HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mlb_hn

726 karma · joined December 29, 2017

playing with little space aliens at julius.ai
submissionscomments
mlb_hn··on All Activities Monitored
Seems parts are a bit misleading and exaggerating capabilities. E.g.

>> Images from the cameras are in turn fed to computer programs that allow analysts to track suspects, and even to rewind to look back over their paths, like watching TiVo.

I'm pretty sure that really just means that they digitized footage and the analysts did the actual tracking manually but it reads as having good image recognition back in 2006.

mlb_hn··on The U.S. military, algorithmic warfare, and big tech
I think the disinformation you're thinking about matters [cf 0], but being able to project power to the right place at the right time requires a lot of logistical planning and material even if the information can be trusted. There are a lot of military areas where AI can inform traditional bureaucratic processes from planning to command and control [cf 1].

DOD maintains a lot of troops/bases/relationships around the world, and my guess is they want to be optimizing all of them as much as possible and be able to adapt policy to changes. Like any large organization, it's hard for the higher ups to have a good grasp on what's going on at lower echelons. They've had some pretty bad policy decisions handed to them from not being able to explain what was going on (e.g. the disbanding of the Baath party in Iraq). Being able to algorithmically integrate the information they've got and present it to policy makers has been an unsolved problem in its own right without the disinformation stuff.

[0] Whaley,B. (1982). "Toward a General Theory of Deception" https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/0140239820843710...

[1] MCDP 1. (1997). "Warfighting" https://www.marines.mil/Portals/1/Publications/MCDP%201%20Wa...

mlb_hn··on Twitter says it will restrict retweeting world leaders who break rules
Have there been any studies on how many people actually see those tweets, and of those, how many remember the content and then agree/disagree? I'm a bit unsure how data based any of these actions are.
mlb_hn··on Microsoft President: Democracy Is At Stake. Regulate Big Tech
Abramowitz and Sanders (2008)[1] is a good article showing the debate going on 10 years ago over whether or not we were even seeing polarization, which supports the possibility that tech is a spurious factor.

A really cool causal factor (e.g. Green, Palmquist, and Schicker, 2002, [2]) is the effect of civil rights and voting rights acts in the 60s. Essentially, young conservatives subsequently started primarily joining the Republican party and it took 30 years for the effects to really be visible (kind of like messing with pH levels where the color eventually just changes).

[1] http://www.acsu.buffalo.edu/~jcampbel/documents/AbramowitzJO...

[2] http://www.uvm.edu/~dguber/POLS125/articles/green.pdf

mlb_hn··on COVFEFE Act
Sadly, Library of Congress was archiving all tweets at the time. They stopped doing so later that year [1]. I don't know if it was ever resumed or not. Fortunately, tons of people are archiving that sort of thing on their own anyway :)

[1] https://blogs.loc.gov/loc/2017/12/update-on-the-twitter-arch...

mlb_hn··on Image identified as by USA 224, a classified satellite
I get that. It's complicated because no one knows what happened; did he order it declassified and they just did it poorly or was he instead saving whoever originally took it a huge deal of trouble.
mlb_hn··on Image identified as by USA 224, a classified satellite
While that's accurate, it looks like the classification markers were blacked out post picture. That's important because it indicates that they didn't go and declassify the picture on the original system to share it.

So the picture was taken, the classification markers were blacked out, and then POTUS tweeted it. We don't know the classification of the device which took the photo, the classification of the system on which the markers were blacked out, or when the decision was made to declassify the image.

mlb_hn··on Now Streaming on YouTube: Confessions from a Presidential Hit Squad in Gambia
Wharley (1982) is a great paper formalizing how militaries use deception [1]. There's a lot of combinations of tactics to use disinformation to distract from the truth beyond the chaff case.

[1] https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/0140239820843710...

mlb_hn··on U.S. Unleashes Military to Fight Fake News, Disinformation
I'm a bit confused on what sort of authorities anyone's got here or what the actual intent of the program is. Ultimately, does DOD have any sort of authorities to do anything about potential US person speech and how would that be constitutional? They have a need to understand who's doing what in various theaters, but I'm not sure why anyone would want DOD messing with content in the US.
mlb_hn··on Are spies more trouble than they're worth?
They've definitely gotten things very wrong, e.g. in 1989 Howard Schaffer, Deputy Assistant Secretary of State for South Asia, testified to Congress "“We’re confident that [the Pakistani supported Afghan Government] will be neither communist nor messianic Islamic” [1]. Then Pakistan helped the Taliban seize power in the ensuing civil war.

[1] U.S. Congress. House Committee on Foreign Affairs. (1989). Developments In Afghanistan And Their Implications For U.S. Policy. Congressional Hearing, Feb. 21, June 14, 1989.

mlb_hn··on Are spies more trouble than they're worth?
The US Army had previously pointed out a similar issue to the BBC article, where a lack of internal guidance and oversight was leading to analysis and collection of non-optimal data [1]. Just like in academia, there seems to be a bit of a tension in getting to useful predictive insights to issues.

[1] http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/Afghanistan...

mlb_hn··on Tufts Ph.D. ‘Punished’ for Reporting Adviser’s Fabricated Research: Lawsuit
For anyone having trouble with the paywall, adding a '.' after the .com and before the '/' lets you close the popup. Otherwise, disabling javascript also works.
mlb_hn··on Facebook emails show internal concerns being raised about Cambridge Analytica
David Carroll tweeted "... effects cannot be measured. There are no control groups in elections" [1]. His stake in it was getting access to his data though, not coming at it from a data science perspective. I'm not sure I agree with his assessment about it not being measurable though.

[1] https://twitter.com/profcarroll/status/1161446789850906624

mlb_hn··on The Dysfunctional Trillion-Dollar U.S. Fighter-Jet Program
I think we agree on the sourcing, just we disagree on the definition of "inside".
mlb_hn··on The Dysfunctional Trillion-Dollar U.S. Fighter-Jet Program
The current title I'm seeing is "Inside America’s Dysfunctional Trillion-Dollar Fighter-Jet Program" which seems misleading as well; it's more of a history of press releases. Doesn't look like they interviewed anyone actually working on it aside from the fellow in charge if that.
mlb_hn··on Facebook Said It Would Give Detailed Data to Academics. They’re Still Waiting
SS1 researcher responded on Twitter, https://twitter.com/SolomonMg/status/1164927631957143554.

TLDR: they've been working on building a framework to preserve privacy and then to train researchers on how to access the database. That isn't a simple process.

mlb_hn··on List of military tactics
Deepmind did a demo of it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cUTMhmVh1qs
mlb_hn··on List of military tactics
Nope, generals play politics and talk funding. Which is logistics.
mlb_hn··on MoviePass database exposes 161M records
I'm more concerned about the propaganda issue. I argued a couple years ago (heavily edited) when I left the Army that foreign actors (read: Russia) were data mining stolen data for fracture lines to amplify [0] which makes it hard to form a comprehensive list of politically relevant topics.

[0] https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/NCO-Journal/Archive...

mlb_hn··on A.I. Is Learning from Many Humans
Interesting that FT adds that first bit to copy/paste.
mlb_hn··on Could Removing Social Media Metrics Reduce Polarization?
Right before social media started to take off the academics were arguing if we were already seeing polarization [e.g. 0]. It might be worth considering whether the polarization trend changed with social media before attributing causes and potential solutions.

[0] Abramowitz, A. I., & Saunders, K. L. (2008). Is polarization a myth?. The Journal of Politics, 70(2), 542-555. http://www.acsu.buffalo.edu/~jcampbel/documents/AbramowitzJO...

mlb_hn··on Jeffrey Epstein's Death Was on 4Chan Before Officials Announced It
For those that don't read the article, someone posted about the medical response to Epstein's suicide on 4Chan before the news picked it up. A lot of people had access to that information at the time.
mlb_hn··on Major Technological Changes Are Coming More Slowly Than They Once Did
The author doesn't seem to include any metrics for how they're measuring technological changes, or am I missing that? Seems like a graph and numbers would be useful for measuring what sort of slowdown it's talking about; most of the arguments seems to be looking at what wasn't accomplished.
mlb_hn··on Trump’s paid Thiel’s Palantir $1.5B so far to build ICE’s surveillance network
While Trump's undoubtably been helping Palantir, I'm not entirely sure how much can be attributed to Trump vs. ongoing procurement issues. E.g., the military's previous analysis software was arguably vaporware [1] and should have been replaced anyway. If the government doesn't have access to decent analytical software, it runs around like a headless chicken (e.g. the wars in the middle east).

When it comes to ICE, it looks like Palantir's just integrating data from different sources. Surveillance is an issue, so the question seems to be whether the government should be able to tap into that data in the first place.

[1] https://www.businessinsider.com/palantir-is-the-killer-produ...

mlb_hn··on The Phony Patriots of Silicon Valley
I think the author might be confusing nationalism and patriotism? I'm not sure what's unpatriotic about working with other countries while recognizing that those countries have their own interests.
mlb_hn··on Are We Living in a Computer Simulation? Let’s Not Find Out
Or the flip side, if the goal of the simulation is to see how simulations react when they figure out they're in a simulation and if we decide to never try to figure out whether we're in a simulation they'll reset the simulation, that means we need to prove that we live in a simulation.
mlb_hn··on Soon only the rich will be able to escape the heat. In Iraq, it’s already so
Um, Iraq has had numerous issues not directly related to global warming in the last 40 years which might have impacted their electrical infrastructure a bit (wars, occupations, firing the government, corruption, etc.).
mlb_hn··on Instagram’s lax privacy practices let a trusted partner openly flout its rules
I'm a bit confused what the lax privacy practices are supposed to be. The stories were public and companies scraped them (IANAL but as the article even points out, hiQ vs LinkedIn seems to mean it's legal). They seem to have only scraped public posts as well.
mlb_hn··on What a deepfake video of Mark Zuckerberg reveals about how we're manipulated
Or imagine it at scale. It seems there are two uses of deepfake which have separate effects:

1) High profile low volume content that trends (article)

2) Low profile high volume content spam (your point)

The second one seems like a much harder problem than the first (but both matter). Everyone already gets dozens of spam/phishing emails and links a day and not much has been done about it. I have no idea what the impact of deepfakes on the latter even looks like.

mlb_hn··on GPT2, Counting Consciousness and the Curious Hacker
Wait a second, is Buzzfeed planning on using GPT with the article text and A/B testing to generate perfect headlines and save on overhead?
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →