HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

michaelkeenan

1,213 karma · joined June 9, 2008

michael.keenan@gmail.com

michaelkeenan.net

michaelkeenan.blogspot.com

submissionscomments
michaelkeenan··on Car Autonomously Powerslides Into Parking Space
Yes, I think that will slow the adoption of robocars significantly, especially in the USA. See Templeton's section on liability in the essay on problems with robocars: http://www.templetons.com/brad/robocars/roadblocks.html

"[Robocars may first be adopted in] other countries, such as China, Singapore, India or Japan. These high-tech countries have very different liability systems, and indeed very different forms of lawmaking that can simply wipe away the liability problem with the wave of a pen."

michaelkeenan··on Car Autonomously Powerslides Into Parking Space
If you'd like to learn more about how autonomous cars will change the world, I strongly recommend the robocar essays of Brad Templeton: http://www.templetons.com/brad/robocars/

Highlights:

-Cars that don't crash due to human error would save 40,000 lives and a million injuries (NIH). Mostly young people, for whom car accidents are the leading cause of death among major categories.

-Not crashing would save 230 billion dollars of accident cost (NTSB). About 2-3% of GDP.

-Not driving would free up 50 billion hours (or 1 trillion dollars) of people's time. Around 8% of GDP.

-Electric cars (more feasible when the car can go to a service station when it's not being used, because one of the major problems with electric cars is that storing lots of energy in a battery is difficult) would save 50 billion gallons of imported gasoline, replaced with the equivalent of 5 billion "gallons" of domestic-source power plant fuel. Thus eliminating about 12-15% of the USA's CO2 emissions and nastier pollution.

-There would be a serious reduction in the urban land devoted to the ~600 million parking spaces, estimated to be up to 10% of urban land in many cities.

michaelkeenan··on Request HN: Please all update contact info in your profile
Please also add your location if you're comfortable sharing that.
michaelkeenan··on The Japanese Soldier Who Fought WWII for 30 Years
Thanks for your very civil, truth-seeking reply! I don't usually notice or remember usernames on HN but I've noticed that in your comments before.

I don't know much more about Operation Downfall that you won't have already come across, but there is one detail you'll be interested in - from the Wikipedia article on Purple Hearts:

"During World War II, nearly 500,000 Purple Heart medals were manufactured in anticipation of the estimated casualties resulting from the planned Allied invasion of Japan...In 2003, there were still 120,000 of these Purple Heart medals in stock." - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Purple_Heart

michaelkeenan··on The Japanese Soldier Who Fought WWII for 30 Years
> The United States never wanted to land invade Japan - the second option to bombings was a blockade to starve the army out.

I don't think that's correct. I've read that the alternative to the bombs was a huge invasion called Operation Downfall. According to Wikipedia: "The U.S. Navy urged the use of blockade and airpower to bring about Japan's capitulation...The U.S. Army, on the other hand, argued that such a strategy could "prolong the war indefinitely" and expend lives needlessly, and...supported mounting a large-scale thrust directly against the Japanese homeland...Ultimately, the Army's viewpoint won."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Downfall#Consideratio...

michaelkeenan··on Finland makes broadband a 'legal right'
> the US has perhaps both the least-regulated

It is difficult to argue about this because there's no good unit of measurement for regulations.

But I would look at practitioner licensing, drug availability, tort law, and insurance requirements. My impression is that the USA is highly regulated (and more importantly, poorly regulated) in those areas.

michaelkeenan··on When Capitalism Meets Cannabis
> What the people retailing pot will find is that an easily-growable agricultural commodity is subject to perfect competition and prices will be driven down to a very low level.

That might depend on the regulatory constraints. From the article: "A batch of regulations known as Amendment 1284, signed by the governor on June 7, is expected to put many dispensaries out of business, eliminating the amateurs and semipros who jumped in because there was nothing to stop them, but greatly strengthening those who have the wherewithal to remain standing."

As in other industries, onerous regulations might help large companies by raising barriers to entry and hindering startups that can't afford to jump through the hoops.

michaelkeenan··on Computer program writing great, original works of classical music
And also great for low-budget computer games.
michaelkeenan··on Facebook is Dying
Thanks fnid2 for taking the bet! To clarify the terms of the bet though, I only want to bet on traffic rankings in the USA. It wouldn't surprise me if some Chinese website/s outcompete Facebook in world traffic rankings by then, but that's not really fair because the Chinese government bans Facebook. Is that acceptable to you?

Can you contact me (email address in my HN profile) so I have your email address?

If I win, I'll choose whatever GiveWell ranks as the most cost-effective charity at saving lives in 2015 (http://www.givewell.net/charities/top-charities).

If Alexa closes in the next five years, I suggest that the default action is to cancel the bet, unless we both agree on a new metric.

I'm going to use the email reminder service 3mindme.com to remind me about this bet in 2015, and also add it to my "todo" file in case 3mindme.com doesn't exist in five years.

I'm open to making additional bets with others too, so if you're reading this and want to bet, it's not too late.

michaelkeenan··on Facebook is Dying
I'd like to bet against the notion that Facebook is dying. I suggest this metric: on May 7, 2015, Facebook will still be one of the top five websites in the USA, measured by Alexa traffic ranking (http://www.alexa.com/siteinfo/Facebook.com), and it will still be the most popular social networking website in the USA, again measured by Alexa traffic rankings.

USD$200, winnings go to the winner's favorite charity? Feel free to suggest different terms, metrics, betting amounts, or to make it a personal bet, not a charitable bet.

michaelkeenan··on Reasons You Should Quit Facebook
I'd like to bet against that opinion. I suggest this metric: on May 3, 2015, Facebook will still be listed in the top five websites in the world by Alexa traffic ranking (http://www.alexa.com/siteinfo/Facebook.com), and it will be the most popular social networking website in the world, again as measured by Alexa traffic rankings.

USD$200, proceeds go to winner's favorite charity? This bet is open to ams6110 or anyone else. Feel free to suggest different terms, metrics, betting amounts, or to make it a personal bet, not a charitable bet.

michaelkeenan··on Books all kids should read at school (a list)
You might be interested in the "unschooling" ideas of David Friedman (son of Milton Friedman):

http://daviddfriedman.blogspot.com/2006/02/case-for-unschool...

http://daviddfriedman.blogspot.com/2006/02/unschooling-advan...

http://daviddfriedman.blogspot.com/2007/12/home-unschooling-...

http://daviddfriedman.blogspot.com/2007/12/home-unschooling-...

michaelkeenan··on Books all kids should read at school (a list)
If we want children to understand nutrition, exercise, sleep, social skills, or any other subject, then we should figure out how best to teach those subjects. It might be books or it might be normal classes. I strongly suspect there are many children, especially those with autodidactic tendencies, who could learn most subjects better and faster from books than from lectures. But that probably isn't all children.

I propose offering students a choice - would you like a class on nutrition, or would you like to read the/a book on nutrition, and have an expert available for questions (preferably online)? Students who choose unstructured learning but then fail to achieve can be placed into classes.

This way, industrious or gifted students won't be held back by the pace of other students, or by the speed at which the teacher speaks. And this might encourage autodidacticism, which I think is incredibly valuable and efficient.

michaelkeenan··on On the Shortness of Life - Seneca (50 AD)
I think that last one was Shakespeare:

"Cowards die many times before their deaths. The valiant never taste of death but once." - William Shakespeare, Julius Caesar, Act II, sc. ii (1599)

michaelkeenan··on Lessons from eastern Europe's flat tax
I downvoted for two reasons: first, because of the "everyone knows" comparison of "uncultured, mouth-breathing trashbag-fuckers" vs. "brilliant, cultured, educated people" which is the opposite of my experience.

Second, for the tone: "uncultured, mouth-breathing trashbag-fuckers" are the words of a status-seeker, not a truth-seeker. Hacker News is above this.

michaelkeenan··on Apple Sues Nexus One Maker HTC
Paul Graham wrote an essay on software patents in 2006. I found it helpful to get an overview of the wider issue:

http://www.paulgraham.com/softwarepatents.html

I wonder whether this part is relevant:

"When you read of big companies filing patent suits against smaller ones, it's usually a big company on the way down, grasping at straws. For example, Unisys's attempts to enforce their patent on LZW compression. When you see a big company threatening patent suits, sell. When a company starts fighting over IP, it's a sign they've lost the real battle, for users."

michaelkeenan··on My New Philosophy Website
I suggest adding a <title> tag. Currently my browser is just displaying the URL as the title in its tab.
michaelkeenan··on The fallacy of fairness
"As you know, fairness is a concept that was invented so that children and idiots could participate in arguments." - Scott Adams (http://www.dilbert.com/blog/entry/fairtaxes/)
michaelkeenan··on How I Landed A $50/hr Side Gig With Little Effort
Be polite! Polyamory is common enough among geeks and SF area types that there must be a few HN-reading polyamorists. It's brave of Pavlina to write about tabooed topics[1]. And it can't be any more fun for polyamorists to encounter incredulity and derision than it was for the first open homosexuals or interracial couples.

[1] cf. http://www.paulgraham.com/say.html

michaelkeenan··on Why Economists are often Cheapskates
We often measure charity in dollars donated. Occasionally we measure charity by percentage of wealth donated[1].

What would happen if we measured charity in terms of lives saved? As PG has mentioned, things which you measure tend to improve[2]. I would rather improve charity outcomes than inputs.

Economists sometimes claim that most charities are very inefficient[3]. Maybe economists give to more efficient charities, so their dismal charity record might look better when measured in lives saved rather than dollars donated. (If this seems like a weak apology for the lack of charity of economists, I agree. It is sad that a disproportionately high fraction of economists give nothing at all to charity.)

[1] e.g. http://www.mint.com/blog/trends/charity-who-cares/

[2] Point 7 of Startups in 13 Sentences: http://www.paulgraham.com/13sentences.html

[3] http://blog.givewell.net/?p=480 and http://www.overcomingbias.com/2009/09/lost-charity.html

michaelkeenan··on Y Combinator Startup Library
The link to "Journey to the Center of Google" is broken. It should be: http://www.gq.com/news-politics/newsmakers/200502/google-lar...
michaelkeenan··on --All You Zombies--
That could have used a spoiler warning vinutheraj.
michaelkeenan··on Reuters: Google phone with T-Mobile contract in Jan
I will bet 2:1 odds that Google will not sell the phone for $99 to people with old Google accounts. I'll put up USD$100 (against your $33), payment to be made by donation to the winner's favorite charity, proof by forwarding the email receipt. Reply to this comment or see my contact details on my user page to take up the offer and work out the details.

Edit: changed from 2:1 odds to 3:1 odds (edit 2: the original edit changed the other side's amount from $50 to $33, though as jfoutz pointed out I'm not thinking of ratios correctly, so I've changed the ratio back to 2:1 and left the $33 as $33).

Edit 3: thanks kw_ for taking the bet! For the record, the main reason I think I'll win is because the iPhone reportedly costs $179 to make[1], I'm assuming the cost of the Google Phone will be similar, and I don't see it making sense for Google to sell it at a loss. I choose the charity Village Outreach, because it is the top-rated charity at the charity-effectiveness-judging organization GiveWell[2].

[1]http://9to5mac.com/gigom-who-rich-iPhone-34040

[2]http://www.givewell.net/charities/top-charities

michaelkeenan··on Why James Chartrand Wears Women’s Underpants
> Do people choose realtors based on their photo?

Yes, but not consciously.

> Perhaps it's just some custom that's been passed down

I'm sure they have tested ads without photos, or with photos of something other than people, and found that photos of attractive smiling real estate agents work best.

If it surprises you that this works, I recommend reading Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion by Robert Cialdini. He is a psychologist who has spent years not just studying persuasion in laboratory settings, but "going undercover", taking courses and even doing jobs in all kinds of persuasion professions - door-to-door salespeople, fund-raisers, recruiters, advertisers, etc. He noted hundreds of techniques that he was taught, or that he learned or observed, and categorized them into six principles of persuasion, each forming a chapter of the book.

The book is useful to entrepreneurs who need to market their startups, and useful to humans, who need to understand the techniques that are being used by sales people and marketers of all kinds. I recommend it to everyone. (In case you're worried, Cialdini doesn't recommend unethical techniques, though he does describe some so that you know what to watch out for.)

michaelkeenan··on No One Peer-Reviews Scientific Software
timr:

Second, this type of critique is pushing hard on a straw man. The implicit assumption is that each paper is a stand-alone morsel of truth, and that the peer-review process somehow guarantees a paper's claims. This is not the case, and no scientist believes it to be true...The "skeptics" have it wrong, not because they're incorrect about human nature, but because they're attacking a fictional vision of science that exists only in their minds.

The article:

The concept of “peer review” is increasingly being treated in the popular discourse as synonymous with “the findings were reproduced and proven beyond a shadow of a doubt.”

This is never what peer review was intended to accomplish. Peer review functions largely to catch trivial mistakes and to filter out the loons. It does not confirm or refute a paper’s findings. Indeed, many scientific frauds have passed easily through peer review because the scammers knew what information the reviewers needed to see.

michaelkeenan··on Federal officers use video game console to catch child pornographers
Pedophiles don't tend to be the sharpest tools in the shed

It feels good to say mean things about our enemies, but I find it implausible that someone's credibly found a link between pedophilia and low intelligence. (Presumably people don't admit to being pedophiles, so you can't find a random sample of them to study. You can study pedophiles who get caught, but presumably those are the least intelligent pedophiles, so you can't draw conclusions about pedophile intelligence from them. I think it's safer to assume pedophiles have a normal distribution of intelligence.)

michaelkeenan··on Buffett: Wealth, Estate Taxes, and the Ovarian Lottery
It is unfair that your country of birth is arbitrary. Surely the appropriate policy to ameliorate that is to relax immigration barriers? That seems more relevant to the problem than estate taxes.
michaelkeenan··on Tell HN: Can we stop commenting on troll comments?
Erecting walls is never the answer. Any community, from a website to an entire country, suffers if it decides to close itself off from the world. There are too many examples to list.

Though you are correct that many communities suffer when they restrict membership, that isn't an infallible rule.

Communities that have benefited from restricting membership include the Freemasons, Mensa, and the online community TheRoot42. Those are just a few we know about! Many closed communities are also at least somewhat secret. Barriers to community entry are sometimes beneficial (not that I'm advocating it for HN).

Entry difficulty is a significant contributor to group cohesiveness (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Group_cohesiveness).

michaelkeenan··on Ask HN: What industry needs technical innovation?
Government. It has a high barrier to entry (win an election/revolution) and a high consumer switching cost (move far away, get a new job, learn a new language). If the governing industry were more competitive, I think its quality of service would be better.

The Peter Thiel-funded Seasteading Institute is trying to decrease the start-up cost and the consumer switching cost. Paul Romer has another approach with the Charter City proposal he's advocating.

michaelkeenan··on This shouldn’t be the image of Hack Day
I moved to Taiwan last year, and I can confirm that dancing girls are very common in all kinds of irrelevant contexts, particularly expos. It's weird to me, but I haven't heard any women here complaining about it.
← PreviousPage 6 of 9Next →