HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

meowface

12,270 karma · joined May 9, 2013

submissionscomments
meowface··on Claude Fable produced a counterexample to the Jacobian Conjecture
It's so soon that it may be rational to delay certain math and software projects until smarter models arrive
meowface··on Claude Fable produced a counterexample to the Jacobian Conjecture
I don't know why you're saying this, given this is not sycophancy and instead is an actual example of Claude Fable finding a real counterexample. I would get it if the mathematician had in fact posted something untrue or crankish, but he posted something true.

Frontier models have solved several major open problems in mathematics in the past few months, so this should not be a huge shock. "Anti-AI psychosis" will probably grow to outcompete AI psychosis by year's end.

meowface··on Claude Fable produced a counterexample to the Jacobian Conjecture
The interesting thing about using Claude Fable 5 is it's nearly as irritatingly sycophantic as past Claudes while genuinely being smarter than the previous models. So you get a kind of yo-yoing of it glazing you as a creative genius and disappointedly revealing to you that your ideas are bad and dumb.
meowface··on Claude Fable produced a counterexample to the Jacobian Conjecture
The tweeter, Levent Alpöge, is a professional mathematician who works at Anthropic.
meowface··on Moonshot AI suspends new subscriptions due to Kimi K3 demand
No offense but that seems like a...not good use of money. For the $100/month or $200/month tier you'd get way more out of Claude Fable 5, which is definitely a better model than K3 for coding.
meowface··on AI advice made people less accurate but more confident – sudy
This could also apply to deferring to an inaccurate textbook or professor, though.

We know people are going to defer. The solution here is to make AI (including the free tiers) more reliable.

meowface··on The classifiers Anthropic puts in front of Fable are too zealous
Oh yeah, I've noticed the same, for sure. But that's basically what I was expecting. The best model is not necessarily always going to be the most cost-effective/sensible model for a particular use case.

Fable-class models will probably be cheaper for Anthropic to serve within the year, though. And rumors are GPT-6 is of similar size and intelligence to Fable and may come out within the next few months. OpenAI models tend to give you more bang for your buck, probably in part due to OpenAI being able to throw more capital and compute around on top of being particularly willing to loss-lead to stay competitive with Anthropic.

meowface··on SWE-1.7 Reach Near GPT 5.5 and Opus Intelligence
At this point I barely put any value in any of the benchmarks. I just use the models for coding (and related things like software product design/planning/ideation/etc.) tasks and judge them subjectively, and also see how others judge them subjectively on HN and Twitter.
meowface··on The classifiers Anthropic puts in front of Fable are too zealous
To summarize: the classifiers Anthropic puts in front of Fable are way, way too zealous and have way too many false positives.

From my experience, the model itself is very useful when it isn't refusing any of your prompts.

meowface··on Command and Conquer Generals natively ported to macOS, iPhone, iPad using Fable
- I agree that trying to hamfist a poorly-engineered game-like rendering engine into Claude Code was not wise - hence my agreement in my initial post that "Claude Code is seemingly currently not very well-engineered".

- All of the stuff unrelated to rendering/display is the complicated stuff I was referring to. It's actually not easy to get an agentic harness (even one with, say, the simplest TUI imaginable) to work as well as Claude Code and Codex do.

- I included "necessarily has to be" to separate the two - it does not necessarily need to have a weird buggy rendering engine thing, it does necessarily need to have lots of careful agentic massaging.

- I do not understand how the implication "writing a game engine is easier than writing Claude Code" could have been drawn from my reply.

meowface··on Command and Conquer Generals natively ported to macOS, iPhone, iPad using Fable
There are multiple levels to the irrelevance of your reply.
meowface··on Command and Conquer Generals natively ported to macOS, iPhone, iPad using Fable
I agree Claude Code is seemingly (currently) not very well-engineered but I think you may be moderately underestimating how complicated it is/necessarily has to be.
meowface··on Show HN: ctx – Search the coding agent history already on your machine
I promise your post was already downvoted when I saw it. It is possible some people upvoted it afterwards, changing the net karma.

It is possible you were not intentionally choosing to use an LLM to write/modify your posts, but they largely read like LLM output. The tool you're using may use an LLM and may be rewriting significant portions of your text.

meowface··on Show HN: ctx – Search the coding agent history already on your machine
But just to be clear: you are absolutely, completely denying an LLM played any role in writing any of your comments on HN? You are certain? You're claiming you did not use an LLM in any way in the production of them? Not even to "edit"?

And for the record you were downvoted by other people long before I saw your reply.

meowface··on Show HN: ctx – Search the coding agent history already on your machine
The number of LLMs (and possibly very odd humans) replying to this thread is unusual.
meowface··on Show HN: ctx – Search the coding agent history already on your machine
You did write the above comment with an LLM, though. Why are you now denying it?
meowface··on Show HN: ctx – Search the coding agent history already on your machine
Seek help.
meowface··on 24-bit/192kHz music downloads and why they make no sense (2012)
I still prefer lossless over MP3
meowface··on 24-bit/192kHz music downloads and why they make no sense (2012)
They don't have anything like that anymore
meowface··on Department of Commerce has lifted export controls on Claude Fable 5 and Mythos 5
Because Dario is an ASI doomer and deeply fears the power and danger of hyperintelligent AI and it'd be extremely irresponsible to not warn people "hey, this thing can do things the past models couldn't, and the future models may do it even better".

He was trying to be pro-social.

meowface··on 24-bit/192kHz music downloads and why they make no sense (2012)
Correct. I've paid for Tidal for a decade because I just like the peace of mind that it's closer to the original recording. I'm sure it's mostly placebo, but I like it.
meowface··on Department of Commerce has lifted export controls on Claude Fable 5 and Mythos 5
I'm not sure what you're saying. They spent ages adding guardrails to Mythos. Then they spent ages creating a whole new even more guardrailed version of Mythos called Fable. Then they added tons of classifiers so API requests to Fable would get rejected even if you ask a question like "what is a molecule". They put the thickest layer of bubble wrap around the model of any model in history. And then just today they made the classifiers even much more extreme than at the initial launch.

If they were truly honest in their beliefs of the potential risks of this model, how would their behavior have differed? I would expect exactly the behavior we see, if they were being honest in their belief.

Also note Dario here saying they shot themselves in the foot commercially with how they handled the rollout of the model - you can tell by his reflexive reaction how ridiculous he considers the accusation: https://youtu.be/v1wZwxY3CMg?t=2103

meowface··on Claude Code is steganographically marking requests
I think there's basically zero chance of that. I also think a human likely either wrote the code or gave pretty specific instructions to the agent on how to write the code.
meowface··on Department of Commerce has lifted export controls on Claude Fable 5 and Mythos 5
I can't roll my eyes hard enough at all the people who say this shit about Anthropic every day. I know I'll get downvoted. I know it's lame to complain about future downvotes. I don't care anymore.

Anthropic was correct in their assessment and early warning of Mythos's capabilities, and they did this rollout pretty well. They were not hype marketing. They were being genuinely cautious and honest.

The Trump admin was largely unreasonable with the sudden export control. (Though not entirely unreasonable.) The export control also had not much to do with Anthropic's pre-release warnings. See: GPT-5.6 currently being held up by the federal government.

meowface··on Department of Commerce has lifted export controls on Claude Fable 5 and Mythos 5
Yes, I am pretty sure it was simply poorly worded.

They almost definitely mean "you will notice even more false positives during seemingly routine coding/debugging tasks than you did at the initial launch". Which is not surprising, given the ordeal they've been put through. Hopefully it won't be too bad.

The main depressing thing for me is it's now only 7 days on the subscription, and then full API pricing, with no mention of even a plan to bring it back to the subscription in the future. (The initial launch mentioned two weeks of subscription, then API pricing, then a hope to return it back to the subscription not long after.)

meowface··on Claude Code is steganographically marking requests
It is quite possible this was intended as a "fast burn" measure, yeah
meowface··on Claude Code is steganographically marking requests
I have definitely become much worse at writing code, myself, for that exact reason, but I strongly suspect that's orthogonal to this, especially since this is a tiny amount of code. Underhanded code is not really a software engineering discipline. It's largely a psychological operations practice. I think they're possibly just not quite trained in the art of what could be considered intelligence tradecraft.
meowface··on Claude Code is steganographically marking requests
There are a few different things here. The actual steganography technique by Claude Code here is fairly smart and subtle; it's appropriate for a binary signal. The less-clever part is the implementation of the underhanded code on the client.

For "MMO geopolitics fingerprinting", you can in theory do the entire thing mostly or entirely from the server, with the client not actually ever receiving any underhanded code per se. Such as sending dynamic stylesheets that vary in a pretty plausibly deniable way that can be secretly extracted from screenshots. Same for the character swap stuff. A very good analyst could still potentially detect it, but it's much harder.

With this, there's the smoking gun of the semi-deobfuscated underhanded code in the client. It will always have to exist in some form, but you can write it in a way where it not just looks like regular code but actually has a believable purpose and behavior which could plausibly be normal and benign for implementation of a feature or telemetry or whatever. They did not really do it in a sufficiently "cleverly psyop-y" way, so to speak.

meowface··on Claude Code is steganographically marking requests
I'm sure they've had complex server-side detections for a while. But for the client parts: it should only contain the parts that must be on the client, and it could be done in a more benign-looking way. For example, the unavoidable client parts could've been done more fuzzily/broadly, for plausible deniability, and then narrowed on the server. (They may already have been following that strategy before now, without being noticed.)
meowface··on Claude Code is steganographically marking requests
>It's just the first layer and there are multiple layers underneath this that we don't know about.

Oh, of course. I am sure this is the tip of an iceberg of tons of server-side detections and analytics. But, still, the client-side portion could've been done more cleverly.

What I meant was "some of the specific things in this little client-only snippet could've stayed server-only". I am sure long before they added this they already had tons of other mostly-server-side detection coverage.

← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →