HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

molbioguy

515 karma · joined July 15, 2011

submissionscomments
molbioguy··on Restoring Trust in Government and the Internet
In addition to the transparency, oversight, and accountability that Schneier proposes, there also needs to be some ability for the population to reasonably assess risk. A lot this stuff is driven by fear. And the government does use that to its advantage to push things through that might otherwise be objectionable. If the population of our country is scared to death of possible terrorist attacks (as it seems to be), then I don't see how that same population will vote/protest to restrict the government as long as it claims to be protecting them from imminent disaster.
molbioguy··on Don't Plug Your Phone into a Charger You Don't Own
I thought developer accounts were limited to 100 test devices per year. Does this get around that limit?
molbioguy··on Existential Depression in Gifted Children
A starting point might be this article by Sue Jackson: http://psych.wisc.edu/henriques/papers/Jackson.pdf
molbioguy··on Existential Depression in Gifted Children
"Existential depression" is not a euphemism, it has a specific meaning. While, I do not have the primary references to back up my point [so I guess you may take me to task for that] I too am very much immersed in the gifted field. There is most definitely a consensus among the people who deal with gifted children, especially their emotional needs, that existential depression hits earlier and more often in these kids than in the general population of children. I do not know about giftedness in general, including adult giftedness.
molbioguy··on Existential Depression in Gifted Children
Giftedness is misunderstood. That even highly educated audiences don't get this is evident in some of the comments here. Giftedness is terribly named. It is more affliction than blessing. Giftedness is rare. Gifted kids are not the same as brilliant high achievers. They have high IQ's but are also underachievers (by regular standards, not some elevated bar) and often dropouts. They should be highly successful but are not and often commit suicide. Gifted children are routinely dismissed as overly privileged or advantaged kids, and usually do not get any special needs attention in schools. People see their intellectual side and ignore their emotional needs and problems. I can say from personal experience that while gifted kids are exceptional in many ways, they also tend to lead difficult lives with many challenges because they are so deeply misunderstood. Even by their own parents.
molbioguy··on Existential Depression in Gifted Children
The narrow focus is odd, even if true, and might serve better as a footnote.

Not odd at all. The concentration or severity of existential depression in gifted children is well documented if not well known. And Jim Webb, the author, has devoted a good deal of his life (30+ years) to understanding the needs of and helping the gifted, with a focus on gifted children [1]. He also founded SENG (Supporting Emotional Needs of the Gifted) [2].

[1] http://www.greatpotentialpress.com/authors/james-t-webb-ph-d...

[2] http://www.sengifted.org/

molbioguy··on Physicists offer new theory on cancer
I also disagree that all that stuff should be obvious to everybody.

It doesn't. But not everybody publishes something in journals. When you do, you have a responsibility to know your subject.

They are thinking about it not as a random mutation but as an intentional genetic program which just makes much more sense.

This actually makes little sense to me. The replication machinery and programming is deeply established, not a random mutation. The mutation is in the genes that regulate the system. The inappropriate execution of the replication is the key and that's well established to arise from mutational changes in regulatory elements.

molbioguy··on Physicists offer new theory on cancer
Physicists have made great contributions to molecular biology, but this isn't one of those cases. This one is so wrong at so many levels it's hard to to justice to it. Much of it just misinterprets things we already know.

In the article it says:

Davies and Lineweaver claim that cancer is actually an organized and systematic response to some sort of stress or physical challenge. It might be triggered by a random accident, they say, but thereafter it more or less predictably unfolds.

There's nothing new here. Cancer is basically deregulated cellular replication and proliferation. These are core processes in multicellular organisms, so of course they unfold predictably. The trigger is often a mutation ("random accident") in a key regulatory gene.

The article says the new theory "challenges the orthodox view that cancer develops anew in each host". But we know that the mechanism of proliferation does not develop anew in each cancer; only the trigger is different in different cancers.

The physicists say “We envisage cancer as the execution of an ancient program pre-loaded into the genomes of all cells,” and that "it will express genes that are more deeply conserved among multicellular organisms, and so are in some sense more ancient."

Since cellular replication programs are deeply rooted and ancient because they are fundamental processes, this shouldn't be surprising.

"Sure enough, cancer reverts to an ancient form of metabolism called fermentation, which can supply energy with little need for oxygen, although it requires lots of sugar." Guess they are unaware that your muscle cells do they same when they are starved for oxygen! Anaerobic "fermentation" is a standard part of our metabolic system under certain conditions.

This goes on and on...

molbioguy··on Google Doodle of Roswell anniversary is a point-and-click adventure
There are multiple paths to victory. Several more than what's been listed in the comments so far. Explore and play with it!
molbioguy··on Life is not a conveyor belt
Part of the problem with viewing life as a conveyor belt is that you build up expectations of what's ahead. I think that one of the OP's points was that you may be very disappointed (even feel a bit cheated) to learn that happiness is not inevitable, even if you follow all the required steps. So instead, don't just follow the steps. Question, think, break 'rules' if you have to. Make your own choices and don't just follow the prescribed path. You won't get a second chance.
molbioguy··on 4th of July DUI Checkpoint - Search without consent...
The best line in the video is at 5:10 where an officer says:

"But he's perfectly innocent and he knows his rights. He knows what the Constitution says." as they continue to search his car.

I don't see how government authorities can expect people to to be law abiding when they themselves are not. They've clearly taken the principle of the ends justify the means.

It's a very sad state for our society.

molbioguy··on Show HN: Google Glass + Tesla Model S = GlassTesla
As others have said, Glass + driving will lead to increased accidents and will likely be banned in the same manner as texting while driving. A recent study by AAA showed that voice-to-text messaging is more distracting than making calls with a cell phone. For the average person, multitasking while driving will almost always be more dangerous. Pilot HUDs are not comparable, because they are focused on flying, the task at hand, and pilots are highly trained in using them. I doubt that users will restrict themselves to map apps while driving.
molbioguy··on A future made of Glass
Google Glass is an innovative product that will surely cause some problems. I admit I'd love to have one, but given what cellphones have done to life, I fear that we are rushing into radical changes without due thought.

Privacy issues when Glass users record every interaction they have (and potentially post to their social networks). Capturing my daugther's first words is sweet. Capturing my naked partner could be different. No need to hold up a phone -- very convenient. And it will surely all be there on the web.

Glass also could further the trend towards self-indulgent isolation and distraction. Are looking at me or reading mail? Texting while driving is bad, reading tweets and viewing images while driving (all hands free) will be worse.

People already spend too much time photographing/capturing experiences instead of actually experiencing them. Glass will accentuate this. The goal in life should be to live in the present, not record for posterity. And frankly, I have my own life; I don't want to share every bit of yours...

molbioguy··on What I Learned from Icon
I wish I had something more important to say, but I just wanted to note that Icon, albeit obscure these days, was/is a neat powerful language, especially for complex text processing. I remember using it back in the 80's for fun projects like writing a chaos generator and more useful things like scanning for patterns in DNA/protein sequences (yes, we had a few sequences even back then). It seemed so exotic with it's fancy backtracking pattern matcher, generators and co-routines -- especially for someone coming from a C background. The biggest drawback for me was lack of popularity, which meant I couldn't share the programs I wrote and couldn't get help from almost anyone I worked with since none of them used Icon or even knew about Icon. For anyone interested, it's still available for many platforms at http://www.cs.arizona.edu/icon/ . I got my first Icon distribution on magnetic tape :)
molbioguy··on Glasshole
Glass makes it so much more convenient to record others. While you can do this with smartphones, the process is so much more obvious with those devices. Most people won't know if they're being recorded or not with Glass. And by putting the device close to your face, it's less likely someone will try to move it aside or block it.

It all comes back to privacy being a sense of control over what someone releases to the world about themselves. Glass helps take away that control (as does secret NSA data collection). People are uncomfortable when someone else controls the release or collection of their personal data (images, whereabouts, friends, etc).

molbioguy··on Absolute knowledge is absolute power
I think a key feature of privacy is empowerment or control. People generally want to feel that they are in control of their lives. By being selective about what information you make available to others or even generally available to all, is a very important way to express your sense of control over your own life. Even if you like to broadcast as many of your thoughts, photographs, likes, and geolocations as possible, you do that with a sense of control. You decided what to release. When the NSA sifts through your data, they decide what to collect, what to use, who to share it with. And they never tell you any of it. I think that loss of control is one of the factors that makes people uncomfortable with loss of privacy.
molbioguy··on Supreme Court rules human genes may not be patented
I don't get the cDNA part of the ruling. If the spliced message exists naturally, and it must in order to be expressed, how does a DNA copy of that spliced message represent something novel whereas the full unspliced gene does not. After all most cDNA is initially generated from a naturally occurring template in the cell, since you're looking for what's naturally expressed.
molbioguy··on I hired someone with Asperger's – now what?
As others here have pointed out, "Asperger's" covers a broad spectrum of behaviors and it's not fair to a) put this label on anyone who displays some of the behaviors (that covers too many people), nor b) try to minimize the diversity of behaviors by focusing on just a few (the diversity is much, much greater). The same thing happens with the horribly named "gifted" label. People only focus on the high achievers and completely miss the fact that not all gifted or Asperger's fit that stereotype. It's just so easy to label people and move on without really considering what's going on. A great article called the "Misunderstood face of giftedness" on this was just in Huffington Post http://www.huffingtonpost.com/marianne-kuzujanakis/gifted-ch...
molbioguy··on The Misunderstood Face of Giftedness
The definition of normal (at least for kids) is becoming dangerously narrow, and we're at risk of correcting behaviors with medications that will do more harm than good. In my view, we're sacrificing a measure of behavioral diversity primarily to make classrooms run more smoothly. This article talks about how gifted children have a particularly high risk factor for misdiagnosis and unnecessary medication.
molbioguy··on Saving Normal
In the drive to identify, treat and cure psychological and mental "disorders", I think we're rapidly narrowing the definition of "normal" to the point where it doesn't make sense. Diversity of thought and behavior is a hallmark of a robust society. We need to be very careful about going about trying to "correct" that diversity. A lot of talented individuals will be caught in the dragnet of abnormality.
molbioguy··on [dead]
In the drive to identify, treat and cure psychological and mental "disorders", I think we're rapidly narrowing the definition of "normal" to the point where it doesn't make sense. Diversity of thought and behavior is a hallmark of a robust society. We need to be very careful about going about trying to "correct" that diversity. A lot of talented individuals will be caught in the dragnet of abnormality.
molbioguy··on I used Google Glass
If someone is being photographed, is there any way for that person to know that Google Glass is recording video? I would feel really uncomfortable if a colleague had Google Glass on at a meeting or at lunch or in my office, unless I knew I wasn't being recorded. The privacy concerns on this are enormous in my view.
molbioguy··on "Overreacting" considered harmful
I used to think that words were just words, logical things with defined meanings. I have come to understand that there really are "poisonous" words; words, phrases, attitudes that absolutely have impacts well beyond their dictionary definitions and the speaker's likely intent. If you include these things when conversations are tense or critical, the situation is likely to destabilize and get worse. Making the conversation "safe" and non-threatening is very important. Steering away from emotional arguments and focusing on facts is also key. All of this is harder to do in any text message or email as well, as body language and other social cues are unavailable.

Added:

This comes up a lot in employer - employee conversations. If you want your team to function efficiently, you really have to create a safe environment for comments and discussion.

molbioguy··on The End of Ragequitting
While I respect Jeff Atwood's comments, and I suspect he's leaning on the side of being inspirational, I think equating suicide with "ragequitting" (directly or indirectly) is unfair. The consequences are so different, it sort of trivializes suicide.

But also, I must admit that I am a little disappointed in Aaron. I understand that depression is a serious disease that can fell any person, however strong. But he chose the path of the activist long ago. And the path of the activist is to fight, for as long and as hard as it takes, to effect change.

I never knew Aaron, but I know that while one can choose to be an activist, one can't choose whether they have clinical depression. It is a serious illness that is hard to fight. And by all accounts I've read, Aaron put up quite a fight trying to deal with the extreme pressure he was put under. In that light, I think Jeff's comment is harsh.

molbioguy··on Creating a Great Place to Work
In my experience, a very important component in attracting and retaining great employees is providing them with meaningful and challenging projects. The best need to apply their skills to solve problems that they find interesting. In the process, they get to learn new skills they value. No amount of office equipment/swag/benefits will keep the really good employees if their minds are not kept stimulated and engaged.
molbioguy··on What Petraeus and Broadwell could have used instead of Gmail
Agents were able to use “digital forensic techniques to determine the person behind the keyboard at the time the emails in question were sent,”

How does this work? Does this refer to tracking IP addresses accessing the account? And is this information provided by Google?

molbioguy··on The Waiting Place
If Theodore Geisel felt he was stuck in the waiting place for too long (and therefore missed his chance to write the great American novel), his work does not reflect it and is obviously immensely important. So was he really right about how bad the "waiting place" is, given the work he actually created while there?
molbioguy··on Everything's broken and nobody's upset
Patience. As the rate of technological change accelerates, patience is slipping away. How long can you wait for the next improved version with new features? From a technical point of view, it's all possible, so why isn't it available yet? I'd say that both consumers and investors can't wait very long, so businesses push out features (sometimes prematurely) to meet the demands, which fuels the impatience for new features. Vicious cycle started.
molbioguy··on Why I don't wear the same shirt everyday
You're right and that wasn't my intent. Sorry. I was hoping it was clear I was more interested in the statement, but out of the context of the OP. Guess it was too far out of context...
molbioguy··on Why I don't wear the same shirt everyday
"Routine creates boredom, and boredom constricts creativity."

Somewhat out of the context of the OP, but I respectfully disagree with that statement. Routine also creates a structure or foundation on which to be creative. Although counterintuitive, in my experience it can be hard to be creative (in a productive way) when you're given total freedom or have to start out from scratch or in a new way every time. You waste your energy trying to explore too many different areas, whereas when you work in structured environment, you can focus on the just the portion where you want to be creative.

← PreviousPage 6 of 8Next →