420 karma · joined October 25, 2008
Also, the halting problem's insolvability is straightforward to see without knowing any of Godel's work. :)
The Communist Manifesto was similarly arrogant and angry, but at least somewhat understandable. :)
Not just the rasterizer, but any application that wants to take full advantage of Larabee will have to use the SIMD vector units to the max.
Larrabee might turn out to have great performance (which I hope), but if it does, the reason will not be black magic or breaking laws of physics. The reason will be SIMD.
The way to get maximum performance out of a given chip area is to use SIMD, and that's here to stay, with all the associated issues.
If all threads in a block have the same number if iterations, you're fine; different blocks can take different number of iterations. As long as the number of blocks is much higher than the number of SMs, the machine will dynamically schedule the blocks to available SMs.
If each thread takes a different number of iterations, it's more difficult, but you can still do dynamic allocation yourself, by running as many blocks as you have SMs, and having each thread pick up work as it needs. You can also randomize the assignment of work to threads, so the expected amount of work is roughly the same. This all depends on the particular problem and data, though...
As for the 8-bit nature of the problem - this is true, you're not utilizing the floating point units that are the biggest advantage of the GPU. How large are the vectors you need to do PSADBW over?
Also, the comparison between American kids and Indian kids in the US is not quite fair, since these Indians are a highly biased sample of the true Indian population.
So the difference must be in something else, too. My personal guess is that the math in the US schools must be just too "easy". So, if kids everywhere on average learn about 60% of the math they are taught, they will be better in countries where the math taught is more advanced.
By all means, one year is not too late - you should change your research project to something that's your very own. If your advisor doesn't let you, change your advisor too.
I think you're exactly the type that needs to lead a project, and be the first author, instead of contributing bits here and there, implementing somebody else's "vision". Leave that for those that think academic success is putting their names on the maximum number of papers.