HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mezzie2

211 karma · joined August 14, 2024

submissionscomments
mezzie2··on Only 5.3% of US welders are women. After years as a professor, I became one
I'm female and I've been here, on and off, since Hacker News was founded. (I burn accounts every so often so I don't get attached to them.)

I participate for a few reasons:

1.) I'm a 3rd generation techie and that's a fairly rare perspective, particularly for people of my age group (I'm 36). HN is one of the few places online that can appreciate that nuance and why it might matter. Related to this, I'm a woman who can in no way be considered an interloper or someone who doesn't understand the culture or the professions. I'm basically here to offer the perspective that the average HN user might hear from his daughter in 10-30 years when I opine on gender stuff.

2.) It's one of the few places with a decent age spread amongst users. Too many other sites are dominated by people under the age of 30 (to be generous).

3.) It's text based and amenable to long format textual discussions, which are how I prefer to interact online since I joined the WWW in 1993 and grew up with the text based Web.

4.) It's somewhere online where a good chunk of the userbase is more technologically proficient than I am and I like talking to people who know more than me about esoteric subjects.

mezzie2··on Young Doctors Want Work-Life Balance. Older Doctors Say That's Not the Job
How do you feel about loan forgiveness for those of us who made good decisions at the time and the conditions changed?

On a personal level, I got MS my very last semester in graduate school. This prevents me from doing the career I trained to do and I instead am working in a lower paying position. Because I can work at all, I'm still on the hook for all my loans even though I can't actually make use of the education I acquired. (Disability discharge is only if you can't work at all, so if you go through all of med school and get a TBI in a car accident the week after you graduate and can't practice but can still work retail, you still have to pay all that money back).

On a societal level, what about the people who were in college during the GFC? I graduated in 2010 and plenty of people graduated in '08/'09/10 who made very reasonable decisions about what to study and how much to take out in loans that got upended because our government and Wall Street can't manage their liabilities. For example, I counted on my father's help to reduce the loans I took out for undergrad, but I ended up with a ton of loans my senior year because everything crashed. Is that my fault or bad decision making? That as a 17 year old I couldn't better predict where the economy would be in 4-5 years than the adults and politicians in charge? Or the kids who've recently gone into CS after it was promised to them as a golden ticket only for the COVID years to fuck them over?

I agree that we shouldn't expect society to be on the hook for bad decisions, but painting student loans as only the result of bad decisions basically looks at the people falling through the cracks and shrugs, declaring them acceptable losses. That doesn't make people want to participate in society or engage in good faith. Which is also a problem.

mezzie2··on Young Doctors Want Work-Life Balance. Older Doctors Say That's Not the Job
I understand that. I think it's morally repugnant and a sign of an ethically bankrupt society. I also have very strong feelings about the amount of debt we place doctors into as well as the fact that we place all the burden for malpractice on them vs. putting some of that burden on the insurance companies and administrative overhead that create the policies that make malpractice more likely. Doctors wouldn't have to be artificially scarce in order to make giant salaries if they weren't almost all in exorbitant amounts of educational debt. The lack of political will the US has to take care of sick people is a disgusting symptom of our infrastructural and institutional collapse.

Is a healthcare system where nobody cares about the desires and will of the patients a healthcare system or a sinecure producing machine for people who know anatomy and physiology?

I personally will likely be fine. I did a stint in a medical library and am literate in medical research (and can therefore take on a lot of the work that doctors previously did when they had more time with patients - I can show up to appointments/procedures with very clear recommendations and advocate for them in a way that is respected as I have the credentials to be taken seriously by medical professionals). I also have a medical doctor + several NPs in my family and can be tended to outside the system if it does collapse. I'm worried about everyone else and the society in which we're raising our children and grandchildren.

mezzie2··on Young Doctors Want Work-Life Balance. Older Doctors Say That's Not the Job
I feel like the patient desires should matter here. Personally, as someone with complex medical needs that entails spending a lot of time with doctors and healthcare professionals, I want the best care possible. The best care possible does not come from people who are sleep deprived and chronically stressed. (I do see the argument that doctors should be trained to handle stress spikes, but that's different than running on empty for months/years). I wouldn't want a lawyer handling my case that has only slept 4-5 hours a night at best for months or whose body is constantly full of adrenaline and cortisol: That lawyer is going to do a shitty job.

It shouldn't be on us as patients to memorize the change over times between shifts to choose when to go in based on getting a rested doctor (actual advice that's traded around). The medical hazing culture is directly harmful to patients and is, in my opinion, a violation of the Hippocratic Oath.

If you want to work yourself to death in order to make a ton of money, go into fintech or join a hedge fund instead of playing with peoples' lives. If you can get into and through med school, odds are you could pick up another just as high paying profession.

mezzie2··on Dramatic drop in marijuana use among U.S. youth over a decade
Oh, it can be.

I live in MI and weed is really, really cheap here. I don't smoke, but I partake in edibles (I have MS and nerve pain that meds can't do much about). I can get 2000mg of edibles for 40 bucks. And that's without price comparing: That's just going to the closest dispensary near my house. And lots of places do penny/free joints with a very low/no minimum purchase.

mezzie2··on Amazon tells employees to return to office five days a week
I'm a huge fan of Zoomer fashion and the minute they reach enough critical mass in the workforce for me to adopt it professionally, I'll be there. Or once I finally have enough wrinkles/am in my 40s so nobody mistakes me for one of the kids with all the attendant headaches that brings. (It's super interesting to me how generational fashion rolls into the workforce - I can wear skinny jeans or jeggings to work now because Millennials are a decent enough chunk of people writing the dress codes now. I remember when the only option were those stupid trouser pants, but I thank my lucky stars I wasn't working in the pantyhose era. Fuck. That.)
mezzie2··on Amazon tells employees to return to office five days a week
Dude, it was a direct response to a suggestion to try different brands of clothes. I simply responded by pointing out a different, unseen variable - that clothing requirements in professional spaces differ by sex and unfortunately there's not really an opt out for uncomfortable clothes in my case.

I'm a woman. I have breasts. They impact my life in some ways. Sometimes that impact is relevant to a discussion - in my case, it's a factor in why WFH is more comfortable. I have sensory issues that are probably familiar to the numerous people on HN and, since HN is generally full of curious people who have a cultural disdain for doing things 'just because' or following uncomfortable social norms for no reason, I shared a variable that may not have been considered because a lot of people here actually like being introduced to data they hadn't incorporated to their worldviews yet.

If you can't grok hyperbole, I'd recommend looking up some middle school Language Arts lessons.

Also, sexuality =/= gender, and mentioning that I have breasts and that they're a statistically unusual size isn't 'exerting' anything any more than Yao Ming complaining about clothes/shoe shopping would be. If you can't hear someone talk about their body without sexualizing them, that's a you problem.

mezzie2··on Amazon tells employees to return to office five days a week
Agreed. This is one reason I am so open and informal in certain digital communications at work. I'm in my mid-30s so I'm old enough to be a 'real adult' in the work place and be the change you want to see and all that.
mezzie2··on Amazon tells employees to return to office five days a week
No, that idea has completely eluded me for the two decades I've spent in the workforce.

My bra size isn't even manufactured/sold in my country, and at one point in my life I was a size that was so rare one company in the world made it.

And this is without getting into non bra issues like my shoulders being much smaller than my bust by size and while some alterations are possible, changing the shoulders requires essentially redoing the entire garment if that can be done on a garment at all. Truly fitting professional clothing would essentially require bespoke or made to measure clothes and I'm not rolling in money. (And even if I was, I'd prefer to spend it on weird tinkering hobbies like the rest of you.)

The clothes that fit me best off the rack involve substantial amounts of stretch and are too casual for the workplace. (Mostly tops; skirts are very easily altered).

mezzie2··on Amazon tells employees to return to office five days a week
The primary reason females have to wear bras in professional environments is because men sexualize them. I find them horrifically uncomfortable.

I was using hyperbole as a rhetorical device to point out some of the absurdities of professional dress codes - I would have thought that was evident from context. Imagine a man who worked in a building that doesn't allow shorts even though it lacks A/C; he might make a comment along the lines of 'god forbid the customers know we have legs.' Or men who are in professions where they have to wear full suits in the summer.

I talked about it because my femaleness is directly relevant to why I feel uncomfortable in professional clothes since the biggest reason is bras, which men don't wear.

mezzie2··on Amazon tells employees to return to office five days a week
The layers! Especially since my dad (a Boomer) did actually really like Doom...
mezzie2··on Computer Science Personality Disorder?
> If everyone in a community were high in agreeableness, say, this will feel nice to the people in it, but could have downsides if no-one feels able to engage in conflict, disagreement or argue for controversial ideas.

Can confirm, because libraries/Library Science is like this. What is best for the patrons or society comes second to how everybody in the room feels about a plan and everybody's 'lived experiences'. By far my least favorite part of the field, as a woman who's pretty low in 'agreeableness'.

For an extreme example, I remember a group project in my MLIS where we talked for three hours unable to choose a topic because everybody had to be in agreement. It was the stupidest waste of my time I'd ever encountered and they were not receptive to my declaration that it didn't actually matter and we'd not remember this in three years anyway. External validation and 'community' were a big deal to them, so my saying that anything wasn't actually that important was a huge social faux pas. I eventually just left and told the rest of the group to let me know when they figured out what we were doing.

mezzie2··on Amazon tells employees to return to office five days a week
Weeeelll, one of the issues is that I'm female and am sensitive to pressure. Wearing a bra all day everyday SUCKS, especially since I'm a very strange size and shape so finding ones that fit costs hundreds of dollars and hours of my time. But God forbid men be aware that we have breasts and that sometimes they dangle or have nipples.

Sizing up also doesn't work for women - we look slovenly then unless we go tailor everything which is more time and $.

I prefer being able to work in a sports bra and sweatpants.

mezzie2··on Amazon tells employees to return to office five days a week
I'd say another generational issue here is that informal digital communication is often seen as 'unprofessional' by the older generations in a way informal in person conversations are not. If you greet someone with a high five and a 'how's it hanging?' in person, that's fine and you making connections, but if you use emoji/abbreviations/gifs/deliberately are informal in your digital communication, it's 'unprofessional'. The only reference points the elders in the office have for digital communication is email: The most formal of digital communication media.

I'm a core/elder Millennial and there's a wide gulf in how I communicate in a Teams chat with my immediate team versus how I communicate via email to an external party. I find that a lot of Gen X+ people bring a really sterile, HR approved vibe to all their digital communications and then complain there's no way to build relationships. (Not all - my supervisor is a Gen X former teacher and he manages informal digital communication fine, as do the few Gen X and Boomer coworkers who've been online for decades.)

mezzie2··on Amazon tells employees to return to office five days a week
Even if I had access to public transit, I'd be driving every day because I'm on immunosuppressants and public transit is a germ pool. Same reason I'm not a fan of working in person with parents of small children.
mezzie2··on Amazon tells employees to return to office five days a week
I find nurturing a social life much easier when I'm WFH because I don't end each day dead on my feet from being overstimulated all day, being in uncomfortable clothes, etc. It also means I don't have to choose between chores and going out after work/on weekends. (A lot of my job is being available for issues and/or requires waiting on SMEs so I have downtime). And it means my social battery isn't drained by the 40 conversations about coworkers' kids that I don't care about (I participate to create a good social environment, but it's just not an enjoyable conversation topic for me) so I can spend my social energy on people and topics that actually fill my cup.
mezzie2··on Founder Mode, hackers, and being bored by tech
I have MS and an MS diagnosis in 1994, 2004, 2014, and 2024 are all wildly different experiences. A lot of progress has been made in this area very quickly, to the point where you can see the stratification/differences in progression based on diagnosis year very clearly in support groups and neurology practices.

I'm about 10 years post diagnosis and in those 10 years a ton of progress has been made. It's to the point where I've moved from considering MS a probably lifelong incurable disease to 'if I can hold on for ~20 more years without significant relapses, it can probably be cured or controlled.'

mezzie2··on How America's universities became debt factories
Yeah, I'd consider the COVID kids to be in a similar boat to those of us who were in college for the GFC. The only reason interest rates were raised as suddenly and drastically as they were is because of COVID, which is a freak event. (Albeit one we should have been planning for as a country.)

There are ways to get student loans discharged in bankruptcy now, and one of the criteria that can be used is essentially that you were sold a bait and switch. (e.g. if the school majorly misrepresented what graduates from certain majors earned) I'd argue that there are cohorts who had that happen on essentially a societal scale, and we should modify the existing legal principle to include deception by the government/industry and not just by educational institutions.

I also think there might be societal stability benefits to this - one of the biggest black pills I've ever encountered was that in the GFC, people could lose their houses/go bankrupt and be allowed to start over even if they took out a NINJA mortgage, that the mortgage brokers/sellers individually saw no punishment, and almost all the high up people who caused/exacerbated the issues got off scot free or were eligible for new starts. If an adult in their 30s-50s makes a bad choice, we have to bail them out or help or not hold them accountable? But the kids who made bad decisions at 17 should be held to them for life? It was just a clear case of shitting on people without the power to push back that it made me revile a lot of American 'values'.

mezzie2··on How America's universities became debt factories
I feel like allowing bankruptcy in certain situations would make sense.

For example, I took out undergraduate and graduate loans to train for a career that, due to a freak health event (I got MS) in my last semester of grad school, I couldn't actually do. Currently, the disability discharge works in a way where if you can do any work at all you're on the hook for the full amount.

So someone who went to school to become an actuary/doctor/lawyer/etc, suffered a severe head injury and afterwards can only work a retail or fast food job is still on the hook for all their loans and has to pay them off on poverty wages.

Another case is people for whom the economic landscape changed so drastically so quickly that the decisions they made when entering school might not be relevant when they leave school. Think people who started undergrad in 2005/2006/2007 - they might have made perfectly reasonable decisions about what college to go to and how much debt to take out based on expected future return, and then that return tanked while they were in school + there were several years of scraping by during which interest accumulated due to no fault of their own.

mezzie2··on The Department of Everything – Dispatches from the telephone reference desk
Most public libraries have them. A large part of the patron base of the public library in 2024 are people who are marginalized and a lot of them come to the library because they lack other internet access. There's also the elderly, the disabled, etc.

The main problem is that libraries don't run the staff levels to make in-depth phone reference feasible, and a lot of public libraries don't have advanced level/academic knowledge available in their hardcopy print collections + don't have people on hand with that level of specialty knowledge to provide high level and in depth answers efficiently (if given a choice, hiring a children's librarian makes far more sense for a public library than a physics expert, but she probably can't answer high level physics questions).

Academic libraries have the subject expertise, but those librarians' time is too planned and valuable to spend on phone reference. Chat reference is usually shared across institutions with librarians in different locations to allow for sharing the work and deduplication of work - one subject area specialist can do chat reference for multiple institutions.

There are plenty of people around who can still do this, but they're usually paid to do other things instead.

mezzie2··on Have ‘hobby’ apps become the new social networks?
> Maybe this is just a reflection of what you consider "fun".

This is what I'd suspect. I'm a lesbian and hang out pretty equally in very male dominated and very female dominated places online. I find it really interesting that most hobby/fandom spaces online do unofficially segregate by gender to the point where it's common in both to just assume everybody there is male/female (and straight, of course, because this all kind of relies on straight gender roles).

> Discord isn't a single integrated community; there are plenty of servers that aren't sausage fests, maybe you just haven't been interested in, or invited to, them?

Yeah, I'm in several female dominated servers and have been in the past. I will say that more of the female dominated servers are private/not advertised, specifically to keep them from being overrun and keeping them a manageable size.

In general, the women care more about curating the social space for ease of connection and are more conscientious when it comes to things like considering how big a server can be before it's a pain to mod, what the impacts of creating another channel would be, what the impacts would be of creating restricted channels would be, etc. Guys wing it more.

mezzie2··on The Internet Archive has lost its appeal in Hachette vs. Internet Archive
So people with perfect vision and hearing should be able to check out materials from a library and people with impairments shouldn't? That's also against the law.

So you're against the existence of libraries at all? Since they provide free access to the fruits of someone else's labor? That is at least an honest position. I won't pretend to have any respect for it, but at least it's consistent.

mezzie2··on The Internet Archive has lost its appeal in Hachette vs. Internet Archive
Nothing preventing them from having good ideals and few brain cells. Which is where my opinion falls: I agree with their ideals but their tactics are bad. I don't want friendly soldiers marching into machine gun fire, personally.
mezzie2··on The Internet Archive has lost its appeal in Hachette vs. Internet Archive
> Projects such as Anna's Archive are going to be much more critical than ever.

I look forward to all the new AA mirrors + contributions that are going to come from disgruntled archivists.

And everybody in the libraries/archives space going on downloading sprees. Most of us have personal illegal libraries. We just don't share them.

mezzie2··on The Internet Archive has lost its appeal in Hachette vs. Internet Archive
> Yeah that’s totally fine. The metaphor of an ebook library is bad and illogical.

E-book lending is pretty much the only accessible option for people with sensory impairments. I think they're a larger portion of the population than writers, so why do writers' monetary interests overwrite accessibility concerns? Plenty of books aren't available in large print or audio versions; e-books are a great way for us to read those books. Big text is best text.

mezzie2··on The Internet Archive has lost its appeal in Hachette vs. Internet Archive
Also, physical books can be rebound/repaired. The binding is usually the point of failure, and even smaller libraries often have rebinding equipment. I worked in libraries for over a decade and I could probably count on one hand how many books (as opposed to CDs/DVDs/other materials) that were weeded due to condition versus because they simply weren't used or contained out of date/wrong information.
mezzie2··on The Internet Archive has lost its appeal in Hachette vs. Internet Archive
> (To be clear, it's not that I'm a big fan of Kiwifarms or anything, but Byuu's tragic story is enough for me to think that the site has significant cultural and historical value, regardless of its ethical orientation.)

Even if it didn't, preserving places like KF is necessary to prevent future scholars from having a really warped idea of what the Internet was like in the 2020s. I find KF extremely off putting (I lurked there long enough to form my own opinion), but I'm not sure how a person is supposed to research how to prevent unhealthy communities from forming without examples of said communities.

I also find it darkly hilarious/sus in light of the fact that one of the primary points of the social justice movement is how we've whitewashed/erased our history. (e.g. how Americans' history education has minimized the perspective of Native Americans or omitted uncomfortable facts about racial discrimination). Are they against historical revisionism or do they just think they'd pick better things to 'erase'? I feel the same way about censoring books that use the n-word: knowing that was at one point acceptable really hammers home how acceptable open racism was for most of American history. Censoring/omitting places like KF from archives (when those archives claim to be representative/neutral) is going to give the impression that there was far more consensus on the 2010s/2020s Internet than there actually was. It's misleading.

mezzie2··on The Internet Archive has lost its appeal in Hachette vs. Internet Archive
> Choosing to sacrifice the rest of IA for a grandiose or idealized vision of how the world should work is a betrayal of those who donate to IA in hopes of funding the much more tangible goal. If he wanted to take the stance he took, he should have spun the library component out of IA and served it as a separate legal entity to take on that risk.

Hard agree, and this is how I've felt since they started this whole boondoggle.

> Maybe the community trust in IA has been misplaced. The mission on their website clearly says they want to serve "All Knowledge" but I'm not alone in thinking it would be best for them to narrow their scope to just internet-related things, and specifically, things that aren't served by other archive or library sources.

I'm a librarian/archivist and my very first career goal back in the 90s was to work for the IA - digital preservation is why I went into the field. They've essentially torched my opinion of them by doing this, and I was one of their biggest supporters/proponents. Even my most charitable readings of their actions lead me to think that either their egos got in the way (because oh goodness did they ever get accolades within the profession and librarianship/archivism has a severe problem with not thought out armchair activism) or they're just idiots when it comes to tactics and strategy. Either of which suggest to me that they are thoroughly unsuited to run an archive of any importance.

mezzie2··on The Internet Archive has lost its appeal in Hachette vs. Internet Archive
> This was the inevitable outcome of "National Emergency Library" and they knew or should have known it.

They knew. I have an MLIS and took one copyright course and could tell immediately that what they were doing was illegal/wouldn't hold up in court. For them not to know would suggest that their staff is less informed than I am, which can't be true.

mezzie2··on AnandTech Farewell
Fair point.

I used to live in Flint. Maybe that's why I didn't remember to mention it...

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →