HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mnewme

452 karma · joined November 22, 2020

submissionscomments
mnewme··on If digital computers are conscious, they are conscious at the hardware level
Well at least the slug has intent.
mnewme··on If digital computers are conscious, they are conscious at the hardware level
Actually I work in a AI (like actually training models) and yes the models are insane, still the architecture has not in its core changed. Also „reasoning“ is actually a bad word for what really happens.

There are many famous voices in AI that have the same opinion as me.

Where should consciousness arise? Nothing happens without a prompt and nothing happens afterwards, nothing is saved, nothing is changed? There’s no drive state, no homeostasis, nothing at stake. It makes no sense logically

mnewme··on If digital computers are conscious, they are conscious at the hardware level
That would still be circumventing. There are other architectures that could be more dynamic, LLMs are not.

It is completely different. Our brain rewires itself to store memories, there is no memory storage for humans.

mnewme··on If digital computers are conscious, they are conscious at the hardware level
No they don’t have memories. With an harness you just send historic data into the prompt.
mnewme··on If digital computers are conscious, they are conscious at the hardware level
We use the same terms for computers and brain, but the analogies are misleading. LLMs don’t even have memory, how do you have consciousness without memory? The architecture probibits any signs of consciousness.
mnewme··on If digital computers are conscious, they are conscious at the hardware level
Nope, only if the architecture changes. Still probabilistic prediction models
mnewme··on If digital computers are conscious, they are conscious at the hardware level
That is a lazy definition. A machine doesn’t even want to watch TV. Apes are conscious, dolphins are, maybe octopus, but definitely not LLMs
mnewme··on If digital computers are conscious, they are conscious at the hardware level
Yes, there is a lot of philosophy on that, but the way LLMs work is inherently different from brains, though we use similar terms, hence the confusion. You are right there may be artifical intelligence, just not with LLMs

LLMs are still statistical models that predict the next token; that hasn’t changed, even when they are autoregressive.There is no intent whatsoever.

I agree on the last part, pseudoscientific

mnewme··on If digital computers are conscious, they are conscious at the hardware level
Thinking LLMs are conscious is as ridiculous as thinking a thermostat wants the room to be warm
mnewme··on If digital computers are conscious, they are conscious at the hardware level
Most sci-fi is about genuinely sentient AI, and we are far from that. There is no sign of any intent or internal motivation. If you know anything about machine learning, you know that the idea that LLMs have any form of consciousness is ridiculous. Humans just like to anthropomorphise, that is all.
mnewme··on ECB launches survey on the new euro banknotes
In the big picture, the amount of resources poured into this contest is probably close to 0%.

Also why worse? Some great designs out there.

mnewme··on ECB launches survey on the new euro banknotes
There is enough info online, this is just the survey. Yes site looks like shit, but cool they ask the people.
mnewme··on ECB launches survey on the new euro banknotes
I don’t really get why this gets so much hate. Seems like this is the era of Eurohate.

I think it is great that people get asked for their opinion, why not.

mnewme··on Elon Musk says Grok will make 'historically accurate' Odyssey film by year-end
The self-proclaimed „genius“ apparently doesn’t get that there were no cyclops and gods in Ancient Greece…
mnewme··on Meta is testing an AI bedtime story app for people with no imagination
They basically copied Oscar Stories shamelessly
mnewme··on Who's afraid of Chinese models?
He also forgot Europe in the equation. More and more companies use Chinese open models on European inference because of geopolitical concerns and data privacy, which could be a problem for the big US ai labs if they loose on the market.
mnewme··on EU ban on destruction of unsold clothes and shoes enters into application
I have lived both in the US and two European countries. Food quality is not even on the same scale. So much better in Europe, you can’t even compare, no wonder life expectancy is higher.
mnewme··on EU ban on destruction of unsold clothes and shoes enters into application
Exactly this! People compare to Europe as a whole when convenient and then cherry pick when it is inconvenient
mnewme··on EU ban on destruction of unsold clothes and shoes enters into application
This whole story that Europe suffers from overregulation is just in parts true, and mainly lazy thinking.

In fact there was a study by an American law school that came to the conclusion that the US has more bureaucracy than many European countries…

Recommended read: https://www.andybudd.com/archives/2026/04/the-lazy-myth-that...

mnewme··on Show HN: ParseHawk – 100% Local Document AI with API, CLI, and Web UI
Cool project
mnewme··on Can Europe train a frontier AI model on the compute it owns?
https://www.europarl.europa.eu/legislative-train/package-dig...
mnewme··on Can Europe train a frontier AI model on the compute it owns?
You are not up to date, this is already in legislation process and needs the vote of the parlaiment, highly likely it will come. There is also a simplification package and a migration pact. A lot is happening right now
mnewme··on Can Europe train a frontier AI model on the compute it owns?
It is partly located in the EU and primarily funded by European countries
mnewme··on Can Europe train a frontier AI model on the compute it owns?
FLUX by Black Forrest Labs would disagree there and it is built right in Germany.
mnewme··on Can Europe train a frontier AI model on the compute it owns?
Actually at MoE. Though Deepseek took that approach and improved it by a lot.
mnewme··on Can Europe train a frontier AI model on the compute it owns?
It does matter, for example for all countries that signed the ECHR. And most European countries even have more rights guaranteed by the state and by EU.

You are trying to move goalposts instead of trying to counter my arguments

mnewme··on Can Europe train a frontier AI model on the compute it owns?
Actually right now the reverse is happening. GDPR will become easier there is simplification coming, there will be less national goldplating
mnewme··on Can Europe train a frontier AI model on the compute it owns?
They do in many other areas. Look at ASML or look at chemicals
mnewme··on Can Europe train a frontier AI model on the compute it owns?
Yes but you can make the reverse argument as well: many US companies have offices in Europe and often their research departments.

This whole US vs Europe discussions are fruitless anyways

mnewme··on Can Europe train a frontier AI model on the compute it owns?
I don’t know why you think the American definition of human rights is universal?

It is. Look at the freedom of press index for example. And as the US doesn’t accept foreign courts, there is not really a legal apparatus against the state outside of the US, which many European countries do have.

Belarus is not part of the EU, nor did it sign many of the international human rights

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →