HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mlinsey

5,217 karma · joined April 18, 2008

www.twitter.com/mlinsey

Engineering @ Homejoy (YC S10)

hnchat.com:8pJMixG6jypNc7WE7714

submissionscomments
mlinsey··on Pinterest, We Have a Problem
Flickr enables their users to mark their images as not-sharable, which now includes disabling anyone from sharing the images on Pinterest: http://venturebeat.com/2012/02/24/flickr-pinterest-pin/

Legally (IANAL but my understanding is), Pinterest only needs to comply with DMCA takedown requests. Instead they are being proactive and allow people to tag images as "nopin", vastly reducing the need for tedious or unreliable monitoring of Pinterest for copyrighted content, as content owners must do for almost every other sharing site. That's a good thing, and they should be applauded for it.

I suspect you might dislike the opt-out vs. opt-in nature of the nopin system, but new technologies have been accused of facilitating the death of copyright ever since the invention of the radio, but it turned out that most of those inventions created a lot of value for the world and for creators who adapt to the new medium.

mlinsey··on Justin Kan Launches Exec (YC W12) For Real-Time Mobile Jobs
The multitasking founder is an interesting emerging trend - Jack Dorsey being the most prominent example, and Steve Jobs before him. If an effective founder is the rarest commodity, and their role at mid-to-large startups can be reduced to its most essential elements, it makes a lot of economic sense.
mlinsey··on Forget $3B In Revenue: Things "Don't Look Good" For Facebook
Doesn't sound too bad at all, frankly. Someone is just trying to add a little drama to what is otherwise a big success story.

It is certainly true that usage of Facebook is rapidly shifting towards mobile, and that currently Facebook doesn't have any ads on mobile. That has got to impact revenue growth somewhat. But ads coming to Facebook mobile sometime soon is about as obvious as can be - and I'd bet on them doing it in a way that takes advantage of that platform's strengths and makes their company even stronger.

mlinsey··on France convicts Google Maps for unfair competition
Google maps includes sponsored locations when you search for things on the map.

Are we going to also prosecute Google for providing free web search, making it impossible to make a competing search engine that charges users 10 Euro cents per query?

mlinsey··on How to Be Relentlessly Resourceful [a practical guide]
That's a valid perspective, and one that can help you become a world-class specialist. Entrepreneurship, however, very much requires you to be a generalist. There are just too many areas to consider: fundraising, hacking, product design, user acquisition, recruiting, leading a team, product management, marketing, PR, accounting... Zero entrepreneurs are well trained in every one of these areas before doing a startup. Entrepreneurship is about trying to learn how to do something new, unfamiliar, and unpleasant every day. This requires focusing on your weaknesses, even in areas you aren't inherently passionate about.

You certainly don't have to be a generalist to be successful - world-class specialists add much more value to the world than the median entrepreneur. But you do have to be a generalist to be a successful entrepreneur, and it's in that context of entrepreneurship that you should evaluate Jason's post and PG's essay on resourcefulness.

mlinsey··on Codecademy Partners With The White House
In general, press for early stage startups is something you get because you work hard at it, have an effective strategy to get it, and (sometimes) have the resources to hire help to get it. In this way it is not unlike achieving success in other parts of building a startup. Very little of it is the press looking at all of the companies in the space and blessing the ones they deem best.

PG wrote an essay on this topic that's somewhat old but still on-point: http://paulgraham.com/submarine.html

Edit: That said, I'd add that I disagree that there is nothing new or special about the Codecademy product vs. it's competitors. I'm not sure I really understand why it's better myself, but I have certainly seen it inspire and click well with more new coders than other such sites, so there's probably something I'm missing specifically because I'm not a beginner.

mlinsey··on How Rick Santorum Is Making His "Google Problem" Worse
I think the only problem here is that Google isn't updating fast enough to reflect an increased interest in Santorum the person.

When you say: I think his politics are repugnant, but less than 1% of Google search queries for his name are looking for Dan Savage's prank.

I am sure this is true today but I think it was definitely not true a month ago, and a year ago the opposite would probably be true. The difference between this and other Google bombs is that people really do the word Santorum in everyday conversation. (Well, perhaps not 'everyday', but definitely in contexts unconnected to Google search results and with the alternate definition of the term in mind.) I would expect that most people searching for "Santorum" before 2011 probably heard the word in that context and are wondering what it means.

mlinsey··on How Dropbox Became The Startup Steve Jobs Wished To Own – with Drew Houston
"To people on HN it's a huge plus, but to real world users..."

I think the opposite. If HN readers tastes' are similar to the average founder in the Valley, they are vastly more likely to use Macs and iPhones together than the average real world user, who is much more likely to use Windows/iOS or Windows/Android.

mlinsey··on Parents of overweight children don't know their children are overweight
This is true, but overcomplicating things for most people. You'd have to be a serious bodybuilder to get to the "obese" range of the BMI chart and have that be healthy. The density of muscle is higher than fat but not so much higher (1.06 g/L vs. .9 g/L) to be able to get you to obese levels without looking like a pro wrestler.

The lower half of the "overweight" range is more ambiguous, but statistically speaking the health risks for this range are much less as well (and some studies have determined people in that range to be on average healthier than those in the normal range, perhaps because it includes more physically active people with more muscle). But if your BMI is at a level associated with severe physical health risks (30+ and especially 35+), it's unlikely that muscles are the explanation unless that's obvious.

mlinsey··on Apple television rumored to come in 3 sizes, including 32" and 55"
I agree 4K is too far out to be realistic for an Apple TV released next year, but in general it's a common Apple strategy to essentially finance the production of a new component and buy up the entire production capacity for that component, so that sometimes even the vendor selling it to Apple can't use it for their own product. We've seen them do this sort of thing with Samsung a few times, just to pick one example.
mlinsey··on How to lose time and money
The first couple YC batches were small enough that the money invested was probably a very small portion of what PG/Robert/Trevor earned from Viaweb.

For later batches, it had become evident that YC's model was promising, and YC also raised money from outside LP's.

mlinsey··on Zynga Chief Seeks to Claw Back Stock
Anytime you have both vesting schedules and at-will employment, your employer can fire you at any time and you will not get any unvested stock. Startups need to do this all the time when employees are underperforming or a bad fit. Renegotiating so that you can get a portion of that stock and stay employed is perhaps, if this were an isolated incident, a much better deal for the employee than getting fired.

Where this becomes very distasteful is if these aren't isolated incidents of very underperforming employees but Zynga using its leverage to negotiate compensation down arbitrarily. Even if a developer is performing just as well as expected upon hiring, it is unlikely that they could get a guaranteed offer of $1M from another company, and so Zynga could easily force a renegotiation of an unvested grant worth $5M down to $1M. This would be reprehensible - even if that employee isn't really adding $5M worth of value, if they are performing up to the expectations that were set when they were hired then the agreement should be honored - getting a chance of a huge upside is one of the reasons employees take lower salaries and work longer hours at startups in the first place. A company that abused its bargaining position like this should not expect to be able to hire good employees in the future.

There isn't really enough information in the article to know that this latter case is what's happening. There are scenarios in which this behavior is very malicious, and scenarios in which it's relatively reasonable. It all hinges on how the employees in question were performing and how common this tactic is. I don't think anybody here knows those details, so we should really try and avoid the typical internet rush-to-judgement here. I don't know anything about the internals of Zynga, but I have seen HN get out the pitchforks for other companies when the real story turned out to be much more mundane.

mlinsey··on Incoming: A Native Gmail iPhone App. Finally.
I'm so dependent on Gmail-specific features that aren't in The mail app that I use the Gmail mobile web interface exclusively, despite the drastically decreased responsiveness from using a web app. This will be a breath of fresh air.
mlinsey··on Grub with YC alumni
This page was sent out to a bunch of YC founders before posting it here. Just scanning the list I see at least two YC alumni (and usually three or more) at every meal except for La Fiesta, where it's apparently just me so far!
mlinsey··on The Jobs book
Kottke was one of Jobs' friends at Reed, then later traveled with him to India and also was one of Apple's first employees, helping to assemble computers in the garage. He stayed with Apple for eight years.

The story Winer is referring to is how Kottke never got any stock options. According to Isaacson's book, Jobs refused to even talk to him about the issue, instead brushing him off and steering him toward other execs who told him that as a technician he was ineligible for any options.

Eventually, Wozniak ended up giving Kottke some of his own options.

mlinsey··on Apple’s Earnings Fall Below Street Expectations
Impressive that iPhone sales, despite dipping vs. the previous quarter, were actually up 21% year-over-year. The year-ago quarter was the iPhone 4's launch quarter. If I'm remembering correctly, the iPhone 4 was supply-constrained around launch but could be found in stores somewhat easily by the end of August 2010.

Undoubtedly the presence of the Verizon iPhone accounts for most of this difference, but it's still very impressive that the iPhone 4 had many more sales in its last quarter (as the flagship phone) than its launch quarter.

mlinsey··on Start-ups hit Cash Crunch in Silicon Valley
Those numbers being off just by a factor of "only" 10-50X (which I think is reasonable given Compete's record) would make a big difference for a B2B site. Even more important from the perspective of a startup would be the presence of an upward trend - and with Compete, I've seen their estimate for our traffic fall by over 50% in months where we grew by around 40%.

I'm pretty sure for a "decent sample" - at least, accurate enough for the data to be useful for anything - you need to be at least a top 100 site, and even then I've heard stuff from a couple webmasters of those sites that Compete data is off by an order of magnitude or so.

mlinsey··on Start-ups hit Cash Crunch in Silicon Valley
I don't have access to Indinero's data, but for my own startup, Compete's data is no more accurate than a random number generator. Both the absolute numbers and the shape of the graph have essentially zero resemblance to the real data.
mlinsey··on Spotify now requires a Facebook account to sign up.
This isn't really about the main thrust of your argument, but I wanted to address this:

What would be the end result of this? On a particularly music-filled day I might send 100+ posts about songs I've listen to? Really? People will ever look at that? If it's part of the main news feed, it's spam. If it's not, nobody cares... except Facebook, who can mine such data

Perhaps the key mechanism for new Open Graph developers to present their content in the news feed (and thus take advantage of the distribution possibilities there) is through aggregations. The workflow for signing up to be an Open Graph Developer actually makes you create one. What this means is that while there will be hundreds of posts from your friends about listening to songs in the Ticker, the news feed will have something like "10 of your friends listened to Foster the People today!", which actually happened to me yesterday and was actually the first time I had heard about that band. One click allowed me to listen to them on Spotify. I ended up finding a new band I liked through my friends, and I used Spotify a little bit more. So there are use cases here that can work really well, with aggregation making the volume of content that comes from autosharing more manageable.

mlinsey··on Poll: Facebook usage
Not quite. More like, instead of pressing the 'like' button on each story you want to share, there will be a "share what I read on FB" button which acts like a switch-it doesn't start sharing until you opt-in, but then it shares everything automatically until you turn it off.
mlinsey··on Google Flight Search
Were those Southwest flights? I think SWA doesn't let any of the aggregators display prices for their flights - I was pleasantly surprised that I saw Southwest flights at all.
mlinsey··on Icon Ambulance
Exactly, this is a perfect application of Jobs' quote from the '80s about how a carpenter wouldn't put a piece of plywood on the back of a cabinet, even it was just going to face the wall.
mlinsey··on Can’t Wait (YC S11) is a mobile social network for movie trailers
YC has always preached launching as soon as possible, which means that upon launch you'll only get a tiny hint of a startup's future ambitions.

I actually think the way forward is a little bit more obvious for this one. Without even talking to the founders or seeing their pitch, you should be able to think of a number of interesting directions. To pick the most obvious one, wouldn't being the IMDB of the mobile/social era be pretty cool? Is that even really "niche"?

mlinsey··on On Safety: A Word From Airbnb
this has taken too long for this to happen. If you note in EJ's post, she states that she would not be compensated for any damages and she was on the hook. Airbnb didn't step up to the plate until it was posted on Techcrunch.

Is this really the case? EJ's post from June says this in the fifth paragraph: "They have offered to help me recover emotionally and financially". I cannot find anything in her original post that contradicts that. Can you point me to a paragraph number and sentence where you are getting the info that she originally would not be compensated?

The only source for the idea that EJ would not be compensated seems to be the original TC article from today. That was sourced from a company spokesperson who was citing policy, and was contradicted by Chesky's post here. Given the original blog post, it seems a lot more probable that this is a detail that TC (and Airbnb's spokesperson) got wrong, not that Airbnb changed their mind.

mlinsey··on Google Plus: Tagging automatically shares private photos
I'm with you. This is how it works on Facebook and I suspect this is how the majority of people expect it to work. Not only that, this is not only the behavior I expect but the behavior I want. I suppose it might be OK with me if someone tagged me in a photo that was private just to the person who took it.

But it would be a huge, huge problem if someone could tag me in a photo and share it to some circles that didn't include me. Fake-tagging people or tagging people in embarrassing photos is a major problem on FB, and the privacy issue here goes two ways: the person you tagged also has their own privacy concerns. What if you tagged an embarrassing photo of me, shared it with a circle of hundreds of co-workers (that you excluded me from), and then not only do I not know the picture is out there, but co-workers can see it by visiting my profile and looking at pictures tagged of me? That would be orders of magnitude worse than the status quo.

I'm trying to think of how you design a system that respects both my concerns and those of the OP, and I can't come up with anything that would be intuitive. (Suppose that you could tag an album full of people and keep it private to yourself, but sharing it with a family circle caused it to also be shared with everyone you tagged? That really would break user expectations). I think the current implementation might be the best one, perhaps with more of a warning in the UI that tagging shares with the person tagged. In essence this is not a privacy complaint, it's a feature request: people want to use tags for a different purpose (organizing private albums) than they are designed for.

mlinsey··on On Succeeding Steve Jobs
I agree with Gruber's analysis, but one part that worries me is the idea of having each SVP accountable for product decisions for their own area. I think that so much of Apple's advantages stem from hardware and software that are designed with each other in mind, that it would be much better to have a single person be SVP Product Design under Cook, so that there was always someone responsible for the entire cohesive user experience. Unfortunately, choosing such a person for this role among the three product SVP's that Gruber names is itself a very difficult political problem, and any choice could result in other talent leaving.
mlinsey··on Dropbox Raising Massive Round at a $5B-Plus Valuation
From the link: "For 18 of the top 21 I used the postmoney valuation of the most recent funding round. The other 3 had grown significantly since their last round, and to estimate the values of those I used the opinions of independent experts and the valuations of the funding offers they are currently receiving."
mlinsey··on Dropbox Raising Massive Round at a $5B-Plus Valuation
Yes, but as explained in the post, that's a decent estimation for the value of the whole portfolio (of the 210 companies through S10).

This is because startup valuations follow a power law, which among other things means that almost all of the value in a portfolio will be in the top 10%. This round of funding is a good example of that principle - if TC is correct, then even among the top 21 companies, a majority of the value will be in the top single company.

mlinsey··on Ask HN: Questions to Ask Before Joining a Startup
When you join a startup, you are trading potential salary (from a big company) for equity. That means you're making an investment, and you should ask all the normal questions an investor would ask: what is the company vision, what's the background of the founders, has the team demonstrated an ability to execute, how big is the market, how does the startup shape up vs. it's competitors, what is the current funding situation, etc.

On top of that, you still should ask all the questions you would of any employer: about the work, making sure you get along with the team, stuff like that.

mlinsey··on Dropbox Raising Massive Round at a $5B-Plus Valuation
41 days ago, PG's estimation for the sum of the value of all YC companies was 4.7 billion. http://ycombinator.com/nums.html

Congrats to Drew, Arash, and the whole Dropbox team.

(Ordinarily I would say that giving congratulations before a deal is confirmed as closed is a jinx, but at this point there is no such thing as jinxing Dropbox. Their ultimate success, whether this report is true or not, is inevitable.)

← PreviousPage 7 of 22Next →