HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

michaelkeenan

1,213 karma · joined June 9, 2008

michael.keenan@gmail.com

michaelkeenan.net

michaelkeenan.blogspot.com

submissionscomments
michaelkeenan··on When Is a “Mark” Not a Mark? When It’s a Venture Capital Mark
Huh, that's an interesting correlation. What examples led you to notice it? Have you found a way to make money from this?
michaelkeenan··on Warned of a Crash, Startups in Silicon Valley Narrow Their Focus
> You seem to be attaching a moral axis to the decision on whether to raise capital

Which part of their comment makes you think that? I don't see it, and I'm curious about how it's coming across differently to others.

michaelkeenan··on Bay Area Politicians Strangling the Region's Key Industry
Um, hi. I have tone feedback on your comment, if you want it. I am of course some internet stranger to you, with the unimportance that carries; this is just a request, not an insult or a demand or anything like that.

I found your comment more unpleasant to read than the non-sarcastic form would have been. I think that sarcasm often obscures meaning in a way that makes conversation less productive, and I think that happened in this case. It seems you weren't attacking the principle I proposed; rather, you were questioning whether it applies to San Francisco (specifically: whether the probability is non-trivial). Without sarcasm, it would have been easier to state that directly. You could have made explicit that you think the 37-year history of no new rent control is better outside-view evidence that it won't happen than the inside-view evidence that the earlier commenter brought up: https://ww2.kqed.org/news/2015/12/15/aaron-peskin-proposes-e...

If that's what you meant, we'd be talking about that. As the article says, "Peskin, who was sworn in as a supervisor last week, says he will ask the City Attorney’s Office to study an idea he thinks will get around the state ban on extending rent control. He wants to explore the possibility of imposing controls on new developments". If there's an interesting conversation to be had about whether Peskin's proposal is impossible considering the history, we could be talking about that, but the sarcastic form of argument doesn't naturally lead to that.

So I request that if we interact again, please refrain from initiating sarcasm and other forms of hostility. (Again, this is just a request; you are of course free to say whatever you want.)

michaelkeenan··on Bay Area Politicians Strangling the Region's Key Industry
A non-trivial probability of future rent control decreases the incentive to invest in new construction.
michaelkeenan··on Colombia’s Milestone in World Peace
> Those responsible for war crimes and crimes against humanity will NOT go to jail

I dislike the injustice, but I've come around to the view that agreements like this are often consequentially appealing. If the end to a conflict leads to one's imprisonment or execution, the incentive might be to keep fighting even with unfavorable odds. I don't know the particulars of this case, but it's possible that a peace agreement could only be reached if it includes this provision, and so it might be worth it.

michaelkeenan··on Mosquitos as Weapons
It's sad that humans choose other humans as their worst enemies. Mosquitoes are a much worse foe. We should be allying against mosquitoes, not allying with mosquitoes against each other!

This is explored in greater detail in this wonderful essay, Foes Without Faces: https://blog.jaibot.com/foes-without-faces/

michaelkeenan··on UK votes to leave EU
Some people downvote sarcasm for reasons like https://mindsarentmagic.org/2014/09/13/never-be-sarcastic/
michaelkeenan··on The TSA is a waste of money that doesn't save lives and might actually cost them
I think the (ostensible) reason is similar to this, from the link:

> As security expert Bruce Schneier likes to note, such screenings don't have to be perfect; they just have to be good enough to make terrorists change their plans: "No terrorist is going to base his plot on getting a gun through airport security if there's a decent chance of getting caught, because the consequences of getting caught are too great."

That is, the act of confiscating the liquids almost ensures that the liquids are already harmless. But if they didn't confiscate the liquid, it (supposedly) might not be harmless. It's a bit like Newcomb's Paradox: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newcomb%27s_paradox

michaelkeenan··on Vote.org is a non-profit that wants to get the U.S. to 100% voter turnout
According to the sidebar in the Wikipedia article on voter turnout[1], increasing education leads to increasing likelihood to vote.

38% - No high school 43% - Some high school 57% - High school graduate 66% - Some college 79% - College grad 84% - Post-graduate

Though, possibly, being educated isn't the same thing as being informed.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voter_turnout#Socio-economic_f...

michaelkeenan··on Vote.org is a non-profit that wants to get the U.S. to 100% voter turnout
I used to think this way. The thing that changed my mind was learning how much people think the USA spends on foreign aid[1]. On average, Americans think 28 percent of the federal budget is spent on foreign aid, but it is about 1 percent. People base policy preference on their mistaken impression. When informed of the correct amount, the number who think America spends too much on foreign aid changes from 61% to 30%.

Foreign aid is one persistently misunderstood issue that I know of, but I worry that there might be many similar issues.

[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2013/11/07/the-b...

michaelkeenan··on Show HN: Watch movies with the freedom to filter
I expect that enabling custom categories could lead to this being useful in ways that you'd never expect. For example, people with misophonia HATE the sound of people chewing loudly. It's not uncommon (the misophonia subreddit has 8,000 subscribers). I'd love to use your filter to mute the audio (and simultaneously turn on the subtitles, if possible) when there are misophonia triggers in movies. People with misophonia are already interested in movie warnings for this (e.g. the subreddit had several high profile warnings about the triggers in The Martian).

If misophonia is a possible useful application of custom categories, there might be many others.

michaelkeenan··on Recording of aerospace executive's speech leads to his resignation the next day
> if he honestly believes that SES-9 required 100,000 pounds of fuel to make its landing attempt, should he really be part of the upper management of a rocket company?

What is the correct amount of fuel used to make the landing attempt? I just googled and didn't quickly find it, though I did find this speculation at StackExchange[0] talking about reserving 15% of the fuel, or 66 tons, for the landing. 66 tons is 132,000 pounds, so 100,000 pounds seems a reasonable rounding - what am I missing? (I don't know anything about rockets.)

[0] http://space.stackexchange.com/questions/4466/how-is-spacex-...

michaelkeenan··on What do economists say about inequality?
> he literally qualified the idea of corporations engaging in anti-competitive behaviour with "if", as if this is some unproven supposition.

I don't think that's the right interpretation of that phrase. PG has been complaining about rent-seeking corruption for over a decade:

"[Buildings are ugly because of] the notoriously corrupt relationship between the government and construction companies." - http://www.paulgraham.com/usa.html, 2004

"[Corruption includes] construction firms that fund politicians' campaigns in return for government contracts, or rich parents who get their children into good colleges by sending them to expensive schools designed for that purpose." - http://paulgraham.com/inequality.html, 2005

"There are a lot of people who get rich through rent-seeking of various forms, and a lot who get rich by playing games that though not crooked are zero-sum...[There are] corrupt practices in finance, healthcare, and so on. Once again, that is exactly my point. The problem is not economic inequality, but those specific abuses." - http://paulgraham.com/ineqold.html, 2016

I think ghufran_syed's interpretation, using 'if' in the logical sense, is correct. (I think it was a poor way of expressing it.)

> It's clear he thinks startups are the larger effect.

I think he had plenty of opportunities to say that startups were the larger effect, and he didn't say that. This sentence would have looked different if he'd meant that: "But while there are a lot of people who get rich through rent-seeking of various forms, and a lot who get rich by playing games that though not crooked are zero-sum, there are also a significant number who get rich by creating wealth."

If startups were the larger effect, the natural way to end that sentence would have been "most get rich by creating wealth." His version was longer and wordier.

For what it's worth, I didn't get the impression that he thought startups were the larger effect, which is why the WaPo article sent me searching for something I might have missed.

michaelkeenan··on What do economists say about inequality?
Weirdly, the figure from the paper is actually 17%, not 14% (http://www.ucl.ac.uk/~uctp39a/innovation_and_top_income_ineq...). I'm not sure where the WaPo writer got 14% from.

Also note that the paper warns that 17% is an underestimate: "Our results are likely to understate the true impact of innovation on top income inequality at the national level for at least two reasons. First, if successful, an innovator from a relatively poor state, is likely to move to a richer state, and therefore not contribute to the top 1% share of her own state. Second, an innovating firm may have some of its owners and top employees located in a state different from that of inventors, in which case the effect of innovativeness on top income inequality will not be fully internalized by the state where the patent is registered. Nevertheless, overall we find a sizeable effect of innovativeness on top income inequality."

michaelkeenan··on What do economists say about inequality?
I didn't remember PG writing anything about startups mostly driving the income gap, and I just searched the essay and didn't find it. Here's what PG wrote about the proportions of each group causing income inequality:

"But while there are a lot of people who get rich through rent-seeking of various forms, and a lot who get rich by playing games that though not crooked are zero-sum, there are also a significant number who get rich by creating wealth."

It's unclear what the WaPo writer is responding to when he says "it's difficult to conclude that startups are mostly driving the income gap."

The writer also has this odd paragraph: "If there is middle ground between Graham and this body of research, it's the idea that policymakers shouldn't go after inequality with blunt instruments, like big tax hikes just for the sake of soaking the rich. Perhaps, instead, they should target rent-seeking, which economists agree is bad for everyone who isn't a rent seeker."

This doesn't look like a middle ground; rather, it's what PG suggests: "if there are people getting rich by tricking consumers or lobbying the government for anti-competitive regulations or tax loopholes, then let's stop them. Not because it's causing economic inequality, but because it's stealing."

And: "startups aren't the problem, [the problem is] corrupt practices in finance, healthcare, and so on."

(But it's a long essay; please let me know if I've missed parts that support a different interpretation.)

michaelkeenan··on Cancer survivors less likely to receive callbacks from potential employers
You're allowed to have a prior: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prior_probability

A study lacking the power to prove its hypothesis doesn't disprove the hypothesis.

michaelkeenan··on The Myth of Welfare’s Corrupting Influence on the Poor
When we see someone say something disagreeable, it's tempting to hope that they also hold another view inconsistent with that. Then we can point out the inconsistency. But if we assume that they hold this other view, we will say irrelevant, nonsensical things.

You ask xacaxulu to "tell us again" something they never said in the first place.

michaelkeenan··on Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their customers’ DNA
> Yet, Women are also more likely to kill there intimate partner. (This flips if you include ex partners.)

When describing a statistic on the internet, especially a surprising statistic, please include a source. We don't know you, so the level of trust we'd have of your statistic is "someone said it on Hacker News", which of course is not very much trust. You might be correct, but others on Hacker News make mistakes, so any sensible person reading that will shrug and think "eh, maybe".

michaelkeenan··on Global eradication of wild poliovirus type 2 declared
It'd be further from the truth if war deaths were increasing, or were decreasing at a slower rate. The war death rate is down to about 5% of its peak.

http://ourworldindata.org/data/war-peace/war-and-peace-after...

michaelkeenan··on Oldest use of the word ‘fuck’ in 1310 English court case
There's an even earlier record of a man named John le Fucker from 1278. It's unclear whether this is an instance of the word "fuck", or whether it's just a variation of some other surname like Fulcher.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_le_Fucker

michaelkeenan··on The Fight to Save a Silicon Valley Trailer Park
It sounds like they're choosing between selling to the highest bidder, or keeping it as a trailer park for the benefit of the residents. There's a third option. If the land is more valuable as a vacant lot than as a trailer park, I hope they consider selling it as a vacant lot and distributing a portion of the difference to the residents as compensation for moving out. Using these numbers as an example:

> his appraiser had valued the property in 2013 at $14.5 million with the mobile homes and at $29.2 million as a vacant lot.

He might sell for $29 million and distribute $8 million equally among the 400 tenants. That's $20,000 per person, which could be more-than-decent compensation for having to move, and the seller still keeps a large portion of the difference in value: 29 - 8 - 14.5 = $6.5 (million).

michaelkeenan··on Atari founder Nolan Bushnell on why life is 'a game'
> it shocked me when I read, "a handful of young men are eagerly banging away on keyboards late on a Saturday afternoon"

It's not so unreasonable to work on a Saturday afternoon. As PG says, "If you’re ever unsure if you should be doing what you’re doing during YC, ask yourself this question: ‘Am I building our product? Am I talking to users? Am I exercising?’. if you’re not doing one of these things, you’re doing the wrong thing."

> Crunch does not make for efficiency. Look at EA if you want to see what crunch does

I don't know much about EA but their stock value seems okay:

https://www.google.com/finance?chdnp=1&chdd=1&chds=1&chdv=1&...

(Though if the recent rise is due to changed policies around crunchtime, that would be really interesting and I'd love to learn about that.)

michaelkeenan··on A Bad Idea from Congress About How to Fund Science
> Why do people think that this has been successful for DARPA? DARPA has spent billions on all kinds of ideas that don't work, including prize competitions.

Some people regard the DARPA prizes as successful because, in some cases, the technology to win the prize was developed.

> DARPA is also known (notoriously, one could say) for operating a good-old-boys system, where you have to butter up the DARPA program managers to get any funding.

Can you explain this a bit more in the context of the prize program? It looks like a criticism of their grant program, but you follow it with:

> So no, I don't agree that prizes have been successful for DARPA.

michaelkeenan··on A Bad Idea from Congress About How to Fund Science
> This is a staggeringly bad idea. Why? Where do I begin? Well, first of all, biomedical research costs money–lots of money. Everyone I know in biomedical research, in which I’ve been working for 25 years, needs money before they make their discoveries. A prize at the end is nice, but you can’t do anything if you can’t pay for equipment, supplies, and (perhaps Congress will be surprised to learn this) people’s salaries.

This point would be more powerful if he explained it in the context of the DARPA and XPRIZE competitions. Spaceships are surely expensive, but multiple teams were funded. Is there a reason that won't happen for the NIH prizes?

> NIH will give these prizes to foreign citizens–and companies! So apparently they will take some portion of NIH’s budget, and instead of awarding it in grants to U.S. scientists, they will give prizes to companies in, say, Russia. Don’t get me wrong: I think science should be supported in every country around the world. But each country has its own system, and the NIH is by far the most important source of funding for biomedical science in the U.S. We just can’t afford to have NIH give out prizes to the entire world.

I don't think it follows that because each country has its own science system, then the US can't afford to give prizes to the entire world. The prizes won't be higher if they're given to international teams; they just might be awarded earlier. Surely it would be more expensive (at least in time) to restrict it by country, because someone else might be able to make the advance faster than the US.

It appears that the author isn't motivated by advancing science, but by funding American scientists. If American scientists need or deserve more money, that should be addressed separately from how to advance scientific progress most quickly. There are probably ways to accomplish giving Americans more money that don't slow down scientific progress.

michaelkeenan··on Ask HN: Can you get to AWS?
A Google query helps with this. For example, search for: 6:07 PM PDT to HKT

Google will return a special result at the top of the page: "6:07 PM Tuesday, Pacific Time (PT) is 9:07 AM Wednesday, Hong Kong Time (HKT)"

michaelkeenan··on How my father gave me a terrifying lesson at 10
George Orwell has a great essay about his visits to coal mines: http://www.george-orwell.org/Down_The_Mine/0.html

"It is impossible to watch the 'fillers' at work without feeling a pang of envy for their toughness. It is a dreadful job that they do, an almost superhuman job by the standard of an ordinary person. For they are not only shifting monstrous quantities of coal, they are also doing it in a position that doubles or trebles the work. They have got to remain kneeling all the while--they could hardly rise from their knees without hitting the ceiling--and you can easily see by trying it what a tremendous effort this means. Shovelling is comparatively easy when you are standing up, because you can use your knee and thigh to drive the shovel along; kneeling down, the whole of the strain is thrown upon your arm and belly muscles. And the other conditions do not exactly make things easier. There is the heat--it varies, but in some mines it is suffocating--and the coal dust that stuffs up your throat and nostrils and collects along your eyelids, and the unending rattle of the conveyor belt, which in that confined space is rather like the rattle of a machine gun. But the fillers look and work as though they were made of iron. They really do look like iron hammered iron statues--under the smooth coat of coal dust which clings to them from head to foot. It is only when you see miners down the mine and naked that you realize what splendid men they are. Most of them are small (big men are at a disadvantage in that job) but nearly all of them have the most noble bodies; wide shoulders tapering to slender supple waists, and small pronounced buttocks and sinewy thighs, with not an ounce of waste flesh anywhere. In the hotter mines they wear only a pair of thin drawers, clogs and knee-pads; in the hottest mines of all, only the clogs and knee-pads. You can hardly tell by the look of them whether they are young or old. They may be any age up to sixty or even sixty-five, but when they are black and naked they all look alike. No one could do their work who had not a young man's body, and a figure fit for a guardsman at that, just a few pounds of extra flesh on the waist-line, and the constant bending would be impossible. You can never forget that spectacle once you have seen it--the line of bowed, kneeling figures, sooty black all over, driving their huge shovels under the coal with stupendous force and speed."

michaelkeenan··on Lost Posture: Why Indigenous Cultures Don't Have Back Pain
Cochrane reviews show that acupuncture works for some types of pain: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21359919

(It's not mentioned in the abstract I linked, but searching Cochrane's site shows that they look at studies comparing acupuncture to a "fake" acupuncture, which is presumably putting needles randomly.)

michaelkeenan··on Why People Are Irrational about Politics
I think that isn't correct, because if it were ever correct, the first candidate willing to choose their platform based on what most appeals to voters would win. I think that has already occurred, and politics is dominated by politicians who adjust their positions to whatever will appeal to voters.
michaelkeenan··on Why People Are Irrational about Politics
I think the correct URL should be http://www.owl232.net/objectiv.htm
michaelkeenan··on Why People Are Irrational about Politics
I don't know how to continue this discussion, because I don't see the part in section 3 where he talks about voter preferences directly coinciding with candidate preferences, nor the part where he says preferences are static. Paul Graham says[1] people should quote the thing they disagree with before they argue against it, and I think that would help here.

[1] http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html

← PreviousPage 3 of 9Next →