HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mewpmewp2

3,684 karma · joined November 13, 2019

submissionscomments
mewpmewp2··on The West forgot how to make things, now it’s forgetting how to code
I feel like I have to disagree here. I don't practice e.g. multiplication or doing math in my head everyday or for years really, but I feel like I'm just as fast at it as I ever was. In fact whenever I have tried things like Lumosity or brain benching games, that I used to do when I was younger, I'm actually faster than when I was younger, despite not having practiced it at all. I feel like all the real world side practice has helped me improve these abilities indirectly, they have all added to my brain's ability to notice novel patterns, see things from different perspectives, apply new intuitive strategies, that I might have not noticed because I was tunnel visioning when I was younger.

There's also plenty of things that I have got for life just by having practiced them when I was child. E.g. I think everyone gets bicycling, but there's also handstand, walking on hands, etc, which I learned as a kid for few years, and I can still do it even if I only do it once a year. In my view code is exactly the same, and maybe in a way even more straightforward, it's easier than obscure math since you don't have to memorize any formulas to solve it easily, albeit I think a lot of math is great because you don't have to memorize formulas in the first place you just have to internalize or figure out the logic or the idea behind it, and then you just have it. I think repetition in math is specifically the wrong way to go about it, it's about understanding, not repetition.

mewpmewp2··on The West forgot how to make things, now it’s forgetting how to code
Well, what I'm trying to say here is that coding is conveying logic, the way you'd evaluate it is how fit it is for its purpose, and if it's long term code, how well it will scale into future.

Now writing is something totally different. In some cases writing ability is not about writing, it's about your thoughts and understanding of life and human nature.

You could simply become a better writer without not writing anything by just observing.

If you are using an LLM to write, what is the purpose of that? Are you writing news articles or are you writing a story reflecting your observations of human nature with novel insights? In the latter case you couldn't utilize AI in the first place as you'd have to convey what you are trying to say within your own words, as AI would just "average" your prompt or meaning, which takes away from the initial point.

With code it's desired that it's to be expected, with good writing it's supposed to be something that is unexpectedly insightful. It's completely different.

mewpmewp2··on The West forgot how to make things, now it’s forgetting how to code
If my internet died in 2020 I would also be useless because probably I couldn't install/download all the libs/frameworks, etc.

But if I didn't need those things, and there was a simple pseudolang syntax which acted exactly the same in all versions, didn't have any breaking changes, I would argue I'd be much better at it now.

Internet, search etc is needed to understand how to setup libs/frameworks/APIs, but logic at itself isn't something that I could possibly forget. AI will help to get those setups quicker without me having to search, but arguably it's all useless information, that will get out of date, that I really don't even need to know. I don't need to know top of my head what the perfect modern tsconfig setup should look like or what is the best monorepo framework and how to set it up, so it would scalably support all different coding languages for different purposes.

mewpmewp2··on The West forgot how to make things, now it’s forgetting how to code
Are we talking about observational ability, creativity, accuracy of communication or grammar here?

There's many more ways to evaluate a writer skill in terms of what they are doing vs what is coding. Coding can be creative, but in most cases you are not evaluating coding as writing, unless it's possibly technical writing, which is still different compared to coding.

mewpmewp2··on The West forgot how to make things, now it’s forgetting how to code
I mean if e.g. AI stopped existing all of sudden, it doesn't mean you would have forgot how to code and couldn't all of sudden anymore, right?

You could forget maybe how a certain lib or framework worked or things like that, or more so how you wouldn't have been up to date with all the new ones, but ultimately code can be represented as just functions with input and output, and that's all there is to it.

As in how could I possibly forget what loops, conditionals or functions are?

I haven't written code myself for 1+ year (because AI does it), but I feel like I have forgot absolutely nothing, in fact I feel like I have learned more about coding, because I see what patterns AI uses vs what I did or people did, and I am able to witness different patterns either work out or not work out much faster in front of my eyes.

mewpmewp2··on The West forgot how to make things, now it’s forgetting how to code
I relate to the idea of having a different level of thinking now with AI. How would you evaluate that someone is overestimating themselves?

As in every little thing that used to be too much effort before, I can just easily get the info, the data now with prompt. The data analysis of something, which otherwise might have taken hours to figure out, I can just have AI write scripts for everything, which allows me to see more data about everything that previously was out of touch. Now you will probably ask of course "how do I know the data is accurate?" -- I can still cross reference things and it is still far faster because even if I spent hours before trying to access that data there wouldn't have been similarly guarantees that it was accurate.

I am thinking so much more about the things now that I couldn't have possibly time to think about before because they were so far out of reach, or even unimaginable to do in my lifetime. Now I'm thinking about automating everything, having perfect visualizations, data about everything, being able to study/learn everything quickly etc.

mewpmewp2··on The West forgot how to make things, now it’s forgetting how to code
I hear this a lot, but also I'm curious. How can you really forget coding?

It doesn't seem to me a thing that I could suddenly forget?

Without AI I will feel frustrated that I'm now much slower, but ultimately it's just describing logic. So I'm a bit skeptical of the claim.

My brain effort is also on other things now, such as how to orchestrate guardrails, how to build pipelines to enable multiple agents work on the same thing at the same time, how to understand their weaknesses and strengths, how to automate all of that. So there's definitely a lot of mental effort going into those things.

mewpmewp2··on Google plans to invest up to $40B in Anthropic
This with the ability to research, iterate on prototypes, in my opinion allows to determine the right thing quicker as well. Of course right now the value is largely intuition based, there may be some immediate revenue/profit, but revenue/profit will take time to follow, so in a way it is a speculative intuition based bet. Financial gains will take time to follow, so for a period of time it will be "trust me bro" for at least some cases, but I suppose future will show, since the intuition seems so strong about it. You can't have good data about an emerging tech like that.
mewpmewp2··on Claude Code to be removed from Anthropic's Pro plan?
Of course not, but they cost more than the person using them, it's multiplying the productivity of that person, so if AI multiplied enough as well it would make sense.
mewpmewp2··on Claude Code to be removed from Anthropic's Pro plan?
Agriculture, oil drilling, trucking, etc...
mewpmewp2··on Claude Code to be removed from Anthropic's Pro plan?
Because accounting software is cheaper due to competition. In software eng Claude is currently strongest and there's higher costs involved than normal SaaS. There are many fields in which the tools/machinery cost more than the salaries of people.
mewpmewp2··on Claude Code to be removed from Anthropic's Pro plan?
Yeah, I mean I think there's just too much work and I think devs who are effective with AI won't become unemployed, but their productivity will be multiplied. More will be expected of companies in terms of output, so it will be just more output.
mewpmewp2··on Claude Code to be removed from Anthropic's Pro plan?
But if e.g. a developer can do 50% more, shouldn't it be worth it to pay up to 50% of developer salary for the product?

So the % is debatable of course. There's cases where an AI agent can save weeks worth of investigation, there's cases where you are mainly blocked due to processes, and many different circumstances. It's up to every company on their own to decide it. But if they decide it's 50%, why shouldn't they spend 50% of salary on it?

Like imagine a large company with thousands of microservices. You need to build a feature, before you had to setup cross timezone team meetings to figure out who owns what, what is happening in each microservice, how it all connects together. But now you can essentially send an AI Agent to scour and prepare all this material for you, which theoretically in this planning could save hours of back and forth meetings.

If 1 hour / 1 eng costs $200, then a 10 people 1h meeting avoided would save $200 x 10 = $2000 alone.

I don't see it as a replacement for dev, it's more of a multiplier.

mewpmewp2··on Claude Code to be removed from Anthropic's Pro plan?
It is noticeable and even promoted, large companies do pay such sums for the API, like $5k+ per person per month. Not every eng is using AI that much already, but companies are clearly willing to pay those sums.
mewpmewp2··on Claude Code to be removed from Anthropic's Pro plan?
But if Sonnet is bad it would give bad impression of the product, no? And it also takes compute, so you give a bad hallucinating impression of your product while still losing compute.
mewpmewp2··on Claude Code to be removed from Anthropic's Pro plan?
Nothing for large companies though.
mewpmewp2··on Claude Code to be removed from Anthropic's Pro plan?
Well yes it is expensive, but companies are paying for that. It is far more expensive than the Max and it does go up to or more in some cases compared to the employee salary.

Larger companies are using Claude through AWS Bedrock and are willing to easily pay $5k+ per engineer per month for it.

mewpmewp2··on Israel escalates attacks on medics in Lebanon with deadly 'quadruple tap'
These are the "excuses" by Russia. The only real motivation is to expand its own power and influence in the World. They will find whatever lowest hanging fruit to justify the actions they think will lead to it. They will try to propose a rhetoric that sounds as if they are justified to something. Everyone does that, not just Russia, but there are countries and leaders who always want to expand at the cost of others, and there are countries who just want to be and are fine with their borders. If it wasn't decade old broken promises by someone from NATO or whatever they would of course dig for another reason as part of the propaganda. There is no rational reason for a peaceful country without goals of expansion to fear NATO. They don't like the expansion of NATO because it limits their abilities in the future to expand.

