8,027 karma · joined July 24, 2007
I don't recall much of the letters now, but they did leave a lasting impression of a mind that was both powerful and deeply concerned with ethical questions. I'm not sure I'd have liked Tolkien, but the letters were a great read.
This suggestion is similar to the NIH public access policy (adopted in 2008), which requires the results of NIH-funded research to be made freely available within 12 months of publication. The new memorandum gives agencies some freedom in how they respond - they don't need to adopt exactly the NIH policy - but it is clearly in the same spirit.
Here's an analysis from Peter Suber, a leading advocate of open access: https://plus.google.com/109377556796183035206/posts/8hzviMJe...
Suber focuses on the connection to FASTR, a major piece of open access legislation introduced into Congress a few days ago. Broadly, FASTR has a lot of overlap with the White House directive. FASTR would require every Federal agency with a budget over 100 million to adopt an open access policy. A significant difference - and one that I expect is of interest to HN - is that FASTR has provisions to enable text mining. That would potentially be of interest to some startups. Much more info here:
http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/hoap/Notes_on_the_Fair_Access_t...
If you'd like to support open access, take a few minutes to look at the Alliance for Taxpayer Access's (ATA) call to action on FASTR:
http://www.taxpayeraccess.org/action/FASTR_calltoaction.shtm...
It is also of interest to follow the responses from John Wilbanks and Heather Joseph, two of the authors of the petition (and long-time advocates for open access):
Wilbanks notes that the memo covers research from "NSF, Ed, EPA, NASA, USDA, HHS, Commerce, Interior, Defense, Energy, Trans, DHS, Ag, State, Smithsonian". He also implies that while this memo is great progress, it falls short of a full open access mandate enabling reuse and text-mining of content.
http://www.taxpayeraccess.org/action/FASTR_calltoaction.shtm...
The ATA were closely involved in the passage of the NIH Public Access Policy (2008), which makes all NIH-funded research openly accessible within 6 months of being published.
http://www.earlham.edu/~peters/fos/newsletter/11-02-06.htm#n...
Note also the linked studies. Summary: the majority of OA journals don't charge fees.
"in practice [PLoS fee waivers are] rare": well, among the people I've spoken with, 100% who asked for a waiver got one. So at present it's apparently not difficult to get a waiver. And when you say "they'd have to change their policy" that simply does not follow. What is true is that they'd have to figure out some way of funding it. Eliminating fee waivers is just one approach. But there are many other ways it could be funded. What would matter in that instance is how committed the people running PLoS are to the waiver.
https://plus.google.com/109377556796183035206/posts
Suber is one of the world's leading advocates for open access to science.
For even more complete coverage, you can follow Suber's Open Access Tracking project. The project can be followed in several ways, including on Twitter:
Senators John Cornyn and Joe Lieberman
In the House, Representatives Michael Doyle, Frederick Boucher, Michael Capuano, Jerry Costello, Bill Foster, Barney Frank, Gregg Harper, Paul Hodes, Tim Holden, Dennis Kucinich, Rick Larsen, Zoe Lofgren, Stephen Lynch, Dana Rohrabacher, Fortney Stark, Debbie Wasserman Schultz, and Henry Waxman
I only follow the politics of open access loosely, but my impression is that Lieberman has been a strong supporter since well before it was fashionable - well back into the 1990s.
I disagree with many of these people on many things, but I think this work is admirable, and worth supporting.
Edit: I notice that Senator Ron Wyden is missing from Wikipedia's list. Not sure what's up with that. He was definitely involved.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Research_Public_Access_...
The act has not yet passed. It was re-proposed in 2010 and 2012, each time with increased support from a bi-partisan group of sponsors, in both Houses. Cornyn is still a sponsor.
My understanding is that Cornyn was instrumental in the passage of the 2008 NIH public access policy, which makes NIH-funded research available within 6 months of publication:
This is by far the largest victory for open access to date. It would, however, be eclipsed by FRPAA, should it pass.
Given all this, I believe it is natural that Cornyn has an interest in the case, and questions.
It's unclear how many of those researchers followed through on the boycott. Some did -- I've met many scientists who say they send letters similar to LeCun's. I've also met some who signed, but who now admit (often sheepishly) that they didn't follow through.
Text of the letter is here:
I resubmitted since I'm pretty sure this is of interest to many HN readers. Examples of why it's interesting include:
1. Google's deep learning work is now being used to power Android voice search (http://googleresearch.blogspot.ca/2012/08/speech-recognition... ); and
2. Dean claims that "We are seeing better than human-level performance in some visual tasks," in particular, for the problem of extracting house numbers in photos taken by Google's Street View cars, a job that used to be done by a large team of people (http://www.technologyreview.com/news/429442/google-puts-its-... ).
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dilution_refrigerator
There are other, more sophisticated methods of cooling, which can go even lower in temperature.
Something I didn't deal with at all was spider traps. My thinking there was that this was a relatively shallow crawl, so the dangers of getting badly stuck weren't too great. For deeper crawls this would be essential.
You have since edited that out. So you appear to have read the article after writing your comment.
On your last sentence: I didn't comment on your position one way or the other.
EDIT: The parent comment has now been edited to remove the original starting sentence: "I don't have 46 minutes to spare on a strong headline, but I will say this...".
"After the first night of the 2008 SciFoo conference at Google, @gnat Torkington's twitter stream contained a gem: 'At SciFoo opening session. 300 people standing around networking. Meanwhile, Larry Page is quietly unpacking chairs at the back of the room.' (from memory, not exact)"
The CEO (or any leader)'s job is to make sure that whatever needs to be done, gets done. Sometimes, that means unpacking the chairs.
The US is ranked just 31 in the world for net migration rate: http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/imm_net_mig_rat-immigratio....