HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mftrhu

303 karma · joined May 11, 2017

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/mftrhu; my proof: https://keybase.io/mftrhu/sigs/VmVZb3Bi2xjXA9N9Yg55vP7KmmbkF9OSGOZ-ykVkKl4 ]
submissionscomments
mftrhu··on Internet in a Box
No, a locally-run LLM would not be a 10x better solution than having a copy of Wikipedia - plus StackOverflow, the other StackExchange websites, and a lot of other wikis - thanks to Kiwix, a copy of Khan Academy's educational content, of the relevant OpenStreetMap data, of Project Gutenberg, and of dozens more GB in textbooks, reference material, and entertainment.

The illiterate part of the community would be better served by interacting with the community - by fostering connections between people, improving literacy, and giving them tools - rather than with any sort of LLM, let alone one that has been cut down enough to run on cheap, under- (and often intermittently-)powered commodity hardware.

mftrhu··on Italy lifts ban on ChatGPT after data privacy improvements
> Maybe someone like von der Leyen had a word with the current Italian government, which has caved on other issues as well.

Von der Leyen can have as many words with the current Italian government as she wants, but the Garante per la Protezione dei Dati Personali is an independent administrative authority, and its current president got his mandate in 2020.

mftrhu··on Italy's ChatGPT ban attracts EU privacy regulators
> They couldn't even get the bloody cookie law right.

What are you talking about?

> Good luck banning a text interface. Christ, we could probably proxy it over morse code.

Yes. You could. How many people have the know-how to do that, though? How many of them have an ham radio license? How many of them would be willing to deal with the eventual consequences of getting caught breaking the law?

mftrhu··on Italy's ChatGPT ban attracts EU privacy regulators
"No-one cares about privacy, they just pretend they do" is a dismissive non-argument. "You don't care about workers' rights, you care about worker equality" is word games: you are just re-defining what that expression means.
mftrhu··on Italy's ChatGPT ban attracts EU privacy regulators
You keep on conflating data protection agencies with governments. They aren't the same thing - the Garante per la Protezione dei Dati Personali is an independent administrative authority - and even the GP pointed that out.
mftrhu··on Italian privacy regulator bans ChatGPT
> If you're saying that Italy is truthful about their reasoning but China isn't, what sort of process is being used to determine that?

I don't know. What sort of reasoning lead to your initial claim?

mftrhu··on Saying Goodbye to GitHub
There is indeed a problem with the way all these models are trained, and too many people want to pretend that colour can be laundered out <https://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23>
mftrhu··on Saying Goodbye to GitHub
> If you didn't want people or AI to learn from your code, open source was not the right option.

There's nothing wrong with other people using - learning and creating derivative works of - one's open-source code, provided they respect the terms of the license. It seems to me that the real issue is the fact that these licenses don't have enough teeth.

mftrhu··on Saying Goodbye to GitHub
> All because... the person who did it first wants attribution? They want their name to be included in some credits.txt file that nobody will ever read?

Yes, and yes. Those would be the terms that person publishes their code under. If you can't agree to those terms - maybe because including a single name in a credits.txt file that no-one reads is somehow too onerous for your process - then you are always free to re-implement that code on your own.

mftrhu··on Italian privacy regulator bans ChatGPT
... what does the Vatican City State have to do with this decision from the Garante per la Protezione dei Dati Personali, an independent administrative authority of the Republic of Italy?
mftrhu··on Italian privacy regulator bans ChatGPT
How is it the same? Is it because both sentences contain the word "claim" in them, do you disagree about the Garante acting to enforce an EU directive, or what?
mftrhu··on Meta wants EU users to apply for permission to opt out of data collection
Are there any incentives for companies to not collect data about their paying users? Who is even doing this?
mftrhu··on UK: Food inflation rises to 18.2% as it hits highest rate in over 45 years
We already have food stamps.
mftrhu··on Twitter’s $42k-per-month API prices out nearly everyone
... they are.
mftrhu··on AI Generated Seinfeld banned on Twitch for transphobic jokes
Fractal wrongness. Fascinating.
mftrhu··on AI Generated Seinfeld banned on Twitch for transphobic jokes
> What did transgender people do before the treatments and therapies? How did they live in their original state all their lives without our medical interventions?

What did diabetics do before treatment and therapies? People with asthma, myopia, or really any other health issue? What does it matter?

> Do we know that the treatments help in the sense that treated people commit suicide less than untreated people before the treatments were available?

Why do we need to know that? What's the point of it? We don't evaluate effectiveness of any treatment by comparing current data with likely non-existent, pre-treatment (read: more than a century old, in this case) data.

mftrhu··on AI Generated Seinfeld banned on Twitch for transphobic jokes
Or it could be much lower, as Pfafflin, 1998, the 2015 USTS, Wiepjes, 2018, and Danker, 2019 all seemed to find.
mftrhu··on AI Generated Seinfeld banned on Twitch for transphobic jokes
> The treatments I'm familiar with, especially those that are assisted by prescription drugs, are quite new and unsupported

The treatments you are familiar with have been around since the thirties. Research on them started with the Institut fur Sexualwillenschaft, which has been since burned down, and hundreds of papers have been published on the topic since, dealing with thousands of patients all over the world, with their findings all being remarkably consistent.

How hard have you actually looked into it?

mftrhu··on AI Generated Seinfeld banned on Twitch for transphobic jokes
No. Here's a paper which is frequently misquoted by people failing to read its open-access text in its entirety, and relying on third-parties often creative interpretations of it. It has been discussed by its author - Cecilia Dhejne - multiple times over the last decade, notably during her Reddit AMA https://thewinnower.com/papers/7252-science-ama-series-i-m-c...

> Thank you for your question and I am happy I was invited to AMA.

> I am aware of some of the misinterpretation of the study in Plos One. Some are as you say difficult to keep track since they are not published in scientific journals. I am grateful to friends all over the world who notify me of publications outside the scientific world. I do answer some of them but I can’t answer all.

> I have no good recommendation what to do. I have said many times that the study is not design to evaluate the outcome of medical transition. It DOES NOT say that medical transition causes people to commit suicide. However it does say that people who have transition are more vulnerable and that we need to improve care. I am happy about that it has also been seen that way and in those cases help to secure more resources to transgender health care.

> On a personal level I can get both angry and sad of the misinterpretations and also sometimes astonished that some researcher don’t seem to understand some basics about research methology.

mftrhu··on Insulation: First the body, then the home (2011)
If you have a Decathlon nearby, you could try theirs. The basic Wedze thermal underwear - very much not fancy, 100% polyester, but warm and more than OK to wear indoors - is only €6.99 for a pair of pants or shirt. They also carry more expensive items, some of them in wool, and usually much cheaper than other brands.
mftrhu··on ThinkPad as a Server: The Follow-Up
> Curious what the power draw is with an older Thinkpad like this while idling and under load.

I have an X230i running Debian, and I got it to idle - screen on, backlight low, no browser open, Emacs and Syncthing running - at around 8 W. It gets up to ~10 W with light usage - i.e., a few browser tabs open - ~13 W at 40% load, and ~17 W at 75% (I tested the last two with x265 video playback, which doesn't get hardware acceleration on Ivy Bridge).

The i3-3120m in it should have a TDP of 35 W, but I don't think I ever saw it draw that much.

mftrhu··on We tried to run a social media site and it was awful
Intimidation is the act of using threats - direct and indirect - humiliation, embarrassment & co. to make other people too fearful to perform actions which they would otherwise be free to engage in.

For that, speech is usually more than enough, especially if performed by a large ingroup against a small outgroup.

mftrhu··on The Next Button
> If you think you are more powerless than a serf 500 years ago because Bezos has more money then you, then you are the one who gave away your power for no reason

That's not at all what GP was saying - I quote, with emphasis added:

> I hear people who are pro-capitalism say “the poorest people in the US have it better than kings did 500 years ago”, which is only true if you’re considering the stuff those people have. If you’re considering the ability to self-actualize it’s not at all true.

mftrhu··on As unions decline, inequality rises
No. They keep whatever actual wealth they might end up creating - if and when they even manage that - and the only thing that trickles down from them is their ego.

I prefer not being subject to their whims.

mftrhu··on As unions decline, inequality rises
Are they, really?

How did they end up not having enough cash on hand to cover minor emergencies, then? How are they going bankrupt over healthcare costs - even when insured through their job - while having to worry about not being able to take a day off?

mftrhu··on My building has replaced our keys with an app
"The law" is a thing that is going to be interpreted and enforced by a human judge, one who is likely going to frown upon a landlord's creative interpretation of it.

A judge's job is not to apply the law to the letter, but to the spirit. They are not going to throw their hands up when a tenant is kept out of their unit, no matter what the landlord might have decided to sneak in into the rental agreement: the law is there to protect the tenant.

mftrhu··on No one wants to have kids anymore
I'm just confused. I mean, I suppose one could argue that - "you cannot whether you will like something unless and until you try it" - if one was in the mood for a stupid argument: people can and do have opinions on, say, not losing their limbs without having someone chop them off.

They can listen to third parties which had the same experience, have experiences which are similar but less intense, or just use their imagination and figure out whether the person they are - whose values and goals they hopefully know - could possibly enjoy whatever is being discussed.

I still have no idea how someone saying "I won't pursue that because that's not what I want for myself" could possibly be "patronizing", even assuming it could be false.

mftrhu··on No one wants to have kids anymore
> Patronising is thinking you know you don’t want kids without having them. You don’t. You have no idea what it’s like.

... what?

mftrhu··on Emergency declared and curfew imposed following North Carolina power grid attack
As someone wrote elsewhere, "please stop spewing unconfirmed politically motivated conspiracy theories."
mftrhu··on Emergency declared and curfew imposed following North Carolina power grid attack
> No sir, you are. You're absolutely fine with rampant sexual misconduct in our schools and pretend none of your politically inconvenient crimes have occurred while "the other guys" are evil for demanding their children be in a safe learning environment.

"You are absolutely fine with rampant sexual misconduct"?

That's a pretty harsh thing to accuse someone of, especially in the context of a discussion of people writing to schools they are not related to to complain about LGBT+ topics being discussed. Going from that to rampant sexual misconduct, also, feels like a bit of a leap.

← PreviousPage 4 of 7Next →