HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mmcclure

4,503 karma · joined January 21, 2013

Co-founder of Mux (YC W16). Software developer and organizer of video community things (Demuxed, SF Video Technology). You can find me on Twitter @matt_mcclure

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/mmcc; my proof: https://keybase.io/mmcc/sigs/2TecG4FqAN88M5UaETYwdA4JegapEYa3ojaIrONVVDo ]

submissionscomments
mmcclure··on Homeschooling hits record numbers
Yes, it was extremely clear that your position is that it’s overfunded.

    OK, so we agree SFUSD is not underfunded?
No, we don’t, I just wasn’t trying to make that point. There’s absolutely debates to be had about SFUSD, including how they spend their budget (personally I would make big cuts at the central office and redistribute to the schools), but the thought that $28k/kid is too much in SF just isn’t grounded in reality.

    two thirds of students are behind grade level in math, and there's no opportunity to be grouped with kids in other grades.
This type of broad statement is true, but also obscures the realities of the student population SFUSD is mandated to serve. That high level number includes special education, non-English speakers, etc. Generally speaking, the data for kids with a similar socioeconomic background to the one I suspect your kids have are doing fine in SFUSD, particularly in K-8.

For example, a low key popular school with “bad scores,” Flynn[1]. ~30% of the student population met or exceeded the standard for math. That number jumps to 65.4% for kids with college-educated parents, and 81.3% for grad school. Race is an unfortunate proxy here, but it’s 70.8% for white students.

Not trying to convince you to send your kid to public school, of course, just calling out that there’s nuance required when comparing outcomes and what can work for families.

[1] https://caaspp-elpac.ets.org/caaspp/DashViewReportSB?ps=true...

mmcclure··on Homeschooling hits record numbers

    My original point in this subthread was that SFUSD is NOT underfunded. Do you believe it IS underfunded?
Your original point was not that it's "not underfunded," it was that it's overfunded (and substantially so, based on other comments). Your top(ish) comment on this thread to the $28k per student average:

    I'm saying it's a lot.
My only argument here is that I don't think $28k is unreasonable, particularly when viewed against the cost of private alternatives.

    then that would rule out almost all SFUSD schools, which kind of defeats the point of the discussion!
We go to our attendance area SFUSD school and love it. There are plenty of SFUSD and private schools that would not be on our list, be it for academic reasons or logistical.

    I made a tool to do that
Cool, I dig it! Annoying, unsolicited feature request would be to allow addresses or zip codes rather than requiring geolocation :)
mmcclure··on Homeschooling hits record numbers
And, it's worth noting, the uh...deselection process. Private schools can kick kids out, public schools cannot.
mmcclure··on Homeschooling hits record numbers

    I was generous in my estimate for each of the line items. I chose a one room school house as an example because it's easy to grok, and anything larger would be cheaper due to economies of scale.
I would argue that economies of scale don't apply to education in the same way they apply to other businesses at large. Sure, you theoretically get the benefits of scale with central organization, buildings, centralized services, etc, but once you get to the classrooms themselves most of the cost simply scales linearly with the number of students.

    This $28k number is false. Most parochial schools charge about $12k.
I'm not sure what we're talking about here anymore. You're using K-8 as the dominating factor for this gotcha a few times in this thread. There are more K-8 parochial schools, yes. "Most parochial schools charge about $12k" is true, unless you're talking about high school. Exactly 1 parochial school is less than $30k (SF Christian, at $16k). From there (limited to religious schools):

    - Sacred Heart ($31k)
    - Archbishop Riordan ($32k)
    - Saint Ignatius ($34.6)
    - Sacred Heart ($60k) 
    - Jewish Community School ($65k)
I might have missed some in here since I'm going by names, but given that SF Christian is the cheapest private high school on SF Chronicle's list[1] I don't think that matters for my point.

You started this thread with average cost per student across all SF public school students, which includes special needs, high school, etc, but move to median prices for debate, and structure most of your argument around the cheapest schools (K-8). Mea culpa on my end, though: you are correct that when I was saying "cheapest I've seen," there was an unfair modifier of "cheapest schools on my personal spreadsheet" which is limited to schools within a reasonable commute and that we'd be willing to send our kids to. You're absolutely correct that there are cheaper parochial schools available as long as you only need K-8.

Using averages for private schools, which feels more applicable to your starting premise, private schools in SF average $27k, $28k, and $52k, for elementary, middle, and high school (again, referencing SF Chronicle's data). I still feel comfortable with my original premise that averaging $28k per student across all of SFUSD students is not an absurd number.

    So looking at the sticker prices (which I've listed above) may give an inflated view of total income.
Sure, that's fair! But we're not talking about income, we're talking about average cost per kid. We can't actually know the details under the hood, but again, those schools specifically in your list are usually subsidized by a larger religious organization, so the sticker price doesn't truly reflect that cost anyway.

[1] https://www.sfchronicle.com/projects/2025/sf-bay-area-privat...

mmcclure··on Homeschooling hits record numbers
I think your reasoning is flawed, but fine...if the goal is to try and have the cheapest possible one room school house. That $200k gets eaten up pretty quick by things like security, janitorial, building maintenance, support staff like principals, librarians, guidance counselors etc etc. If you’re meaning to include total cost for the full time employees (the teachers) in the list, then the salaries are a lot less attractive once you’re done covering benefits, etc.

I've got multiple kids, so I'll admit I think about schools here a lot. The absolute cheapest private schools I've seen in San Francisco are subsidized by religious institutions. The tuition for those schools per child is roughly $28k. Non religious private schools usually start in the $40k range and can easily get into the $50s and well beyond.

My point is that it's hard to point at some issue of inefficient public bureaucracy, because clearly private institutions aren't able to do it any cheaper. I would also argue they wouldn't try, because their goal is a good education, or at least better than the public alternative (that only spends $28k per kid).

mmcclure··on Homeschooling hits record numbers
Are you saying that's a lot or a little? Tuition for most (non-religious) competitive private schools in San Francisco is easily twice that amount.
mmcclure··on Gold Prices Top $4k for First Time
I think this is overall fair/accurate in terms of crash fatigue, but crypto has crashed by 85+% multiple times in the last decade. I'm not sure that's the best proof point in this list of things that don't actually happen.
mmcclure··on Show HN: WeUseElixir - Elixir project directory
I’m not sure I’m following. Gleam is inspired by Elm in a lot of ways, and the major draw over Elixir would be the Elm-inspired type system, but Gleam is still a language not a web framework (which Elm is not either, since it only targets clients afaik).
mmcclure··on Show HN: WeUseElixir - Elixir project directory
> Gleam takes inspiration from Elm, so if that's your thing and something you'd consider using, probably go with that rather than Phoenix. Again, if your team can handle it.

I think you meant Elixir there, not Phoenix?

mmcclure··on Help us raise $200k to free JavaScript from Oracle
I agree that Oracle has been a perfectly fine trademark holder in all of these regards in that they are entirely irrelevant to JavaScript and have been for as long as I can remember.

The point here is that them not doing those things would be codified. Deno's not trying to take the trademark from them for themselves, they're trying to get the USPTO to agree that JavaScript is a generic term at this point and unable to be trademarked or owned by any one entity.

I'm not sure how that changes any of the bullet points you've got above. It's nice that points 4 and 5 would become completely impossible and not just improbable because the trademark owner currently doesn't care enough to do it.

mmcclure··on FFglitch, FFmpeg fork for glitch art
Not a lot of info on the page about the process, etc, but this is also called "datamoshing." If you're curious, there's a great talk from Demuxed '21 on some of the details: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qtia43DGSrY
mmcclure··on Our data shows San Francisco tech workers are working Saturdays
Is that the case? The main chart they're showing is specifically showing change in behavior from a previous time period.

> Change is equal to the difference between hourly share in 2024 and 2025 from January through August.

mmcclure··on Areal, Are.na's new typeface
No one said they were, I don't even think this font is available for use outside of are.na's product. This is about craft.

I think they said it pretty well themselves:

    With Areal, Dinamo designed an updated version of Arial especially suited for Are.na, but which still honors the original. Stem thicknesses were streamlined, more characters added (), a monospace version drawn, dark mode functionality optimized. You probably wouldn’t have noticed these changes if you hadn’t read this statement. It’s possible you still won’t. But to us (Are.na and Dinamo) Areal’s existence is satisfying in the way that rewriting an entire front-end is satisfying. As stated in this text block from 5 years ago, “the reason you would create something is because you love it enough to see it exist.”
mmcclure··on Areal, Are.na's new typeface
It's a product whose largest cohort is designers or design-minded people. Them focusing on that as part of the product itself feels like a perfectly good use of their time.
mmcclure··on Build durable workflows with Postgres
Just curious, if you’re already in Elixir and using Postgres, why not use Oban[1]? It’s my absolute favorite background job library, and the thing I often miss most when working in other ecosystems.

