HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

medearis

95 karma · joined February 12, 2008

submissionscomments
medearis··on China has tens of thousands specially trained spin doctors posting blog comments
I don't really see a huge problem with government hiring people to sell its side of a story in itself. For better or worse, there are highly-paid lobbyists on both sides of every policy issue these days.

I think the issue is that the Chinese government does more than "spin." It is acceptable for one party to advocate for a policy by putting it in the best possible light. Its unacceptable to change facts, control information etc. Admittedly, this is a murky line in many cases...

Perhaps what more scary is that most Chinese students I've met know that they don't get the "full truth" in China and don't really care. They seem to be more concerned with China becoming an economic superpower than whether China creates a "good" society.

medearis··on Immigrants See Charter Schools as a Haven from American Youth Culture
While public schools may have been "assimilation engines" back in 1950, my experience was that they are staunchly opposed to the "melting pot" and far more partial to the multicultural mindset. Since main stream public schools are essentially not allowed to teach subjects like ethical reasoning, they are implicitly teaching relativism AKA "tolerance." Public schools also tend to teach academic subjects in a scripted and mechanical way.

I think that this is the phenomenon that the folks in the article are responding to. Hopefully in realizing that there is no catch-all "best" way to educate, I think these charter schools will unlock previously untapped potential.

medearis··on You Will Probably Fail in a Boring and Project-specific Way
True, attracting users and traffic may not be easy and seems to be the fail point for many ideas, but why not consider scaling issues as well? With products like EC2, ruby on rails etc. its easier to plan for the "techcrunch" scenario than ever, so why build your site in fortran on a computer you bought at goodwill? In other words, once you get past the prototype stage, I think it might be worth it to take the extra 5 minutes to do a little research.
medearis··on 10,000 hours
It seems to me that the reviewer read the first 50 pages of the book then put it down and wrote the review. On the whole, I think Gladwell did a decent job arguing that it is a confluence of factors -- base intelligence, hard work, opportunity and savviness, which contribute to success. The 10,000 hour "rule" is just one point among many to basically illustrate that hard work is part of the equation which is sometimes overlooked.
medearis··on Joel Spolsky: Don't Leave The Industry (You Whining Emo Girl)
I'm starting to wonder if, in this day and age, there really is such a thing as a "career job." The system which predominated in the 50's of spending your entire career working for a big corporation and then living off of a retirement pension seems to be faltering. The auto industry is just one example...

To me, programming offers a challenging, generally fun activity with more potential for innovation than nearly any other "job." I didn't get into software to be the modern day equivalent of an assembly line worker. Though I can sympathize to some extent with the position of the "rank and file" engineers (i.e. that many software engineering jobs are a means of putting food on the table), I'm also optimistic that the opportunity to build great things finds those who have a desire to do so.

medearis··on The Economic News Isn't All Bleak
A few months ago, Goldman Sachs "experts" were predicting oil at over $200/barrel. Obviously, things didn't work out that way, which is why the concluding paragraph is exactly right -- information now travels faster than ever in our economy, which will affect the way the economy rebounds. Still, nobody knows exactly what will happen.

It seems to me that the best predictor of how the economy is doing is the way that it is perceived. For all the talk of this being the "worst economy since Hoover," we're not in a depression and not all is lost. I see a lot of optimism accompanying the incoming administration, which will probably do more for the economy in the short-term than any sort of monetary or fiscal policy could.

medearis··on Diary of a Self-Help Dropout: Flirting With the 4-Hour Workweek
He does have to travel to meet with clients, but from what I've gathered, it is not particularly frequent. He had a pretty solid resume as an engineer and is definitely one of the most creative, smart people I know, but I don't think that he had much of a list of prior clients. As I recall, our school kind of set him up with his 2 main clients. Its quite a bold move on his part and inspiring to me. It's only one data point, but its certainly an example of how its possible to carve out a niche.
medearis··on Diary of a Self-Help Dropout: Flirting With the 4-Hour Workweek
I have a buddy who apparently took the 4HWW to heart and moved to Argentina to work as a freelance software engineer... he seems to be doing well.

Personally, I thought Ferriss made it seem a little easy, but who knows? Did you actually do all of the challenges? I guess you can't knock it until you've tried it.

medearis··on Windows 7: "The Linux Killer"
If the issue is really the resource consumption of the OS, I'll believe it when I see it -- thus far every iteration of Windows has been more bloated than the last.

Is XP still shipping on most low-power notebooks though? Not from what I've seen... From what I've seen, most "email, word and internet explorer" users are using vista and getting along OK.

medearis··on Washington Is Killing Silicon Valley
Malone isn't crediting Regan for the internet boom of the 90's. He is saying that cutting capital gains taxes helped spur the electronics boom in the 80's. Since we have had relatively low capital gains taxes for the last 30 years, and most of us agree that low capital gains taxes are a good thing for innovation, why would we consider raising them now?

I do think its interesting that, even when Obama was talking about the potential for large cap. gains tax increases, he made a point to exempt "small businesses and startups." I'm not sure how we could draw that line, but it indicates to me that Obama has exactly Malone's general argument in mind.

medearis··on 'Free-mium,' self-funded models set to gain traction
Its interesting that Rosenberg focuses on the self-funded model only for what he calls "ecosystem" startups. I disagree that the issue is risk in that way that he describes -- i.e. that Facebook or Apple could theoretically crush these companies quickly. Instead, I think the issue is more that the platform itself is unstable. Particularly with a limited platform like Facebook, nobody really knows if these apps will be profitable in 5 years, and even then, what the growth of an "app within an app" will be. Since VC's are generally interested in the big payouts, it always seemed to me like funding Facebook app companies was largely outside the VC domain.

That said, I generally agree with the big picture about self-funding -- its pretty much in line with what PG said in the recent essay about VCs in this recession.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2