HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

milesvp

3,132 karma · joined July 2, 2010

submissionscomments
milesvp··on Docker limits unauthenticated pulls to 10/HR/IP from Docker Hub, from March 1
The last time I had to care professionally about bandwidth pricing for CDN price optimization in the US, wholesale bandwidth pricing was following a pattern similar to Moore’s law, with either bandwidth doubling, or price halving every 18-21 months. This was partly why you could get what looked like good deals from CDN providers for multi year contracts. They knew their prices were just going to fall. Part of what drives this is that we keep finding ways to utilize fiber, so there’s a technical aspect, but a lot of it also comes down to adding more physical connections. There’s even network consolidation happening where 2 companies will do enough data sharing that they will get peering agreements and just add a cat6 patch between servers hosted in the same datacenter and short circuit the network.

It’s been almost a decade so it’s possible things have slowed considerably, or demand has outstripped supply, but given how much data steam seems to be willing to throw at me, I know pricing is likely no where near what it was last I looked (it’s the only metered thing I regularly see and it’s downloading 10’s of GB daily for a couple games in my collection).

Using egress pricing is also the wrong metric. You’d be better off looking at data costs between regions/datacenters to get a better idea about wholesale costs, since high egress costs is likely a form of vender lockin, while higher looking at cross region avoids any “free” data costs through patch cables skewing the numbers.

Not sure about bandwidth between countries, there’s different economics there. I’d expect some self similarity there, but laying trunks might be so costly that short of finding ways to utilize fiber better is the only real way to increase supply.

milesvp··on Ask HN: Can I really create a company around my open-source software?
Youtube has been feeding me a lot of business advice lately. If you are truly interested in pivoting from tech to sales. Right now the best advice is coming from Alex Hormozi (ignore some of his hard work ethos, it’s not nuanced enough until you’ve watched enough of his content). The amount of content he is giving away is criminal, he’s using it as marketing, but he is almost never selling anything, so it doesn’t feel slimey the way most of this content space feels. Chris Do used to have excellent content for getting paid as a creator, his recent stuff isn’t very good though.

I will tell you, if your solution solves a problem that is only painful enough that people might pay $25 a month, you are likely going to have a really hard time with this business. Sales is disproportionately harder the smaller the dollar amount. Also, if you are not willing to give up the first 4 productive hours of your day to sales and marketing you will probably fail.

Ultimately I think the open source doesn’t matter much. You have a solution to a problem. You need to market that solution to people who have the problem, and take their money while they are still in pain. Whether they could have found the solution to their problem through the open source channel is largely irrelevant if you have good enough sales channels to find people who don’t know to look for your free solution. Looking at your site now, I’d be very inclined to remove the free option. The era of freemium is sort of over. You want to be able to give something free to your unqualified leads, but it looks like you want to give away too much with it. You can maintain the npm channel, but it should not be part of your marketing for the paid product. It can still maybe be part of the onboarding process, I haven’t looked at your solution enough to understand what onboarding should look like.

Also, I suspect $25/mo is too little. Pricing is a form of marketing, and too low a price attracts the wrong kind of customers. There have been numerous threads here on HN talking about the quality of customers when adding a zero to their price.

Another thing I noticed on the forms.md page, is it wasn’t clear to me what pain I needed to have that your solution provides. All I know from your page is that if I want to build forms you can help with that, but you haven’t reminded me of what is painful about building forms, or even that it might be difficult. Let alone how your solution will make those pains go away.

There is also no price anchor. You absolutely need 3 pricing tiers on a landing page. One should be high enough you’re embarrased about it. $20 should absolutely be the lowest tier with the expectation that no one should want it. The middle price is what you want to sell for, and it has a slight goldie locks problem, but you can dial that in once you have enough sales.

Good luck.

milesvp··on DOGE has 'god mode' access to government data
To quote patio11,

“The optimal amount of fraud is non-zero

He was talking about the banking system. But he was also hinting at something bigger. There is a game theory problem often referred to as the meter maid problem. What is the optimal amount of meter maids in a city, where optimal can be defined in at least a few different ways, but roughly means the cost to revenue optimal. You end up with a couple of obvious extremes, no parking enforcement means no cost, but no revenue (plus parking may end up out of control if charging for parking is more than just revenue generating). The other extreme is thay you have enough people policing parking that no one ever fail to comply, this is the highest cost, but not the highest revenue, because you don’t get revenue from ticketing. So the answer is that the optimal number lies somewhere where the number of meter maids allows some percentage of people get away with failing to comply with parking rules (whether deliberate or accidental can further complicate the problem since both will happen).

So back to your steelman. Cleaning data is most certainly a desirable thing, but it is likely not the optimal thing, especially if the cost is high. And unauditable access to systems is a very high cost. Seems to me much of this auditing could be done in a much more acciuntable way.

milesvp··on Kids Love Landline Phones
Oh, and you missed an important one for me, which is that many phones will only use half duplex for the codec (possibly made worse by noise cancelling that will cut the speaker when the mic is active). This is annoying because I used to be able to talk to people on land lines, interrupt them, and then wait for them to finish talking so I can have a turn. Now, as soon as I talk, their audio cuts out, and now I can't tell if they've actually paused to let me talk. I find it very maddening, and difficult to hold a conversation.

Luckily, at least on my phone, when I attach a bluetooth headset, I can still get full duplex audio through the headset

milesvp··on AI is stifling new tech adoption?
Strong disagree here. I've been trying to learn Zig, and I'm thwarted enough by chatgpt giving me outdated information on Zig's unstable API that if I didn't have a strong incentive to learn it for it's cross compiler, I'd likely turn my efforts towards another language. This effect can greatly alter the adoption curve of a new tech, which can leave it dying on the vine.

You're not wrong though, in that Stack Overflow has the exact same problem. The main difference is that with Stack Overflow, there was a bonus in becoming the first expert on the platform, so while it does stifle new tech adoption, it at least encourages new tech content creation, which in turn encourages new tech. Though, I don't know if it's a net positive or negative in aggregate.

I think this problem will likely lessen as training becomes cheaper and faster. But right now, there is really strong incentives to avoid any tech that has had breaking changes in the last 3 years.

milesvp··on Children's arithmetic skills do not transfer between applied and academic math
What you describe is one of the fundamental “problems” of associative memories. Which is doing or recalling a thing in one context does not mean you are capable of doing or recalling the exact same thing in another context. Neurons light up based on all the current inputs, and if none of the current inputs light up the neurons that can trigger a skill, good luck doing that skill. This is why practicing in a wide variety of contexts is really important for mastery, you’re essentially increasing the odds that different inputs have a chance to trigger the knowledge that’s locked away in the structure.
milesvp··on Dead Games
Presumably this is Garry Neuman of Garry’s Mod fame. I love that he’s looking to keep these assets from being lost.
milesvp··on 3blue1brown YouTube Bitcoin video taken down as copyright violation
Heh, PirateSoftware, he talks about this, being both sec ops and having worked at blizzard. Apparently it's really common for the big coin farmers (which blizzard doesn't like, and would ban if they could identify all the players) to tell blizzard about zero day exploits to prevent their competitors from using them and crashing the market for gold.
milesvp··on The Zombocom Problem
It’s funny, I did a lot of python programming early in my career, and I didn’t realize just how afraid I was of refactoring until I started doing embedded work. Even as bad as the weakly typed C type system is, I found the compiler to be a godsend for changing my code later.
milesvp··on Why we use our own hardware
As someone who lived through that era, I can tell you there are legions of devs and dev adjacent people who have no idea what it’s like to automate mission critical hardware. Everyone had to do it in the early 2000s. But it’s been long enough that there are people in the workforce who just have no idea about running your own hardware since they never had to. I suspect there is a lot of interest, especially since we’re likely approaching the bring it back in house cycle, as CTOs try to reign in their cloud spend.
milesvp··on What does this button do? – My new car has a mysterious and undocumented switch
I'm having trouble finding what I remember seeing maybe 4 years ago. It was an all in one cellular component with an esim. This is the closest I can find to what I remember seeing. It may lead you to some other solutions.

https://1nce.com/en-us/1nce-connect/10-dollars-for-10-years

I remember seeing stupidly cheap prices for cellular chips, and when I looked into it, it looked like they had bought up a bunch of bulk bandwidth on some really old tech, like 2G. The offering wasn't a lot of data per period but certainly enough to wake up and upload a small amount of data regularly. Seemed like an obvious product, I know that if I'm doing a design, I don't want to have to rely on ongoing costs. I'm surprised I can't find more hits like this one. It's possible that peak IoT led to some crazy business models that had no chance of sustaining. I think they may have banking on the network dying before having to figure out how to purchase more bandwidth.

Digikey was no help. Googling "Lifetime Data Cellular Communication plan" did lead to some other potential interesting hits. chatgpt almost gave me interesting things to look for, but it mostly pointed me at consumer good. Good luck.

milesvp··on Buy Nothing Day
Or worse the same SKU but “for black friday”. It was common for things like TVs to be marketed in such a way as to think it was the same product as previously, but instead was a lesser product like a tv with fewer ports and a shorter warranty (which would imply cheaper life limited components like capacitors).
milesvp··on What does this button do? – My new car has a mysterious and undocumented switch
I work in this space, and I’ve seen advertised components (most likely SOCs) that had “lifetime” cell data included in the price, costing, on the order of, $50. It is becoming increasingly cheap to have low bandwidth cellular connectivity.
milesvp··on Why so many families are "drowning in toys"
Probably has something to do with the price of zero. The concept keeps showing up in random feeds for me, and it’s something both marketers and behavioral economists like to talk about. It seems free short circuits a lot of our normal cognitive pathways.

That said, I learned an interesting trick years ago. If you’re trying to get rid of junk, leaving it on the side of the road with a free sign is not as effective as using a sign with a slightly more than nominal amount. $25 used to be the sweet spot, $50 might be better today. Probably depends on the thing. Make it look like they’re getting a deal. Items tend to disappear after that, though I did once have someone knock and pay.

milesvp··on Google stops letting sites like Forbes rule search for "Best CBD Gummies"
This is absolutely not my experience. My googlefu has gone to shit. I can no longer have some sense for what I’m looking for and find it. Something I know exists, I just don’t know the terms of art to pull up the wealth of knowledge. I used to be able to do a half dozen searches, and finally on page 4 or 5 finally find some clues as to the terms I need. Now, there is no page 4… like ever. Clearly not many people were going past page 3 so they stopped serving that content.

Now I use chatgpt for these kinds of queries, and it feels like using google circa 2004.

I know this is a small edge case, and ultimately I need to use google to crosscheck, but it hints at the rot that has taken over at google, and represents a potential shift. If I could get good reference links from chatgpt, I may be able to stop using google for an increasing number of my queries.

milesvp··on When did estimates turn into deadlines?
> It's a skill issue.

Maybe. Sort of. Skill hints at the problem, but it's more of an experience issue. More experienced developers can give pretty reliable estimates for work they've already done. The catch is, how often do you ask an engineer to do something they've already done? The beauty of software, is that you don't solve the same problem over and over, because if you did, you'd automate it.

So where does that leave us? Well, developers who've seen a lot of different problems recognize when a new problem they see rhymes with a problem they've solved before. That can allow for a very good estimate. But even then, engineers tend to think in terms of best case, or maybe even typical case. I saw a study on this a few years ago, and it showed how often engineers tended to cluster around the median time for solutions. But, since really long tasks, with big error bars have a tendency to really skew timelines, the solution averages was much farther from these median times.

Believe it or not, lawyers have this problem too. They are taught in law school to come up with an estimate based on expected effort, then they apply a formula similar to: double the estimate, then increase the time units. So a 5 hour task becomes 10days. A 2 week task becomes 4 months. Mind you, this isn't the amount of billable hours they're predicting, it's the amount of calendar time that a given task will take until it's complete. This ends up taking into account a lot of variables that lawyers have no control over. Things like court scheduling, or communication delay. I suspect it also takes into account blind spots we humans have around time estimates in isolation. Like, 1 task, if you can focus on it can be done in so many hours. But if you have to do 5 similarly sized tasks, it takes more than 5 times as long, simply because it's easy to expend resources like brain power, and the estimate ignores the refractory periods necessary once the task is completed. (BTW this was one of the problems with the very first stop watch study in the rail yard, where the rail workers didn't work at their sustainable pace, but worked at their depletion pace).

milesvp··on The world is watching the U.S. deal with bird flu, and it's scary
Forgive me, I may be spreading incorrect information. I’m not sure the source I’m quoting, could be that the vaccine I’ve heard mentioned is not for humans? I’ve been hearing rumor of herds of cattle being put down to prevent the spread.

Could also be that the current outbreak doesn’t have a good candidate yet.

Wikipedia seems to think there was a human H5N1 vaccine approved in 2020.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/H5N1_vaccine

milesvp··on The world is watching the U.S. deal with bird flu, and it's scary
H5N1. Avian flu that people have been worried about for decades. There is a vaccine for it, but, of course, low stocks because because it was not mammal transmissible until recently. Minks and cows are known to have caught it. It’s believed to still only be transmissible through ingestion. Given current food practices, it could enter the US food chain similar to ecoli.
milesvp··on Please stop the coding challenges
Interesting. I think I slightly prefer take homes, mostly because they're not as hectic. The problem ends up being, that I don't have any guarantee that the other side will spend any time on it. At least with an in person, I know that the company had to incur a significant cost so I know my time is less likely to be wasted. There's already a growing asymmetry with job searches, and this is one more trend that accelerates that. I still have a non technical friend who's annoyed with me for not completing a take home years ago, because, while the main ask was obviously trivial, there was enough slop in the directions that I could kill hours trying to decide if something was good enough to submit. On top of that it was expecting some fairly narrow set of techs, that, while not difficult to pick up, were not something I was interested in trying to learn enough about for a chance to maybe help some company that "couldn't find any technical talent".
milesvp··on If you need the money, don't take the job
The advice I’ve heard in the general contractor world, is fixed bid only works if you charge appropriately, and are very quick with change orders. As soon as it looks like the scope is changing, be it a request from the client, or some new thing is exposed (often literally). I’d expect the same is necessary for software consulting.

The bigger problem I don’t hear discussed in any of these threads, is that you can only estimate jobs you’ve done before. So, to do fixed bid profitably, it really requires that you are specializing in some set of deliverables. This, actually has some interesting benefits as well, one, is that you can charge a lot more over time, and you can become very efficient as well, which leads to a high profit per effort ratio.

milesvp··on Amish have low cancer rate, but why?
That looks like the work I heard about! I'm surprised I can't find what I thought was the podcast I learned about this. None of my usuals is showing results googling.

This looks like a good summary of the story I heard though.

http://fearlessleadersgroup.com/blog/the-story-of-a-positive...

milesvp··on Amish have low cancer rate, but why?
There's a term for this that I learned recently for this but I'm blanking on it. It has to do with a growing strategy of looking at 2 groups when trying to solve a medical problem. And, rather than find a cure for the problem, they look for differences in the populations that prevents the problem from one of them.

The story I heard that sort of started the movement had to do with international doctors who had volunteered to be part of a childhood malnutrition treatment for some south east asian country. When they got there, the promised monetary support was not there, and they were only given a car and a driver.

So they drove around to see if there was anything they could do to help the children without the vitamin shots they thought they were going to administer and noticed there were families whose children weren't malnourished. It turned out their parents, while they were out weeding their rice fields, were grabbing foodstuff that was considered culturally undesirable. Certain weeds and other things that lived in the fields. Then they'd add what they gathered to their meals. The doctors then made it an education mission, rather than a medicine dispersion mission.

It sounds stupidly simple in retrospect, but I don't think they came by the solution easily. Like, if the food was undesirable, parents may have been very hesitant to disclose they were eating it, let alone feeding it to their children.

milesvp··on C-Motive's electrostatic motors use printed circuit boards instead of magnets
I’ve been doing pcb design around sensor coils for capacitive sensing. My engineering team has been playing with similar ideas around printing coils for other electro magnetic purposes. Motors are an obvious usecase. Good to see others doing similar stuff with printed circuit boards. It takes a way a lot of complexity and pcb processes have some pretty good precision these days.
milesvp··on Laziness Death Spirals
He's missing one very good technique that works for me.

Decide that there is 1 thing, and only 1 thing, that you want to get done today. Ideally it should be something that can be accomplished in less than 30 minutes. Bonus if it can be done in less than 10.

Do it. Maybe you need 20 minutes to get started, maybe you need an hour. Maybe you just can't bring yourself to do it. Give yourself 5 minutes to wallow in the emotion of not wanting to. Take a deep breath, and then proceed to do the thing.

This may not work if the 1 thing is deceptively complicated or fractal. So take care that the thing is actually actionable. Yak shaving can help to get you out of a lazy spiral, but it has a strong tendency to lead to further demoralization.

When you have accomplished the 1 thing. You are done. You are done for the day.

Don't cheat. Don't make this 1 thing inconsequential, like making a list, then crossing off the first task of making the list. Sometimes the list is the most important thing to get done, so that can be ok, but you know when it's not. The thing should be something that brings you closer to something better. A better future for yourself, even if the better future is no longer having to think about the task.

Since you are now done for the day... you can stop. Chances are you won't want to. Chances are, after a short break, you can repeat the process.

Now, one caveat. If this is successful, you must stop early for the day. This is important, because, there is a good chance that there is a reason you're in a lazy spiral. It's probably because you are overworked. People greatly underestimate the amount of calories the brain burns. They also greatly underestimate the amount of time neuronal reuptake requires for hard tasks. You need rest, and the "I don't wannas" are an emotional protection for your brain. The problem is, this technique can be so effective for some people, that you just keep going long past when you should stop. If you do that you are setting yourself up for failure tomorrow, where you will likely be similarly mentally tired.

He does mention the reset in the article. A new day is a chance to break the cycle. This is also fine advice, since there's a good chance you may just need a proper mental break day. What I like about my technique, is that often there is something that is high on a list of things that need to be done to allow for a project or life goal to continue to make progress. It will continue to weigh on you and drain you mentally if you don't give it some attention. By making some small progress, it's much easier to proceed to actually allow yourself to properly rest.

milesvp··on MQTT, once the cornerstone of IoT communication, is starting to show its age
> Resolve Intermitent Connectivity Issues

They lost me at this header. MQTT was quite literally designed for satellite based communication. Its biggest strength is dealing with intermittent connections. If you’re going to fire and forget important data with MQTT you’re already using it wrong.

milesvp··on Large language models reduce public knowledge sharing on online Q&A platforms
I’m not sure how to take you comment, but I feel the same(?) way. I love that I can use LLMs to explore topics that I don’t know well enough to find the right language to get hits on. I used to be able to do this with google, after a few queries, and skimming to page 5 hits, I’d eventually find the one phrase that cracks open the topic. I haven’t been able to do that with google for at least 10 years. I do it regularly with LLMs today.
milesvp··on Large language models reduce public knowledge sharing on online Q&A platforms
This happened to me the other day. I had framed a question in the ordinal case, and since I was trying to offload thinking anyways, I forgot that my use case was rotated, and failed to apply the rotation when testing the LLM answer. I corrected it twice before it wrapped around to the same (correct) previous answer, and that’s when I noticed my error. I apologized, added the rotation piece to my question, and it happily gave me a verifiably correct answer.
milesvp··on How Discord stores trillions of messages (2023)
I have stared into the abyss and seen the eyes of cthulu. I am much happier writing embedded drivers than I was trying to make sense of why previous devs thought it was a good idea to move bounded tunable server side api calls to the client, allowing it to effectively write arbitrary sql calls across multiple databases.
milesvp··on Tortured by regrets? A new study details how best to overcome them
This is partly why I don’t feel bad about not buying bitcoin at $12. I did the math, and given my general investing strategies, where I rebalance periodically, I doubt I’d have made more than couple hundred thousand. It’s real money, but not the millions I once imagined I’d have made. Also, it felt risky at the time, so the money I might have lost would have been real to me at the time.
milesvp··on Fluoride at twice the recommended limit is linked to lower IQ in kids
>People choose to purchase unhealthy food

Yeah, sort of. I’m immediately reminded of reports of health problems of people in countries that traditionally grow quinoa. The global demand for this amazingly nutritious food has priced it so high that many of the poorer in the regions that grow it have switched to cheaper, less nutritious foods.

I am also reminded that if I want to buy “peasant food”, I have to pay a huge premium over much cheaper, crappier, less nutritious processed food. That is to say, foods that were commonly cheap and readily available many centuries ago, are no longer cheap.

I find it slightly disengenuous to simply say that people choose to purchase unhealthy food without acknowledging that individuals are presented choices that are often suboptimal. I cannot reasonably buy bread without added sugar. That is not a choice I have made, that is the landcape I live in. I choose to buy less bread as a result. But I alone cannot change the economic landscape, even though you are absolutely correct that there are food which are cheaper and more nutritious than alternatives.

I would also be really cautious about “enforcing healthy standards”. I don’t know how old you are, but I’m old enough to have seen some pretty shitty “healthy standards” pushed en mass, and then codified through major lobbying by interested parties.

← PreviousPage 4 of 32Next →