HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mercurialshark

507 karma · joined October 25, 2012

AI, Data Privacy and Public Policy Attorney; Founder of Thoughtly

Substack Newsletter: Eschewing Dystopia, a Practical Guide

chase.substack.com

---

submissionscomments
mercurialshark··on Just Say No
No. I'm speaking to professional misconduct. Touching on their point, that a professional conduct regulatory body would not preclude participating in the precise activities they reference as unethical.
mercurialshark··on Just Say No
As an attorney myself, I wonder if you are insinuating that participating in lawful government programs conducted by DoD or the IC, like SIGINT or cyber warfare operations amounts to professional misconduct (edit)?

By that logic, providing legal counsel to any number of federal government departments or agencies is a violation of professional conduct. Which, of course, it is not.

mercurialshark··on Airbnb “Bribes” Host with Cash Under NDA After Partiers Destroy Apartment
Clickbait title.

Why is this a bribe and not a settlement compensation offer? Good luck settling with your insurance company or an employer without signing an NDA and forgoing future action.

mercurialshark··on America's Reverence for the Bachelor's Degree
I think the title "Reverence for the Bachelor's Degree," is inadvertently misleading.

There certainly isn't profound respect or reverence for a bachelor's degree itself, from employers or anyone else. However, there is an expectation of social and to some degree, field specific exposure.

Perhaps the point of the article is there are far more useful ways to gauge someone's career/field specific potential than a bachelor's degree. And if there are more practical assessment tools than not having a bachelor's degree shouldn't be a barrier to entry.

mercurialshark··on Hebrew University Archaeologists Find 12th Dead Sea Scrolls Cave
“prove that Dead Sea scrolls from the Second Temple period were hidden in the cave”

“the findings indicate beyond any doubt that the cave contained scrolls that were stolen.”

“The material, when published, will provide important new evidence for scholars of the archaeology of Qumran and the Dead Sea caves.”

“The discovery towards the end of the excavation of a pair of iron pickaxe heads from the 1950s (stored within the tunnel for later use) proves the cave was looted.”

Well, at least they are sure of themselves.

mercurialshark··on Telling the whole truth in a post-truth environment
Sadly "post-truth" rhetoric misses the point entirely and manages to endorse ignorance of reality.

When was society ever persuaded by "facts" alone? It's more than intellectual cowardice and naivety - it's lazy thinking.

You still need to convince people that certain facts presented are of such significance as to supersede preconceived notions, prejudices or personal opinions.

Throwing a temper-tantrum and feigning shock when people don't agree with you is like speaking louder at someone who doesn't speak your language. Try instead to learn how to communicate effectively and persuasively.

mercurialshark··on Paralyzed man regains use of arms and hands after experimental stem cell therapy
I remember an earlier article highlighting the potential benefits of olfactory stem cells for damaged brain tissue repair.

Engraftment of human nasal olfactory stem cells restores neuroplasticity in mice with hippocampal lesions

https://www.jci.org/articles/view/44489

mercurialshark··on The World of Fake Vacation Destinations
I guess the author is unfamiliar with Epcot.
mercurialshark··on Ransomware gives free decryption keys to victims who infect their friends
Reamde would have unfolded quite differently had this been the case.
mercurialshark··on Second Chinese Firm in a Week Found Hiding Backdoor in Android Devices
(Feigns shock)
mercurialshark··on First Ever Quadriplegic Treated with Stem Cells Regains Upper Body Motor Control
This is incredible. A non-speculative, non-hypothetical-petri-dish-stem-cell-potential announcement, but tangible, life altering progress that's happening now.

I hope they continue with the initiative and other institutions follow their lead soon if it proves successful.

mercurialshark··on An Interesting SETI Candidate in Hercules
This is possibly exciting. Its metallicity is almost identical to that of the Sun.

If hypothetically it were the best case scenario, something broadcasted by a sentient being, then the position that the universe simply isn't old enough to be densely populated becomes a lessor issue.

Considering that our sun is a third or fourth generation star, based on its metallicity/age and if heavier elements are necessary for advanced civilizations to evolve - it's possible that the intergalactic space race is only just beginning.

mercurialshark··on A Tragic Loss
The loss is of Joshua D. Brown, 40, of Canton, Ohio. A former Navy SEAL and technologist. Josh was a member of the Naval Special Warfare Development Group (SEAL Team Six) prior to founding Nexu Innovations.

http://www.legacy.com/obituaries/ohio/obituary.aspx?pid=1799...

mercurialshark··on Snowden calls for whistleblower shield after claims by new Pentagon source
Oh wow, why not disseminate classified information to your priest or scout master? A foreign journalist is equally arbitrary. Being a self-identified position of authority or confidence does not endow that person with clearance or special knowledge.

"He didn't dump information on a random server somewhere." - That's exactly what he did. Once it left the secure facility, it was no longer secure and vulnerable - tis the point.

mercurialshark··on Snowden calls for whistleblower shield after claims by new Pentagon source
Correct, there are a number of people that look at the actions of a contractor that exposed operational material and think - that's treason. There is a long history of Pentagon leaks regarding policy decisions (ex. shifting budgetary priorities or weapon system programs). However, to expose ongoing operational details - literally in the correct sense of the word - risks lives. Lives, assets and sources which he was willfully indifferent to. Not exactly the work of a patriot, as he likes to self-identify.
mercurialshark··on The Obama Administration Has Embraced Legal Theories Broader Than John Yoo's
He was not a constitutional lawyer. It's amazing that line ever got traction. Teaching con-law is like teaching biology in med school. It's a required course. Being a scholar requires scholarship and you'll be hard pressed to find Obama's con law scholarship/publications.
mercurialshark··on Study: People Want Power Because They Want Autonomy
"I think well intentioned paternalism is a greater cause for authoritarian desires than narcissism and ego validation."

This, absolutely.

mercurialshark··on Denmark confirms US sent rendition flight for Snowden
Well part of it is pretty simple. He stole, as in removed classified information without permission from a secure facility and disseminated millions of pages of classified information to non-approved parties (everyone in the world). If it were legal to remove classified information without permission, because you felt entitled to, then that could be a legal defense. But it's clearly not, so he sought political asylum in Russia. If however, there was a directive from the President or office of legal counsel to shut down the program and if NSA had kept it running, him exposing an illegal program could be a legal defense - had he gone through the appropriate channels. But there was nothing illegal about it at the time. So he committed the crime, not NSA...
mercurialshark··on Alien life could thrive in ancient star clusters
I'm always surprised this isn't discussed more or at least a variable to consider among others for updating the Drake Equation.
mercurialshark··on Sheryl Sandberg Says an MBA Doesn't Matter in Tech
As many have noted, it's not necessarily 1:1 useful in the context of advanced skills training. However unsavory, many mid to large tech companies have a relatively high concentration of engineers who later received MBA's in very senior positions. So yes - the cliche that it's a way to climb the corporate ladder can still ring true for tech, if the tech company you want to work for is structured in the conventional way.
mercurialshark··on How the F.B.I. Can Detain, Render and Threaten Without Risk
The author and title confuse the issue at hand. The subject, a US citizen, travelled abroad under his own free will. The Due Process Clause of the Constitution only applies domestically. Had the FBI detained him on US soil and rendered him to foreign entities, that would trigger due process scrutiny.

Being that he was already in Somalia, the FBI can coordinate with host countries (and intelligence agencies) to interrogate individuals. Not only is the FBI not obligated to return him to the US, it's by no means obvious that they can forcibly extradite, even if they had wanted him returned to the US. Sure - they could request (as the State Department and FBI do all the time) - but that's a different issue.

Disclaimer: I'm not saying it's good, just that the issues (and therefore the author's conclusions) are presented inaccurately.

mercurialshark··on The Needless Complexity of Academic Writing
While I would agree, I still find Judge Posner and Justice Scalia's writing full of puckish eloquence and therefore entertaining...
mercurialshark··on The Needless Complexity of Academic Writing
Reid Hoffman said it best, when explaining why he wasn't going to change the world through the academy, when his advisor told him - "If more than a handful of people understand what you've written, it's insufficiently academic."
mercurialshark··on Edward Snowden at IETF 93
I pretty much agree with Marc Andreessen, on each point. Instead of attempting to paraphrase his points, just watch:

http://www.cnbc.com/2014/06/05/snowden-a-traitor-andreessen....

mercurialshark··on Living in Switzerland ruined me for America and its lousy work culture
I hardly "lived" there, but I found the culture to be lacking a sense of silliness and in general less personable. It's like what they say about German comedy, it's no laughing matter.

I still really like Switzerland.

mercurialshark··on Apple Music Matches Files with Metadata Only, Not Acoustic Fingerprinting
Last summer, Sander Dieleman was working on recommending music based on audio signals, while interning at Spotify. Very interesting work:

https://benanne.github.io/2014/08/05/spotify-cnns.html

mercurialshark··on Amazon details its plan for how drones can fly safely over U.S. skies
I like the idea of rivers serving as a natural drone highway. They weave through most cities/towns, provide insulation from populations on the ground and relatively easy recoverability (as opposed to being destroyed on impact).
mercurialshark··on New Horizons phones home
Pluto = dwarf planet, so it's irrelevant to statement. Also, we certainly haven't visited all dwarf planets.
mercurialshark··on New Horizons phones home
Great answer, thanks!
mercurialshark··on New Horizons phones home
Why does the BBC refuse to capitalize the letters in NASA as an acronym? Is it British grammar or do they not realize it's in all caps?
← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →