HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mellavora

3,838 karma · joined March 13, 2015

Never fully domesticated.
submissionscomments
mellavora··on Stanford A.I. Courses
Shooting from the hip:

entropy of a single signal, say a sequence of letters, "ababababab" is the scaled "average" surprise per letter. So if they are uniformly distributed, each letter is equally likely/unlikely to come next in the sequence, where if instead one letter only 1/1000th of the time (aaa....aaa...aa..a.z.aaaa), then when the rare beast shows up, it is a big surprise, so the total amount of surprise available in the sequence is high.

That's entropy.

The same thing would be true for a sequence of numbers.

But what if there is some relationship? if aaabaa occurs frequently with 111211, if you line up the sequences by timestamp?

In this simple case, if you know the letters and you can spot the relationship, then there is zero surprise in the number sequence. The cross entropy "letters plus numbers" has the same entropy as "letters" or "numbers" in isolation.

And as you move away from the 1:1 correspondence, you'll see the cross entropy increase until it reaches its max at "entropy(letters) + entropy(numbers)" -- no information shared between the two systems.

To bring it home, I think of cross entropy as the amount of information shared between two signals.

Others might think of it slightly differently.

mellavora··on Bill to allow corporate landowners to vote in elections in Seaford, Delaware
And one day we'll even let them drive cars!
mellavora··on DIY-Audio-Heaven
> I was pleasantly surprised by the significant difference in quality, considering the Superlux headphones were almost five times cheaper.

Maybe your post needs an edit?

mellavora··on Neanderthal Flute
Who approved the PR?
mellavora··on Neanderthal Flute
This is a strange and limiting definition of music, and rather unfair to the birds.

Jokingly, when I sing, it is also hard to tie the sounds coming out of my mouth to particular notes....

seriously, there are birds who sing in a choir/band; the lead singer is the only one who gets laid, his friends "only" help him to sound his best and to give social support to his efforts to impress. Point is a very dedicated effort for a group of animals to coordinate soundmaking as a form of social communication to arouse emotion and bonding. How is this not music?

I've seen people write code in languages that don't even have types, like most computer languages do. Obviously they are not programming. That's right, hard-coding in assembler or even strict binary/hex is as far from programming as you can get!

mellavora··on Neanderthal Flute
Yes, a few objections, or at least requests for clarification.

You propose that necessary conditions for "spiritual" are "consciousness" and "empathy". These phenomenon are regularly seen in trees, and also in most motive forms of multicellular life.

You then propose that sufficient conditions would additionally include existence of an ego AND its dissolution.

If ego is the thing that gets in the way of spiritual, then wouldn't beings that don't have ego be inherently spiritual?

And for those beings that have an ego, given that the ego is made from the non-ego, how do you distinguish between when they are spiritual and when not? I've found that my self is often less aware of my spiritual aspect than I would like, but I'm also very seldom aware of how I coordinate my heartbeat or how I breath or digest food.

How do I know that I'm not enlightened? And just because I "know" this, does it make it true? Does it matter more if I believe in God or if God believes in me? What is this barrier between me and enlightenment? isn't the ego just as much an expression of "spirit" as the heartbeat?

mellavora··on Businesses are in for a mighty debt hangover
Sounds like you are discussing the demographic pyramid. 100 years ago, life expectancy was roughly 40 years. Death cleared out the old.
mellavora··on Coloring in R's Blind Spot
Huh. Those are my gripes about python, and it would also die without the ecosystem.

Except that python also lies about it.

"You don't need curly braces, indents are enough"

"what do you do when your code is more than 80 chars long?"

"Oh, that's simple. Because Python is simple. You wrap it in a curly brace."

If you have a blank line between two parts of a function, why does this fail when you paste it into the interpreter? Solutions? Oh, that's simple. Just put four spaces on the blank line. Unless your linter doesn't like that, because it means you have a line with trailing spaces.

And I'm not even touching advanced crazyness, such as package management and versions.

Thanks for listening to me complain. I'm going through a difficult transition right now.

mellavora··on Coloring in R's Blind Spot
I'd rather stick to my R guns than my python pea-shooters, thank you very much.
mellavora··on Coloring in R's Blind Spot
so, only twice as much code!
mellavora··on The future of programming: Research at CHI 2023
What makes you think it is clearer in your brain than it is in your words? My experience is that in my case it isn't.
mellavora··on Capturing the Flag with GPT-4
Suspect this is a troll posting, but on the off chance I'm wrong... The LLM gives the output of a command. To do so, it has to be able to determine when the command exits. This is exactly the halting problem.

For a trivial example, what is the output of:

```

while True:

  pass

print("goodby world") ```

(this is also proof that leaving out the curly braces makes code harder instead of simpler #python-lie-to-me. multiple edits to get this to render correctly on HN )

mellavora··on Software firms across US facing tax bills that threaten survival
What percentage of the services provided by today's government were not around at the founding?

I'd very much like to see government downsize, but if you want to pay taxes at the level at which the country was founded, you also have to restrict government activity to that level.

Not sure if that is tenable.

mellavora··on Sold a Story: How Teaching Kids to Read Went So Wrong
You are right it is `required methodologies`, but wrong on the source.

The source is corporations which sell curriculums which are mandated by regulation. These curriculums are designed to be easy to sell to governments, which means they tick all the regulatory boxes, but don't actually teach.

Our public education system is not designed to educate, it is designed to return profit to a few corporations which supply it.

How do I know this? Sister is a professor of education and has to fight against this stuff all the time.

mellavora··on Building LLM Applications for Production
Wait-- so Algorithms, Data Structures, and Complexity is out of date?
mellavora··on It's difficult to read an audiophile guide as an analogue engineer
Key word "isolated".

The high-speed bluegrass I enjoy has so many string events, so close to each other (in time), that almost none of them are isolated.

mellavora··on It's difficult to read an audiophile guide as an analogue engineer
Fortunately Hacker News is different
mellavora··on It's difficult to read an audiophile guide as an analogue engineer
I thought class T amplifiers were trash. Class D are more along the lines of "dogs*t".
mellavora··on It's difficult to read an audiophile guide as an analogue engineer
Torroidy, with the steel shield to reduce hum.

https://sklep.toroidy.pl/en_US/index

mellavora··on SBF’s legal defense is being funded with Alameda money he gave his father
I've usually seen the opposite.
mellavora··on UK: Food inflation rises to 18.2% as it hits highest rate in over 45 years
I don't quite understand. Are you commenting on the much discussed U.S. Housing Prices Fall for First Time in a Decade" stories? https://time.com/6217372/us-housing-prices-fall/
mellavora··on Club-Wielding Ancestors: Myth or Reality?
> How many of those 77 million are dead?

And of those, how many are dead because they forgot to bring their gun to the swordfight?

mellavora··on The developer job market is insane
> there are professions like child care, education, healthcare where personnel is always needed and overworked.

and also severely underpaid, and demonized if they try to organize.

mellavora··on America’s banks are missing hundreds of billions of dollars
I fail to see how larger TV sets equates to huge increase in living standards.

Maybe we could measure living standards by looking at mental health statistics? Percent of population on prescription mind-altering drugs?

Do bigger houses, leading to greater social isolation, actually represent an increase in living standards? I get that bigger house == bigger house, but maybe the metric is flawed.

mellavora··on Zero one infinity rule
Now all I have to do is guess which order you used them in, and I'll have full access to your system!
mellavora··on Zero one infinity rule
> If you follow every rule you subscribe to dogmatically, then you're doing something more akin to religion

My impression of religion is dogmatically following only a changeable subset of the rules you subscribe to, where subscribe means "they are in our special book"

mellavora··on California cancels salmon fishing season
I wonder if today's epidemic of depression isn't in part fueled by the consumption of milk from grieving cows.

That distress has to get into the milk; this is one of the pathways of epigenetic regulation -- meaning the distress is heritable, and may impact cross-species.

And it is a completely unneccessary practice. See https://ec.europa.eu/eip/agriculture/en/find-connect/project...

On this farm, calves are kept with cows for 5 months after birth.

mellavora··on California cancels salmon fishing season
> the cow has no concept of morality, only survival.

Actually, many non-human animals have been shown to have strong view on fairness .

If we assume evolution is mostly correct, then the assumption that "morality" only originated in humans is rather suspect; it should be a component of every social animal.

Cows are herd animals. Thus very likely to have a sense of morality.

mellavora··on California cancels salmon fishing season
> The ocean is really big and its teeming with life.

The ocean is really big and was teeming with life.

There, fixed it for you

mellavora··on Bee and butterfly numbers are falling, even in undisturbed forests
An explosion which sometimes, but not always, includes vertebrates.

And which usually happens on a time scale which most of us would consider "long"

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →