HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

michael_nielsen

8,027 karma · joined July 24, 2007

https://michaelnotebook.com
submissionscomments
michael_nielsen··on Very realistic CGI
The artist behind this, Alex Roman, has produced a 12-minute CG piece (the "Third and the Seventh", briefly mentioned in the article) that is absolutely amazing:

http://vimeo.com/7809605

He apparently quit his job and worked fulltime for a year to create it. It is, I think, the most amazing work of art I've seen created by an artist in my lifetime. I've watched it perhaps 20 times. (Sorry for the hype, I find it impossible to talk about this any other way.)

michael_nielsen··on Wrong scientific beliefs that were held for long periods
The "force" of gravity is not a fundamental concept in general relativity.

Here's a way of thinking about what's going on.

Consider a large mass, like the Earth. That mass curves spacetime in the vicinity of the Earth. A small object, like a satellite, simply moves completely freely in a "straight line" (i.e., geodesic path) according to that curved geometry. The curved geometry is such that those geodesics are just the satellite orbits that we see. In other words, the satellite isn't affected by any "force", it's just moving in a straight line in a geometry that happens to be curved, so we see it doing circles around the Earth.

It's exceedingly neat: in John Wheeler's great phrase, matter tells spacetime how to curve, and spacetime tells matter how to move. No forces required! Of course, after the fact you can tack on a notion of "force", but it's in no way fundamental.

Same thing is going on with projectile motion here on Earth.

Once you internalize this point of view, the statement about holding your arm in place becomes a lot clearer. The "natural" force-free thing your arm wants to do is to move along geodesics of spacetime, which means falling toward the Earth at an acceleration of g. But if we exert a (muscular) force to keep it up, then we can hold it in place. In short, in this point of view, forces are things which cause deviations from geodesic motion.

michael_nielsen··on EPIC Lawsuit to Suspend Deployment of Body Scanners at US Airports
It's not the airlines. It's the TSA, an entirely separate organization. I've little doubt that most of the airlines hate this - it almost certainly negatively impacts their bottom line.
michael_nielsen··on Mark Zuckerberg on What Hollywood Doesn't Get About Silicon Valley
Zuckerberg is flat-out wrong in his assertion that Hollywood doesn't understand people building something just because they like building things. I'm quite sure he's right when it comes to some people in Hollywood, possibly even many of the most powerful people. But I'll bet that what gets a great writer like Aaron Sorkin up in the morning is the same kind of creative impulse that drives hackers. Sorkin is a hacker - just in a different medium.

None of which is to say that Sorkin's portrayal of Zuckerberg is at all accurate. In the West Wing, Sorkin once wrote: "You think I think that an artist's job is to speak the truth [but] an artist's job... is to captivate you for however long we've asked for your attention." I think he's quite right, but it's a heck of a philosophy if you're making a movie about someone still living.

michael_nielsen··on What algorithm blows your mind? (Reddit compsci)
Speaking of incredibly cool algorithms based on Fourier transforms, the Schoenage-Strassen algorithm for multiplying integers is also amazing:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sch%C3%B6nhage%E2%80%93Strassen...

At least to me, it seems hard to imagine that multiplying two N-bit integers could be done with less than O(N^2) operations. Schoenage-Strassen lets you do it using O(N log N log log N) operations!

michael_nielsen··on What algorithm blows your mind? (Reddit compsci)
The quantum search algorithm: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grovers_algorithm

It lets you search a completely unstructured N-item search space using the square root (!) of N queries, not the N queries you'd think were necessary.

Also, the algorithm is so simple that once you know it's possible, and provided you're very comfortable with basic quantum mechanics, it's almost trivial to find the algorithm.

michael_nielsen··on Paul Buchheit: Serendipity finds you
A closely related story, from HN user kenjackson (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1647146 ):

"How long will you need to find your truest, most productive niche? This I cannot predict, for, sadly, access to a podium confers no gift of prophecy. But I can say that however long it takes, it will be time well spent. I am reminded of a friend from the early 1970s, Edward Witten. I liked Ed, but felt sorry for him, too, because, for all his potential, he lacked focus. He had been a history major in college, and a linguistics minor. On graduating, though, he concluded that, as rewarding as these fields had been, he was not really cut out to make a living at them. He decided that what he was really meant to do was study economics. And so, he applied to graduate school, and was accepted at the University of Wisconsin. And, after only a semester, he dropped out of the program. Not for him. So, history was out; linguistics, out; economics, out. What to do? This was a time of widespread political activism, and Ed became an aide to Senator George McGovern, then running for the presidency on an anti-war platform. He also wrote articles for political journals like the Nation and the New Republic. After some months, Ed realized that politics was not for him, because, in his words, it demanded qualities he did not have, foremost among them common sense. All right, then: history, linguistics, economics, politics, were all out as career choices. What to do? Ed suddenly realized that he was really suited to study mathematics. So he applied to graduate school, and was accepted at Princeton. I met him midway through his first year there--just after he had dropped out of the mathematics department. He realized, he said, that what he was really meant to do was study physics; he applied to the physics department, and was accepted.

