2,466 karma · joined May 31, 2022
> without impugning the remarkable piloting feat Piché performed by landing the plane without fuel, the Portuguese Aviation Accidents Prevention and Investigation Department’s report ultimately found that had Captain Piché and his crew identified the leak sooner, and followed the appropriate procedure instead of performing a fuel transfer from memory, they would have been able to conserve enough fuel for a normal landing at Lajes.
Two overlapping errors then - the mechanics installing the wrong part, and the crew failing to properly follow procedure - and the pilots still managed to land everybody safely. Pretty wild.
Do you really think people don’t know how they’re framing the situation when they choose to use language this way? It’s all just an innocent misunderstanding, that just so happens to serve the interest of existing power structures?
Is fallout’s ‘Buffout’ this ‘bufo?’
What kind of issues though.
There have been people I’ve met online, then go to know and befriend offline. There are friends offline, who I’ve kept in touch with online. But there is nobody I know solely online that I would consider a friend, and it would take a lot to change that. IRL is simply a different thing altogether for me. It’s hard to imagine making a ‘real’ friend without try at IRL interaction.
One key point is that - “pick any topic where people disagree” - most knowledge-seeking I perform via a chat bot is to get a sense of what most people generally agree upon. A quick poll of the zeitgeist of the corpus it was trained on. What used to take me 10-15 minutes on Google now takes me 2-3 minutes with Gemini.
That holds true for Claude code too - I’m relying upon the fact that other people have already solved my problem, or have at least solved the components I need to tie together into a solution for my problem - I’m just fast forwarding through the process of digging them up myself and making sure they’re interoperable. The lion’s share of the tasks I set forth for an LLM is just ‘go find me something like this.’
How some people get from that, to weeks of AI-triggered mania, I simply do not understand.
yeah this I agree with and am familiar with, and I guess I'm guilty of just assuming that this is what people are talking about when they say that LLM-generated stuff is their own speech - because,
> people where they treat the LLMs output as their own literal thoughts
just seems like a different issue altogether. lying about the provenance of something isn't a matter of speech, it's a matter of - I don't know, deception / dishonesty. It's like a separate issue.
very interesting that we both sort of saw it different ways though.
huh... is that really feminism? or just homosexuality / asexuality?
That’s a brave look
Isn’t ‘speech’ what happens when one party chooses to share their words with another? If I use chat gpt to generate a sentence, then deliver the sentence to someone else to be read, have I not ‘spoken’ to them? Just because I didn’t write it doesn’t mean it’s not my speech.
> The no-speech position argues that because no person stands behind a model’s words at the moment of generation, those words are not First Amendment-covered “speech.”
No person, except the user who used the tool to generate the content, surely? What the user does with the content they create is up to them - but the tool communicating the result of the work to the user is certainly not ‘speech’ - unless it’s the user ‘speaking’ to themself. The user is the author of the output, effectively. It only becomes ‘speech’ once they choose to make it available to others.
under what circumstances is it beneficial to have less awareness of oneself?
Is the test that only humans will be too lazy to jump through this hoop?
> HUMANS WHO TRIED CHECKOUT: 000000000
Yep ok gotcha. Looks like I’m in good company, then.
The thing that really gets me about this stuff is - is all about the content, the actual content is what really matters, you need to have content that actually works, that people find appealing, otherwise you have dogshit. A staccato bullet point of marketing speak is dog shit. It’s nothing, it’s less than nothing, customers are repulsed by it, and rightly so. bad presentation you can sometimes get away with, but bad content? Almost never. And this is bad (LLM generated) content, at a glance.
You’re really suggesting people should leave behind everything they’ve ever known and start a new life in a foreign country because of… healthcare?
Clickbait / misleading title - these aren’t private chats:
> says an Anthropic spokesperson, “These shareable links are not guessable or discoverable unless people choose to share them themselves. When someone shares a conversation, they are making that content publicly accessible, and like other public web content, it may be archived by third-party services.”
These are publicly shared convos, turning up in search engine results - just like every other publicly available content the search engine had crawled/indexed.
This is the system working as intended / expected