusion and complaints yields this advice: there are at least three common modes for interacting. 1) up/down | left/right, 2) radial (follow the mouse pointer) and 3) relative radial (follow the pointer, but use it as an an offset in degrees of the original position).

The latter is useful for something like a volume control (or any real-world control, really). Otherwise one wrong click and you're at max.

In each mode you want both a linear and logarithmic scaling option. Otherwise you have the "soundblaster volume" problem where all the range is between 0 and 30, and 31 to 100 is largely ornamental.

There's a bonus mode using the number in the middle as a target. If you click and drag on that, you get the up/down mode even if the outside zone is normally radial. This guarantees that nobody is happy and seems to be the alternate standard in much audio software.

Click to activate THEN mousewheel to increment/decrement (again, using the linear or log scaling) is a sane compromise.

meanguy··on Introducing Google Drive... yes, really
Microsoft continues to cling to some weird file extension restrictions regarding what you can do with SkyDrive. Leading to idiotic documentation notes like this:

"(downloading any audio file type, and uploading Waveform Audio File Format (.wav) only, is supported)"

http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/live/hh826545.aspx#f...

Yeah, I get it. No MP3. But dozens of common file formats are missing and they just quietly added support for a few Adobe types. Yes, SkyDrive: the system that won't let you store an .eps file.

meanguy··on How to get a stolen domain back?
OP mentioned revenue was via Google AdSense. So he'll need to get that sorted out as well.
meanguy··on How to get a stolen domain back?
I look forward to hearing how NameCheap and Google handle this. Followup please? Good luck.
meanguy··on Awesome jQuery File Upload
Psst..

  var xhr = $.ajax({ type: "HEAD", ...
  xhr.getResponseHeader('Content-Length')
I wound up using Silverlight. Sigh.
meanguy··on Awesome jQuery File Upload
Yet another nice stab at the problem. But every time I look through a component like this, it simply does not work. The corner cases kill you with end user complaints.

No fault of the engineer: THIS NEEDS TO GET BUILT INTO THE DAMN BROWSER.

Yes. Upload. With an actual progress bar. Built into the app you sit in all day. Imagine that.

Sending messages to a PHP server script so you can have the server tell you how many bytes were sent? Even the dumbest terminals knew how to show a bytes uploaded count with XMODEM in 1977.

Google Music installs a friggin client app to hash and upload your songs. DropBox still can't get drag and drop working and STILL limits files to 150MB if you upload via HTTP.

This is such a basic scenario I simply don't understand why it hasn't been solved. And don't even get me started on the Upload Straight to Amazon S3 via Flash/Silverlight doodads. Nobody can seem to get those working reliably either.

meanguy··on In Which I Tell You to Stop Whining About CoffeeScript
I converted some old, overcomplicated, YUI-inspired javascript that relied heavily on class inheritance: big win. I converted some events-gone-nuts code that talked to Google Maps: not a win.

The productivity issue that nobody seems to talk about: the damn compiler is slow. We're talking seconds, but it adds up. (The CSS compilers are far worse.)

I'm used to save/refresh/boom! when coding HTML. Now it's save, contemplate what the hell could possibly take so long, stare sadly at the compile output window, tab, reload, oops, reload again.

meanguy··on Defining Property
Unfortunately the Constitution eventually meets the road: Copyrights and Patents -- in US law -- derive from Acts of Congress.

If you think there's any chance of repealing that stuff and going back to Jefferson's quaint musings on the topic I think you're misguided. There's simply no way to frame an argument on the nature of "property." Nobody understands it and Congress ain't budging anyway.

But Fair Use is inherently flexible, arguable and relatable by the guy who uploads NASCAR highlights he doesn't own to YouTube.

Read up on the DMCA's Fair Use exemptions and the EFF's numerous victories. And think about it in the context of current culture. You're never going to mobilize nascarfan83 to read up on law, but you can probably get him to sign a petition that clips under 20 seconds are okay on YouTube.

meanguy··on Defining Property
You're mixing patent ("idea") with copyright ("property"), but perhaps that's not a bad thing. I don't think copyright is hopeless (as pg implies), but I do think patents are fundamentally broken. So bear with me:

The copyright debate should be reframed in the context of expanding the notion of Fair Use. The definition of "property" isn't shifting, but people's behavior in regards to what they perceive to be Fair Use of property most certainly is. When a fan posts ("NO COPYRIGHT INTENDED") in the description of an infringing NASCAR clip on YouTube, that's what he's trying to say. It has nothing to do with piracy or property.

Likewise, there's no such thing as Fair Use for patents. But some reasoned debate there is likely to achieve change far more quickly than any attempt to blow up the patent system.

meanguy··on StackOverflow
If by "StackOverflow" you mean "Tumblr" then yes, I agree totally.
meanguy··on RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing'
In that case, you'd likely be charged under a fraud statute (misrepresenting a product) versus counterfeiting (misrepresenting the source of a product). Selling a sugar pill isn't a trademark violation. Stamping Viagra on it is.
meanguy··on RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing'
Counterfeit is different than generic: it was explicitly defined in Section 202 of SOPA as "falsely representing the source, manufacturer or distributor." As I wrote in a previous essay "You can still buy your overseas boner pills; they're just less likely to say Viagra on them."

The USDA can identify the source of bad pork; the FDA similarly needs to investigate bad batches of medicine.

meanguy··on Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Corporation
Ok, I'll bite Mr. Corporation Replacer. Where does the long-term R&D investment come from?

Microsoft Research alone outspends Y Combinator by a factor of 50,000,000. And they're thinking 10+ years out. Money aside, their internal expertise and contact network far exceeds "the guy who made Django."

Kudos for what you've done, but when you start talking this way I feel obligated to point out that you're a grain of sand on the beach compared to the Fortune 50--or even CMU/Berkeley/MIT.

You're doing something totally different. Own it. Say what you're for, not what you're against. Say what you're building, not what you're killing.

The fact that people who interview you keep painting you into these corners means that the general public still doesn't understand what's going on with YC. Less hyperbole, more concise vision. Your essays often achieve this, your PR should too.

meanguy··on Amazon Simple Workflow - Cloud-Based Workflow Management
Depends on your volume, of course, but seems expensive. 1 million jobs scheduled, 4 steps per job? $200. And you're locked into their API.

You can have 8 workers each polling an Amazon SQS queue once a second for $19/month.

Having had huge problems with their queues (3 minute lags, spurious duplicates) I'm wary of Amazon's polling-based API. SWF's long-poll feature is smart versus SQS, however.

meanguy··on Why I Unlicense
Different types of creative work may deserve a different treatment. (The same people who want copyright protection reduced to 5 years max probably haven't thought through the GPL implications!)

Imagine you wrote a truly great short story. Straight up copyright might be optimal. It'll get copied around regardless. Encouraging derivative works probably doesn't buy you much. And CC-BY seems as low as you'd want to go. Anything less, and Hollywood just gobbles it up and nobody sees your name on the poster. This goes against your strategy of "getting known by getting copied."

Also, times change. Musicians who license songs CC-BY-NC are free options in the Vimeo music service that offers background tracks to video creators. Meanwhile, old-school artists are one click away from actually getting paid. And public domain music seems deeply buried in the archive.org ghetto. So choose carefully, grasshopper.

License choice is part of modern web marketing. But it's a short-term bump and nobody knows the long-term effects. Also: if the most interesting part of your art is the license, you're doing it wrong.

meanguy··on Tom's Hardware's take on SOPA
Ahem: http://news.cnet.com/8301-31001_3-57358947-261/dns-provision...
meanguy··on A Depressive Journey With MongoDB
"the only thing I had in my mind was MongoDB."

Well, when you approach it like that...

meanguy··on Tom's Hardware's take on SOPA
If PayPal or Google take down a site, it shifts liability to them. Addressing liability is a big part of SOPA and the DMCA before it.

And you're right: laws don't work that way. But debate over pending, proposed legislation most certainly does.

meanguy··on Why wasn't the Windows 95 shell prototyped on Windows NT?
Yeah, I file that under "Raymond glossing things over." NT 3.5 shipped 11 months before Windows 95 did!

People forget that Microsoft wasn't always a lumbering giant. Ship dates:

NT 3.1 - July 93 NT 3.5 - September 94 NT 3.51 - May 95 NT 4.0 - July 96

Platform support: Intel, MIPS, Alpha, plus PowerPC on 3.51 and 4.0.

meanguy··on Why wasn't the Windows 95 shell prototyped on Windows NT?
Raymond also glosses over this a bit in his article. Microsoft wasn't selling Windows 95. Microsoft was selling an upgrade product to corporations who ran Office.

There were few (if any) 12MB machines, it was mostly 8MB or 16MB. (If you had 4MB, Windows 95 would boot and you could play Minesweeper.)

The target market had 8MB systems. Which needed to run Windows 95 + Office 95 flawlessly. 4MB was a lie and a fake goal -- which made it all the way to the box -- that made sure an 8MB system could run Office.

User Interface and Plug and Play were the risk items. I personally thought giving the critical path guys shitty dev machines was shortsighted -- we had plenty of ways to make sure the overall system met performance goals.

NT wasn't that much bigger. It had the Win16 subsystem (WoW), so there were basically two copies of Windows running at all times. Still, NT fit comfortably in 8MB and ran every version of Office (old and new) well in 12MB.

TL;DR: arguments over 4MB and one cycle of upgrade revenue stalled Windows and IE development for 15+ years.

meanguy··on Why wasn't the Windows 95 shell prototyped on Windows NT?
As someone who worked in the systems division throughout the 90s, I've often found Raymond's history a bit odd.

"Windows 95" was originally "Windows 93" and explicitly wasn't going to have a new user interface. They wanted to maximize revenue and not force people to re-train. It slipped and slipped and slipped...

The UI was actually prototyped and built not on Windows NT, but Cairo -- the thing that was supposed to come after Windows NT 3.1. It also slipped and slipped and slipped...

Paul Maritz (now of VMware) thought it was a great idea to have lots of teams, under competing vice presidents, build overlapping systems technology that needed to remain compatible at the legendary Windows level.

So. Stupid.

It basically took until Windows 7 to get the mess he created straightened out.

The key shuffle had the Cairo UI developers -- but not the designers -- move from under VP Jim Allchin to VP Brad Silverberg's group. Design was managed by Joe Belfiore, a very junior guy with no design or UI design experience. Nobody wanted the job (interface was not respected then) and he manned up and took it. He's now VP over Windows Phone.

But this engineering team was sort of -- uh -- let's just say Allchin didn't really fight to keep them. The types of guys who never quite realize width is (x2 - x1 PLUS 1) resulting in everything from blurry icons to blurry images/faxes for a decade. Who then refuse to fix the bugs because they "don't see it and it would add risk to our ship date."

After Windows 95, these devs went on to build the first IE. Yet again in a mad "must ship" panic, again led by people with no visual or design experience, again under Silverberg. So that's where all the box model madness and "things just don't line up" nonsense started.

meanguy··on Tom's Hardware's take on SOPA
Not shilling. Take away the DNS portion, take away the government extension portion, but leave Section 103 please:

It extends the DCMA's definition of service providers to include Ad Providers and Payment providers (not DNS, not tinkering with search results). Under VERY LIMITED circumstances, with explicit penalties. So if a site is overseas, devoted solely to pirated content, and is using Google Ads and PayPal to make money -- you can at least send a takedown to the US Companies involved and cut off the revenue if you can't get the content down.

In this case, it also extends Safe Harbor to include Google and PayPal, further protecting them.

To me, this is a sane and sensible extension of the DMCA that reflects 13 years of bad guys coming up with ways to avoid it.

meanguy··on Tom's Hardware's take on SOPA
Unfortunately you can't really cite something that isn't there. My point is that there's nothing in SOPA that says what Tom's Hardware claims.

The bill breaks down into two main sections.

Section 102 covers foreign sites only. It grants the government the power to tinker with DNS and remove sites from Google search results. It only applies to sites registered overseas that have no US points of contact. In other words, it's an attempt to deal with sites that moved overseas to avoid the DMCA. This is the core of why the bill exists. Debate the DNS technical issue all you want, but since Tom's Hardware isn't overseas, none of this applies to them.

Section 103 extends the DMCA to allow individuals to send takedown notices to payment providers and ad networks. Again, I can't cite something that isn't there, but you can read the bill (it's really rather short) and see that it explicitly does not mention DNS. That stuff requires action by the Attorney General and separate approval by a Judge (section 102).

Both section 102 and 103 powers further limited ONLY to sites that "primarily designed or operated for the purpose of, has only limited purpose or use other than" copyright infringement (17 USC 501), circumventing copyright (17 USC 1201), or trademark infringement (18 USC 2320).

Is Tom's Hardware a site that is primarily designed for the purpose of copyright infringement? Not at all. The bill doesn't even apply to them.

There are certainly parts of the bill worth tweaking and debating, but it's going to be hard to make progress on that in the total absence of facts.

I also think it was a huge mistake for PG to boycott and uninvite people from the demos over SOPA.

If a company stands up and expresses an opinion which matches its business interests during the debate over an unpassed bill -- that somehow renders them unworthy to talk to entrepreneurs who have a different opinion? The bill is in flux and the debate is heated (and, as shown above, largely uninformed).

If anything, the way to fix some of these idiotic, outdated copyright laws is to combine great tech with the IP assets held by the old guard and open up new opportunities. But PG doesn't want the two sides even talking while the debate is under way? That's premature and shortsighted.

meanguy··on Tom's Hardware's take on SOPA
"It would require web services like YouTube, Facebook, and Twitter to monitor and aggressively filter everything all users upload."

False. It's the opposite actually. A site continues to have existing safe harbor protection UNLESS it does this. Even Congress knows you can't put this type of burden on sites.

"It would deny site owners due process of law, by initiating a DNS blacklisting based solely on a good faith assertion by an individual copyright or intellectual property owner."

False. Individuals and corporations cannot DNS blacklist, or block from Google results. That's only allowed based on a request from the Attorney General, requires approval of a Judge, and only applies to foreign companies that explicitly and solely exist for the purpose of copyright infringement.

In short, it's the worst article I've ever seen on Tom's Hardware. And like watching something on CNN when you clearly know more about it than they do, I'm left to wonder if they're this wrong on everything, or it's just a rare case of them talking about something they know absolutely nothing about.

But I do see why we're so worried about politics affecting the web. We're not good at it and we're too lazy to actually read the proposals. We sure are great at moving incorrect information around, though!

meanguy··on What, exactly, is a Product Manager?
Product manager: coordinating officer, delegating company divisional chores / From manufacturing to vacuum-wrapping packaging, a model of corporate exacti-ture / He's pre-eminent -- isn't it evident? -- as his title infers / His word is law, yes it's an advantage / if he's managing the product that is yours
← PreviousPage 2 of 2