NATO is for countries that want to stay as they are without having to be as scared that Russia decides they would be their next target for expansion. If those countries in the east didn't join NATO, Russia would use another excuse to at first opportunity invade and occupy those countries.

mewpmewp2··on Claude Opus 4.7
Still I don't previously remember Claude constantly trying to stop conversations or work, as in "something is too much to do", "that's enough for this session, let's leave rest to tomorrow", "goodbye", etc. It's almost impossible to get it do refactoring or anything like that, it's always "too massive", etc.
mewpmewp2··on Ransomware Is Growing Three Times Faster Than the Spending Meant to Stop It
What do you need to do to improve culture in the correct way?
mewpmewp2··on An AI Vibe Coding Horror Story
I don't know what to make of the article. First I thought it seems like a made up LinkedIn story, it seems too crazy while talking about it in such a casual manner. Ultimately I don't know, maybe it was vague for a specific reason. I guess one thing I'd find odd is that whoever developed it, that they didn't run and get stuck with CORS issues, if everything was done client side to those services and that they managed to get API keys, subscription stuff everywhere while still making mistakes like this. And no mention of leaked api keys and creds which UI side there must have been, right?

> Everything that could go wrong, did go wrong.

Then this claim seems a bit too much, since what could have gone more wrong is malicious actors discovering it, right? Did they?

Maybe I have trouble believing that a medical professional could be that careless and naive in such a way, but anything could happen.

I guess another thought is... If they built it why would they share the URL to the author? Was author like "Ooh cool, let me check that out", and they just gave the url without auth? Because if it worked as it was supposed to it should have just shown a login screen right? That's the weirdest part to me, I suppose.

mewpmewp2··on Apple's accidental moat: How the "AI Loser" may end up winning
I guess yes, that's a harness difference, and you can also configure CC as a harness to behave very differently, but still with same harness and guidance, "to me" there's still a difference in terms of Opus 4.6 and e.g. GPT 5.4 or which GPT model do you use? I've been using Claude Code, Codex and OpenCode as harnesses presently, but for serious long running implementation I feel like I can only really rely on CC + Opus 4.6.
mewpmewp2··on Apple's accidental moat: How the "AI Loser" may end up winning
But even other tasks, like research etc, where dates are important, little details and connections are important, reasoning is important, background research activities or usage of tools outside of software development, and this is where I am finding much of the LLMs most useful for my life.

Even Opus makes mistakes with dates or not understanding news and everything correctly in context with chronological orders etc, and it would be even worse with smaller and less performing models.

Scheduling, planning, researching products, shopping, trip plans, etc...

mewpmewp2··on Apple's accidental moat: How the "AI Loser" may end up winning
I mean to me even difference between Opus and Sonnet is as clear as day and night, and even Opus and the best GPT model. Opus 4.6 just seems much more reliable in terms of me asking it to do something, and that to actually happen.
mewpmewp2··on Why AI Sucks at Front End
But even then, what is a fancy CSS wizardry that AI couldn't do for instance, but would be trivial for the author?

Or is it that AI is not as creative?

mewpmewp2··on Why AI Sucks at Front End
What is an example UI that AI would fail to create?
mewpmewp2··on Why AI Sucks at Front End
I'm wondering what would be a specific example that AI would fail to create front-end wise, since I've been having quite good experiences with it.
mewpmewp2··on Ask HN: Hiring in the age of AI-assisted coding: what works?
So if I use only Claude Code for everything I do, what would that mean to you?
mewpmewp2··on Ask HN: Hiring in the age of AI-assisted coding: what works?
What is an example of that 100% end to end that worked?
mewpmewp2··on Git commands I run before reading any code
Obviously a very unpopular opinion, but I guess for my own sake it's hard to write commit messages, because for me it's that I have never really even found use of other people commit messages, and I rarely even attempt to. Ultimately code is code and I don't care about how it got to how it is. I got same issue with documentation and comments or really anything that isn't building stuff. I don't like writing it, don't like reading it either... ADHD?

So, before AI came and saved me from writing commit messages I had alias that ran the whole git add . && git commit -m ... && git push with a fixed commit message. But of course we had squashing so PR title was the one to eventually go there, so maybe that part is fine. But all my side projects had just that.

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →