HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

miloshh

420 karma · joined October 25, 2008

submissionscomments
miloshh··on Geek business myths
I'm totally with you on the "ideas as answers", but I feel the article is bashing exactly these kinds of ideas - the ones that "geeks" tend to have.

There seems to be a number of people here that often say things like "execution" or "knowing what customers want" are what matters, as if those weren't composed of many good ideas, too.

miloshh··on Geek business myths
Having your own opinions is also not a bad thing. If unsure, you might consider asking Paul Graham for guidance on this, too.
miloshh··on Geek business myths
Yes, I completely agree that there are many bad ideas (or even some whose quality cannot even be measured). But that is different from saying they are irrelevant.

I have seen many bad ideas, but I have also seen very smart, hard-working people stuck on a problem for a few months, while they really needed a new idea to move forward.

Also, if a good idea saves you a month of hard work, it is worth exactly as much as the month of hard work, isn't it?

In academia, smart, hardworking people are a dime a dozen, and a huge success is usually at the end of a string of many good ideas. I don't know mch about building a company, but I doubt it is very different.

miloshh··on Geek business myths
You say that based on what? Did you read it?

"The only thing a Ph.D. means is that you're not a moron, and you're willing to put up with the bullshit it takes to slog your way through a Ph.D. program somewhere." If he instead said that it is neither necessary nor sufficient to have a Ph.D. for task X, I would actually agree. But that would be too banal to catch attention.

"Microsoft has never had a single brilliant idea in its entire history. Microsoft has achieved success largely by seeking out and destroying other people's brilliant ideas." Depending how you look at it, seriously?

"The idea is very nearly irrelevant." If he instead said that he as an investor has no time/ability to tell good ideas from bad ones, it would have been reasonable, but this way it is insulting to people that work with ideas.

miloshh··on Geek business myths
I apologize for the personal attack. However, the author insulted, without much argument, so many groups at once (geeks, Microsoft, people that appreciate the value of ideas, Ph.D.s, etc.) that I would claim there is some ground for calling him an asshole.

I still think a community should listen to people with insight more than to people with money (especially if it isn't his own money, as in the case of a VC).

miloshh··on Geek business myths
Downvoters, please explain what is good in the article.
miloshh··on Geek business myths
What a dumb asshole. Everything in the article is either banal, a straw-man, or very questionable, which contrasts a lot with his tone.

This guy somehow luckily got into a position of power where he is allowed to invest other people's money. Nobody would ever listen to him if it wasn't for that twist of fate.

miloshh··on Is There Anything Good About Men?
Interesting theory, but wrong. In fact, the right answer is well known, and does not involve memes at all.

The reason why it's equally good for the genes to produce a male or a female, and why there's an equal number of males and females in almost all animal species, is that the expected number of offspring for a male and a female is equal. It has to be that way, because everybody has exactly one father and one mother.

While it might be true that 8/10 of females and 4/10 of males of a given species reproduce, the males reproduce more when they do. A smaller probability of a higher number will give you the same expected value.

I think this argument (among many others) is nicely explained in the Selfish Gene by Dawkins.

miloshh··on What I Wish I Had Known About Developing C/C++ From Linux Before I Started
I think you misunderstood what refactoring means in an IDE. Suppose you want to rename a method. There might be many other methods of the same name in different classes, local variables of that name in other methods, or even classes with that same name in differen packages. Eclipse automatically does all of this for you.

I honestly don't understand how regexps and strong bookmarking skills could help you - the editor needs true knowledge of the language to carry out this task.

miloshh··on Don't Fall In Love With Your Model: The Cautionary Tale of my Recent proof that P=NP
Is it really a joke? The guy might actually be the pompous jackass that he appears to be. EDIT: OK, I see it's published on April 1st. :)
miloshh··on Don't Fall In Love With Your Model: The Cautionary Tale of my Recent proof that P=NP
Yes, but that is for an N x N matrix. It is more useful to express the complexity in the size of the input, in which case matrix multiplication is N^1.5 or better. (As far as I know, the best known algorithm is pretty close to linear, but it's not known if a linear one exists.)
miloshh··on Ask HN: what linear algebra do you use most often for practical problems?
As long as the 100 vectors fit in memory, it shouldn't be too bad. I think the commonly used algorithm to find the first singular vectors is Lanczos iteration, where the key operation is multiplying the 100 vectors by the large matrix. I don't know if there's an existing library for this though...
miloshh··on Python’s lambda is broken
Well, I would disagree - the problem is that there is no apparent mutation in the given example. There is hidden mutation, in that the list comprehension mutates its variable. This is probably done for efficiency, but I would claim it's a bad design decision.
miloshh··on Nature v nurture? Please don't ask
Of course, but the point is, identical twins are consistently more similar than fraternal twins.

Furthermore, identical twins are about as similar when growing up together, as when growing up apart.

miloshh··on Congrats, Dropbox (YC S07)
Yes, it's great for that purpose, except when two ore more people edit too vigorously at the same time. E.g. a file is updated by your friend, while you're working the same file open in an editor. When you save, you overwrite his changes.

If you have a solution to this problem, let us know... :)

miloshh··on How laziness changes thinking in Haskell
I think you will run into problems like this pretty early on, and no worry, they're all fixable. :) The other links in this discussion are good, and here's another one: http://www.haskell.org/haskellwiki/Stack_overflow
miloshh··on Language-python: A Python Parser Written in Haskell
Yeah, but in a way a lexer is a parser, just a simpler one (so you can write it from scratch, without a library like Parsec). Most lexers can deal with comments and string constants already, so you could extend it to do "{" and "}" as well...
miloshh··on Where did all the wealth go? To our kids.
Perhaps there was too much currency in the system, but I think the actual, real wealth of many people did decrease too. They were better off than they are now, their wealth physically went down. They don't have things now that they did before. The output of the economy decreased, while the resources stayed roughly the same, so less wealth is being created. This is true even if you completely forget about the existence of money.
miloshh··on Language-python: A Python Parser Written in Haskell
Yeah, Parsec is great - I used it to parse some shading languages. I have thought about the error recovery problem, and I think for some C-like languages there might be a solution, although I never tried it. You could use a "smart" lexer that divides the incoming stream into functions (based on counting "{" and "}") and run Parsec separately on each function. I can't think of anything much better...
miloshh··on An idea whose time has come: Entrepreneurialism has become cool
An optimistic article, but I wonder if entrepreneurialism has become cool only in very limited circles - like here.

Out in the real world, with the crisis and rising unemployment, it is once again becoming a sign of life success to land a safe job in a large corporation. It seems that getting hired by (say) Google is even more impressive now than a few years ago.

Another thing that worries me is that there are no IPOs anymore, so the only options for small businesses are to stay small (and unimportant) or sell the business to a large corporation (making them even stronger). And with more regulations and bailouts from the government, corporations might just be getting stronger than ever. I hope it is not true, I'll be happy if you prove me wrong.

miloshh··on Young people prefer the sound of MP3s to uncompressed music
According to the article (and the one linked in it), the percentage of people that prefer MP3 quality is rising, that's all. It does not say these people would actually be able to tell that the recording they prefer is an MP3.
miloshh··on Young people prefer the sound of MP3s to uncompressed music
It might well be that many people complaining about "soulless, thin MP3s" would not be able to tell a 160kbps VBR MP3 from the original in a controlled experiment. Low-quality headphones and speakers are obviously a different matter, but if you're telling somebody that compression makes their music soulless and thin, you're an audio snob without any facts.
miloshh··on Remove cap on H-1B: LinkedIn CEO
Yes, that is true, in the early stage (before the start-up looks like a respectable company from the outside), it's more complicated. Ideally, you would use a different kind of visa, e.g. F-1 OPT if you have a degree from a US school, or TN if you're Canadian/Mexican. But I agree, the system is screwed up, and making it much harder for non-American founders than it should be. Let's hope Obama administration improves something...
miloshh··on Remove cap on H-1B: LinkedIn CEO
Are you sure start-ups cannot afford H1-B? It might be a few thousand in lawyer fees, but that might be well worth it, especially if a few key founders need H1-B. Since more than 50% start-ups had some immigrant founders, I'm assuming that a large part of them had H1-B rather than some other visa or green card.
miloshh··on 3D duck, done in Javascript, 4k.
Nice demo. But unsurprisingly, if something is Turing complete, you can do rendering in it, too. The bigger question is - why did we get into this sad situation where "web" and "performance" are antonyms?

The standard answer would be that you need full control over the machine to get performance, and you really don't want to give full control over the web for security reasons. But this answer is false. We just need more advances in code validation, e.g. something that would prove a piece of code cannot do system calls.

miloshh··on Why functional programming doesn't catch on
To all the fellow FP fans - why spend so much time trying to convince nay-sayers that FP is great, that it makes code shorter, simpler, safer, more robust, more fun? They will not get it anyway, until they try it. And sadly, they won't try it. Let's just use FP to our advantage and crush the competition!
miloshh··on The Eligible Bachelor Paradox
Actually, I think critic above had it right. Sure, women are considered more attractive when 20-30, and get a lot of attantion from men in that age, much more than men do at any point in their life. After women get past 30, things simply get back to "normal", but to them this seems as a shortage. In fact, single women above 30 seem to be the only group that ever refers to a "shortage of suitable males" - in my experience, younger women and men are generally surprised as to why such thing should ever exist.

Furthermore, the theory that men are trying hard to marry, and the most attractive ones "succeed" to marry at a younger age, just does not seem to be realistic, especially not in modern society. There are good reasons for men not to marry early.

miloshh··on HN: you are guilty of premature optimization
When I keep thinking which other, more efficient ways of achieving financial freedom you might have had in mind, I cannot help the word fraud popping up. I'm sure that's not what you meant, but I have no idea what you did mean. :) Investment banking? Consulting?
miloshh··on Linux to spend eternity in shadow of 'little blue E'
Hmm.. I agree these are becoming bad habits, but what if all the good habits fail? That is actually a very common case, I think.

I once couldn't make sound work on a laptop, so I tried all the obvious tricks - check if the mixer isn't accidentally set to zero etc. But when all failed, I decided to download the latest nightly build of ALSA, recompile it, and guess what - it solved the problem. I still don't know what it was...

I have similar stories with GPU support and power management, and I think I'm not alone. But we're getting into too much detail...

miloshh··on Linux to spend eternity in shadow of 'little blue E'
I think those complaining about Linux in the desktop being in shadow are missing the point. They are always implying that the problem is people being stupid, or the costs of retraining being high, or evil Microsoft's marketing, or sysadmins trained in Microsoft stuff that don't want to change...

Face it... Linux is hard. I am close to a Ph.D. in CS, have spent years programming in several languages on different operating systems, I'm a geek that tries out new Linux distros just for fun, and I still find it very hard to make them work. I always find myself recompiling the kernel, sound drivers, etc from sources. I always have to turn off automatic updates, because they always screw up the installation - this kind of badness simply doesn't exist on Windows.

The simple, dumb Windows model of software installation, where the vendor is responsible for providing a working self-installer, and every program occupies its own directory, just seems so much better than the intricate repositories of Linux distros, which you cannot bypass without risk of screwing up your system.

I like Linux and I will keep playing with it, but I'm not surprised by its minimal share in the desktop world.

← PreviousPage 5 of 6Next →