[1] https://github.com/oban-bg/oban

mmcclure··on U.S. senators introduce new pirate site blocking bill, "Block BEARD"
Most of the collection is DVD and/or Blu-ray, but he's got some VHS tapes and video games across a few platforms. When he was giving me the spiel about joining he was explicit that he doesn't have any Laserdisc or Betamax, though.
mmcclure··on U.S. senators introduce new pirate site blocking bill, "Block BEARD"
I recently joined a local independent video rental store and it's so, so good. My partner looked at me like I was crazy when I told her, but she was a convert after one trip to pick out a movie in person.

Something about browsing in person is just so much more enjoyable than flipping between 9 services. Having a cinephile right there behind the desk that wants to nerd about movies and help pick something out is awesome. It's not a big store, but they've got thousands of movies in their catalog, which is (apparently) way bigger than any of the streaming services.

This doesn't solve your problem, but for the folks that are near the few remaining physical rental stores: consider supporting them, because they're great.

Edit: Actually, on the "your problem" part...maybe give the store a call? Looks like he'll mail discs too: https://myvideowave.weebly.com/services.html

mmcclure··on Vanilla JavaScript support for Tailwind Plus
I love seeing a mainstream/popular project embracing web components. We've been working on a web components project for media players[1] for a while for the same reasons:

    Instead of being coupled to a specific JavaScript framework, these custom elements work anywhere you can use a <script> tag
But...React is still the elephant in the room here. Maybe TW is just in a different world if they're truly just anticipating folks using this via a `<script>` tag, but if not, very curious how they're going to deal with some of the web component (WC) stuff we've dealt with, like:

- Despite signals/promises, React 19 didn't add full support for WC. React uses a diff algorithm for reconciliation. There are some rough edges for any "complex value" cases in the incomplete solution for 19's WC support with client vs server side rendering. This results in us being required to use 'use client' for parts of our component architectures, meaning WC providers aren't able to take full advantage of SSR.

- WCs are async loading, which in combination with React can have a negative impact on performance for things like core web vitals (and the dreaded cumulative layout shift).

- WCs are just different from React patterns. Each WC creates a DOM element, but React components don't have to, which just inherently means different shapes of code.

- React focus management libraries don't play nice with WCs. We've talked to multiple devs/companies that were excited about/using WCs that backed out because of cross-ecosystem complexities like this.

- React Native is, uh....a whole thing.

On a somewhat separate note...one of my complaints about TW historically has been that it feels like "just classes" (great!), yet requires a build step (oh...). I'm a little confused to see them leaning into `<script>` tags given that, so am I just missing something?

[1] https://github.com/muxinc/media-chrome

mmcclure··on Developing our position on AI
Some students treat AI like those things. Others are effectively a meat proxy for AI. Both ends of the spectrum would call themselves "AI fluent."

I don't think the existence of the latter should mean we restrict access to AI for everyone, but I also don't think it's helpful to pretend AI is just this generation's TI-83.

mmcclure··on Ask HN: Is HN slowly starting to experience enshitification?
I truly do not ask this to be pedantic or snarky, but “enshitification” is a very specific type of platform decay related to business models. How does that apply here?
mmcclure··on A Supermarket Bag and a Truckload of FOMO
Yeah, I've been a fairly vocal curmudgeon about Tailwind within my team. Some folks really like it. They're doing the work and I trust them, so I rolled with it.

I still have qualms with Tailwind. My classic CSS sensibilities are offended, but whatever. The part that I still don't like is really what this post boils down to: a massively complex build system that creates footguns in the weirdest places.

That being said, Tailwind that's set up well in coordination with a complex design system really does feel like it's a win. Seeing that in action was an aha moment where I was able to see value that made some of the tradeoffs worth it.

mmcclure··on Volkswagen reintroducing physical controls for vital functions
> In 5 years of daily driving I rarely used Tesla’s maps and opted for my phone connected via Bluetooth.

> IDK perhaps you haven't used Tesla, but carplay just is incredibly inferior.

Necromancy here, but I'd missed this earlier. If it wasn't clear in my comment somehow, I was referring to driving my Tesla daily for 5 years. It is interesting that I have the exact same feeling about the iPhone vs Nokia argument, but opposite: the switch to CarPlay from Tesla's infotainment was hands down the biggest upgrade of our new car.

mmcclure··on Volkswagen reintroducing physical controls for vital functions
> CarPlay maps are garbage.

What? The benefit of CarPlay is that I can use my map app of choice. Apple Maps, Google Maps, Waze, whatever. In 5 years of daily driving I rarely used Tesla’s maps and opted for my phone connected via Bluetooth.

mmcclure··on Volkswagen reintroducing physical controls for vital functions
I overall liked our Model Y, but the infotainment/touch screen situation was my biggest complaint.

We recently switched to an ID Buzz because our family outgrew the Y. The interior is a huge improvement over the Y (which, fair, it is a more expensive vehicle) and CarPlay is just objectively better than Tesla’s infotainment, but the rest of the software is pretty meh. I really miss a lot of little things like phone keys and a built in dash cam, though.

mmcclure··on Apple Invites
It feels like everyone's talking past each other in a big way on this thread. You don't need an Apple Device to participate in one of these events. At most you might need an iCloud account, which, (imo) is pretty much the same as Meta and crew.

Unrelated to that point, as other posters have called out, folks pretty consistently overstate the cost of Apple hardware relative to peers. You can spend $800 on a new iPhone 16, the latest release, or half that on an iPhone SE. Both of these options are available right now on Apple.com. This feels like saying you'd need to spend $1000+ on an Android because that's how much the newest Pixel costs.

mmcclure··on Genetic repair via CRISPR can inadvertently introduce other defects
Yeah, better analogy, but still a little flawed because that still makes it seem much better/precise than it is. It's "find and replace all" that might:

- occasionally match very similar, but not exact text

- will often subtly alter the text around the replacement area, either by deleting characters or altering others.

mmcclure··on Genetic repair via CRISPR can inadvertently introduce other defects
This is the "ethically fraught" bit I was referencing. Once this genie is out of the bottle and into the gene pool, there's effectively no moral/ethical path to putting it back in.
mmcclure··on Genetic repair via CRISPR can inadvertently introduce other defects
A lot of the graphics that explain how CRISPR work show this very careful snipping of a strand of DNA. Tiny little scissors making pinpoint accuracy revisions. I think that's lead to a deep misunderstanding for most people (including myself) on how this technology actually works.

CRISPR is amazing, but it's still a fairly blunt tool. The article talks about one way: guide RNA can often bind to sequences that are very similar to the intended sequence, but not exactly, meaning it's probable that for every intended cut you're making several unintended ones. The "scissor" action itself, Cas9 protein, is less like a scissor cut and more like a jagged tear, which can damage surrounding DNA.

The repair pathways themselves are also imperfect. It's not a copy/paste like infographics show, it's more like emergency duct taping broken ends together.

All of that stuff combined...Again, amazing technology, but I get extremely nervous when I hear people talk about introducing CRISPR-based gene editing into the human gene pool. The generational effects there are still entirely unpredictable at this stage, could be disastrous, and any actual paths to trying to roll things back would be deeply ethically fraught.

mmcclure··on Show HN: Winamp and other media players, rebuilt for the web with Web Components
Ahh ok, I see your point. I'll open an issue on the repo to track this, makes sense to me! Either way, helps to really drive the point home that "it's just a normal media element in a slot."
mmcclure··on Show HN: Winamp and other media players, rebuilt for the web with Web Components
Thank you for the feedback! I'm not quite sure I'm following, though. By the wizard do you mean the framework/element picker within a theme? Would you want the wizard there to be something where you can put in a URL for a subtitle track and we'll add it to the generated tag?

If you're seeing something weird around subtitle syntax then there's probably a documentation issue somewhere (or I'm misunderstanding your question). Subtitles themselves should work with a standard `<track>` in the media element, and the only other place we touch them is via the captions button/menu to toggle those tracks.

← PreviousPage 2 of 12Next →