HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mkr-hn

8,354 karma · joined July 22, 2010

Email: mkr@mkronline.com
submissionscomments
mkr-hn··on Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete my websites
You might feel different when you're disabled.
mkr-hn··on A global house-price slump is coming?
Numbers would be interesting to compare to the widespread discussion on HN that makes it seem common.
mkr-hn··on DaVinci Resolve for iPad
Then what's the relevance of the comment about stability? This thread is about the coming iPad version. It's reasonable to assume you're talking about it (or confused and in the wrong place), given that's the topic of the submission.

Desktop video editors are notoriously unstable (assuming since you didn't specify). It's probably not the same codebase, and it'll be operating under clearer constraints the developers can target for maximum stability and performance.

mkr-hn··on Show HN: I'm trying to guess your personality by your comments with an NLP model
Time to buy a Sodastream, discontinued tactical vest, and/or resin printer and spend more time outdoors to validate the reading.
mkr-hn··on Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener and less car-centric
I assume dropping someone off or picking someone up to go to/from somewhere outside wouldn't count as parking.
mkr-hn··on DaVinci Resolve for iPad
How could you try something that didn't exist?
mkr-hn··on Pocket Casts Mobile Apps Are Now Open Source
Overcast produces an export with everything, but warns they don't know of any apps that import it. The nice thing about OPML though is it's XML. An importer will just skip what it doesn't understand and import the subscriptions.
mkr-hn··on Copilot under fire as dev claims it emits 'large chunks of my copyrighted code'
You're thinking of patents. Novelty isn't important in copyright.
mkr-hn··on Copilot under fire as dev claims it emits 'large chunks of my copyrighted code'
I wonder what the discussions with the lawyers are like at companies who want to use it. Are they all advising to avoid it and let someone else be the test case?
mkr-hn··on Why do teachers give girls higher marks than boys? Researchers have the answer
You seem determined to misunderstand and misrepresent me. I don't know if you're just having a bad day or doing it on purpose, so I'm going to move on and let you figure yourself out.
mkr-hn··on Part of the long-lost star catalogue of Hipparchus found in medieval parchment
What makes you think no one is?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_Codice_Ratio

mkr-hn··on Why do teachers give girls higher marks than boys? Researchers have the answer
It doesn't stop at grades. That's the problem. People inclined to discriminate are not discriminating in their discrimination. When I say mistreatment, I mean being sent to the principal for made up reasons because the teacher just doesn't like you. Ignoring bullies terrorizing you right in front of her because "you need to man up." Stuff like that.

People who decide to get even by treating some people different are not good people who actually care about the people they're discriminating against. They have contempt for those people and want to see them suffer.

mkr-hn··on Ableton Note – A playable iOS app for forming musical ideas
Live is first and foremost a tool for making electronic music in the same way Cubase is for making live band stuff. You can use one for the other, but you'll fight against the design goals that underly them. I would love Cubase's expression maps for handling keyswitches in Live for those rare times I use orchestral stuff, but I know I'll need to spend money on the top Max device for it if I want to get serious about sampled instruments. And I don't, because 99% of the time I'm making ridiculous sounds in Massive/Massive X. Live is all about the painless automation and clip launching. Automation is central to electronic music. Clips are fun to goof around in, but also let musicians cut up their songs for dynamic playing during actual live sets.
mkr-hn··on Ableton Note – A playable iOS app for forming musical ideas
I had hoped to use it to draft ideas on the go, but I don't play an instrument, so I lack the timing practice to use it the way it's made to be used (live). I really need the note editor and sequencer from the big desktop program to be productive in it. However, it's fun to poke around in, and I'm sure they'll add missing features over time.
mkr-hn··on How Faithful Is Amazon’s Rings of Power to JRR Tolkien’s Books?
Have you checked out Outer Range? It's a little weird, but it was a good twist on the genre in the same way as Cowboys & Aliens. You get your usual conflict over land, but the why unfolds with each episode.
mkr-hn··on How Faithful Is Amazon’s Rings of Power to JRR Tolkien’s Books?
I don't know much about the lore, don't know anything about attacks on fans, and didn't find it boring. I watched it alongside a rewatch of the entire Stargate franchise now that it's on Prime again with the change in ownership. What response are you looking for here?
mkr-hn··on How Faithful Is Amazon’s Rings of Power to JRR Tolkien’s Books?
That's been my experience. I like the show and have largely tried to ignore purist grognards. It's hard when they seem to be well-represented in the media and discussion around the show, but I've managed to go right on enjoying it in spite of their endless negativity.
mkr-hn··on Why do teachers give girls higher marks than boys? Researchers have the answer
You're talking about mistreating some children for the benefit of others. These are people, not an algebra problem. Do you hear yourself?
mkr-hn··on Americans' Trust in Media Remains Near Record Low
It was easier to disagree without annoyance before those views got so disagreeable. There's a huge difference between a minor disagreement over taxes and dealing with someone vomiting conspiracy theories about litter boxes for furries at school and secret trafficking operations at pizza parlors.

Conspiracy theories used to be relatively harmless. They're how we got Stargate and X-Files. I can't just live and let live when the view I disagree with is the view is that there's a secret queer cabal indoctrinating children. That kind of claim has consequences that "maybe capital gains could be lower" doesn't.

mkr-hn··on Why do teachers give girls higher marks than boys? Researchers have the answer
Not much comfort to people who suffer in school because all the teachers saw them as an actor in a system instead of a person.
mkr-hn··on GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion
Embrace: How nice that we don't have to worry about GitHub closing for lack of funds. Thanks, Microsoft!

Extend: Make people dependent on GitHub Copilot. Require a Microsoft account (soon).

Extinguish: Sunset git and transition to Microsoft's own source control system.

mkr-hn··on GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion
It's a new approach compared to Amazon taking open-source code and building AWS services that kill off attempts at self-funding (dual licensing/support services) by the people who made it. I hope it's not as successful. Amazon at least abided by the letter of the licenses.

>> "I'm not too sure yet, but I wouldn't be surprised if we wake up one day, and just like how it went with Facebook buying oculus, we will all of a sudden require some "microsoft account" to log into Github."

See: Minecraft. It was already a goldmine when they bought it, but they built it into an even bigger one before forcing millions to have a foot into their ecosystem. Copilot might be their way of making everyone dependent on GitHub before "moving on" from git and offering a Community Edition of their own source control system.

It'll be easy. A lot of people hate Git.

mkr-hn··on GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion
The point is access to the source. If that access is mediated through a system that doesn't tell you where the code comes from or how it's licensed, it's failing at open source.

It's not like they don't get it. Even Microsoft will provide the source of its products under certain circumstances for this exact reason.

https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/sharedsource/

mkr-hn··on GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion
There's no need for the repo owner do anything: they already indicate the license. GitHub even shows a simple explanation of the license in the repo's main page. GitHub has all the data it needs to respect the license. If their trained model can't reproduce the license for the repo a fragment comes from, then they've failed in their social and legal responsibilities.

I do understand how ML works. I know it's probably not possible with how it's currently done. That doesn't make it legal or ethical.

It would actually be great for everyone if it showed both the license and repo. Imagine you pull up a great function with Copilot and want to explore the source for more insights. You can't with how they've done this.

mkr-hn··on GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion
>> "Like someone else said, there was a version of this where they asked people to opt-in and got community involvement. In true MS fashion, they just did it without asking and people are rightfully pissed."

I'm probably not the first person to say it through this whole debacle, but that might be me: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33242619

>> "Copilot was Microsoft's first test of people's trust after the GitHub acquisition. It's going very, very, very poorly. There were ways to do this with consent and collaboration with the people and projects it takes code from, but they're acting like classic Microsoft here."

mkr-hn··on GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion
You're free to put your code under something like CC0 if you feel this way. Everyone else who puts their code under a license that requires at least attribution and expects Microsoft to follow it can continue taking Microsoft to task for ignoring that responsibility at scale.
mkr-hn··on GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion
I didn't say anything to dismiss or discount that some people just don't care or have a different view. I carefully qualified my comment to only address people who don't know, and they do exist in large numbers.
mkr-hn··on GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion
Yep. Four years might be a long time in Silicon Valley, but not in Redmond. Satya Nadella has worked at Microsoft 30 years. This is a company that can think past the next quarter.
mkr-hn··on GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion
A sizable, possibly plurality cohort of fully adult tech people is young enough to not know about United States v. Microsoft Corp. This would explain a lot of comments I see on this topic.

If you don't know Microsoft's history, a lot of what more informed people are worried about seems overblown. Copilot was Microsoft's first test of people's trust after the GitHub acquisition. It's going very, very, very poorly. There were ways to do this with consent and collaboration with the people and projects it takes code from, but they're acting like classic Microsoft here.

Too many people are focused on what's legal. It's fine to think of, but law is the last stop before the breakdown of society. Microsoft skipped society and went straight to sparking an inevitable test of and possible reshaping of copyright law.

mkr-hn··on GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion
I highly recommend looking into the history if this really is new to you.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Cor....

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →