HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

michaericalribo

1,124 karma · joined May 3, 2017

submissionscomments
michaericalribo··on Julia: A Post-Mortem
Definitely not paradoxical. Network effects of out-of-the-box tooling/features—I mean a robust, extensive set of libraries to accomplish basic and moderately complex statistical / ML tasks—is the table stakes here, and depends strongly on whether more than a “few people do” already.
michaericalribo··on Julia: A Post-Mortem
I already solve real problems in Python—why bother learning yet another language, and one our data engineers/backend folks don’t know? That larger context of implementation / development / deployment is a huge deciding factor for real-world problem solving, not how “great” a language is from a design perspective.
michaericalribo··on Julia: A Post-Mortem
That may be true for elaborate analyses, but doesn’t really address exploratory analysis that changes dramatically from command to command. The use case for REPL-driven data science is experimentation, not performance
michaericalribo··on Julia: A Post-Mortem
Your last sentence seems to ignore the reality that plotting is only one step in a larger pipeline. It sounds miserable to need to write analytics code twice, once in Julia “for everything else” and again in Python just for the plotting. I’ll just write the whole thing in Python and save myself the headache.
michaericalribo··on Show HN: I wrote a book about using data science to solve “everyday” problems
Nice! Real-world problems like these are what spurred my interest in statistics/data science, and I agree with your sentiment that intro stats books are a terrible way to cultivate enthusiasm and curiosity about ways to solve problems using data.

In my experience, the most difficult parts of the process are (1) translating from qualitative problems “in the field” to a formalized technical problem, and (2) all the wrangling necessary to implement the formal problem using field-collected data.

I find that I spend most of my time as a data scientist working on these parts of the process, and often don’t have the bandwidth or even requirement for more advanced methods. Not that fancy techniques are the goal, per se, but I do notice I rarely have the opportunity to use them.

michaericalribo··on In the ’80s, she was a video game pioneer. Today, no one can find her
I can't claim to be authoritative on cultural practices in China, so I hedged my language so I wasn't overreaching :) And there's usually some exception to every rule...

That's really interesting! Can you explain it a little more? I can't read Chinese, so it's a bit opaque what's going on...

michaericalribo··on In the ’80s, she was a video game pioneer. Today, no one can find her
I'll admit that I consider myself "generally left-wing...and social liberally", and it was a real cognitive disconnect when my wife didn't want to take my name...It's such an ingrained tradition, so it required serious self-reflection to get to the bottom of my own reaction.
michaericalribo··on In the ’80s, she was a video game pioneer. Today, no one can find her
Wow! I'd argue it's offensive—or at least quite rude—to willfully ignore someone's name. What gives someone else the right to determine what's best for me? How patronizing!
michaericalribo··on In the ’80s, she was a video game pioneer. Today, no one can find her
Likewise, women in China typically / often do not take their husband's name.
michaericalribo··on In the ’80s, she was a video game pioneer. Today, no one can find her
Frankly, why would I care if it confuses someone else? My spouse and I don't make important decisions vis-a-vis our relationship, on the basis of other people's convenience.

The "problems" you describe are just...nonexistent, and really not a big deal. I have literally never encountered confusion about our marital status, problems with forms, or difficulty being introduced.

michaericalribo··on 'Any evidence for Planet Nine is gone'
When I was a boy, we had nine planets! Kids these days don’t know what they’re missing, schoolyard speculation about Planet X was the good life...
michaericalribo··on TurboTax Tricked You into Paying to File Your Taxes (2019)
Also (for me): it's easier that doing it by hand, and that's something I'm willing to pay money for.
michaericalribo··on Show HN: Hush Docs – private Google Docs alternative that works without internet
I don’t mean to be overly glib, and I get that this is intended as a collaborative-first tool, but:

Why not just use an offline-first format like docx (collaborative: comments and track changes), synced with Dropbox or similar (sync across devices)?

michaericalribo··on You don't really need a virtualenv
That’s not every minor bump, though, and is worth the extra effort!

Also, my use case is 100% non critical from a security standpoint, so I can afford to be careless... your point definitely stands in sensitive environments

michaericalribo··on You don't really need a virtualenv
> One day a minor release of Python is out

It is decidedly not true that I want to update my venv for every minor version bump!

I deploy to a cloud service w/ a specific version; my package manager is slow to update; I develop collaboratively using a shared container w/ a fixed version.

Updating shared resources with every new release is not always realistic, and that makes it so that I do need (or at least want) to use a virtualenv.

michaericalribo··on NumPy 1.20
Yeah! That’s what I mean...under the hood data frames use numpy arrays, but the abstractions of pandas are much easier to work with.
michaericalribo··on NumPy 1.20
Sidebar: I originally used the word “gunmetal” and that...was even less correct.

Get this guy a dictionary!

michaericalribo··on NumPy 1.20
Heh, I’m probably misusing that term—forgive me, I’m just a script kiddy! :D

I meant that it can serve the role of low-level, nitty gritty machinery, entirely separate from its use case as a module unto its own right.

Eg, pandas (in some sense) is just a convenience layer on top of numpy—but to me that’s like saying any piece of software is “just a convenience layer on top of python.” It’s partly a means to an end! Not just an end unto itself.

Numpy enables a whole new class of functionality, independent of its direct use as part of my software. Is there a better word for that?

michaericalribo··on Diamonds aren’t special and neither is love
> I have told myself my marriage is different

Being in love does feel earth-shatteringly special, unimaginably unique, irreplaceable; but the author is right that that’s how everyone in love feels.

I don’t think that cheapens love, or means that my love for my spouse is “less” because others feel symmetrically the same, or even because I could have felt it with someone else, too.

I think that is what it is to be in love: an overwhelming all-consuming feeling of everything being one-of-a-kind and precious and Right. Thank God it’s not impossibly rare, or only possible under the most specific circumstances!

(This is not to say that love is easy or feels like that all the time—it takes a lot of work, but that work feels worth it and important because of how it feels during the moments when it does come effortlessly.)

michaericalribo··on NumPy 1.20
NumPy is incredible to me: it serves not only as a critical bare-metal layer, but also an essential tool in its own right, and I can’t imagine using Python without it. I do numerical work—ML/data science/statistics—and I simply couldn’t accomplish any of what I do without the functionality provided by NumPy. np.array alone is worth all the king’s gold.

It is interesting to me that in many respects it serves as “guts”. I definitely drop down to use numpy directly with regularity. But it’s also possible to do 80-90% of the job without ever explicitly using the module itself. It’s baked in everywhere, to the point that it feels like just another standard library.

Exciting to see progress! Keep up the good work, numpy team :)

michaericalribo··on Oldest Libraries in the World
DNA?
michaericalribo··on Oldest Libraries in the World
That is one interesting innovation, but not the only interesting innovation: centralized repos of knowledge, scribes used to copy and thus distribute handwritten books, a dedicated focus to literacy(even by just a few privileged individuals)...those are all fascinating.
michaericalribo··on Persistent Anti-Muslim Bias in Large Language Models
This is a great illustration of the tensions between theory and practice in ML / AI:

To some degree, this may be "just" aa matter of a poor training set: too few / unbalanced examples. Can't we just use a better dataset?

But this also reflects a more systemic problem with descriptive / learned behavior, rather than ontological representations: we will always have these dataset problems, to be fixed after the fact when someone points out the flaw. See also facial recognition of non-white faces.

We want intelligent systems that can learn from the world, but that's not an accurate mental model of how humans learn. Often, we learn our values and develop opinions in spite of empirical representations—I don't read the newspaper to find out what Muslim people are like, I start from my values / convictions (all men are created equal, every person deserves respect and the benefit of the doubt prima facie) and maybe update on the basis of observations of media depictions.

Yes, a computer may be able to imitate human speech after reading a lot of text...but that doesn't mean it understands the content of that text.

michaericalribo··on Show HN: Smug – A fast, dependency-free session manager for tmux
It says it's inspired by tmuxinator and tmuxp...as someone who uses tmux often but none of the above, what are the differences in the tools? What makes any one of these a better choice than the others?
michaericalribo··on Apple: Keep iPhone 12 at least six inches from pacemakers
> Apple shared the information through its support page on Saturday.

Does that mean that if you have both a pacemaker and an iPhone 12, you would still only know about this if you sought out the support page?

That's very reactive, and not so helpful—I would be more likely to go to a hospital if my medical device failed, than to a consumer electronics support page...

michaericalribo··on The Hundred-Page Machine Learning Book
You're right, but not in a good way...that part says it's good for

> a software engineer or a scientist who wants to become a machine learning engineer or a data scientist

and earlier in the page it says

> you will be ready to build complex AI systems, pass an interview or start your own business

I think that's misleading, and just not true.

:(

michaericalribo··on The Hundred-Page Machine Learning Book
> All you need to know about Machine Learning

Eek. This type of extreme claim makes me even more skeptical than I already was of such a short overview. Each of the topics listed could easily fill 100 pages themselves...

All who needs to know? Hopefully not anyone actually using this in their job. Maybe it would be a useful reference for the definition of the term, but it's completely wild to suggest you'll have any understanding of SVM, NN, CV, or gradient descent after only 100 pages, much less all of them...

michaericalribo··on Chemotherapy with light; only one injection required
This is not injecting the light itself...! :)

But also a really fascinating technology! I wasn’t aware of photosensitizing, what a novel way of inside and outside used in conjunction

michaericalribo··on Ask HN: How many % of Machine Learning projects “fail”?
This doesn't directly answer your question, but, there's an important distinction to draw between two use-cases for "ML":

1. ML is used to improve UX / ops 2. Other people's jobs depend on the quality of the ML output

1 can encompass things like offering recommendations or optimizing click-through. 2 is things like analytics-as-a-product in smart manufacturing.

I assume 1 is a lot easier to "succeed" at: if I receive a bad music recommendation, I just move onto the next one.

2 is harder to do well, and the output quickly loses credibility when it's bad.

That said, bad ML in high-stakes contexts (by which I mean, someone else is using the ML to do their job better) should get weeded out pretty quickly...so for the total effort and care taken to address 2, they may be more successful on average.

michaericalribo··on A Computational Model for Intelligent Manufacturing
I work in this space, and it’s always interesting to see how others are solving similar problems—and exciting! Classical methods (under the auspices of “SPC”, alluded to in this post) are very outdated, but also, very ingrained in manufacturing circles.

I’m disappointed to see this only applied to a “toy” example...the real value is proven (or not, as is often the case) when the “rubber meets the road” and is applied to real problems on the factory floor. A POC like this is a nice demo, a fun exercise, but a long way from “productionized and used by real manufacturers.” The lack of a real example suggest to me this hasn’t actually been used in the field...

I’m also curious how one would communicate a very technical/abstract model like this to existing practitioners of eg Six Sigma. My experience has been there is a lot of friction in introducing new methods in such an old-school setting: not only do old habits die hard, but quality engineers are often hired explicitly to do particular six sigma analyses. The difficulty is in convincing a client that these methods (a) can be useful and reliable in the context of traditional methods, and (b) aren’t intended to replace their role. I’ve seen the most traction w methods that connect directly to established SPC procedures, while also pushing the limits of these known and _interpretable_ techniques.

← PreviousPage 5 of 10Next →