HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mehrdada

3,441 karma · joined April 3, 2011

submissionscomments
mehrdada··on Elon Musk makes $43B unsolicited bid to take Twitter private
> Tesla loses money on every car. They make money from regulatory credit trading.

Absolute hogwash. In 2021, Tesla made 43B revenue in automotive sales and only 1.5B in regulatory credits, which is less than net income of over 5B.

That is including massive short term hit by continuing investments in new factories and new products.

Good luck spinning.

https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1318605/000095017022...

mehrdada··on Elon Musk makes $43B unsolicited bid to take Twitter private
> There's also the other possibility that Twitter, as a product, is limited to a more niche audience than something like Facebook.

You state that as if what twitter is as a product is set in stone and delivered as a commandment. It is defined by the product people, engineers, and the executives of the company who have been doing a terrible job at that. If they were competent and the way out was to be Facebook, they should’ve been Facebook by now. FWIW, Facebook was not Facebook either. It didn’t have news feed before it copied twitter. Ironic.

mehrdada··on Jack Dorsey has regrets about building Twitter
Sensationalist title, not what he said at all.
mehrdada··on Fuchsia Workstation
I wouldn't call health insurance "extremely expensive" in the context of Google SWE salaries. On average it probably costs on the order of $5-$10k/head/year at most. My very loose upper bound estimate is $50k/year for all aux benefits and bus/campus costs.
mehrdada··on Fuchsia Workstation
I'd be willing to bet something like Fuchsia is on average L5-6 (or more) given retirement projects at Google attract some very senior engineers that would offset the L3/4s if you amortize them.
mehrdada··on US Senate votes unanimously to make daylight savings time permanent
It’s just PT: Pacific Time.
mehrdada··on Ask HN: Is your company considering inflation in this year's comp review cycle?
> Now adding an extra 7% is not about inflation but about retaining (good) employees.

Sure, and that distinction is the entire point, i.e. retention for [Silicon Valley and similar] tech employee is likely not dominated by the value of 7% but what the labor market dictates in terms of compensation, benefits, and company culture; could be a lot higher but by-and-large not directly driven by consumer price increases.

mehrdada··on Ask HN: Is your company considering inflation in this year's comp review cycle?
Let's say you earn 500k and your cost of living is 200k leaving you with 300k additional disposable income. Assuming a 7% increase in your cost of living, you still have $300-$200*.07 additional disposable income. The question now is, why should the company be the one absorbing this loss and not the employee selling the labor, to put it bluntly, let alone adding an extra 7 percent to your extra $300k? Even if they are able to pull a price increase, they will be under pressure by shareholders to keep the profits to preserve the share price to offset the collapsing multiples. Surely at the borderline compensation levels or below, cost of living increases can make a material difference to the employee's ability of providing their services in the first place, out of their control (analogous to a negative gross margin for a vendor), and force them into pursuing an alternative solution (reducing expenses, moving to a different location, moving to a different industry).

However, if the employees are significantly above that limit, the primary reason the employee is able to justify their additional earnings must be competition in the labor market, so that should be the driving factor here as well.

mehrdada··on Ask HN: Is your company considering inflation in this year's comp review cycle?
For instance, if my employees are earning 500k+ and driving Teslas, I don't think the price of oil, lettuce and tomato, and even general rental market would be materially impactful like, say, the increase in Los Altos home prices.

What really makes a difference is how much a competitor is willing to pay, their scale, their work environment, and how well they sell themselves.

mehrdada··on Ask HN: Is your company considering inflation in this year's comp review cycle?
Precisely as arbitrary as how you choose to measure it, or more.
mehrdada··on Ask HN: Is your company considering inflation in this year's comp review cycle?
> I can’t imagine what gave you that idea.

I can't imagine it being that hard to imagine :) considering this is the second paragraph of wikipedia[1]:

Prices will not all increase at the same rates. Attaching a representative value to a set of prices is an instance of the index number problem. The consumer price index is often used for this purpose; the employment cost index is used for wages in the United States. Differential movement between consumer prices and wages constitutes a change in the standard of living.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflation

mehrdada··on Ask HN: Is your company considering inflation in this year's comp review cycle?
Not to be dismissive, but why would a company specifically care about some arbitrary number called "inflation" vs overall pressure from the labor market, which presumably must have some encoding of that, considering they seem to clearly paying a person enough not to justify leaving?

P.S. It is especially amusing considering lots of "only if I were to leetcode I could increase by X" coexist with many posts that diss on leetcode and whine that it filtered them out and it is not "relevant to the work they are doing". Perhaps the system is working then?

mehrdada··on Deepfakes, can you spot them?
Did not mean to be dismissive of your point. It is just that the overhang of blockchain as a solution to everything is so prevalent that sometimes need intervention.

It is true that the cryptographic primitives that blockchain is built on are relevant to many other things that we can do and have done. Blockchain in fact utilizes those properties to build a distributed shared state on which the parties have consensus. That, however, is a very special use case of those primitives. If you need message authentication, digital signatures have done that for decades and you don't need an expensive associated database to accomplish that.

mehrdada··on Deepfakes, can you spot them?
If you require knowing "an address belongs to whitehouse", why not just serve some content on that "address" (let's say "whitehouse.gov").

Or just sign a message and serve the signed message.

Oh no... that nail did not require the blockchain hammer.

mehrdada··on Why I will never buy another Samsung device
Until Apple mass produces a foldable phone I will put my chips on "it is crap".
mehrdada··on Chris Lattner left Swift core team
Objective-C was not originally designed by Apple (or NeXT)
mehrdada··on Apple unveils contactless payments via Tap to Pay on iPhone
Is that right? My understanding is the physical AppleCard has a fixed number that is simply not printed and relies on rotating CVV via the standard chip reading like most standard chip cards. The device-based ApplePay can rotate its number but that too only rotates CVV by default.
mehrdada··on Alder Lake Core i9 processor is faster than the M1 Max
By "I/O" I am including memory bus, not merely devices.
mehrdada··on Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment systems in Netherlands
Sure you have a choice--most obvious is Android and in fact that is what most people use. I really don't understand how you can call Apple a monopoly unless you call all vertical integration such. You don't have a choice of your own seat manufacturer when you buy a vehicle either. That's not particularly "anticompetitive".

In any case, this is beside my original point. My original comment was addressing a specific argument that suggested users are not a stakeholder in this matter because the agreement is between developers and Apple, which I find to be a ridiculous characterization. I am not holistically evaluating Apple's market positioning here. As one other comment points out, this is ultimately a broad political choice for the society at large, not necessarily one that could be concluded one way or the other by abstract analysis.

[My personal opinion on this matter is pretty much orthogonal to the "payment methods" debate which I find to ultimately be a negotiation between corporate entities on who earns how much. What I do want for the society to regulate is the ability for the end user to run their own software stack should they choose to, on a device they pay for. I am comfortable with the fact that should you choose to run iOS, you get the entire iOS experience.]

mehrdada··on Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment systems in Netherlands
I don't think your description of "free market" with some arbitrary constraint on singular party, i.e. Apple, is quite self-consistent, but I digress; the argument is not hinged on holding "freeness of the market" as self-evidently good.

> if all the end-users truly believe that, all the others will fail from no users

Not necessarily. There is a possibility that each individual user may not be valuable enough to the developer to negotiate the Terms of Service imposed on them by the developer. Nor does logistics allow for such negotiation. By voting with our wallets, Apple acts on behalf of all of us securing some of our interests, meanwhile pocketing some money for their mediation service, just like a lawyer, non-profit, union, lobby group, co-op, or agent would do.

mehrdada··on Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment systems in Netherlands
> You as an end user are not party to the agreement that Apple has with the developers. You are of course free to choose not to do business with...

Under the same logic, you, as the developer is also free to not do business with Apple and build on iOS.

Or you could see it with the angle that Apple is in effect hired by us, the end-users, to negotiate on our behalf to ensure the ecosystem cannot dictate unilateral terms unfavorable to us.

mehrdada··on Alder Lake Core i9 processor is faster than the M1 Max
> It could very well be that moving Intel's design to TSMC's fab would lead to it running circles around M1

Or not. There is no reason to believe Apple design has not been a major contribution to the performance. Sure TSMC process is a major component but to quote yourself it does not follow that that explains all of it. It could very well be that a hypothetical Apple design to Intel fab would still run circles around current Intel chips (or not). What we do know is system architecture is sufficiently different, and that it is likely to have a material impact on performance.

mehrdada··on Alder Lake Core i9 processor is faster than the M1 Max
M1, M1 Pro, and M1 Max are all distinct dies, with M1 Max being quite a bit larger, with a larger cache, and more I/O compared to its M1 Pro sibling. The 24-core M1 Max, however, is a binned die of the 32-core M1 Max. There are lower core bins of M1 Pro that are only available on the cheaper 14-inch MacBook Pro. M1 is also available in two forms, one with a 7-core and the other with 8-core GPU.
mehrdada··on Jack Dorsey and Marc Andreessen's crypto feud puts Web3 at risk
If* a technology were to be dependent on lack of "feud" between two individuals, I wonder if it has any intrinsic merit. That is especially ironic for something that bangs on the decentralization drum.

[*] Not claiming all interpretations of "web3" fail that condition, but if they do.

mehrdada··on Google is wrong. Apple’s iMessage is a failure
try bootloop
mehrdada··on Google is wrong. Apple’s iMessage is a failure
Perhaps. Perhaps not. Considering there are dozens of other chat apps with huge market shares on both platforms, is it inconceivable that they had a better product than most chat apps? (Until quite recently iMessage was the only widely distributed and usable end to end encrypted messaging platform out there, for example.) It is Google who controls the majority of smartphones, not Apple, yet they have not been able to effectively "abuse" their market position, mind you.

Personally, whenever I carry an Android, I'd very much prefer Signal or WhatsApp than Google Messages app.

mehrdada··on Google is wrong. Apple’s iMessage is a failure
I wouldn't say so... It pays well and has relatively little accountability (proof: look at how many chat apps failed while PMs congratulated themselves launching them). You might not be able to have any meaningful impact but you won't suffer much consequences either. Heck if you play your cards right you may even land the CEO spot.
mehrdada··on Google is wrong. Apple’s iMessage is a failure
Text is much less disruptive to the people around you and also private. I probably would not be comfortable reading out most of my texts aloud without thinking twice even if recognition were perfect.

(But it is not really just text. People send multimedia content all the time.)

mehrdada··on Google is wrong. Apple’s iMessage is a failure
> If you spent the same amount of money that you spend on an iPhone 13/11 on an android, it wouldn't brick.

In my experience that has not been quite true. Do you consider it fair to consider top of the line Pixels with mainstream non-Pro iPhones? I'd say they are roughly in the same price class. If so, I can tell you almost every other if not every single Nexus/Pixel generation has major and widespread issues after a year or so. iPhones usually have none of that and they have longer software update cycle.

mehrdada··on Google is wrong. Apple’s iMessage is a failure
Is it though? You have a reasonably consistent and good experience from iPhone SE to 13 Pro Max. Why would it be unreasonable to expect the same from Androids?

(Personally I have found the real differentiator is not the price, but the amount of crap the vendor adds. There are crap 1k+ phones running Android and often you can find some cheaper ones that have a better software experience)

← PreviousPage 2 of 25Next →