HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

melange

218 karma · joined September 17, 2013

submissionscomments
melange··on Confusing UI in iOS7
My mother in law barely noticed the upgrade to her 4s, but she did like the iOS7 version of the app 'teevee2'.
melange··on Confusing UI in iOS7
I look forward to seeing your smartphone UI.
melange··on Confusing UI in iOS7
"Any change can be construed as kicking a percentage of users to the curb."

True! But not by a rational person.

melange··on Google to Encrypt All Keyword Searches
They wouldn't collect the information at all if they cared about privacy.
melange··on iMessage for Android
Storing files in the cloud is a commodity service. Why wouldn't they outsource it? They use AWS too.
melange··on Why I Hacked Apple’s TouchID and Still Think it is Awesome
The question of whether fingerprints obtained this way are good enough to fool TouchId is still unanswered.

If it were this easy, why do the hacks use carefully made fingerprints from clean polished glass?

What matters is not whether one pristine fingerprint can fool TouchID (note that we don't know how many failed attempts were made), but what percentage of fingerprints found in the wild can fool it.

melange··on Google to Encrypt All Keyword Searches
Why isn't google open with the data it collects? Surely that would be an easy step towards "organizing the worlds information and making it universally accessible".
melange··on Confusing UI in iOS7
Users are not idiots - they are just people with different priorities to you. That's why this is a deeply flawed approach to design.
melange··on Confusing UI in iOS7
I couldn't agree more. I think iOS7 is a great upgrade in general, but the reminders app is confusing and visually terrible. Notes is pretty bad too.
melange··on Confusing UI in iOS7
Presumably you haven't tried it and are just relying on blog posts for your opinion.
melange··on Confusing UI in iOS7
Except this doesn't seem to be borne out in reality. I have installed it for people in their 60's, 70's and 80s who find a Mac barely usable, who have had no trouble at all with moving to iOS7 after using iOS6.
melange··on Apple Updates iMac
OSX is unix
melange··on Autism diagnoses are up 78% in 10 years. We're dramatically overdiagnosing it
Why was this being downvoted?
melange··on The Free Software Foundation is even more relevant now than before
I'm not confusing anything, although I agree with you about Google. The point is that if source code is always available the value of software goes to zero, and the only value is in information. This leads to the existence of companies like Google, who rely on the data they hoard to make money. It also accounts for the "do consulting" explanation for how to make money out of free software.
melange··on The Free Software Foundation is even more relevant now than before
Free software stands in opposition to free data. When software is free data becomes the center of value and therefore is hoarded.
melange··on The Free Software Foundation is even more relevant now than before
So it's worse, but it confirms to FSF's philosophy.
melange··on Apple Ran Out Of Gold iPhones Because It Underestimated How Much Asia Likes Gold
Funny how a long in the tooth phone has taken more than 1% of the US market in 2 days and is the fastest selling phone in history by a huge margin:

https://mobile.twitter.com/asymco/status/382147503644098561

melange··on Chaos Computer Club breaks Apple TouchID
A meticulously placed fingerprint was made on a clean and polished glass surface as if it was being taken by the police. Nothing like a normal fingerprint left by accident.
melange··on The Free Software Foundation is even more relevant now than before
How is it better than regular android?
melange··on Chaos Computer Club breaks Apple TouchID
You haven't actually made any points at all. You've just called him names and added some dismissive words after a few quotes from him. You don't have to convince anyone that you dislike Gruber. That much is obvious.
melange··on Chaos Computer Club breaks Apple TouchID
That picture shows a carefully polished phone into which someone has meticulously placed 5 careful fingerprints - as if they were being taken at a police station, nothing like the fingerprints you get in normal use.
melange··on Chaos Computer Club breaks Apple TouchID
Those techniques still haven't been shown to work in practice because CCC was only ago to unlock the device using a carefully made high quality print, not one lifted in an ecologically valid situation.

What matters is the rate at which copies of real prints are rejected, not the fact that one carefully made print can be made to work.

melange··on Chaos Computer Club breaks Apple TouchID
Nobody has been able to use those low quality fingerprints to defeat TouchID.
melange··on Chaos Computer Club breaks Apple TouchID
Actually it hasn't been demonstrated at all. They dusted a carefully made high quality fingerprint to defeat TouchID, not an opportunistic one taken from something an unwitting victim left behind.

Until they do that, this doesn't really indicate much about how weak TouchID is in the real world.

melange··on Chaos Computer Club breaks Apple TouchID
So rather than addressing the point, you attack him on something completely different. Presumably because there are actually no examples where he's been wrong about TouchID.
melange··on Chaos Computer Club breaks Apple TouchID
What would you call more reckless than having no passcode at all?
melange··on Chaos Computer Club breaks Apple TouchID
Getting a precise enough print is the hard part. Note that they started with a perfect, carefully staged print, so they haven't really cracked it.
melange··on Chaos Computer Club breaks Apple TouchID
I don't see hundreds of thousands of fingerprints being lifted from people to fabricate 2400 dpi fake fingers 'every day'.
melange··on Chaos Computer Club breaks Apple TouchID
Teaching users to create separate accounts might be better, but so would any number of impractical suggestions.

It is perfectly reasonable to expect an application to provide more security than the user account provides because in the real world, we know that people don't always lock their computers. Not all applications are risky, but one that centralizes a users credentials is clearly so.

Pretending otherwise is simply not acknowledging the real world.

melange··on Chaos Computer Club breaks Apple TouchID
It is considerably harder to fake.
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →