HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

michaelkeenan

1,213 karma · joined June 9, 2008

michael.keenan@gmail.com

michaelkeenan.net

michaelkeenan.blogspot.com

submissionscomments
michaelkeenan··on Why People Are Irrational about Politics
What do you think of the points he brings up in section 3, where he addresses this?
michaelkeenan··on NASA's Radar Found 4 Men Trapped in Rubble in Nepal by Their Heartbeats
I think you might be replying to a different idea than reverend_gonzo was proposing. I think he's just noting that not-obviously-useful technological advances can have unexpected applications. I don't read him as saying that not-obviously-useful technological advances are the best way to save lives in Nepal.

If you just want to save lives, donate to whichever charity GiveWell[1] says is the best charity at saving lives per dollar. Every other use of money is vulnerable to the "but you could save more lives a different way" criticism.

[1] http://www.givewell.org/

michaelkeenan··on Internet trolls: Proactive policing
It's a great paper, and a great application of machine learning!

Though, the FBUs had worse readability than NBUs. I think you're misinterpreting the readability index - higher is worse, not better. From the paper:

"Users who get banned in the future (FBUs) (a) write less similarly to other users in the same thread, (b) write posts that are harder to read (i.e., have a higher readability index), and (c) express less positive emotion."

michaelkeenan··on Female Chimps Seen Making, Wielding Spears
You make some interesting points, but there should be a norm against introducing a political topic on a non-political thread. There's a way to get to a political point from most non-political topics, but then every thread leads to a political fight.

I think it's especially important not to criticize a political point that no-one has brought up in the thread already. It's always tempting to address the worst arguments rather than the best ones, and there's more leeway to do that we we're not constrained by replying to something someone's actually said.

michaelkeenan··on Croatia just canceled the debts of its poorest citizens
> Let's just look at the predictable consequences...Banks and other corporations will never lend money to poor people again. Full stop.

I'd like to bet against that prediction. I suggest $100 to the winner's favorite charity at even odds? I predict that one year from now, I'll be able to find an example of a Croatian corporation having loaned money to a Croat with income below 1,250 kuna. My contact details are in my profile.

michaelkeenan··on The Ronco Principle
> pg or my investors wouldn't care about the social issues of the young people working in my sweatshop

I think it's rude to accuse people of hypothetical malfeasance. If there's evidence that someone is callous, show us the evidence. If you think you know of scenarios in which they would be callous, then just tell us what evidence led you to that conclusion instead.

michaelkeenan··on The Mind of a Con Man (2013)
Nothing wrong with that. From the FAQ:

Q: Are reposts ok?

A: If a story has had significant attention in the last year or so, we kill reposts as duplicates. If not, a small number of reposts is ok. - https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html

michaelkeenan··on The Mind of a Con Man (2013)
Reading this:

> Rumors of fraud trailed Stapel from Groningen to Tilburg, but none raised enough suspicion to prompt investigation.

And this:

> The two students decided to report the charges to the department head, Marcel Zeelenberg. But they worried that Zeelenberg, Stapel’s friend, might come to his defense.

I'm reminded of a system to identify cases where there's widespread knowledge or suspicion of malfeasance, but people are reluctant to come forward. The nonprofit Sexual Health Innovations has created a system called Callisto, where you can report sexual abuse, but have the allegation locked until someone else has accused the same perpetrator of sexual abuse too. This is intended to help cases where someone abuses multiple people, but each is afraid that they won't be taken seriously because they're the only one coming forward.

A similar system might help to spot academic fraud. Here's an article about the system: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/10/21/college-sexual-assa...

michaelkeenan··on Reaction to the Sony Hack Is 'Beyond the Realm of Stupid'
> tell me how the Taliban killing ~130 children and some teachers is just a statistical outlier that people whouldn't pay any attention to.

My comment didn't mention people not paying attention to a bombing. My comment was about estimating the risk of dying in a bombing, not about people's reactions to it.

> Yawn...

There are more civil ways to express that.

michaelkeenan··on Reaction to the Sony Hack Is 'Beyond the Realm of Stupid'
I tried to roughly estimate the risk.

There are 18,000 theaters that could be targets. Let's say there are 10 showings over the opening weekend that might be bombed, so if you attend, there's a 1 in 180,000 chance you'll be in the bombed theater (assuming there's only one bombing). Let's say there's a 5% chance it's a real threat (personally I'd estimate around 1%, but let's use 5% to be conservative). That gives a 1 in 3.6 million chance of being in the bombed theater.

Compare to car accidents. There are 1.27 fatalities per 100 million miles traveled in the USA. If the movie theater is five miles away, that gives you a 1 in 7.9 million chance of dying in a car accident on the way to or from the movie.

If we stop calculating there, it looks like you'd be roughly twice as likely to be in the bombed theater than to die in a car accident on the way to the theater. (Note that this is the chance of being in the bombed theater, not of dying in the bombing. Presumably, most people in the theater would survive.) To me, that seems like an acceptably negligible risk.

More detailed calculations could include the chance of dying conditional on being in the bombed theater, and could include the chance of more than one theater being bombed, and adjust for the chance of the bomber being foiled or the bomb not working, and could adjust for which theater you're seeing it in (theaters in major cities are more likely targets than small towns).

michaelkeenan··on How to make the Internet a nicer place to live
I like this a lot.

I'm even more interested in system-level approaches to the problem. The voting systems of reddit and Hacker News and Slashdot are an improvement over the forums that came before, but more is possible. Are there any technologies that don't exist but could?

For example: an ebay-like system for rating someone's civility after you argue with them. (This might work better if ratings from well-rated people were weighted more.)

Or maybe an internet-wide troll-reporting system. There could exist a browser extension (maybe a part of the Reddit Enhancement Suite) that tags or hides comments from people who are frequently downvoted, or frequently rated poorly in the civility system.

Or a narrow AI that predicts your karma based on the words you use. If there are words that are often in downvoted or rated-uncivil comments (perhaps "lol", or "bullshit" especially if it's the first word in the comment, or "+1" especially if it's the entirety of the comment), it could warn you and check you want to continue.

Or if you're arguing in a domain-specific forum, like r/politics or r/economics, you're tagged with your score in a domain-relevant quiz (e.g. this for politically-relevant news: http://www.pewresearch.org/quiz/the-news-iq-quiz/).

Or a multi-variable voting system that asks for upvotes and downvotes for civility, apparent truth-seeking, agreement, and more.

Or much more broadly, what society-level interventions are possible? Lead exposure lowered IQ, and iodine-supplemented salt raised IQ, and IQ seems to cause (or at least be strongly correlated with) non-violence. Have we already made use of all the easy biological interventions like that?

Any other ideas? What systems will the most polite, truth-seeking internet forums of the 2020s use?

michaelkeenan··on Breakthroughs that have unleashed AI development
> Give it five to ten years, human-like and beyond-human intelligence will be built

That's probably a bit early. The Machine Intelligence Research Institute has collected various surveys of experts asked about this question. The one with the earliest estimates asked the question, “Assuming beneficial political and economic development and that no global catastrophe halts progress, by what year would you assign a 10%/50%/90% chance of the development of artificial intelligence that is roughly as good as humans (or better, perhaps unevenly) at science, mathematics, engineering and programming?” Of 19 replies, the median estimates for 10%, 50%, and 90% were 2025, 2035, and 2070, respectively."

Other surveys and research are described here: http://intelligence.org/2013/05/15/when-will-ai-be-created/

michaelkeenan··on Peter Thiel Is Wrong About the Future
What is a good procedure for determining whether someone has good judgment? Is it never making an investment in a person or company that turns out wrong? Then those who never invest at all have the best judgment. But that can't be right.

I think good judgment is shown by those whose investments (of money, time, trust, reputation, or anything) turn out to be better than those in their class. By this measure, Thiel has shown good judgment - his investments of money, time and trust have turned out unusually positively overall. It's been...colorful, at times, but unusually positive overall.

To show someone has poor judgment, one would need to point to a pattern of poor decisions, preferably some hard metric (like investment returns). A single instance of misplaced trust seems inadequate. Does Thiel trusting Elon Musk cancel out his (probably delegated) trust in that Thiel Fellow? I think it does and much more.

michaelkeenan··on Peter Thiel Is Wrong About the Future
There are two essays about awful work that I like to contrast. One is George Orwell writing about 1930s coal miners: http://www.george-orwell.org/Down_The_Mine/0.html

The other is "I Was a Warehouse Wage Slave" by Mac McLelland in Mother Jones magazine, writing about working in a fulfillment center in 2012: http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2012/02/mac-mcclelland-f...

It seems to me that mining was vastly more physically demanding and dangerous, to the extent that when McLelland complains about physical hardship at the fulfillment center I'm unsympathetic; and that fulfillment center work is vastly more dehumanizing, in contrast to the miners who, for all their toil, had pride in what they do.

michaelkeenan··on Americans throw out more food than plastic, paper, metal, and glass
Tentatively - this might not really be much of a problem? In many situations, we deliberately make sure we have excess capacity because it's better to have too much than too little. For example, I have a server running idle most of the time, but it's available to pick up a large long-running task when a user requests it. Analogously, when catering for an event, people often aim to have more than enough food for almost all scenarios, so they'll throw away food almost all the time. Running a restaurant is catering an event every day. When I was a teenager, I worked at Subway and we'd try to have more than enough bread (we only ran out once when we didn't anticipate a large sports-win-based city-wide party), so we'd throw away excess bread at the end of each day.

Of course, people are starving and that's terrible. But reducing food waste in developed countries doesn't seem like a powerful lever to reduce it. Non-wasted food isn't going to be transported to developing nations. Reducing food demand would likely decrease food prices, but I wouldn't expect a large decrease. If my understanding is correct, the food supply is quite elastic, meaning we can easily produce more if there's people willing and able to pay for it.

I think that the two main problems behind starvation are the lack of purchasing power of the poverty-stricken, and broken political systems. Solving those would eliminate starvation, even if the developed nations waste as much food as they like.

(I'm no expert on this and welcome any corrections or opposing views.)

michaelkeenan··on Father and Daughter Reunion
Right. A survey showed that parents usually expect that children want more time with them instead of work, but that that's not usually what children want:

"One of Galinsky's more surprising findings centered around a question she posed to both children and parents: "If you were granted one wish to change the way your mother's/your father's work affects your life, what would that wish be?" Some 56 percent of parents anticipated that their children would want more time with their parents and for their parents to spend less time at work, yet only 10 percent of the children actually wanted more time with their mothers and only 16 percent wanted more time with their fathers. A far larger proportion, 34 percent, wished that their mothers would be less stressed and less tired, and 28 percent wished this about their fathers." - http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2008/05/listen_to_the_c....

michaelkeenan··on Hal Finney being cryopreserved now
If there were no government or Friendly AGI doing it for everyone, I imagine it would chain backward through time: those still alive who are friends and family of the cryo-preserved would resurrect them. Then, those people would know older cryo-preserved people, and would resurrect them. (Unless, I suppose, the cost were exorbitant and the cryo-resurrected didn't have the means. But this is a future, post-death, probably post-singularity world; it'd probably be a society of abundance.)
michaelkeenan··on The Highest-Paid CEOs Are The Worst Performers, New Study Says
Future expectations about stocks affect their price today. If a company is known to be in trouble, its shares will already be cheap. (A few people, most notably Warren Buffett, can reasonably disagree with this, because they're already very rich from beating the market. Everyone else should just assume that Warren Buffett has already traded the share down to its appropriate price.)

I suspect that the overconfidence explanation given in the article is closer to the right explanation. I was suspicious at first, but then the article gave figures about mergers. It's widely known that mergers usually don't meet expectations, so maybe overconfidence would lead a CEO to think they could escape this statistical fate.

michaelkeenan··on To Protect Legitimate Interests, Seattle Should Cap All Forms of Innovation
> there's no law of the universe that says that "disruption" is a good thing, and there certainly isn't any clean way to weigh the interests of one big established industry with those of a large, successful, wealthy competitor industry.

There's something fairly close to a law which says that disruption is a good thing. Industries can only be disrupted by entrants that provide products that consumers prefer, so we have almost-a-law: disruption is a preferable-to-consumers thing. There a few cases where that's not socially desirable (I suppose crack replacing cocaine would be an example) but those are exceptional enough that I think we ought to regard disruption as presumed good unless shown otherwise.

Similarly, a decent heuristic for choosing whose interests to consider out of an established industry and a competitor is to let consumers choose which one is better. Of course this can be difficult for those in the established industry, but we're in a society-wide Prisoner's Dilemma over this, and a useful function of government would be making sure we all cooperate. Letting consumers choose the best companies is cooperation; protecting your own industry is defection. I'd be better off if my job and income were guaranteed, but I'd be worse off if everyone else got the same deal.

michaelkeenan··on Is it wise to criminalise lies?
> POLITICIANS never lie. So you should not be allowed to lie about them. That seems to be the logic behind an Ohio election law

Is that really the logic? This could have benefitted from quoting a supporter of the law on why they like it. That would have been more...honest.

michaelkeenan··on Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen
> most hilarious thing...Bwahahahaa!...massive hypocrisy and lack of self-awareness. Amazing.

This insulting style of persuasion has been shown to backfire. Here's a study on this effect - Negative Persuasion Via Personal Insult: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/00221031679...

An individual directly insulted by a communicator attempting to persuade him will show a “boomerang effect” by increasing the extremity of his initial attitude position

You might be correct, but you're increasing the libertarianism in the world, not decreasing it.

People ought to step back from their beliefs about whether they right, and instead argue in such a way that, whether they are right or not, they advance the state of knowledge. Insults and ridicule don't do this! Insults can change people's beliefs, but usually in the opposite way we intend, and only by inflaming emotion, not based on any evidence about the world, so they're a tool wielded with equal efficacy by both the correct and the mistaken.

Creationists, racists, and all the others we know to be wrong can all belittle and insult their opponents too. Only by sticking to the best kinds of disagreement (http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html) can we make progress, because people whose beliefs are wrong can only make flawed arguments. Those who are correct already hold the advantageous ground, so fight there, not in the quagmire of flamewars!

More generally, people aren't usually especially at fault for being wrong, so they don't deserve insults. I must be wrong about some percentage of my beliefs, as must you. Any libertarian is likely to be right about something that you and I are wrong about.

This HN article didn't need to be a flamewar about libertarianism. Even if you're right, you're opponents will likely respond with a similar tone, and you don't need libertarians belittling you about your views on economics or whatever. It won't change your mind, just as your insults don't change theirs.

If a libertarian is to doubt his libertarian ways, it'll be through the same way we might ever be persuaded about something. First, probably, we'll learn that someone we like and respect holds the view, and we'll realize it's a position that reasonable people can hold, not just idiots or bigots or sociopaths. Then we'll learn there's nuances that we'd not encountered before - maybe we'd only heard strawman versions of its arguments before. Then we'll shift slightly such that it seems like it applies in some limited situations. And so on, and maybe we'll hold a new belief after that.

michaelkeenan··on Confessions of an ex-TSA agent
The USA spends about $6.93 per passenger on security. Israel spends about $56.75 per passenger on security.

Source: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/11...

michaelkeenan··on Economics Simulation
> Of all the third-world countries that have developed, they have almost uniformly made heavy use of protectionism, foreign-ownership limitations, etc.

Do you have a citation for that? I suspect it might just be trivially true because all countries, especially developing countries, make heavy use of protectionism for some definitions of "heavy". It would be useful to show a relationship between level of protectionism and economic growth. My impression is that most economists think that protectionism harms economic growth.

I pre-commit to changing my mind if there's a correlation between greater protectionism and greater economic growth.

As mentioned in the latest Gates letter, huge progress has been made on reducing global poverty recently, and it continues to be made. He says it's likely that there will be almost no poor countries by 2035.

michaelkeenan··on Join Wall Street. Save the world
If you're interested in effective altruism, you might be interested in the Effective Altruism Summit, which will be held from June 30 to July 6 in San Francisco. All four of the effective altruism organizations mentioned in the article (GiveWell, Giving What We Can, The Life You Can Save, and 80,000 Hours) are participating, along with some not mentioned. Peter Singer, Peter Thiel, and Jaan Tallinn (co-creator of Kazaa and Skype) will give talks.

http://www.effectivealtruismsummit.com/

michaelkeenan··on Come here and work on hard problems – except the ones on our doorstep
> Most of the homeless in SF actually want to be on the streets.

To those surprised by this sentence, jarjoura might be influenced by this recent Priceonomics blog post: http://blog.priceonomics.com/post/43085729257/the-street-kid...

"Most street kids we spoke to came from one of two backgrounds: either they had job prospects (whether good or dead-end) but preferred the freedom of homelessness, or were transient homeless who fell in love with the street kid community...Street kids defied our expectations of living on the street as a last resort; instead they seem to be drawn to the Haight."

michaelkeenan··on The End of Power
> a small fraction of one percent controls well over 2/3 of the world's assets

Citation for that? Wikipedia says that the richest 1% of adults owned 40% of global assets[1], though that figure is from 2000.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Distribution_of_wealth#21st_cen...

michaelkeenan··on Why do we eat grains? Thermodynamics
> 10,000 years isn't enough time for humans to adapt to eating grains, so we should eat like cave men instead

One of the details of that argument is that grains contain phytic acid[1], which humans can't digest. Phytic acid binds with important minerals, such as calcium, magnesium, iron, and zinc, making them unavailable when digested. Cows, sheep, goats, and other non-humans produce various phytases, enzymes that digest phytic acid, but humans don't. Some people (such as Marlene Zuk, author of Paleofantasy, recently linked on HN) say that 10,000 years is enough to adapt to a new food, and cite lactose tolerance as an example. But lactose tolerance is the result of a single SNP, which can occur in at least two places. To digest phytic acid, humans would need to evolve a whole new enzyme. You need more than 10,000 years for that.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phytic_acid

michaelkeenan··on “Paleofantasy”: Stone Age delusions
The Wikipedia article on the Neolithic Revolution[1] says:

"nutritional standards of Neolithic populations were generally inferior to that of hunter-gatherers, and life expectancy may in fact have been shorter, in part due to diseases. Average height, for example, went down from 5' 10" (178 cm) for men and 5' 6" (168 cm) for women to 5' 3" (165 cm) and 5' 1" (155 cm), respectively, and it took until the twentieth century for average human height to come back to the pre-Neolithic Revolution levels."

The citation is to a Michael Shermer book.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neolithic_Revolution#Consequenc...

michaelkeenan··on Nootropics – The Facts About “Smart Drugs”
> I have never seen any evidence of regular users of smart drugs doing anything smart.

Paul Erdős famously claimed that amphetamines helped him in mathematics:

> After 1971 he also took amphetamines, despite the concern of his friends, one of whom (Ron Graham) bet him $500 that he could not stop taking the drug for a month.[34] Erdős won the bet, but complained that during his abstinence mathematics had been set back by a month: "Before, when I looked at a piece of blank paper my mind was filled with ideas. Now all I see is a blank piece of paper." After he won the bet, he promptly resumed his amphetamine use. - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Erd%C5%91s

michaelkeenan··on Sealand, HavenCo, and the Rule of Law
> an employer from whom I could have no possible legal recourse in the event of a dispute.

That part is easily solved: the dictator can put up a bond in some trusted country. The bond is forfeited if the dictator betrays you. The contract laws of the trusted country apply.

It could be that some enterprising dictator could gain a better reputation for respect of property than the US government[1]. A reputation for respecting property rights, combined with a country, is an extremely lucrative asset, and it would be costly to lose it.

> As a business owner, I then have the choice of doing my business in a major Western democracy with an elected government

If moonchrome can offer a better regulatory environment, you might prefer to do business with him. Maybe your business is melanoma detection. HN user danifong approached YCombinator with that idea, and Graham told her[2]: “The trouble with the melanoma detection idea is that you’d spend most of your time dealing with legal and regulatory crap. That sort of work doesn’t really take advantage of your skills.”

[1] The USA has questionable regard for property rights, e.g. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kelo_v._City_of_New_London

[2] http://daniellefong.com/2010/02/11/how-law-shapes-the-busine...

← PreviousPage 4 of 9Next →