HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

molbioguy

515 karma · joined July 15, 2011

submissionscomments
molbioguy··on Parler CEO says he was fired by board
Slightly off-topic, but I think it's important to recognize that Parler was placed in the unfair position of having to perfect it's moderation systems in a very short time as their user base ramped up exponentially. Twitter et al had a lot of time to work out their issues and their moderation strategy has 'evolved' substantially over time (and it is still not optimal). I've not seen any messages from Parler defiantly saying they would not try to moderate violent content. If they were not 100% successful, I'd chalk that up to growing pains. Twitter was never subjected to the same level of compliance. Parler was punished for political reasons.
molbioguy··on Parler CEO says he was fired by board
To the best of my knowledge, yes.
molbioguy··on Parler CEO says he was fired by board
This is misleading. The ID requirements were there to provide a 'verified' account status similar to Twitter's blue check mark. It wasn't some arbitrary requirement. I bet Twitter requires this as well for the verified status.
molbioguy··on Antarctica McMurdo Station Webcams
Looks very "Martian". I could easily imagine this was a rover photo from the future.
molbioguy··on How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler
Then see [0] which points out that Brandenburg vs Ohio makes hate speech protected unless there is direct incitement.

[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_speech_in_the_United_Stat...

molbioguy··on How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler
The article linked does mention Parler, but focuses more heavily on YouTube, FaceBook, Twitter and Redit.
molbioguy··on Facebook Indefinitely Suspends Trump
Ouch! This isn't my area and you're right I haven't researched this topic in any depth (though I did look at Diaspora), so I'm not surprised it shows. My original comment was around meta-ethics and this is pretty far from that starting point.

Decentralized platforms like Diaspora may be viable alternatives someday, but my possibly ill-informed pragmatic gut tells me they won't be viable alternatives for many years to come.

Thanks for your patience and persistence. It was interesting!

molbioguy··on Facebook Indefinitely Suspends Trump
>With federation, the content can be stored on any platform, with hooks to pull in into your feed. >At that point, the differentiators are UX quality, level and type of moderation, data licensing model and tracking/spying/ad components.

This sounds like it would work to avoid censorship but I'm pretty sure I don't fully understand the mechanics of how distribution is handled and how users would find the appropriate site that hosts the content the user is seeking in cases where their normal node decides to block it.

I was hasty in dismissing this line of thought. There's more merit to it than I initially thought.

molbioguy··on Facebook Indefinitely Suspends Trump
> Unless you're trying to create a gigantic following (presumably to make money), why would that matter?

Is that what you think this is about? Money? Censorship is almost always about power and the desire to destroy opposition. It is a means to instill fear and stifle the discussion of any 'unpopular' ideas. It separates people. Money comes later.

I have few issues in communicating with friends or family. But now I have to think twice about what I say in public. Conversations must be limited to topics approved by the tech giants and the people who hold power. And I can't easily hear what a lot of other people say. It's definitely limiting. McCarthyism again?

Your solutions are interesting but don't address the problem I'm interested in. Thanks for the thoughtful discussion.

molbioguy··on Facebook Indefinitely Suspends Trump
Thanks for the explanation. Sounds like it would be a move in the right direction. I think the weak link is that until there is true competion, the big platforms will simply exercise their rights to ban posts from people they dislike regardless of how they arrive. Small platforms won't have equivalent reach. But it's a starting point.

I wish I shared your optimism. The level of censorship currently being imposed and surprisingly supported by news media is frightening and disheartening. Twitter just permanently banned Trump claiming that his tweet declining to attend the inauguration was inciting violence!? Scumbags indeed. I wonder if HN moderators will shadow ban me for this comment that mentions Trump?

molbioguy··on Facebook Indefinitely Suspends Trump
>1. All social media platforms are required to share APIs to allow other platforms (e.g., Diaspora, Mastodon, etc.) to pull as well as post content from/to the larger platforms;

Genuinely cool idea, but how would this work from a technical perspective? And if anyone could cross-post content on any platform, wouldn't the platforms argue that it violates their right to control content on their platforms?

And what happens if you get a concerted effort across platforms to block individuals based on political/moral stances? Within 2 days (I think) Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, Redit and others have suspended and/or blocked content from Trump and various Trump supporters. The ex-first lady is asking "big-tech" to take additional actions, whatever that means.

molbioguy··on Facebook Indefinitely Suspends Trump
I stand corrected, there are reasonable alternatives to Facebook. But Twitter seems to be a unique channel for global communication. You may be right that we shouldn't expect to have global reach, but if some people have that opportunity while others are denied based on the content of their message, how is that fair? Isn't it up to individuals to reject the message or ignore it if they deem it offensive?
molbioguy··on Facebook Indefinitely Suspends Trump
I don't disagree. But to me, that concensus is embodied in laws. Morals are still relative, not absolute, though they may be widely shared.
molbioguy··on Facebook Indefinitely Suspends Trump
Good arguments. And I stand corrected, there are reasonable alternatives to Facebook - I was thinking of Twitter.
molbioguy··on Facebook Indefinitely Suspends Trump
No argument that Facebook is currently within its rights to censor anyone they want for any reason they want. I think the debate is around whether they should have those protections, given that at present they are virtually a monopoly within their sphere and people don't have viable alternatives to use once they are kicked off of Facebook. BTW, my private property rights can be overriden whenever the governement or utilities or even neighbors can show a public need.
molbioguy··on Facebook Indefinitely Suspends Trump
According to that principle, you can do anything you want under the umbrella that you find it ethical. Who made you the arbiter of ethics or morals? That's why there are laws. Laws provide objectivity.
molbioguy··on Facebook Indefinitely Suspends Trump
So, at worst, delete the post, not ban the user (though I don't support that). In my view, the posts are inferred by some to incite destruction, but there are equal grounds to say that no explicit order was made in any post. Again, it's personal opinion.
molbioguy··on Facebook Indefinitely Suspends Trump
> You do not have to make a Facebook account, after all, and since Facebook is not the only game in town ...

Isn't that part of the problem? Facebook (and Twitter) are so common and widely used that alternatives are not remotely equivalent. Communication via those alternatives is extremely limiting.

molbioguy··on Facebook Indefinitely Suspends Trump
Agreed. It's not their responsibility to educate users. Maybe it's their responsibility to educate themselves on what their users assume.
molbioguy··on Facebook Indefinitely Suspends Trump
In some cases, yes. But in other cases they just represent the view of the vocal majority or those in power. Laws are official and objective, morals are relative. It's fine to base decisions on agreed upon laws. Appealing to morality is just using your own opinions
molbioguy··on Facebook Indefinitely Suspends Trump
It's treated as such by a lot of it's users. They do not have expectations of being censored. The items you mention are paid services. Facebook isn't for most of its users.
molbioguy··on Facebook Indefinitely Suspends Trump
The statements by Facebook and others pushing moral justifications around Facebook's censorship fail to entertain the possibility that even morality is subjective and relative. Facebook makes its decisions based on its own goals and preferences and morals. Facebook has established itself unfairly as a moral arbiter on a platform that is so widely used that is treated like a public utility. The people who currently agree with Facebook may someday be on the opposite side of Facebook's moral righteousness and be censored. What then?
molbioguy··on Sleep tweaks boost night owls' wellbeing
One item mentioned in the article that matches my personal experience is the importance of sleep consistency or regularity. Waking up at the same time and sleeping at the same time each night has been beneficial, even if those regular times are shifted from what the article suggests. There was a study that touched on this [0].

[0] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-017-03171-4

molbioguy··on Boredom: Is resistance futile?
I didn't realize that boredom had been classified into 5 categories. Who knew boredom was complicated.
molbioguy··on Why don’t our brains explode at movie cuts?
I think the fact that the movie represents a part of your visual field makes it understandable -- the surrounding setting is stable. If everything around you changed instantly, your brain would have a hard time adjusting. Might be interesting when more sophisticated VR is available.
molbioguy··on How to Be Polite
Politeness serves as a buffer. It gives you time to evaluate the situation and gain more information while keeping you from making a rash judgement - both positive and negative. Later on, it keeps you from unnecessarily making enemies of the people you don't respect but must nevertheless deal with. It works hand in hand with patience, which I see as being in very short supply these days. In my experience, it is an extremely valuable trait.
molbioguy··on Should holiday email be deleted?
Vacation deletion of emails could be workable IF the only things that came across your work email were work-related requests from real people. However, for most people, the separation of work and personal (or pseudo personal) in email is not so complete, and many emails are notifications from automated (no-reply) systems. Deleting messages in these cases may cause more headaches upon return than it's worth.

Being resolute about putting aside work and email while on vacation is a personal responsibility, not an email robot's function. Put up a reasonable out-of-office message and put down the technology if you're on vacation.

molbioguy··on Ask HN: Who isn't in the software industry/not a hacker?
I'm a senior scientist at a biotech company. I do engage in some software development now, but my formal training is as a bench scientist. I read HN because I enjoy the intelligent topics and conversations.
molbioguy··on The Case Against Adverbs
I dismissed this article quickly and summarily! Adverbs are important and their loss in everyday speech (where I often notice it) is annoying.
molbioguy··on Is the MOOC Bubble Bursting?
Good point (and same to @ambler0). I have little first-hand experience here so I may be way off base, but on average are families paying far less than the retail price of 60K/yr? I mean, if your family had a 100K income, would you still get a break? How much loss is Harvard absorbing?
← PreviousPage 4 of 8Next →