HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mediaman

6,587 karma · joined April 20, 2009

submissionscomments
mediaman··on LangChain Announces 10M Seed Round
Yeah it’s kind of a disaster. Partly because they’ve been moving so fast, and their docs don’t keep up. But for actually building stuff on it, they have a ways to go.

Good for quick demos on Twitter though.

mediaman··on 50% of new NPM packages are spam
That’s like arguing against using locks on doors because they’re pickable.

You’re right: they can be defeated.

But they might cut it by 80-90%, and be complemented with other tools to reduce the flood to a trickle.

mediaman··on Plane Lands/Takes Off in Only 20 Feet (2013)
Alaska's population is lower than it was 7 years ago. More people have moved away than moved in every year for the past 10 years.
mediaman··on Launch HN: Outerbase (YC W23) – A new UI and editor for your database
Yes, a view-only mode would work. Ideally it would not just be a static view, but would allow users to run some queries (perhaps constrained?) on the table, so they can get a list of their customers who ordered last quarter but not this quarter, for example, or other similar queries.

But disallowing them from modifying the DB would be fine.

Maybe limiting it to tables established by the Creator, and with a certain View/Dashboard arrangement, would work.

mediaman··on Launch HN: Outerbase (YC W23) – A new UI and editor for your database
Regarding pricing: do you offer monthly subscriptions for "view-only" users?

Here's my use-case. I am fine paying $50 a month for someone to make dashboards, create queries, etc.

However, that's too much (and significantly above other tools) for the "users" of the product: for example, salespeople who I would like to enable to see what products their customers have used. I'd expect something in the 10-20 range per head per month for them, in exchange for more limited functionality.

Some companies solve for this by charging for "creators" (dashboard designers, the people who set up the database connection, or run more custom queries) versus viewers. This encourages broader adoption within a company. $50/mo for any type of user is pretty steep.

mediaman··on GPT-4
I'm sorry, but that is a terrible metric.

This sounds like a definition from someone who never interacts with anyone except the top 1% performance level of people, and those who have had strong levels of education.

Go into a manufacturing, retail or warehouse facility. By this definition, fewer than ten or twenty percent of the people there would have "general intelligence", and that's being generous.

Not because they are stupid: that's the point; they're not. But it's setting the bar for "general intelligence" so absurdly high that it would not include many people who are, in fact, intelligent.

mediaman··on The uncanny failures of A.I.-generated hands
I've been curious about the hand problem.

It seems like it’s caused by the massive number of permutations possible with hands: all the joints, combined with all the angles at which they can be seen.

I’ve wondered if this could be solved by creating a massive permutation of hand images using rigged 3D hand models (using, for example, Blender, or coupling with Unreal), and programmatically putting them in all possible combinations and angles possible from the rigging and then rendering millions of images of these combinations.

Then the image models could learn from that artificially created dataset.

Anyone with actual knowledge know how people are trying to tackle this?

mediaman··on First Republic Bank files 8-K – Tech only 4% of total deposits; no sector >9%
It’s not always 90 days, but the American federal bankruptcy system does allow for clawbacks on payments made immediately leading up to a filing.

Meaning, the bankruptcy administrator will absolutely file and get a judgment on your assets, which will be forcibly collected, if you received a payment from a bankrupt entity within the window established by the court.

mediaman··on Haraldur Thorleifsson's Personal Site
It's true of any large company. There are many people not doing anything. Simply because of the number of employees, and the manner in which large companies tend to stop focusing on outcomes.

That doesn't mean most were not doing anything, but "most" is not the word used in the comment to which yours replies.

mediaman··on Want an unfair advantage in your tech career? Consume content for other roles
My experience (not specifically with engineers) is that very, very few people read the 10K, 10Q or other public statements of the company they work for.

