44 karma · joined June 27, 2019
If AI enabled everyone and their dog to build Google Docs clones in one day, you can be sure that your market value won't go up but plummet, so keep the trick to yourself.
1. Poor quality drivers. The money is not there. Intel and AMD might throw a couple of engineers on it but the process is always catching-up: slow and incomplete. Think of video, audio, power management, etc. I recently bought an AMD laptop just to discover modern standby and my jack headset are not supported, that my internal mic and speakers occasionally stop working and otherwise are too low, etc. After two kernel releases all these problems persist, even if they were acknowledged by the developers that are working on it (very resource-constrained). "Linux-ready" laptops might be a safer option but in general they are not cheap and they share most of the shortcomings listed here, it's just a safer gamble and you pay the insurance premium. Of course, if Linux had been sold OEM for 30 years with hardware vendors providing state-of-the-art drivers even before releases, this would be a different story.
2. The state of the display server. Multiple HiDPI screens with different scaling factors are not properly supported. This is an all too common requirement nowadays: FHD laptop + FHD/UHD external screen. X+xrandr is slow and buggy with most video drivers. Even after ten years, Wayland adoption is slow both by compositors and by apps. And critical functionality is missing or in alpha-state, for example screen sharing (a must have in these WFH days), be it because of the design of Wayland itself or because it depends on technologies that are still more immature (PipeWire, portals, etc).
3. Fragmentation at all levels: distribution, package manager, desktop, toolkit. From the perspective of an app developer you get a tiny market share with no clear target platform and a propensity to break backwards compatibility every now and then. This of course enables a negative feedback loop wrt to my previous points. Must read/watch from kernel developers: Molnar: http://files.catwell.info/misc/mirror/ingo-molnar-what-ails-..., Torvalds: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pzl1B7nB9Kc. These problems are not unknown to Windows users (WinForms|WPF|UWP|WinUI and MSI|MSIX|exe, for example) but are way worse in Linux.
Stopped reading at the headline. Some hyperbole I tolerate, but this one has gone way too far.
I was all the time thinking of this since "I've had a thought in the back of my mind to write a replacement".
What is smooth in Windows 10?
The GUI is a chaos in every conceivable way. Have you used it in mixed-dpi fractional scaling setting lately? Even the builtin software is plagued with legacy apps that are unable to scale well and are aesthetically alien to the modern platform. Font sizes range from ridiculously small (file explorer) to ridiculously large (Edge location bar) and there is no font scaling factor that fits them all... that is when they even honor it. Most third-party apps look ancient. Installers are often blurry and unreadable. All Qt 5.x apps show scaling problems also, this is acknowledged as an important issue in Qt bug tracker. The task view (Win-Tab) has many visual glitches: it often flickers and reaccommodates itself after the initial rendering, it's not even smooth.
Some of these problems are often attributed to their compromise to maintain backwards compatibility. Well, it's just the oposite, they are mostly the result of the schism they themselves created with Windows 8 and UWP (that not even Microsoft uses for their important apps). Now they are trying to fix it with XAML Islands, WinUI 3, Project Reunion and whatnot, they throw so many names that nobody really knows what is the platform they are developing to.
There is nothing smooth in Windows 10. There are some great ideas and implementations lost in a rage of hubris and incompetence that started ten years ago and it's yet to see how much damage control they manage to do now.