I was happy for him. But I lamented all the false starts he had made, and how his career opportunities appeared to be passing him by. Many years later, in 1987, I was reading the New York Times magazine and saw a full-page picture akin to a mug shot, of a thin man with a large head staring out of thick glasses. It was Ed Witten! I was stunned. What was he doing in the Times magazine? Well, he was being profiled as the Einstein of his age, a pioneer of a revolution in physics called "String Theory." Colleagues at Harvard and Princeton, who marvelled at his use of bizarre mathematics to solve physics problems, claimed that his ideas, popularly called a "theory of everything," might at last explain the origins and nature of the cosmos. Ed said modestly of his theories that it was really much easier to solve problems when you analyzed them in at least ten dimensions. Perhaps. Much clearer to me was an observation Ed made that appeared near the end of this article: every one of us has talent; the great challenge in life is finding an outlet to express it. I thought, he has truly earned the right to say that. And I realized that, for all my earlier concerns that he had squandered his time, in fact his entire career path--the ventures in history, linguistics, economics, politics, math, as well as physics--had been rewarding: a time of hard work, self-discovery, and new insight into his potential based on growing experience."

Source: http://www.colby.edu/colby.mag/issues/84n3/ivory.html

michael_nielsen··on Why Most Published Research Findings Are False
There's also a nice short summary in this blog post:

http://www.marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2005/09...

michael_nielsen··on Why Twitter Is Massively Undervalued Compared To Facebook
Facebook's revenues this year are expected to be in the neighbourhood of $1 billion (http://www.insidefacebook.com/2010/06/22/exclusive-discussin... ), a near doubling from last year. Given that, their current valuation is totally unsurprising.
michael_nielsen··on William Gibson says the future is right here, right now
News headlines are typically NOT written by the author of the article. This is something I've heard many journalists complain about. To my knowledge, the Wikipedia article on Headlines (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Headline ) is quite accurate: "Headlines are generally written by copy editors, but may also be written by the writer, the page layout designer or a news editor or managing editor."

So Gibson probably didn't write the headline.

michael_nielsen··on Google's first employee
Silverstein's old Stanford homepage is here: http://www-cs-students.stanford.edu/~csilvers/ Interesting to get some idea of what his background was when he went to Google.
michael_nielsen··on 2010 Physics Nobel Prize (Graphene)
There's an excellent short overview (with many links) of why graphene matters here:

http://blog.joerg.heber.name/2010/10/05/great-the-physics-no...

It punctures some of the hype, while still conveying what's interesting.

michael_nielsen··on Ask HN: Audio of awe-inspiring and impressive people for an experiment?
The ted.com audio files are available on iTunes (and probably many other places). I find many of those speakers quite inspiring. Even better, although much longer, are the Long Now talks, which are available both on the Long Now website, and on iTunes.
michael_nielsen··on Reasonable Doubt: Innocence Project Co-Founder Peter Neufeld on Being Wrong
I've known many police officers who care deeply about guilt or innocence.
michael_nielsen··on Paul Graham is now tweeting
I prefer Reader as well. My information gathering preferences are (1) Reader; (2) Delicious; (3) FriendFeed; (4) Twitter; (5) etc...
michael_nielsen··on Paul Graham is now tweeting
Thanks for the clarification --- I had misread your previous comment as advocating a different information-gathering strategy, not as avoiding the particular information source (Twitter) entirely. Of course, I have no problem with that, even though I personally find Twitter quite useful in this regard.
michael_nielsen··on Paul Graham is now tweeting
In disagreeing with the rule I stated, you're advocating reading tweets which are either (a) uninteresting, or (b) contain only information already widely shared. Are you really advocating that? (And if so, which part?)

I agree with you about the echo chamber. But it's virtually impossible to live inside an echo chamber when you follow people who share mostly information that is not widely held. By definition, that means those people aren't merely echoing the crowd, and this will take you away from people with me-too tweets about iPhone antenna issues (or whatever the news of the hour is).

michael_nielsen··on Paul Graham is now tweeting
A rule that is obvious, but which most people on Twitter don't follow, is that it's best to share information that is simultaneously (a) interesting and (b) not already widely shared by others. Most people aim either for (a) or for (b), but not for both. csallen's suggestions elsewhere in this thread are useful, as with one exception they fulfill both (a) and (b).

This rule can be tipped upside down: it's best to follow people whose tweets mostly fulfill both these criteria. This rules out a very large number of people. It's amazing how many people fill their tweetstream with the news of the day from TechCrunch (or HN). It may be interesting, but it's already widely shared.

Personally, I find twitter most useful as a highly tailored source of links. That makes it sound similar to news sites such as HN, but the experience is different because you choose which people to follow. For instance, I get a lot out of following @NicholasGruen, who ran the Australian Government's Gov2.0 taskforce, @rjlipton, a leading theoretical computer scientist whose blog was the main clearinghouse in the scrutiny of the recent claimed proof the P is not equal to NP, @gnat of O'Reilly Media for an eclectic collection of tech-related links that for the most part fall outside the purview of the standard sources (TechCrunch etc), etc. Of course, those particular sources are just ones I find interesting, and they may not interest you. The point is that if you choose people whose tweet streams match your informational needs, Twitter can be very valuable.

michael_nielsen··on Intuitively Understanding Quantum Mechanics
This article doesn't quite aim to be an intuitive explanation of quantum mechanics. What it does is, however, closely related, and may be of interest to anyone who wants to know more about quantum mechanics: it's a simple explanation of Bell's inequality and it's experimental violation. It's the violation of Bell's inequality which essentially forces us to abandon our ordinary realist conception of the Universe. This is perhaps the strongest single piece of evidence in favour of the quantum mechanical view of the Universe.

(Disclaimer: I wrote the article.)

michael_nielsen··on People have no bloody idea about saving energy
This article buries an important story beneath bombast. A much better read is David MacKay's (free) book "Sustainable Energy - without the hot air": http://www.withouthotair.com/ As the book itself says, it's an analysis of sustainable energy based on "numbers not adjectives".
michael_nielsen··on Rare Sharing of Data Leads to Progress on Alzheimer’s
Thanks for the shout out, Pete. A few bits and pieces:

Creative Commons has started an organization called Science Commons that has done some great work on getting scientists to share their data:

http://sciencecommons.org/

A promising step in this direction is Sage Bionetworks, which is attempting to use an open source style approach to drug development:

http://www.sagebase.org/

There are some very well known people behind Sage, and it's received backing from Merck (and Science Commons), among others. See, e.g., http://creativecommons.org/weblog/entry/19646, which states that Merck has backed them to the tune of 150 million dollars. At the moment they're just getting off the ground.

A much broader overview on open data and related issues can be found in Peter Suber's open access timeline: http://oad.simmons.edu/oadwiki/Timeline

Another interesting step is the Federal Research Public Access (http://www.arl.org/sparc/publications/articles/FRPAA-introdu... ), which would make most US-government sponsored research publicly available. It's not quite the same as open data, but is very consonant with it.

michael_nielsen··on Update on Deolalikar’s Proof that P≠NP
A useful summary update is provided by Terry Tao here: http://rjlipton.wordpress.com/2010/08/10/update-on-deolalika...

There is also an interesting comment on the utility of such discussion here: http://rjlipton.wordpress.com/2010/08/10/update-on-deolalika...

Finally, a general overview with many links can be obtained here: http://michaelnielsen.org/polymath1/index.php?title=Deolalik...

michael_nielsen··on Massively collaborative mathematics
Also submitted 9 months ago (see http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=881884 for discussion), this seemed worth resubmitting in the light of much of the current discussion on HN.
michael_nielsen··on How to Take a Walk
Cory Doctorow has a very thoughtful blog post that expands on this theme and really picks out what's wrong with accusations of "too much time on your hands": http://boingboing.net/2002/02/03/too-much-time-on-his.html It's good enough that I periodically reread it, and recommend it to others.

(Just submitted it as http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1591218 )

michael_nielsen··on If You’re So Damn Smart, Why Aren’t You Rich?
I like the converse: "If you're so rich, why aren't you smart?"

It's attributed to MIT's Paul Cootner, supposedly as a comeback to a money manager who asked him why, if Cootner was so smart, he wasn't rich?

michael_nielsen··on I need a software that ....
As a variant, this is amusing:

http://www.google.ca/search?q=%22I+wish+my+computer%22

michael_nielsen··on I need a software that ....
I get (slightly) more interesting results from:

http://www.google.ca/search?q=%22I+wish+there+was+software%2...

michael_nielsen··on The Acceleration of Addictiveness
The "Slow movement" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slow_Movement ) is an interesting example of an attempt to create a mass movement that addresses some of these issues, while not completely cutting off modern conveniences.

(I'm linking it not because I agree, but because it's an interesting example of an attempt to collectively change people's response to modern technology. Examples like the Amish are in a similar vein, but much more extreme.)

michael_nielsen··on The Top Idea in Your Mind
A very closely related idea is that most people have a "ground state": an activity that they naturally gravitate toward when nothing else intervenes.

For many people, their ground state is shopping, or talking with friends, or watching tv. Nothing wrong with any of these.

For some people, their ground state is aimless coding, or writing, or drifting around some community (e.g., the community of actors, or musicians, etc). Again, nothing wrong with any of these, and they may be a useful way of learning, or having ideas.

But for a very small number of people their ground state is much more focused. I've known people whose ground state is writing papers about physics or mathematics. And it's simply unbelievable what such people can get done in a year. (Note, mind you, that very few professional physicists or mathematicians fall into this category.)

I haven't founded or worked at a startup. My observation-from-the-outside is that founders often have to take on many different tasks. And I wonder how difficult that must make it for any of them to become a ground state task.

michael_nielsen··on They Will Steal Your Idea. They Cannot Steal What Really Matters.
I agree, on all fronts.

"Ideas don't matter, only execution does" is just a pet peeve. It's as obviously false as the notion some people have that their (totally obvious) idea is really valuable.

I like Derek Sivers formulation: ideas are a multiplier on execution. With a really amazing idea (like the formula for the first high-Tc superconductors) even run-of-the-mill execution yields big returns.

← PreviousPage 10 of 17Next →