A friend of mine used to be a management consultant for one of the big firms. On one memorable project she worked with senior executives of a large ($1b + revenue) non-tech company that had retained the consulting firm, to do an operational diagnostic. It became incredibly clear that many of these senior execs had never really read the company's financial statements in any detail, that they did not understand that the company was cash flow negative, and that they did not know that the company's debt load was increasing over time as it financed losses with bond issuances.

At the same time they were spending incredible amounts of money on luxurious office furniture and trappings.

Stories like this were common. Most managers knew their area, but did not learn about the business more broadly. (Could be selection bias with firms that hire management consultants!)

So, kudos to the engineers who read these and have a rough idea of their company's financial position and how the business works. It's not clear that this is the median experience.

mediaman··on Matty Benedetto Designed and Prototyped 350 Inventions in 3 Years
Don't get me wrong - I love 3D printing! I use it myself to make enclosures for electronics projects, or to replace parts that have broken on my old sailboat, which happens often. Notably, I don't turn to my business to injection mold these parts, because it makes no sense to make a mold for one part! Without 3D printing, I'd probably have someone mill custom parts, which is a lot more expensive.

But I'm a realist. Look at the total poundage of all resin sales to the 3D print market. It would be generous to call it a rounding error in comparison to conventional resin sales. People like you or me are not the norm. The market for conventionally produced high volume parts is enormous compared to hobbyists 3D printing stuff at home.

That's because most people consume the same small set of products repeatedly, and they care about cost, and some of my machines produce at a rate of ten parts per second with part weights 90% less than what's feasible with 3D printing. It's just the way markets work: most volume is accounted for in a small percentage of products, and engineers will always be able to get much more efficiency out of a specialized machine designed for a small number of high volume items than a general purpose machine that can produce anything.

mediaman··on Matty Benedetto Designed and Prototyped 350 Inventions in 3 Years
Molds are surprisingly complicated. They weigh 1,000 pounds or more; some molds we have weigh 10,000 pounds. They're made of high grade tooling steel that must be annealed to the right hardness and ductility. At each injection, they are subject to pressures of 25,000 pounds per square inch, and this happens every ten seconds 24/7 for the duration of the run (which can be weeks or months). Over time, plastic cuts into the steel, like water on rock in a canyon. So it takes lots of milling time, because tool steel can't be cut fast, like wood or aluminum.

The molds also have to be machined to high tolerances. Take vents as an example. Vents allow the ambient air inside a mold to escape as plastic fills, but they must not allow the plastic to escape out the mold on the same route, so they must be machined to a tolerance of around 3 tenths of a thousandth of an inch. That in turn requires high precision CNC machining over fairly large spans, and with many subassemblies to make sure the two halves fit together just right.

Some kinds of molds can be completed faster. Usually smaller parts, or parts where a base size of a mold has already been completed and you are just using inserts. Or if the mold is not expected to last very long, it can be made out of weaker material, which also cuts faster.

I think there are some interesting software opportunities to improve mold build lead times. I suspect some of the design of the molds could be more procedural and automated than they are. That would help cut down the engineering time. And some people are exploring 3D printed molds, which is a cool idea, but currently they are very weak and not useful for production because nobody yet has figured out a way to 3D print high grade tool steel.

3D printing has actually likely increased the number of mold designs we're doing, because it makes it easier to innovate and iterate, and easier for a customer to feel comfortable with a design and move forward with it. It reduces customer utility and engineering risk, and so cuts the total cost of product development.

mediaman··on Matty Benedetto Designed and Prototyped 350 Inventions in 3 Years
I'm a partner in a plastics manufacturing facility (injection molding, thermoforming).

3D printing has been big for us. No, we don't make money directly from it, or not very much. And it's extremely expensive per unit.

But it allows us to design a part for injection molding, and then iterate it many times until we are happy with the functionality of it.

Once we commit to an injection mold, it might be $15k or $30k to get it made, and it'll take 6 months. But we know that the fit will be nearly perfect by the time those first shots come out. Then we can roll with making thousands or hundreds of thousands of parts per day at the efficiency of scale.

The way that 3D printing is used by hobbyists looks fairly different than the way it's used in industry. In industry, we're mostly still using traditional design-for-manufacturing principles for the prototype: for example, we're designing it so that it could be injection molded and ejected properly from a mold, even though the 3D print doesn't need that. That's because our intent is to merely confirm what we see in Solidworks in the real world, and to show a customer an idea in their hands in the shape and form it'd actually be produced at scale.

I'm not compelled by the idea that 3D printing is going to make a big difference by allowing very small runs of parts (except for prototyping in the manner above). That's because like everything, there is a power law when it comes to parts. Nearly all the revenue comes from medium and higher volume products. Sure, it's useful in niche applications, and for things like jigs, but as much as people love to talk about the power of long tails, it rarely is as good a fit to the real world as the power law.

But the idea that 3D printing is making a big difference in improving the design and innovation with those medium to higher volume products made with conventional manufacturing methods is absolutely true.

mediaman··on ChatGPT and the AI Apocalypse
There's an alternative view on what some call "price gouging."

The idea is that the market is providing a strong incentive for you to figure out how to get bottled water to the disaster zone. This is wildly unpopular: people view it as capitalists profiteering off a disaster. And it's true, they are.

In response, people demand prohibition of price gouging.

But the result is a lack of product availability. For example, one study linked anti-gouging laws with limited product availability during the pandemic. [1]

To take the example of the increase in costs of goods leading to a hurricane: there is a risk that the hurricane will veer off path, and all the extra goods will just sit, unbought. The anticipation of high prices causes vendors to logistically stage larger quantities of goods to the market. Mandated 'normal' prices lead to scarcity.

So ultimately we're left with a choice: do we prevent price gouging, and content ourselves with lack of product knowing that nobody made an 'unfair' dollar? Or do we let price gouging happen, knowing it'll result in better product availability and reduce hoarding?

[1] http://journal.apee.org/index.php?title=Parte1_2020_Journal_...

mediaman··on A Relational Spreadsheet
Completely agreed - I've found it vastly more powerful than other tools, and handles 100k+ rows with speed, even loaded with Python code in each cell. I've been surprised how much I can get done with it, and its ability to display multiple tables on a single page for sequential filtering is powerful.
mediaman··on The vertical farming bubble is finally popping
The reason for the long-tail bets being improbable is important, though!

If the reason is because it takes lots of capital, or because there are network effects (e.g., AirBnB, eBay), or because it's a winner takes all market, or some key piece of technology has to be proven out, then sure, shoot your shot, someone will get the bullseye and win the day and it'll be a cakewalk raising the next fund.

But if it's improbable because nobody wants it, that's not the same thing.

That's why a bet being improbable should not be the reason to invest in something.

A VC may look at a bet and say, "sure, the win condition is unlikely, but lots of people will want this, so if it wins, it's worth billions." And maybe they write a check.

But if another VC looks at a deal and says "it's not likely to work, and also, even in the optimistic case this is worse than existing solutions," then there is no market problem being solved. This second VC will likely be leaning more on their management fee than their carry to pay the mooring fees for their yacht.

And a phone call to that farmer would have told them that while microgreens don't ship well over very long distances, they do fine in climate controlled trucks over a couple hundred miles. Part of a VC's job is to de-risk investment decisions by validating key assumptions.

mediaman··on The vertical farming bubble is finally popping
What's crazy is that all these variables were known ahead of time.

What is the cost of real estate in rural upstate New York? It's really not that bad! (About $10k per acre, based on a brief search, for land about 280 miles away from Manhattan. A truck could make a delivery in six hours or so.)

So why spend millions in capital expenditures on fancy stacked farms with high tech intense lighting, in order to cut a few tens of thousands of dollars in real estate costs?

The argument was that logistics costs were high. That's kind of true if you're on the east coast, and your alternative is importing from Mexico or California.

It's not true at all if you can get produce from a conventional hydroponic operation six hours away by truck.

Moreover, it's not like conventional hydroponic operations didn't exist, and this was some sort of tail risk that was unexpected. The conventional hydroponic operations already existed! They've been in business for years. All the founders or investors had to do was drive a few hours to go visit them. Or pick up the phone.

mediaman··on My fifth year as a bootstrapped founder
This is actually why the balance sheet is more important than the income statement. The income statement can obfuscate what's happening to cash flow. A close study of the balance sheet reveals whether working capital is consuming retained earnings.
mediaman··on Amazon Q4 2022 Financials
Tim asks about why the $-19bn free cash flow for '22 is not a worry.

All of this is because enormous levels of cap-ex spend: $58bn in net purchases of property and equipment over the year ($63bn gross). The other piece is $9bn in debt paydown of lease obligations, which is not really concerning because it's just a debt reduction.

They don't provide much of a breakdown of this very large capex number. Presumably a lot of it is fulfilment center spend, but there's data centers, vehicles, etc., to consider as well. It really comes down to whether this spend is wise. If this cap-ex will generate strong ROI, it's fine.

mediaman··on Builder's Remedy goes into effect in many California cities tomorrow
It's interesting to hear people describe government-organized supply restriction cartels as some sort of utopia, whereas, in their world, eliminating the cartel is in fact creating an "oligarchy."
mediaman··on What Are 'Dark Factories,' and Do They Exist?
As someone who is a partner in a plastics manufacturing facility, this is a voice of reason.

Factories are vast assemblies of atoms constantly entropically smashing and grinding themselves into dust.

mediaman··on Tell HN: Confluent laying off 8% of staff
Profitability and low debt.

If you're making money and don't owe money, you can't go bankrupt.

Of course, profitable companies can become unprofitable, especially in a negative environment, so the more profitable it is, the safer it is.

The only thing that stops the timer on the bomb is taking in more money than you spend.

mediaman··on The Google layoffs are about personal ambition and poor leadership
Privilege is necessarily a comparative concept.

Most people in America are privileged compared to a rural Chinese farmer.

The median Google employee is privileged compared to average American citizens.

It's healthy to acknowledge this.

mediaman··on The Google layoffs are about personal ambition and poor leadership
Given median comp at Google, working at Google is quite privileged.

Going to Stanford is likewise privileged.

Being privileged isn't an insult, just a recognition of fact.

mediaman··on How to get new ideas
It appears pretty clear that PG wrote what he actually thought in response to ChatGPT's render of his potential thoughts.
mediaman··on Amazon set to begin new round of layoffs affecting over 18,000 people
To be fair, it's unlikely to see many warehouse workers be laid off, because the attrition rate is so high they can just attrit out within months.

The exception would be total warehouse closures, but I don't think we've seen a lot of those because each one is such an enormous capital investment. Though maybe they closed one in response to a union activation effort?

mediaman··on We need a lot more electricians
He said he wasn't upgrading amperage, so wire size requirements for existing breakers should not change.

It sounds like he was adding circuits which means he's running wires for those new circuits anyway.

mediaman··on Spreadsheet with compute-like functions: GET(), POST(), PARSE(), ASK_OpenAI()
I'm not sure if this is what you're looking for, but Grist has relationship-driven spreadsheets where the formulas are all Python code. And you can have multiple tables show on the same page, where selection of one filters the others.

The tables are more database-style than pure unstructured Excel sheet style, but I've found that having a full Python environment in each cell to be pretty powerful, and I've started turning to it for analytical work because I can avoid the mess that larger Excel formulas can turn into.

No relationship except as a customer -- they're at getgrist.com

mediaman··on Trash Train: I put my trash cans on rails so they move automatically [video]
You can use an encoder on the motor and count the rotations to slow down.

Limit switches can be used to maintain calibration, in case the encoder misses some pulses over time.

mediaman··on Ask HN: Why are some YC startups not posting salary ranges when law requires it?
Fun to watch young tech companies learn how to do HR in real time!
← PreviousPage 12 of 34Next →