HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mgfist

1,187 karma · joined January 28, 2019

submissionscomments
mgfist··on Why Switzerland has 25 Gbit internet and America doesn't
For many reasons. Most of which have to do with government bureaucracy and incentives. HSR in California is thinly disguised jobs program with no real incentive or aim to actually build HSR.
mgfist··on US and Iran agree to provisional ceasefire
Change this line from : "so basically Iran gets everything it wants"

to "so basically Iran would get everything it wants under this plan".

I'm not so dumb to understand that this will be the final plan, just commenting that this is incredibly bad for the US as is laid out.

> Any review of the actual deal would show a two week ceasefire in exchange for the strait being open and safe while negotiations continue.

Speaking of this community being kinda dumb - do you really think this ceasefire is enough for all ships to go on their merry way? Deals mentioned over social media are not enough to convince insurance companies that all is safe. And 12 hours later we now have evidence of this - https://www.nytimes.com/2026/04/08/business/strait-hormuz-sh...

Also, my original point is that there is nothing in that deal that is a better long-term outcome than what we had before the war. Maybe that will change in the final deal, but the fact that the starting point of the negotiation is 100% on Iran's side is not where you want to be.

mgfist··on Git commands I run before reading any code
You can, but most of us work in Github and having a PR to dump commits to is very easy and convenient. Then, when you get some feedback on your PR, you can dump more commits and it's very easy for the reviewer to see what has changed since the last time they reviewed it.

I feel like what you're arguing is that you should clean up your commits before anyone else sees them. Fair. But you could also clean it up right before merging to main. It's not that different, except the latter is much less annoying, particularly when going back and forth with people.

I know this is a very github centric workflow, but that's where most engineers work now, and it's nice and easy. This wouldn't work for eg: contributing to linux, but that's not what most of us do.

mgfist··on Git commands I run before reading any code
Yes, I think people who are anti squash merge are those who don't work in Github and use a patch based system or something different. If you're sending a patch for linux, yes it makes sense that you want to send one complete, well described patch. But Github's tooling is based around the squash merge. It works well and I don't know anyone in real life who has issues with it.

And to counter some specific points:

* In a github PR, you write the main commit msg and description once per PR, then you tack on as many commits as you want, and everyone knows they're all just pieces of work towards the main goal of the eventually squashed commit

* Forcing a clean up every time you make a new commit is not only annoying extra work, but it also overwrites history that might be important for the review of that PR (but not important for what ends up in main branch).

* When follow up is requested, you can just tack on new commits, and reviewers can easily see what new code was added since their last review. If you had to force overwrite your whole commit chain for the PR, this becomes very annoying and not useful to reviewers.

* In the end, squash merge means you clean up things once, instead of potentially many times

mgfist··on Git commands I run before reading any code
Why are those not just separate PRs? Or if they really needed to be merged at once - they should still be separate PRs but on a feature branch
mgfist··on Git commands I run before reading any code
Same, but now with AI I don't have to remember that anymore
mgfist··on US and Iran agree to provisional ceasefire
Yikes, so basically Iran gets everything it wants. It paid a heavy price for it, but it would get so much out of this. At pre war ship rates, that toll would be ~$90B per year ($45B if split half with Oman). Iran's government generates something like $40B in income, so this would be absolutely monumental.
mgfist··on GLM-5.1: Towards Long-Horizon Tasks
Posted this after mythos came out? The hutzpah
mgfist··on System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf]
On the other hand I've gotten to use opus-4.6 and claude code and the quality is off the charts compared to 2023 when coding agents first hit the scene. And what you're saying is essentially "If they haven't created God, I'm not impressed". You don't think there's some middleground between those two?

Also they just hit a $30B run-rate, I don't think they're that needy for new hype cycles.

mgfist··on Why Switzerland has 25 Gbit internet and America doesn't
It's got 9m people. The US has 30x the people and 250x the space. It's not comparable.
mgfist··on F-15E jet shot down over Iran
That works for Iran because US air-defense is still comprised mainly of advanced and expensive systems (like the Patriot). It doesn't work as well in Ukraine or Russia because both have figured out drone interceptors quite well. Both countries do the type of attack drone clustering you suggest. I read somewhere that a strike like from Russia that might include 60-70 drones + ballistic missiles in the hopes that one or 2 get through.
mgfist··on F-15E jet shot down over Iran
If only there was a 4 year long war where thousands of drones are flown every day both on offense and defense that we could have learned from ..
mgfist··on Parrots pack twice as many neurons as primate brains of the same mass
Evolution is kinda like pre-training in a sense.
mgfist··on Founder of GitLab battles cancer by founding companies
Oh c'mon. Here's what Sid's done to help others in the process

* Started 10 companies to enable access to others * Detailed policy proposals to make this easier process for others * Open sourced the entire process and all of the associated data (25TB)

and probably other things I missed.

But nah, what would reaaally help is an acknowledgement.

mgfist··on Some things just take time
I see indecision and analysis paralysis far more. And yes, you do need to thing about things, but far too often I see people not do something because they're worried it's not optimal. But not doing something is far worse than doing something sub-optimally!
mgfist··on Student beauty and grades under in-person and remote teaching
> I probably agree with that, but also acknowledge there's no good way to make that completely objective.

Even worse, rich kids have far more means to engage in extracurriculars than poor kids.

mgfist··on Student beauty and grades under in-person and remote teaching
Well nothing is truly meritocratic - even with free tutoring, kids will still have different genetics, different home environments, different upbringings etc..

Colleges in the US that removed standardized testing from their applications, in the pursuit of trying to be more meritocratic, found that fewer students from underrepresented backgrounds got in, not more. In hindsight (and to some in foresight) this makes sense because now schools leaned more heavily on grades and extracurriculars, both of which can be gamed by wealthy families far more easily than a standardized test.

mgfist··on Some things just take time
Yes, but only if you have an ax to sharpen. With a lot of things it takes trial and error to make progress. You can take this pretty up high too - sometimes it takes building multiple products or companies to get it right
mgfist··on Austin’s surge of new housing construction drove down rents
OP wasn't talking about free markets but supply and demand.
mgfist··on Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill
It should be externalized to a degree. Facebook shouldn't be the ones verifying age, but there should be a trusted 3rd party service that does that, which just tells facebook "yes this user is old enough to use your service" or "no they're not old enough".

It abso-fucking-lutely should not be at the OS level though, for so many reasons. Even the implementation alone would be a nightmare. Do I need to input my ID to use a fridge or toaster oven? Ridiculous.

mgfist··on 747s and coding agents
> But here's what I keep wondering: does expanding the scope of the possible eventually erode the deep understanding that makes the expansion valuable in the first place? Like, if you never have to debug a memory leak because the agent handles it, do you lose the intuition that would let you architect systems that don't leak in the first place?

Maybe, but it feels very hard to predict. Neither I nor most engineers I know ~truly~ understands how a computer works at the deepest lowest level. And for those who do, they probably don't understand the deepest lowest levels of chips, and for those who understand that, they probably don't truly understand how those chips are made, and so and so on. Modern life is built on abstractions upon abstractions, and no one can understand it all from the ground up.

My question is whether AI will give us another abstraction on top of what we have, or if it'll just get so smart that it'll do everything, leaving us with no way to contribute (and most likely becoming extinct).

mgfist··on Bars close and hundreds lose jobs as US firm buys Brewdog in £33M deal
Not true (newer investors generally get seniority), but more importantly this is about common shareholders (generally employees and even founders) who never have the opportunity to get liq pref.
mgfist··on 747s and coding agents
All fair, but I think a different interpretation could be that AI allows you to vastly expand the scope of the possible, such to create a situation again where things are challenging and frustrating and fun.
mgfist··on What Claude Code chooses
> But it's sad it does not ask the user more.

You can ask it to ask you about your task and it will ask you tons of questions.

mgfist··on Layoffs at Block
Block isn't a jobs program, and employees cost money. Layoffs suck (I got laid off last year) but the reality is that it's a business and regardless of profitability, if you're not worth more than your salary you're a liability. The severance given is quite generous and fair. My biggest issue is that Block should never have grown so big in the first place.
mgfist··on Magnus Carlsen Wins the Freestyle (Chess960) World Championship
Yes the stamina needed to play classical tournaments is not as there anymore, but he's still very very strong. He just came in second at Tata Steel Rapid, which although is not classical, is still an indication of strength, albeit without the emphasis on endurance.
mgfist··on Magnus Carlsen Wins the Freestyle (Chess960) World Championship
Vishy's still a top player at 56
mgfist··on How I estimate work
Yes, then you must have a rough estimate for that. Or in the other extreme example - in the case of an outage, estimates must be much more precise (i.e. "we should have a workaround in ~30 minutes").

But neither case requires too much thought or discussion. My point was more that estimation ends up overwhelming time and energy, when you can just do the thing instead. I've worked on teams where we've spent more time arguing about how complex a task than it would've been for someone to crank out a solution.

I also don't mean engineers shouldn't collaborate, just that it should be more ad-hoc and not manager/tpm/scrum-master driven.

mgfist··on A flawed paper in management science has been cited more than 6k times
In general Western society has effectively outlawed "shame" as an effective social tool for shaping behavior. We used to shame people for bad behavior, which was quite effective in incentivizing people to be good people (this is overly reductive but you get the point). Nowadays no one is ever at fault for doing anything because "don't hate the player hate the game".

A blameless organization can work, so long as people within it police themselves. As a society this does not happen, thus making people more steadfast in their anti-social behavior

mgfist··on How I estimate work
That's why the right way to do it is to have a hard deadline given to engineers, then the engineers cut whatever scope is needed to actually wrap something up by the deadline
← PreviousPage 4 of 15Next →