HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

molbioguy

515 karma · joined July 15, 2011

submissionscomments
molbioguy··on Is the MOOC Bubble Bursting?
That would be cool. I know Harvard has a huge endowment. That would be a great way to use it. Any data on whether that's true?
molbioguy··on Is the MOOC Bubble Bursting?
While the article may be correct that MOOCs will not achieve the oft-stated outcome of displacing the current higher educational system, I think the argument that the author is making regarding the affordability of college is off base. Harry Lewis in the article states: "At Harvard and a handful of other schools, nobody graduates with any debt (unless they have intentionally borrowed so they could avoid making money in the summer, etc., and even then the amounts are likely < $10K)."

While according to Harvard itself: "The total 2013-2014 cost of attending Harvard College without financial aid is $38,891 for tuition and $59,950 for tuition, room, board and fees combined."

Unless summer+part time work is a lot more lucrative than I am aware of, the only way this would be true is if the students (or their parents) were financially well-endowed. A student that doesn't have rich parents is going to be incurring a fair amount of debt or spending way too much time working instead of studying.

Edit: Harvard is generous with its financial aid, so the author's message is more accurate than I understood (at least for Harvard). Learned something.

molbioguy··on Study participants typically did not enjoy spending 15 minutes by themselves
The real article is behind a paywall so all I have is the Globe article.There isn't much to dig into. Based on he Globe article, the researchers "asked the people how much they would pay to avoid the shock experience if they had $5 to spend." And "...of the 42 people who said they would pay to avoid the shock, two-thirds of men chose to shock themselves..." It didn't say anyone actually stood to lose any real money to avoid shocks. It also doesn't even say how much someone would pay ($5, $1, $0.1), just that they would give up some of (hypothetical) $5 they had. This combined with the fact the shocks were "mild shocks to the ankle" makes me wonder whether that was really unpleasant enough to make the point the Globe headline trumpeted.
molbioguy··on Study participants typically did not enjoy spending 15 minutes by themselves
Just because it's published is no reason not to question the validity of the study. I've been in science long enough to know that flawed work can into important journals.

The Globe article's title and the original title of the HN post focused on the electrical shocks, implying that people would prefer doing something very painful rather than think silently. I can't read the article itself, but the Science Editor's summary included this:

In fact, many of the people studied, particularly the men, chose to give themselves a mild electric shock rather than be deprived of external sensory stimuli.

Doesn't sound terribly unpleasant. That changes a lot in terms of the headline's conclusion, at least for me.

molbioguy··on Study participants typically did not enjoy spending 15 minutes by themselves
I get the point that people may prefer external stimulation to internal thoughts. But I think the result of this study hinge on whether the electric shock was really all that unpleasant. For safety reasons, I'll assume the shock wasn't large enough to be harmful or create anything but a momentary sensation. People are curious, and it would seem a fairly safe environment. What's to stop them from simply experimenting with a new sensation. Roller coasters and scary movies should logically be avoided, but they aren't. The guy they mentioned who shocked himself 190 times clearly must have thought it was fun.
molbioguy··on Why Astronomers and Journalists should pay heed to Biologists about ET
Evolution doesn't ensure advancement in the sense of greater capabilities or greater longevity or long-term survival either. Most species on this planet have gone extinct. What's to say that species capable of altering their world don't have a higher risk of catastrophic failure. The time scales are large and there's no evidence to make a strong assertion that we as a species will be around long enough so that we can colonize galaxies. There is an assumption that advanced civilizations will last for long periods of time. It's not clear to me that's valid. And what time scale is needed for galactic colonization? Why should that be different elsewhere?
molbioguy··on Why Astronomers and Journalists should pay heed to Biologists about ET
maybe I'm missing it, but I don't see any significant outlays of funds for colonizing the moon yet. Lots of plans an good intentions, but no will yet. And yes, it may be possible to cheaply build self-replicating robots that colonize the galaxy. But that, too, is just a speculative prediction. We're not there yet. And just as governments decided it would be better to spend their wealth on terrestrial matters rather than the moon, it remains to be seen how long it will take to make those self-replicating colonizing robots in large enough numbers to make a dent in the galaxy.
molbioguy··on Why Astronomers and Journalists should pay heed to Biologists about ET
The resources required to traverse interstellar distances are astronomically greater than terrestrial travel (pun intended). Most species die out. How long do you believe it will take to have human explorers on the nearest extrasolar planet. And that's the easiest, closest one. Then think about how many species go extinct on this planet. There's no certainty that we will survive long enough to explore that far.
molbioguy··on Why Astronomers and Journalists should pay heed to Biologists about ET
So why is it inevitable that any civilization that can evolve to the point of space travel will necessarily have the desire and capability to continue to expand before extinction? We've only been around a relatively short time and there is no certainty that we will be around long enough to be able to spread across the galaxy. If someone had told me in 1969 that 45 years later we would have lost the capability (or desire) to colonize the moon, I would have thought it highly unlikely. But here we are.
molbioguy··on A beginner's guide to funemployment
I can admire the philosophy of funemployment, but I wonder if it's a life-stage thing. What I mean is that it seems like you have to first do all the opposite things to achieve the freedom to be funemployed. My son is a teenager and is naturally funemployed. I admire his ability to avoid the responsibility and work-drive that weighs me down. But if I let him continue, will he not end up unemployed rather than have the ability to be funemployed? How do you strike the right balance?
molbioguy··on Genome Editing (in primates)
Human genome editing seems inevitable, but there will be delays based on ethical and medical concerns. However, I wonder if the pet industry is a more likely target. Given the vast amounts of genetic data already available for dogs, one could envision a fair amount of engineering in breeds to correct for the medical problems created by pure breeding. Also, given the low(er) cost of genome sequencing, would designer pets (fish, mice, rabbits, etc) become a possible product for some bio startup?
molbioguy··on US Supreme Court says human DNA cannot be patented (2013)
This was debated here last year: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5874274

The cDNA part baffled me and many molecular biologists I know back then (and still does). I tend to think that either 1) the court didn't understand the science or 2) they did but were unwilling to destroy an industry so they found a loophole.

molbioguy··on The inexplicable rise of open floor plans in tech companies
One size doesn't fit all [situations]. In my experience, open plans work when active collaboration is necessary by shortening the communication paths. They also work in the short term when everyone is focused on subsets of a common task. However, open plans are abysmal (again in my experience) when you need time to concentrate (most of my day when I'm programming anything non-trivial).

I hear the same tired arguments about fostering communication and the serendipitous meetings that spark great ideas. However, every single day and for at least 50% of the day, everyone in my open office either grabs headphones or runs away to another spot in the building when they need to get work done individually.

When I bring up objections, I'm told that I can work remotely or wear headphones. I don't see how forcing people to seek all sorts of ways to find privacy is any great recommendation for a purely open plan. If you spend the majority of your day talking and listening to others, I don't see how you can actually get programming done.

Edit: At this moment I can overhear conversations about opening day in baseball, April Fools day, SAP, reporting about inventories in Epicor, the weather, CNN, 3 people scheduling meetings and having phone conversations and one person trying to talk to our network provider. Not to forget, there are 2 people in the hallway complaining about personal issues and getting coffee. And an elevator that keeps beeping every few seconds. I can't wait to see what great idea all this is going to generate in my head.

molbioguy··on Why I like Java
But when you learn Java, there aren't any powerful language features you can use to solve many problems.

I know it's not pure, but Java does force you to think in an object-oriented way. And there are problems where that's an advantage.

molbioguy··on Coming Soon to Hacker News: Pending Comments
I think I understand the motivation, but this smacks of elitism to me. Unless the 1K users constitute the majority, then by definition a minority of HN users will effectively moderate (and can potentially censor) the discussions. That seems very unfair.
molbioguy··on Free unlimited rebooting experience from vintage operating systems
Appropriate username :)
molbioguy··on Free unlimited rebooting experience from vintage operating systems
Fun!

I spent way too much time watching the systems reboot after I understood that the dialogs were active. Very nice collection. Curious how this was done. Screen captures, recreated from videos?

molbioguy··on Snowden-haters are on the wrong side of history
Commenting on the comments, not the original post. Seems to me there's some confusing of issues going on. MLK vs Snowden is not a reasonable comparison -- one was a lifelong activist and the other is a first-time whistleblower. Their roles and goals dictate different actions, including whether to stay put or run, among other things. Secondly, the issue of the legality of NSA actions versus their constitutionality is quite different. Laws can be found unconstitutional. So while the NSA was ostensibly following the law, Snowden claims they were violating the constitution. One does not invalidate the other.
molbioguy··on Extreme Diets Can Quickly Alter Gut Bacteria
Not sure if good or bad, but something for potential soylent consumers to consider.
molbioguy··on Successful People Start Before They're Ready
Branson is one data point. Are there others? One point does not make a trend. I tend to think there's merit (though I have no hard evidence) in the idea that you can't wait for all the pieces to be in place before you try something, but I think it's dangerous to suggest that's the recipe for success.
molbioguy··on Programming is a Terrible Job
For me, control over what I work on or how I solve a problem is the key to satisfaction. The more rigid the constraints, the less creativity allowed, the more boring the job. It's hard to find jobs that consistently allow enough creative latitude to keep the tasks fun and interesting. The OP's point about not being a general software engineer (implying specialization) might make sense. I imagine that more specialized you are, the fewer the people that are around that know more about your area than you. So you might get more creative leeway because you're the expert.
molbioguy··on Google Web Designer
Couldn't open existing HTML files. Seems files must be created in GWD to be edited.
molbioguy··on Ben Chestnut (MailChimp): Creating an Environment for Creativity and Empowerment
I think Ben is very much on target -- good things happen when you favor quantity over a single perfect creation. However, you have to have a way to provide positive supportive pressure rather than negative pressure. Providing people with the right motivation to work faster (and harder?) is a difficult task. Allowing failure while keeping overall standards high.
molbioguy··on Beyond Flat
Minor point. I think the article is incorrect regarding long press being absent on iOS. I think it's been available for some time as UILongPressGestureRecognizer.
molbioguy··on DINO PET // a living, bioluminescent night light / pet
Always an enticing product idea: something bioluminescent that sits on your nightstand. Not as cool as bioluminescent goldfish (as in Big Bang Theory), but still could be impressive. If successful, is this a harbinger of more biological toys?
molbioguy··on How to quickly become effective when joining a new company
By "planning decision" I mean to use this knowledge to make a decision which is more likely to lead to a successful project.

Sorry, still not clear to me what you mean. Please clarify.

Consider the converse to your statement: It can sometimes be advantageous to spend all your time learning as much as possible about the way things are normally done while approaching the job from your own strengths and knowledge.

Nope. The converse of what I said would be: It can sometimes be advantageous to spend all your time learning as much as possible about the way things are normally done before trying to contribute to projects.

"you may delay contributing if you wait until you reach that status before trying" Certainly. However, contributing is also an important part of learning, and you are unlikely to get to expert status if you delay in contributing.

Yes, exactly. Fits with what I'm saying.

I'm sure you'll have something to say, so I'll leave you to have the last say. Thanks for the discussion.

molbioguy··on How to quickly become effective when joining a new company
Not quite sure what you mean by "planning decision". Do mean actively recruiting people with backgrounds and knowledge that are substantially different from your existing group? Do you mean from the individual's point of view whether or not to learn as much information as possible and become an "expert" before contributing? I'm assuming you have minimally sufficient knowledge of your field, otherwise you wouldn't have been hired in the first place.

I'm just saying that it can sometimes be advantageous not to spend all your time learning as much as possible about the way things are normally done at your new job/activity and approach the job from your own strengths and knowledge. In that way you may surprise yourself and others with solutions that they hadn't thought of because they couldn't see outside their box. You will become an expert eventually (if you want), but you may delay contributing if you wait until you reach that status before trying. And although you may look foolish or stupid if your naive idea was wrong, in my experience you don't get fired for trying. You just get embarrassed and then spend your time steeping yourself in the field's dogma :) It's just an observation ...

molbioguy··on How to quickly become effective when joining a new company
My statement is based on personal experiences -- it's an observation and not an authoritative fact; I don't have formal studies to back this up. A really great solution from a new perspective is admittedly rare when you take into account all tasks. However, when there's a problem that's been giving a group some difficulty, I've had many occasions where the new person who was coming from a different background, provided a key advance. It was usually along the lines of something we all thought was either too simple to try, "known" to not work, or just went against all the standard methods we had been taught (like the anecdotal example you provided).

In the context of the article, having minimal knowledge (just enough to understand the problem), also affords you with the opportunity to learn more on your own and develop your own views before someone tells you how to think. While I can't back it up with level of evidence you're asking for, in my experience it's still a good strategy to go with. I realize this is drifting away from the original topic. Sorry about that.

molbioguy··on How to quickly become effective when joining a new company
Agreed. I've always experienced pressure to conform, too. But I know some of my best contributions came when I didn't do things the standard way. Of course, going at things differently is risky, since you have no cover if things fail; however, if you find the right solution, it's very satisfying and can elevate your status quickly.
molbioguy··on How to quickly become effective when joining a new company
Acquire as little information as possible

This is an often overlooked opportunity. Learn as little as you absolutely need so you don't get mired in the dogma. Some of the best solutions for problems come from people who have not yet become indoctrinated in the "standard" methodology. They approach problems with a fresh perspective and can come up with new solutions that everyone else who's been there a while missed. This opportunity is short lived, since everyone inevitably learns all the standard ways, so it is very apt for when you join a new company.

← PreviousPage 5 of 8Next →