HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mkaziz

1,179 karma · joined July 31, 2013

submissionscomments
mkaziz··on Canadians Adopted Refugee Families for a Year, Then Came ‘Month 13’
A) I'm sure he planned that when he escaped from Mecca on a camel.

B) yes kind of like how the Russians went communist and then invaded Afghanistan.

/a whole lot happened in between/

---

Anyway, I'm done arguing. You obviously won't be convinced and neither will I, and I have better things to do than argue with a person on the internet. Good luck with whatever it is that you do and no hard feelings.

mkaziz··on Canadians Adopted Refugee Families for a Year, Then Came ‘Month 13’
a) It wasn't hereditary. b) A bunch of ragtag Meccans came to Medina with a destitute Prophet, where there were two well armed and well established Arab tribes and three Jewish tribes. No armed conflict took place, because there is no reasonable way to assert that that would not be recorded, by both Jewish and Muslim sources.
mkaziz··on Canadians Adopted Refugee Families for a Year, Then Came ‘Month 13’
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_Medina

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_Medina#Rights_...

mkaziz··on Canadians Adopted Refugee Families for a Year, Then Came ‘Month 13’
I mean, they were invited to come over and the Prophet(S) was invited to take a role of the head of state. Generally speaking most (not all) of the native Arab population (excluding the Jews) was happy about it. So in that sense, yes they were "subjugated" in that their were subject to him as head of state. It's not unlike a modern election where even if you're not happy about the result of the election, you're still subject to rules made by the new government.
mkaziz··on Canadians Adopted Refugee Families for a Year, Then Came ‘Month 13’
Conquest: https://www.google.com/search?q=conquest&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8#s...

con·quest/ˈkänˌkwest/ noun

    the subjugation and assumption of control of a place or people by use of military force.
mkaziz··on Canadians Adopted Refugee Families for a Year, Then Came ‘Month 13’
I referred to the act of emigration and the pact of brotherhood, not the subsequent conflicts with the Jews. There was no "conquest" of Medina. Conquest implies an invading army subjugating a native population, which didn't happen because there was no army - only refugees.
mkaziz··on Canadians Adopted Refugee Families for a Year, Then Came ‘Month 13’
Nadir and Qaynuqa were evicted , not massacred. Qurayza was killed after they betrayed the Muslims in the middle of a seige that Nadir (which had resettled in Khaybar) helped instigate. Khaybar was attacked as a result of that same seige, and after the Muslim victory, they were allowed to keep to their lands in exchange for tribute.

So yeah, not a kumbaya story, but it's sure better than your one-line, sarcastic comment.

mkaziz··on Canadians Adopted Refugee Families for a Year, Then Came ‘Month 13’
... you can say that about any historical event ever and massage it to fit your narrative.

The commandment for Muslims to fight wasn't sent down till a year or two after the emigration, so they were quite literally not allowed to fight or "subdue" or "coerce" anyone. There's a /tonne/ of evidence that the emigration was peaceful (though there were certainly subgroups opposed to it politically and ideologically). It is quite literally one of the least contentious pieces of Islamic history.

mkaziz··on Canadians Adopted Refugee Families for a Year, Then Came ‘Month 13’
Oh. That went completely over my head. Thank you!
mkaziz··on Canadians Adopted Refugee Families for a Year, Then Came ‘Month 13’
You should include a note in your next tax return for the feds to not use any of your taxes to pay for his road/social security/medicare/anything. I'm sure he'd prefer his roads to come only from blueblooded American taxes.
mkaziz··on Canadians Adopted Refugee Families for a Year, Then Came ‘Month 13’
GP didn't imply "force", he implied /encourage/ by calling it civic duty.
mkaziz··on Canadians Adopted Refugee Families for a Year, Then Came ‘Month 13’
No they weren't? There was no conquest on Medina. I have no idea what you're trying to say.
mkaziz··on Canadians Adopted Refugee Families for a Year, Then Came ‘Month 13’
^Yep. When I was sponsored, the US government basically told us that if we try and claim any public benefits for the next 5 years, they'd come after my sponsor for reimbursement. Sponsor had to show adequate financial resources to sponsor our family.

This probably does not apply for refugees, but definitely does for family-based sponsorships.

mkaziz··on Canadians Adopted Refugee Families for a Year, Then Came ‘Month 13’
Wow. I am beyond impressed. I am from a Muslim country and I have heard more than one person say that we may have Islam on our faces, but Westerners have Islam in their hearts. I can't even imagine the effort the Canadian sponsors put into resettling these families.

There is a very direct analogy to this in the early history of Islam: http://www.questionsonislam.com/article/brotherhood-establis... where the Muslims who fled persecution in Mecca were set up with sponsor families in Medina who helped them adapt and stand on their feet. To see that same behaviour in our purportedly selfish day and age warms me to a whole another level.

mkaziz··on Is Fat Killing Us, or Is Sugar?
Do you have a quick synopsis of what happens?
mkaziz··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
I don't think so. Having the Bengali counterbalance would have significantly reduced Pakistan's veering towards theocracy, imo.

But that's speculation, neither here nor there. Who knows how it would have actually played out.

mkaziz··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
It actually is going pretty well. We elected a demagogue and he's as checked and balanced as he can be, given that he has the House and Senate.
mkaziz··on How the Government Ruined US Healthcare – And What Can Be Done
Yeah but you also have situations there like my old man, who got admitted for a heart attack and the hospital refused to operate without ~ his annual income (and we're middle class there) in cash being deposited first.
mkaziz··on Sea Ice Extent Sinks to Record Lows at Both Poles
I don't understand it how they ethically manage to do that. What kind of journalism is that?
mkaziz··on What Does It Take to Climb Up the Ladder?
Having sex was also a major reason. Socially acceptable pre and extra marital sex is still a newish thing in our societies.
mkaziz··on AQAP trying to hide explosives in laptops, official says
No one's talking about that fact that the US trusts Abu Dhabi to have a customs port there[0], but not enough to let a passenger travelling via Abu Dhabi to put a laptop in their carryon ...

0. http://www.etihad.com/en-us/before-you-fly/us-preclearance/

mkaziz··on Hacked Twitter Accounts Post Swastikas, Pro-Erdogan Content
Of all the governments in the world today, I am most impressed by Merkel's Germany. She has remarkable ability to stand strong in the face of criticism and do what's right without bowing to populism.
mkaziz··on U.K. Parliament Gives Theresa May Permission to Start Brexit
What interests me is that, despite that example, folks across the pond made exactly that mistake in November! Maybe we truly can't learn from others' mistakes.
mkaziz··on A subterranean world of water offers a glimpse of Ramla’s past
We marvel at those aqueducts and pyramids in the same way we marvel at this. WE shouldn't pooh-pah one accomplishment just because another exists that we're culturally more familiar with.
mkaziz··on Ask HN: What books fundamentally changed the way you think about the world?
Any reason in particular for Foundation? I'm reading it right now and I love it, but it doesn't strike me as a life changing kind of book.
mkaziz··on Japan's Universities Are Failing
Immigration is not all or nothing. You can allow in a set number of immigrants a year - enough to inject new ideas but not enough to drown out Japanese culture. They're your borders, no one's stopping you.
mkaziz··on Japan's Universities Are Failing
Right, and the current situation is one such consequence of that. Of course they could try something else - they've been trying since the 90's from what I understand, with mixed results at best.
mkaziz··on Japan's Universities Are Failing
It's not a floodgates vs nothing situation. You can certainly decide on an appropriate rate that you're comfortable with - enough to jumpstart the economy but not enough to completely drown out the host culture.
mkaziz··on Japan's Universities Are Failing
Addressing your first point: the problem is that they're stagnating /now/. They don't have the means or will or resources to deal with their problems. There's not enough labour to support the elderly population.

I'm sure they can decrease inflow at an appropriate time, but for now, they need fresh blood and fresh ideas.

mkaziz··on Japan's Universities Are Failing
I mean, the US way works. Immigration, especially of skilled labour, lends real tangible benefits to the US, its growth, and its culture.
← PreviousPage 2 of 14Next →