HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mmcclure

4,503 karma · joined January 21, 2013

Co-founder of Mux (YC W16). Software developer and organizer of video community things (Demuxed, SF Video Technology). You can find me on Twitter @matt_mcclure

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/mmcc; my proof: https://keybase.io/mmcc/sigs/2TecG4FqAN88M5UaETYwdA4JegapEYa3ojaIrONVVDo ]

submissionscomments
mmcclure··on Show HN: Winamp and other media players, rebuilt for the web with Web Components
This was one where we almost didn't include it because it's pretty impractical, but...I still love it. Yes, 100% fun.

If people actually like it we should take a performance pass. In our defense, we at least switched out the original bmp files from the first pass we took at hacking this together.

mmcclure··on AI chatbots are banned from our docs for now
LLMs definitely make "mistakes". It's well-documented by both users and the providers themselves. Even if 5-10% of questions get a hallucination that sends someone down a totally wrong path, that's too much. It's a really high bar, to be clear, but an important one imo.
mmcclure··on How I won $2,750 using JavaScript, AI, and a can of WD-40
I'm not even sure I agree that that one piece renders the entire blog post useless. The process is all there, just because the author didn't share a list of contests doesn't mean someone couldn't do their own research and replicate it.
mmcclure··on Video with Alpha Transparency on the Web
I feel this, and not even in a situation that had complex transparency needs. I went down a path that needed the surrounding background perfectly matched to the video background, and it ended up being easier to render the video to a canvas, get the rendered pixel value, and update the surrounding background. Still necessary even knowing what the video background color should be given browser differences in rendering the video’s color. Prompted a fun conversation internally, though[1].

[1] https://www.mux.com/blog/your-browser-and-my-browser-see-dif...

mmcclure··on Launch HN: Stack Auth (YC S24) – An Open-Source Auth0/Clerk Alternative
If I'm going to reach for a 3rd party auth provider like this, I want to be able to use it across all of my potential properties. For example a Discourse forum, or a Shopify store, etc.
mmcclure··on Launch HN: Stack Auth (YC S24) – An Open-Source Auth0/Clerk Alternative
Looks nice, congratulations on the launch!

I suspect the answer is "no" here, but can Stack be used as an OAuth provider itself? I think all I see in the documentation is using other OAuth providers for authentication.

mmcclure··on Bring crypto back to currency
> The ideal currency has a constant, predictable 2-4% inflation to promote the velocity of money and prevent stagnation.

I always liked this idea, and I a few cryptocurrencies/blockchains tried to do something like it, including Stellar Lumens[1]. Just looked it up to post this and they abandoned it back in 2019.

    Unlike the tokens of other blockchains, lumens aren’t mined or awarded by the protocol over time. Instead, 100 billion lumens were created when the Stellar network went live, and for the first 5 or so years of Stellar’s existence, the supply of lumens also increased by 1% annually, by design.
     
    That inflation mechanism was ended by community vote in October 2019. And in November 2019, the overall lumen supply was reduced. Now there are about 50 billion lumens, total, in existence, and no more lumens will be created.
[1] https://stellar.org/learn/lumens
mmcclure··on Show HN: A personalised AI tutor with < 1s voice responses
Super cool idea. I think it might be getting the hug of death right now because even once I got in I never seem to get a connected bot.
mmcclure··on Tesla Q2 2024 Update [pdf]
Are you referring to Audi's EVs? Or Audi in general?

Either way, looked it up out of curiosity: Audi's parent company, Volkswagen, currently has a market cap of ~58B EUR with revenue over 300B EUR in 2023. Tesla has a market cap of $772B with revenue just under $100B in 2023.

Tesla's stock is trading (and has) at a staggering multiple for the automotive industry. It's fair to call out that their competitors may have their own struggles, but negative growth in Tesla's primary product line is going to make it increasingly tough for investors to stomach that premium.

Elon has a gift for selling a vision, so I certainly wouldn't bet against Tesla on any short-term horizon, but I struggle to imagine that alone will be able to carry their stock price in perpetuity.

mmcclure··on Show HN: I made a Note-Taking app for people who keep texting themselves
This is my flow too. I know it’s silly, but 90% of why I pay for premium is just for the tags in my saved notes messages.
mmcclure··on Run Chromium on Vercel without external services
I went to their org and thought, "well there's the repo right there," but you're right, it's just a README with a link to binaries. https://github.com/chromium-for-lambda/chromium-binaries

Started to make sense when I checked the website and their business model is charging for updated Chrome binaries: https://pro.chromiumforlambda.org/

mmcclure··on Moaan InkPalm Plus is weird, cheap, small, and my kind of e-reader
My partner makes fun of me for always turning the page with my nose and it makes me very happy to hear I’m not alone.

I use the physical buttons if I’m reading on a plane or otherwise sitting down, but I much prefer holding the kindle from the back if I’m reading lying down. I assumed that must be rare given how little attention any of the e-reader form factors have given to it.

mmcclure··on Show HN: Voice bots with 500ms response times
Wow, Kwin, you’ve outdone yourself! The speed makes an even bigger difference than I expected going in.

Feels pretty wild/cool to say it might almost be too fast (in terms of feeling natural).

mmcclure··on Show HN: I built a JavaScript-powered flipdisc display
> Keeping low numer of controllers on one data line, allows to drive these displays with an increadible speed of 15 frames per second (black – to – white).

From Alfazeta's page (including the typos). 15 frames per second feels pretty wild, but would also, unfortunately, change this math pretty considerably if you ran it full tilt.

mmcclure··on NodeSwift: Bridge Node.js and Swift
This has already been corrected, but just calling out a bullet from the feature section:

> Cross-platform: NodeSwift works not only on macOS, but also on Linux, Windows, and even iOS!

Now I'm curious about the iOS bit. Is that intended for React Native?

mmcclure··on Assembly
Seems like it, the footer has a note that it’s “inspired by Core War”
mmcclure··on FTX Has Billions More Than Needed to Pay Bankruptcy Victims
It all goes to the creditors + interest.

> Although all debts will be paid in full, plus interest, nothing will be leftover for equity holders

> Depending on the type of claim they hold in the case, some creditors could recover as much as 142% of what they are owed. The vast majority of customers, however, will likely get 118% of what they had on the FTX platform the day the company entered Chapter 11 bankruptcy.

mmcclure··on Ask HN: Best tool for detecting porn or abusive image
I've used Hive[1] for this and have had quite a bit of success. It's what we use for automated moderation of stream.new.

Lately I've had a solid experience using Replicate for specific models depending on what I want to do.

[1]: https://thehive.ai

mmcclure··on Facebook just updated its relationship status with Web Components
I'm not following, what makes a poorly written React component better than a poorly written web component?
mmcclure··on Why are video players on the web so big?
Browsers' native players work great! ...if your video needs are extremely naive/limited. If you want to support modern streaming protocols like HLS and DASH, or really do anything whatsoever but play back a subset of mp4s, you're out of luck.
mmcclure··on The Stainless SDK Generator
There are open source generators for a ton of languages[1]! We've been reasonably happy with their output for ~5 SDKs over the last few years. We did a massive writeup on our experience at the time[2].

In the end...ongoing maintenance there was still enough of a pain that we made the decision to outsource it. For just one or two SDKs I think we probably would have kept going with it, though.

[1] https://github.com/OpenAPITools/openapi-generator

[2] https://www.mux.com/blog/an-adventure-in-openapi-v3-api-code...

mmcclure··on The Stainless SDK Generator
We're in the process of (slowly) switching our SDKs over to Stainless. I'll be transparent that it hasn't been the easiest/quickest process ever, but the biggest pain point so far is that we were forced to clean up some rough spots around our OpenAPI spec. It was something we needed to do anyway, so definitely not a knock on Stainless, but it did take the first SDK rollout from being a month or two to many months.

The biggest reason we started working with Stainless was to migrate from the open source generator process we were struggling with, but actually ended up transitioning our hand-rolled Node/JS SDK first because it's both our most popular SDK and because the fragmentation of the JS ecosystem has been a surprisingly big headache[1]. Went into it for reduced maintenance, came out pleasantly surprised at how useful I was finding my own SDK's features around `for...of` on paginated routes, etc.

Congrats on the launch, Stainless crew!

[1] https://www.mux.com/blog/keeping-up-with-the-node-ish-ecosys...

mmcclure··on Tesla Cybertruck deliveries halted for 7 days
Yeah...I strongly suspect both of these are getting nuked from a flag/downvote/mod perspective. I kinda get it, commentary about Tesla immediately becomes commentary about Musk, which is effectively just incendiary political discussion at this point.

This post has 226 points, 234 comments, posted ~2 hours ago, and went from the front page to >#100 between two refreshes.

The most popular layoff post had 143 points, 220 comments, posted 5 hours ago and I can't even find it outside of search: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40038549

mmcclure··on Write OpenAPI with TypeSpec
We're also spec-first at my co (pretty mature, large API surface area), but maintaining the OpenAPI spec in YAML is extremely annoying and tedious. This checks a lot of boxes in terms of being interesting, but what does the path from an existing YAML spec to TypeSpec look like? In an ideal world we could just ingest our OpenAPI spec, get the TypeSpec version out, then be able to clean up/iterate from there.

I didn't see anything in the docs, but I would love for someone to tell me this exists.

Re: the post itself, this was much more compelling than TypeSpec's website imo. At the very least it feels like some of these examples, such as the enum bit, should be ported there. Also interesting that there isn't a single mention of languages like Cue[1].

[1] https://cuelang.org/

mmcclure··on Kagi and Wolfram
It took me way too long to start using Lenses. I've been a Kagi user for a while now, but lenses never really seemed that useful. The unlock for me is that I'm often looking for 3D models, so I added one for all the usual 3D model suspects (Thangs, Printables, etc).
mmcclure··on The /unblock API from Browserless: dodging bot detection as a service
I know this is slightly off topic, but I have to ask: Why not create a new account rather than use the same self-described throwaway account you used to ask about raising prices (for browserless?)[1]? For what it's worth, I initially assumed you likely weren't legitimate and didn't engage, so if you want to keep contributing to threads as yourself you might want to consider using a new/different username.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21271224

mmcclure··on The /unblock API from Browserless: dodging bot detection as a service
Scraping itself isn't a problem. Scraping content where people are actively trying to stop it from being scraped is where things get questionable.

    both OpenAI and Google rely on scraping as their foundation for…everything.
OpenAI and Google also (claim to) respect the most basic bot deterrent, robots.txt, with their crawlers. If someone doesn't want their content scraped to be included by search indexes or LLMs/models, then that certainly includes "smaller indie hackers."
mmcclure··on The /unblock API from Browserless: dodging bot detection as a service
I'm a happy Kagi user, but they might be somewhat a bad example. I suspect their actual indexing work is pretty limited, and they only seem to claim that it's for indexing "niche" stuff.

> Our data includes anonymized API calls to traditional search indexes like Google, Yandex, Mojeek and Brave, specialized search engines like Marginalia, and sources of vertical information like Apple, Wikipedia, Open Meteo, Yelp, TripAdvisor and other APIs. Typically every search query on Kagi will call a number of different sources at the same time, all with the purpose of bringing the best possible search results to the user.

source: https://help.kagi.com/kagi/search-details/search-sources.htm...

mmcclure··on The /unblock API from Browserless: dodging bot detection as a service
I can't help but feel a little conflicted about things like this in the current climate. On one hand, as a developer trying to just get some updated stuff into a spreadsheet, this looks extremely useful.

On the other hand, there are a lot of people right now that want to keep stuff accessible to humans and not have it scraped for models. I know the lid's completely off the box on that front so it's probably useless to fight it, but seeing products explicitly designed to circumvent bot prevention feels kinda bad.

mmcclure··on Show HN: Privy - Open-source, privacy oriented alternative to GitHub Copilot
This seems really cool, thanks for sharing!

The thing I find the most valuable about Copilot is it living directly in VSCode. Understand it's not trivial and this has one public commit, but long-term do you have plans to move closer to the editor?

How do you see this in relation to other projects like continue.dev?

← PreviousPage 3 of 12Next →