HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

meany

619 karma · joined September 3, 2021

submissionscomments
meany··on I'm Too Risk-Averse for Index Investing
The author uses Buffets essay to justify value investing over index funds, but Buffet is a strong proponent of index funds for non professional investors.

Instead of stock picking, Buffett suggested investing in a low-cost index fund. “I recommend the S&P 500 index fund,” Buffett said, which holds 500 of the largest companies in the U.S., “and have for a long, long time to people.”

He’s even putting 90% of his own estate into index funds.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.cnbc.com/amp/2019/02/26/war...

meany··on Names of Canada truck convoy donors leaked after reported hack
It sounds like you're saying the "ends justify the means".

Perhaps its not embarrassment that makes people want privacy, but fear of retribution. Consider someone living during the McCarthy era in the US. Speaking up could be career ending, and in the long run, if things had progressed to a more authoritarian regime, life threatening.

As one of the earlier posters said, I think many people see a slide into authoritarianism on both sides of the political spectrum. And it strikes me, that not being able to have secrets or privacy supports authoritarianism more than furthering democracy.

meany··on Shooting an Elephant (1936)
I can appreciate your passion and ideas, but continued rule under a modern western democracy would not be equivalent to the race based colonialism of the past. I think there is nuance to this, and I don't think any of us can speak for all residents of all former colonies. It doesn't seem unreasonable that a situation could get so bad that an individual would prefer continued colony status (which is nothing like it would have been in 1936) under a liberal western democracy over some of the alternatives. For instance, my understanding is that there are some people in Hong Kong, who would prefer British rule to Chinese.

From a WSJ article (https://www.wsj.com/articles/some-hong-kongers-want-to-be-br...):

"On Sunday, hundreds of people gathered outside the British consulate in Hong Kong for a rally urging London to take immediate action to protect British nationals in the city and grant them full citizenship.

“We’re too British to be Chinese,” said Eric Cheung, a 25-year-old Hong Kong resident at the rally who is a British National (Overseas), or BNO. “We share the same ideology with the U.K. We support democracy, we support freedom, we support the rule of law and of course we support the U.K. government,” he said.

“ Boris Johnson, fight for us,” he added, appealing to the British prime minister.

meany··on What 3°C of global warming looks like
I don't think that's an accurate interpretation of what americans think. The majority of Americans don't think the Government is doing enough.

https://www.pewresearch.org/science/2019/11/25/u-s-public-vi... "About two-thirds of U.S. adults (67%) say the federal government is doing too little to reduce the effects of climate change"

https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/04/18/a-look-at-h... According to this: 59% of Americans see it as a major threat and 23% see it as a minor threat. This is close to the Australia (60% and 29%) and UK (66% and 23%) numbers.

I think the media discussion in America on many issues (policing, masks/vaccines, climate change) presents a distorted view of what the majority believes, because sensational, clashing talking heads drive more ad dollars. So why don't we see more action on climate change in America? Well, some reasons: 1) Lobbying efforts often push back or at least water down any change. 3) America's two party system plays to the extremes in both camps rather than the majority viewpoint, which gets lost. 1) most people have more pressing near term concerns that dominate their choices.

meany··on Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair
Would that make almost any exchange between two people theft on one side? Very rarely is there complete equivalent balance.
meany··on Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair
Why do you consider that stealing? I think many readers of your comment define the word stealing as "taking without permission". Are you suggesting that he took that wealth from the staff without their permission? Do you think the staff feels tricked/stolen from? Or would you define stealing differently?
meany··on Amazon copied products and rigged search results to promote its own brands
This is not accurate. They attempt to maximize their profits and private label brands is a major effort to do that across retail.

“With its billion-dollar private labels, Target has become a master at spotting trends, copying them, and capitalizing on them”

“Target, for its part, seemed to see the C9 contract’s expiration as a chance to do what it increasingly does best: develop and launch a stylish brand internally—and keep all the revenue for itself.”

https://www.fastcompany.com/90661935/retail-thrives-on-copyi...

meany··on 100-year-old former Nazi guard has gone on trial, facing charges for 3518 deaths
That’s a bit hyperbolic. How these issues are handled vary by each country and are agreed upon by the host country. Here is a link on the topic.

https://www.findlaw.com/military/criminal-law/foreign-crimin...

meany··on You can't tell people anything (2004)
At least in some of these examples, the problem seems to be rooted in a lack of understanding of the audience/customer. Implicit in this essay is an expectation that the audience/customer will do the work for you. Saying :"We’ll be able to put avatars on web pages. Start thinking about what you might do with that.” Doesn't explain the value proposition or the problem solved. Why should they care? You'll always be disappointed if you expect the audience to figure this out for you. They've got 101 problems they're working on and your asking them to invest in your idea. You need to do this leg work for them.

As for the statement "why would people put documents on the web?" That seems a very valid question. If you can't nail that answer, you haven't invested enough in understanding the customers/audience for who you're trying to solve problems.

Pitching a new idea is hard. You need to iterate on it obsessively, cutting it down to the core value prop in easy to digest words for the specific audience you're talking to.

meany··on Tesla pushes U.S. to boost fuel economy penalties
I think one could make the case that social security, Medicare and Medicaid are safety net programs. That said, I don’t think that means these taxes would necessarily go to help the poor.

Edit - bad spellcheck edit

meany··on Staggering US wealth inequality heaps long-term harm on to minority children
While you're right that deflation would decrease the value of assets, it will also have other impacts that will negatively effect the poor (as well as the wealthy). Liquid assets, such as cash, become more valuable, so investment in creating new assets will decrease, such as starting a business, investing in stocks, business loans, etc. will decrease. This will likely stifle growth, which would likely disproportionately impact those already at the bottom in lower wages and fewer jobs. If companies are playing someone $10 an hour today, and the value of a dollar drops by 50%, business will start lowering salaries to $5. The very wealthy, on the other hand, have access to international markets/investments and would be able to flee the deflationary effect. Such as Eric Schmidt becoming a citizen of Cyprus to avoid taxes.

https://www.vox.com/recode/2020/11/9/21547055/eric-schmidt-g...

-edit grammatical error

← PreviousPage 4 of 4