6,231 karma · joined June 19, 2013
hnchat:Y6segqOpdl3De71p6kZi
When it comes to 'corporate-style mindfulness', I like to think of the mindfulness as brushing a set of fake work-teeth that you may or may not care about.
I'd say it's suprisingly good at exacting reminders and todos from natural language into json 'action objects', or turning what is essentially a run-on sentence of a transcript into a markdown formatted text.
What I've found most fun to play with is to get it to extract metadata like an 'anxiety score' and tags.
Overall, it's clearly 'dumber' than the hosted big models, and in my case I have to deal with a small context window. In general my 'vibe' is that I have to be clearer and more explicit, and it's usually better to just do multiple passes over the same text with very targeted questions.
Oh, and in my case I definitely notice my laptop screeching to a halt when it's processing a big transcript, but in my case I can specifically delay those jobs to a time where I'm not at my computer.
While I still think all this code generation is super cool, I've found that the 'density' of the code makes it even more noticeable - and often annoying - to see the model latch on, say, some part of the conversation that should essentially be pruned from the whole thinking process, or pursue some part of earlier code that makes no sense to me, and then 'coaxing' it again.
EDIT: On the least-spectacular end of things, I guess it would just be a template with enough magic to not need the inevitable adjustments.
But especially the ability to just see some of the stuff it produces, and now to see its thought process, is incredibly useful to me already. I do have autism and possibly ADD though.
The fact that such an AI, with sufficient development, even given what we have now, could present everything on a silver platter up to the execution of the /exact/ commands, and this alone is incredibly useful and can save a lot of time/expense/effort.
The crucial bit is that with, say, a human personal assistant, even if they say they will do exactly what you tell them to do, it's still ultimately inexact. But with an AI, it's trivial to 'decorate' a structured 'command object' (as json, xml, whatever) and from that moment let the deterministic system take over.
If anything, we sometimes want an actual human to /not/ deterministically execute /exactly/ what we tell them to, because perhaps they might know we were angry, drunk, or they just heard something on the news that should invalidate our request.
Either way, my point is that this distinction between 'doing research' and 'doing a thing' is not so dichotomous. In practice, I suspect all but the most autonomously-minded people, and especially non-IT folk, given enough sense of control over the confirmation of potentially 'fuzzy' actions, are happy with an AI doing a ton of stuff for them.
Just like with a real assistant, one could set very clear boundaries as to how much the assistant could spend, on what, etc., or even specify that more money can be spent in, say, a particular period and with a few extra passes (using different models?) just to make sure.
It does really feel like the same animal, because to the degree that I remember the discussions, a lot of it was about a perception of some kind of dichotomy (control or not, being able to 'touch' the product or not, etc.) that really doesn't need to exist.